There’s much more impeachment news on Thursday’s live blog. Follow it here:
Evening summary
Today, Donald Trump became the third president in US history to be impeached. Here’s a recap:
- After a full day of debate, the House approved two articles of impeachment charging Trump with abuse of power and obstruction of Congress.
-
Congress voted 230-197 to approve the first article and 229-198 for the second.
- Members voted overwhelmingly along party lines, with three Democrats opposing one or both articles, and one, 2020 candidate Tulsi Gabbard, voting “present”.
- While announcing the result, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who has cast the impeachment as a sad, solemn occasion, shut down applause from Democrats.
- Afterward, Pelosi evaded questions about when she will hand the articles of impeachment over to the Senate, indicating that wants to first make sure that the Senate will hold a “fair” trial.
- Leader Mitch McConnell said he will address the impeachment on the Senate floor tomorrow.
- As members of the House voted to impeach him, Donald Trump carried on speaking at a campaign rally in Michigan. The moment offered a surreal split screen.
- As impeachment was being debated, an appeals court delivered a long-awaited ruling on the Affordable Care Act. The court said that the “individual mandate” provision of Obamacare was unconstitutional while punting a broader decision on whether the entire law was valid.
- And finally (just for fun): the USDA removed references to Wakanda, the fictional home of Marvel superhero Black Panther, from a list of trading partners.
Updated
A few more impeachment reactions from 2020 Dems...
Joe Biden, the only 2020 candidate name-checked in the articles of impeachment, echoed other Dremocrats and cast today as “a solemn moment for our country”
President Trump abused his power, violated his oath of office, and betrayed our nation. This is a solemn moment for our country. But in the United States of America, no one is above the law — not even the President.
— Joe Biden (@JoeBiden) December 19, 2019
Cory Booker, who along with his 2020 competitors Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders, will be participating in the Senate trial on whether to convict Trump, similarly said: “Today is a sad moment for our country.”
The three-month House impeachment process has uncovered alarming evidence that an American president used his official power for personal gain, put our national security at risk, and obstructed the investigation.
— Cory Booker (@CoryBooker) December 19, 2019
Today is a sad moment for our country.
Amy Klobuchar, yet another Senator in the 2020 race said “the House is fulfilling their constitutional obligation”.
The Founding Fathers included impeachment provisions in the Constitution because they feared that a President could betray the trust of the American people to a foreign power.
— Amy Klobuchar (@amyklobuchar) December 19, 2019
Today, the House is fulfilling their constitutional obligation.
No one is above the law.
Meanwhile, Tulsi Gabbard, the only House member to vote “present” said she was “standing in the center”.
“After doing my due diligence in reviewing the 658-page impeachment report, I came to the conclusion that I could not in good conscience vote either yes or no,” she said.
The Hawaii representative and 2020 candidate instead introduced a resolution to censure Trump for abusing “ the powers of the Presidency for his own personal political gain” .
Updated
Analysis: Impeachment is ‘one more battle in America’s cold civil war’
Read The Guardian’s analysis of today’s historic impeachment vote, courtesy of David Smith:
While no crystal ball can truly foresee whether impeachment will help or hurt Trump in the 2020 presidential election, the House’s ultimate sanction may come to be seen simply as one more battle in America’s cold civil war. That would make it one of the most important yet least consequential votes in congressional history.
RNC and DNC issue contrasting statements on impeachment
Republican National Committee chair Ronna McDaniel said “Nancy Pelosi and her fellow impeachment crusaders have ensured the reelection of President Trump” by voting to impeach him.
At the same time, the Democratic National Committee chair lauded those who voted for impeachment. “Those who voted for impeachment will be remembered for their courage and commitment to protecting our democracy,” said DNC chair Tom Perez.
Republicans and Democrats have stuck with tried and tested talking points, with the former continuing to cast the process as a “sham” and the latter repeating that House Dems had a constitutional responsibility to see the impeachment through.
Updated
Donald Trump is the third US president to be impeached. The moment offered a surreal split screen — as the president railed against Democrats at a rally, they cast their votes against him.
Here’s a recap of the day, in pictures:
Representative Debbie Dingell responded to Trump’s attacks against her and her late husband, writing that his “hurtful words just made my healing much harder”.
Mr. President, let’s set politics aside. My husband earned all his accolades after a lifetime of service. I’m preparing for the first holiday season without the man I love. You brought me down in a way you can never imagine and your hurtful words just made my healing much harder.
— Rep. Debbie Dingell (@RepDebDingell) December 19, 2019
Dingell is a Democrat from Michigan, where Trump is holding a campaign rally tonight.
What's next?
Now that Donald Trump has been impeached, it’s up to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi what happens next. Responding to questions from reporters, Pelosi wouldn’t say when she plans on sending the impeachment articles to the Senate, which is required to hold a trial to decide whether to remove the president from office.
“We’ll see what happens over there,” Pelosi said at her news conference, referring to the Senate. She said House Democrats would decide as “a group” when to send the articles over and name impeachment managers — House members who will make their case in the Senate trial.
Mitch McConnell, the Senate leader, said he will address the impeachment at 9:30 AM EST tomorrow morning.
At 9:30am tomorrow morning, on the Senate floor, I will speak about House Democrats’ precedent-breaking impeachment of the President of the United States.
— Leader McConnell (@senatemajldr) December 19, 2019
Updated
Speaking at his campaign rally, Donald Trump said he regretted that Debbie Dingell, a Democratic representative from Michigan, voted to impeach him even though he allowed a state funeral to proceed for her late husband and have him “the A+ treatment”.
Trump also suggested John Dingell may be “looking up” from hell.
Trump laments that Debbie Dingell voted to impeach him despite the fact that he allowed the normal state funeral to proceed for her late husband, former Rep. John Dingell. Trump then suggests John Dingell is in hell -- to audible groans. pic.twitter.com/wsYfddNIA9
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) December 19, 2019
2020 Democratic candidates laud impeachment
Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren indicated they were ready to take up the torch in the senate.
Donald Trump has abused our diplomatic relationships and undermined our national security for his own personal, political gain. By voting to impeach him, the House has taken an important step to hold him accountable. I'm ready to fulfill my constitutional duty in the Senate.
— Elizabeth Warren (@ewarren) December 19, 2019
A trial in the Senate. Mitch McConnell must conduct a full and fair trial to hold this president accountable. https://t.co/GItUvoLbQe
— Bernie Sanders (@BernieSanders) December 19, 2019
Michael Bloomberg said the House “did its duty under the Constitution,” but added that “unfortunately, it increasingly appears that Senate Republicans will not. The issue won’t be settled until November, by the American people.”
Julian Castro suggested that Mitch McConnell should recuse himself from the Senate trial. “The Senate should do its constitutional duty. Remove Donald Trump from office,” he said.
Pete Buttigieg expressed similar sentiments. “Our lawmakers take an oath not to party but to country,” he said. “That oath is all the more important in the most difficult of times.
Our lawmakers take an oath not to party but to country. That oath is all the more important in the most difficult of times.
— Pete Buttigieg (@PeteButtigieg) December 19, 2019
Today it required Congress to defend the rule of law, our national security, and our democracy from a president who puts his own interests above America's.
Pelosi evaded questions on whether she would commit to sending articles to Senate
Nancy Pelosi would not definitively commit to sending over the articles of impeachment or naming impeachment managers.
“We cannot name managers until we see what the process is on the Senate side,” she said. “So far we haven’t seen anything that looks fair to us.”
Senate leader Mitch McConnell is “in cahoots with the lawyers of the accused,” Pelosi said, but she did not say how exactly a fair Senate trial would look .
Withholding the articles could give Pelosi some leverage over the trial as she pushes McConnell to call more witnesses.
Updated
Adam Schiff: ‘Will the Senate uphold its duty?’
“The question is whether the majority leader will allow a fair trial,” Shiff said, having seen the impeachment inquiry he led come to a close. “We have done our duty in the House, we have upheld the constitution. The question now is will the senate uphold its duty?”
He urged senators to call more witnesses and demand to see documents that the president has withheld. “The president not only abused his office but threatens to abuse it again,” Schiff said.
House Committee Chairmen are joining me to speak live from the U.S. Capitol following today’s historic vote to #DefendOurDemocracy. https://t.co/7XKdmQaJew
— Nancy Pelosi (@SpeakerPelosi) December 19, 2019
Nancy Pelosi said today is a “sad day” for the country. “The president’s reckless activities necessitated us having to introduce articles of impeachment,” she said, before thanking the various House committee leaders who spearheaded the impeachment inquiry.
House Judiciary chair Jerrold Nadler added that the “no one, not even the president is above the law”.
Updated
Donald Trump continued to speak at a campaign rally in Battle Creek, Michigan as a majority of the House voted to pass both articles of impeachment.
“The do-nothing Democrats are declaring their deep hatred and disdain for the American people,” he told the crowd. “This lawless partisan impeachment is a political suicide march for the Democrat party.”
In a statement, Trump’s press secretary Stephanie Grisham said the president is “confident the Senate will restore regular order, fairness, and due process, all of which were ignored in the House proceedings”.
“He is prepared for the next steps and confident that he will be fully exonerated,” she said.
Second article of impeachment passes
The House has now passed the second article of impeachment, which is obstruction of Congress. The final vote was 229-198, with only Democratic congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard voting “present.”
Trump has been impeached on both abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, and the two articles will now taken up by the Senate in a trial to determine whether he should be removed from office.
It is widely expected the president will be acquitted by the Republican-controlled Senate, but the importance of this moment cannot be understated.
A majority of the House of representatives has declared that Trump has abused his power and obstructed Congress, and he will go down in history as only the third US president to ever be impeached.
Democratic congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard, who voted “present” on both articles of impeachment, has issued a statement explaining her stance, which will certainly prove controversial with the rest of her caucus.
Here’s her statement pic.twitter.com/Ky948XxILC
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) December 19, 2019
“After doing my due diligence in reviewing the 658-page impeachment report, I came to the conclusion that I could not in good conscience vote either yes or no,” Gabbard said in the statement.
This moment is quickly going viral. After the first article of impeachment officially passed, speaker Nancy Pelosi appeared to shush the House Democrats who started to applaud.
The glare Pelosi gave her caucus when some Dems started to clap after she announced the first article of impeachment passed pic.twitter.com/8vONZlEyZ3
— Peter Stevenson (@PeterWStevenson) December 19, 2019
Pelosi has emphasized throughout the day that this is a “sad” occasion, and the speaker reportedly instructed her caucus not to appear celebratory of the inevitable result.
Majority of House backs second article
A majority of the House of representatives has now voted in favor of the second article of impeachment, obstruction of Congress, after passing the first article, abuse of power.
The vote is not final until speaker Nancy Pelosi gavels it in, but the tally is currently 221-165, with only Tulsi Gabbard voting present.
Three House Democrats -- Jeff Van Drew, Collin Peterson and Jared Golden -- have voted “no” on the second article of impeachment, which is obstruction of Congress.
Democratic congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard voted “present,” as she did on the first article of impeachment.
Vote underway on second article of impeachment
With Nancy Pelosi presiding over the House, the speaker called for a vote on the second article of impeachment, which is obstruction of Congress.
This vote will go much the same as the first, with one notable exception: Democratic congressman Jared Golden has said he will vote “no” on this article, despite supporting the first article.
Members have five minutes to cast their ballots.
Trump becomes third president in US history to be impeached
The House has passed the first article of impeachment against Trump, abuse of power, by a vote of 230-197.
Donald Trump is officially the third president in US history to be impeached by the House.
The members will now move on to the second article of impeachment, which is obstruction of Congress.
Speaker Nancy Pelosi turned in a green “yes” card moments ago, casting her ballot in favor of the first article of impeachment.
at 8:21 pm, Pelosi grabbed a green card -- green is the yes card -- and handed her ballot to one of the House clerks.
— Paul Kane (@pkcapitol) December 19, 2019
She has voted to impeach Trump.
After much speculation as to whether she was even going to participate in the vote, congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard, who is seeking the Democratic presidential nomination, has voted “present” on the first article of impeachment.
Majority of House members vote for first article of impeachment
A majority of House members have now voted “yes” on the first article of impeachment, but it is not official until the end of the vote is called.
The vote is currently 219-164.
Updated
Congressman Collin Peterson has now voted “no” on the first article of impeachment, becoming only the second (and likely last) House Democrat to oppose the article.
Congressman Ron Kind, who avoided stating publicly whether he would support impeachment, has voted “yes,” as has congressman Jared Golden.
Golden, a Democrat from Maine, announced yesterday that he would support the first article of impeachment, but not the second, so his vote will switch to a “no” when that article is taken up.
As expected, congressman Jeff Van Drew, the Democrat who is expected to switch parties after the impeachment vote and has spent the day on the Republican side of the aisle, has voted “no” on the first article of impeachment.
Democratic congressman Collin Peterson is also likely to vote “no,” but every other House Democrat is expected to support the first article, which is abuse of power.
Vote underway on first article of impeachment
More than 11 hours after the start of today’s impeachment hearings, the vote is now underway on the first article of impeachment against Trump, which is abuse of power.
House members will have 15 minutes to cast their votes, and many are choosing to do it by hand rather than electronically.
LOTS of lawmakers are voting by hand — a way to preserve their vote in the House archives.
— Jake Sherman (@JakeSherman) December 19, 2019
This will take exponentially longer than voting by electronic device, which they are also permitted to do
Meanwhile, Donald Trump, speaking at his campaign rally in Michigan said, “By the way, it doesn’t really feel like we’re being impeached.”
“We did nothing wrong and we have tremendous support in the Republican party like we’ve never had before,” he said.
Updated
Impeachment debate concludes
Adam Schiff, the chairman of the House intelligence committee, has concluded his remarks, wrapping up the debate on the impeachment resolution.
The chamber has now moved on to a vote on the two articles of impeachment.
Schiff delivers final remarks
Minority leader Kevin McCarthy has concluded his floor speech, and intelligence committee chairman Adam Schiff is now delivering the final remarks of the impeachment debate.
Schiff accused his Republican colleagues of spending their debate time spewing a lot of “sound and fury signifying nothing.” But the chairman said the Republican argument boiled down to this question: “Why should we care what the president did to Ukraine?”
Schiff went on to say America should care about the plight of its allies, particularly a struggling democracy like Ukraine.
He also encouraged his Republican colleagues to consider the precedent it would set if the House did not impeach Trump, warning it could signal presidents can just ignore congressional oversight.
Minority leader Kevin McCarthy accused Democrats of acquiescing to their “new socialist base” in pursuing the impeachment of Trump.
“It didn’t have to be this way. Is this why we came here to serve? To trample on due process rights? To issue more subpoenas than laws? To appease the new Democrat-socialist base?” McCarthy said.
“Fortunately, the people will have the opportunity to speak up and render their verdict in 11 short months,” the California Republican continued. “To my fellow Americans -- If you approve of the way this House has conducted its business -- if you want to see your tax dollars go towards endless investigations -- support impeachment.
“But if you want to restore a working Congress -- like the previous Congress that listened to you and worked to bring the best economy this country has ever seen and will once again work with the President to get things done for you and your family -- then join Republicans in rejecting this baseless impeachment. That’s what’s wonderful about this system of ours: we are a government of, by, and for the people.”
House minority leader Kevin McCarthy opened his floor speech by sharing a fact that Democrats will “hate to hear”: “Donald J. Trump is president of the United States,” prompting cheers from his Republican caucus.
“He is president today, he will be president tomorrow and he will be president when this impeachment is over,” McCarthy said.
“Here is our choice tonight,” McCarthy continued, “Will we let impeachment become an exercise of raw political power, regardless if it damages our country? Or will we protect the proper grounds and process for impeachment now and in the future?”
Majority leader Steny Hoyer has concluded his floor speech, and congressman Doug Collins, the top Republican on the House judiciary committee, is now delivering some remarks.
The final two speakers are expected to be minority leader Kevin McCarthy and intelligence committee chairman Adam Schiff.
In his floor speech, majority leader Steny Hoyer praised congressman Justin Amash, who left the Republican Party over his opposition to Trump.
Amash spoke on the floor earlier today, encouraging his colleagues to vote in favor of impeachment for the sake of the country.
“We need not ask who will be the first to show courage by standing up to President Trump,” Hoyer said. “The question we must now ask is who will be the last to find it.”
House Republicans have repeatedly jeered Steny Hoyer as the majority leader delivers his floor speech presenting Democrats’ position on the impeachment resolution.
"Democrats did not want this impeachment. We did not push it," @LeaderHoyer said.
— Ben Siegel (@benyc) December 19, 2019
"Oh, come on!" someone yelled from the GOP side of the chamber.
Trump arrives in Michigan for a campaign rally
As the impeachment debate rolls toward a final vote, Donald Trump has arrived in Michigan, where he is holding a campaign rally tonight.
Upon deboarding his plane, the president did not speak to the press, signaling that he was doing “good,” as he waved off questions.
Trump disembarked from his airplane in Michigan just before 7pm and stood for awhile on a snowy tarmac talking with local mucketys.
— Tom McCarthy (@TeeMcSee) December 18, 2019
To a shouted question from reporters asking how he was feeling, Trump said, “Good.”
He did issue a statement on the Affordable Care Act ruling earlier today, reassuring that “this decision will not alter the current healthcare system.”
Besides posting an all-caps tweet decrying “atrocious lies by the radical left” several hours ago, Trump has remained relatively quiet on impeachment today.
Members of Congress may begin voting on articles of impeachment against Trump as he takes the rally podium.
Updated
Democratic majority leader Steny Hoyer acknowledged the 63 million people who voted for Trump in 2016 but quickly nodded to the 65 million who voted for Hillary Clinton, appearing to prompt some cheers from the Democratic side of the aisle.
The Maryland Democrat also reminded his Republican colleagues that he and the speaker, Nancy Pelosi, resisted the idea of impeachment for months, until the whistleblower complaint on the Ukraine controversy emerged.
The most senior Democrats and Republicans in the House are now delivering their floor speeches, indicating the debate on the impeachment resolution is winding down.
House minority whip Steve Scalise has just finished speaking, and majority leader Steny Hoyer has now taken the mic. Minority leader Kevin McCarthy also tweeted he would soon speak on the floor.
I'm heading to the House floor now to say something my Democrat colleagues hate to hear:
— Kevin McCarthy (@GOPLeader) December 19, 2019
Donald J. Trump is President.
He is President today. He will be President tomorrow. And he will be President when this impeachment is over.
Watch live here: https://t.co/Pk4jPUtJIS
Congressman Steve Scalise, the House minority whip, has been granted five minutes to criticize the impeachment resolution as the floor debate begins to wind down.
The Louisiana Republican accused Democrats of pursuing a “political vendetta” against Trump with their impeachment inquiry, which he said only stemmed from their “fear that he might win reelection.”
“They made up these terms to impeach a president because they couldn’t find any crimes,” Scalise said, claiming the Democrats “hated” the 63 million Americans who voted for Trump.
That last comment sparked boos from the Democratic side of the aisle and some cheers from Scalise’s Republican colleagues.
Doug Collins, the Republican congressman coordinating his caucus’ floor speeches, asked Adam Schiff whether the Democrats had concluded their side of the debate, but the House intelligence committee chairman said they still had a few speakers remaining.
The hearing has now been underway for 10 hours, and the vote on the articles of impeachment is expected in the next hour.
Meanwhile, Trump is expected to take the stage at his campaign rally in Michigan at any moment.
On a historic day for America …
Soon, Donald Trump faces an impeachment vote in the House. This vote marks the latest twist in one of the most turbulent presidencies in US history.
But the challenges to American democracy do not end today. Over the last three years, much of what we hold dear has been threatened – democracy, civility, truth. The need for a robust, independent press has never been greater.
2020 promises to be an epic year – and could define the country for a generation. With your help we will continue to provide fact-based reporting that offers public scrutiny and oversight.
We’re asking our US readers to help us raise $1.5m by early January to support our journalism. We hope you’ll consider making a year-end gift.
We also want to say a huge thank you to everyone who has supported the Guardian in 2019. You provide us with the motivation and financial support to keep doing what we do.
Congresswoman Liz Cheney, the chairwoman of the House Republican conference, was allowed four minutes to condemn the impeachment resolution, more time than almost any of her colleagues.
The Wyoming Republican claimed Democrats had presented “no direct evidence of any impeachable offense” and warned Trump’s impeachment could set a dangerous precedent.
Cheney urged her colleagues on both sides of the aisle to vote “no” on the articles of impeachment to honor the Constitution and their oath of office.
Congressman Drew Ferguson, a Georgia Republican, condemned the impeachment resolution, calling it a “goat rodeo” and a “sham.”
Rep. Drew Ferguson: "This whole flippin' goat rodeo is a sham and a shame, and it will not be forgotten" https://t.co/FksAmxCiem pic.twitter.com/lGNvjpVCsl
— CBS News (@CBSNews) December 18, 2019
Another poll shows sharp divide on impeachment
As the House debate continues on the impeachment resolution, another poll has been released showing the country is evenly divided on whether Trump should be removed from office.
According to the NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll, 48% of Americans favor the president’s impeachment and removal from office, while 48% oppose it.
Trump and his allies have taken to claiming in recent days that support for impeachment is sharply declining. In reality, support for the president’s impeachment has been virtually unmoved since the inquiry’s public hearings started.
Congressman Devin Nunes, the top Republican on the House intelligence committee, accused Democrats of cooking up baseless allegations against Trump to make up for their loss in the 2016 election.
“The only thing that Donald Trump is guilty of is beating Hillary Clinton,” the California Republican said.
Nunes went on to slam his Democratic colleagues for “ripping the country apart ... in their lust for power.”
Echoing dozens of his colleagues, congressman Jim Jordan argued Democrats only pursued impeachment to punish Trump for his allaged success in office.
“When you drain the swamp, the swamp fights back,” the president’s House ally said.
It also appears congressman Devin Nunes, the top Republican on the House intelligence committee, will get the chance to weigh in on the floor.
NUNES is in the House, appears to be ready to speak. Rs are calling the president's top defenders now. We just ticked through Meadows, Jordan, Zeldin, Ratcliffe.
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney) December 18, 2019
After two more of Trump’s House allies, Mark Meadows and John Ratcliffe, spoke in opposition to the impeachment resolution, Adam Schiff predicted history would remember his Republican colleagues poorly.
Rep. Adam Schiff: "I think when the history of this time is written, it will record that when my colleagues found that they lacked the courage to stand up to this unethical president, they consoled themselves by attacking those who did" https://t.co/FksAmxCiem pic.twitter.com/6u0UqfVBEF
— CBS News (@CBSNews) December 18, 2019
“I think when the history of this time is written, it will record that when my colleagues found that they lacked the courage to stand up to this unethical president, they consoled themselves by attacking those who did,” Schiff said.
This condemnation was met by audible groans on the Republican side of the aisle.
Congressman Lee Zeldin, a close House ally of Trump’s, was given three minutes to criticize the impeachment resolution, a relatively lengthy window given most of his colleagues who have spoken in this hour of the debate were only allowed 30 seconds.
Zeldin directed most of his ire at Adam Schiff, accusing the intelligence committee chairman of “cherry-picking” facts and “misleading” the American public.
He concluded by encouraging his colleagues to vote “no” on impeachment. “It’s a total Schiff show,” Zeldin concluded, appearing to prompt a chuckle from the Democratic chairman.
Schiff mocks Republicans for ignoring substance of allegations against Trump
Adam Schiff interrupted the string of short floor speeches to argue his Republican colleagues are unable to address the accusations against Trump, claiming the president’s allies are only able to come up with “process” complaints about the impeachment inquiry.
Schiff’s comments prompted grumbling on the Republican side of the aisle. “Apparently, Madame Speaker, I’ve struck a nerve,” Schiff said.
He went on to say of Trump’s actions toward Ukraine, “They don’t want to defend that conduct. ... What they can’t say is that this president’s conduct was ethical.”
“Auntie Maxine” is now trending on Twitter after congresswoman Maxine Waters delivered her floor speech in favor of the impeachment resolution.
Rep. Maxine Waters: "History will remember those who were willing to speak truth to power. Yes, I called for Trump's impeachment early. This is our country. Our foremothers and our forefathers shed their blood to build and defend this democracy." https://t.co/aIxGsVpGpq pic.twitter.com/BygKolJBAP
— This Week (@ThisWeekABC) December 18, 2019
“This day was not inevitable, but it was predictable,” Waters said, “because this president has shown himself time and time again to believe that he is above the law and he has no respect for our Constitution or our democracy.”
Time check: there is a little over an hour remaining in the impeachment debate, but Republicans have about 43 minutes left compared to the Democrats’ 29 minutes.
Meanwhile, even reporters from Hawaiian outlets have been unable to determine whether one of their representatives, Democratic congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard, will participate in tonight’s impeachment vote.
These are not hard questions. I'm just trying to find out if a sitting congresswoman who represents a district that I cover will take part in a historic vote to impeach a sitting president.
— Nick Grube (@nickgrube) December 18, 2019
The fact that I can't get a "yes" or "no" answer is, to say the least, astounding.
Gabbard was not present for this morning’s procedural votes, and the presidential candidate proposed yesterday that Democrats censure Trump rather than impeaching him.
If Gabbard does appear, it’s unclear how she will vote on the two articles of impeachment.
Updated
One Republican cingressman suggested the House should consider the removal of Nancy Pelosi, prompting a laugh from the speaker.
GOP Rep. Ralph Abraham (who floated a motion to remove Pelosi as speaker during his failed bid for LA governor a few months back) says her removal should, again, be considered
— Sam Brodey (@sambrodey) December 18, 2019
Pelosi, sitting near the back row of the chamber, lets out a little laugh.
An appeals court rules a key provision of the Affordable Care Act unconstitutional
While lawmakers on Capitol Hill are preoccupied with impeachment, a federal judge dropped a long-awaited decision on healthcare, ruling that the Obamacare mandate requiring Americans to buy coverage is unconstitutional but declining to rule on whether the entire Affordable Care Act is valid.
The decision doesn’t have much immediate impact, because Congress already repealed the penalty for those who don’t buy insurance. But the court delayed any decision on whether the entire ACA is unconstitutional because of the mandate, leaving it to a district court to “provide additional analysis of the provisions of the ACA as they currently exist.”
In 2018, a group of Republican-led states filed a lawsuit arguing that individual mandate repeal meant that the entire law should be town down. The Fifth Circut agreed, but the decision was appealed by Democratic state attorneys, including California.
California’s attorney general Xavier Becerra said he will challenge today’s ruling as well.
RE: the #ACA decision.
— Xavier Becerra (@AGBecerra) December 18, 2019
For now, Pres Trump got the gift he wanted—uncertainty in the healthcare system & a pathway to repeal—so that the care that seniors, workers & families secured under the ACA could be yanked from under them.
CA will move swiftly to challenge this decision.
The ruling thrusts the debate of the Affordable Care Act, and its many provisions including protections for people with preexisting medical conditions, back into the national spotlight as the 2020 elections approach.
Updated
Congresswoman Maxine Waters, the chairwoman of the House financial service committee, argued the impeachment resolution would allow “justice” to be served.
Quoting Maya Angelou, Waters said of the president, “When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time.”
Congresswoman Abigail Spanberger, another Virginia Democrat whose district backed Trump in 2016, has also just taken the floor to explain her support for the impeachment resolution.
Spanberger and Elaine Luria, who spoke shortly before her, are two of the vulnerable freshman Democrats who signed a Washington Post op-ed in September asserting Trump’s alleged actions toward Ukraine constituted impeachable behavior.
Congresswoman Elaine Luria, a Virginia Democrat whose district backed Trump by 3 points in 2016, has just finished delivering her floor speech explaining her support for impeachment.
Luria said she spoke today “in support of our Constitution” and the oath she first took at 17, when she entered the naval academy.
The congresswoman said she stood on the House floor with the “resolve to do what is right and not what is politically expedient.”
Several House Republicans actually booed just now as Adam Schiff was challenging their defenses of the president, a first for this historic day in Congress.
Several Republicans are BOOING Schiff on the floor right now. First time I've seen it all day.
— Sarah Ferris (@sarahnferris) December 18, 2019
One Dem in the back of the chamber shouts "Yay!" after Schiff finishes his argument.
Pelosi to hold press conference after impeachment vote
Speaker Nancy Pelosi has announced she and the committe chairs who led the impeachment inquiry would hold a press conference tonight, following the expected passage of the articles of impeachment.
UPDATE: PELOSI will hold a press conference with House committee chairs after passage of articles of impeachment tonight. pic.twitter.com/6VSWlQHU2c
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney) December 18, 2019
Updated
Before Trump departed the White House for his campaign rally in Michigan, some of his advisers -- including his daugher, Ivanka Trump -- were spotted in the Oval Office, sitting near a poster showing the 2016 election results by acreage.
Spotted in the Oval Office before Trump's departure, by @abdallahcnn: Ivanka Trump, Dan Scavino, a framed map of the 2016 election results and Stephen Miller. (Not really that unusual.) pic.twitter.com/4PbTxipx4T
— Kaitlan Collins (@kaitlancollins) December 18, 2019
Earlier today, a judge dismissed Paul Manafort’s state charges -- undermining New York prosecutors’ attempts to ensure jail time for Trump’s former campaign chair, despite a potential presidential pardon.
Manafort is currently serving a 7.5 year prison sentence after being convicted in federal court on charges stemming from special counsel Robert Mueller III’s Russia probe. The Manhattan district attorney additionally charged Manafort, 70, with mortgage fraud and more than a dozen other state felonies.
Manafort’s lawyers argued that the state charges should be dismissed because they overlapped with his federal charges. A state judge in Manhattan agreed. “Basically, the law of double jeopardy in New York State provides a very narrow window for prosecution,” he said, before submitting his decision to dismiss the charges.
Manafort, 70, did not appear in court. He was hospitalized last week after a cardiac health issue.
Congressman Matt Gaetz, one of the president’s closest House allies, has taken the floor, and he has come out swinging.
“This is not about Ukraine; this is about power,” the Florida Republican said. “Donald Trump has it, and Democrats want it.”
Gaetz accused the Democrats of “adhering to no sense of honor” in their handling of the impeachment inquiry, claiming his colleagues on the left have “plotted and planned” Trump’s removal since his inauguration.
Gaetz called the impeachment resolution a “slap in the face” to the Americans who voted for Trump and argued Democrats were merely looking for an “insurance policy” because they cannot defeat Trump.
“But we have an insurance policy, too,” Gaetz said. “It’s the next election, and we intend to win it.”
Time check: congresswoman Diana DeGette, who is presiding over the impeachment proceedings, said two hours remain in the impeachment debate.
Democrats and Republicans each have another hour to make their cases, although the Republican caucus has about six minutes more in their remaining time than their Democratic counterparts.
Trump is on his way to a campaign rally in Michigan, ignoring reporters’ questions about today’s impeachment proceedings as he left the White House.
On day of #impeachment , @realDonaldTrump walks past reporters without taking questions. pic.twitter.com/RLEatOx64n
— Jeff Mason (@jeffmason1) December 18, 2019
The rally is scheduled to begin at 7pm ET, which means Trump could be speaking to his supporters when he becomes the third president in US history to be impeached.
Updated
Congressman Justin Amash, who left the Republican Party over his opposition to Trump, was given two minutes by the Democrats to make a floor speech in favor of impeachment.
“I come to this floor, not as a Republican, not as a Democrat, but as an American,” Amash said.
The Michigan lawmaker went on to argue House members have a duty to vote in favor of the impeachment resolution. “Impeachment is about maintaining the integrity of the office of the presidency,” Amash said.
Adam Schiff mocked a talking point from his Republican colleagues, who have repeatedly slammed the “secretive” nature of the impeachment inquiry.
Specifically, Republicans have complained about the House committees leading the inquiry holding meetings in a basement “bunker,” referring to the room in the Capitol where lawmakers receive classified information.
“This is apparently what they call depositions,” Schiff joked.
Congressman John Lewis, a civil rights icon who marched alongside Martin Luther King, called on his colleagues to support impeachment, arguing they have a “moral obligation to say something, to do something.”
Dem. Rep. John Lewis on impeachment: "For some, this vote may be hard. But we have a mission and a mandate to be on the right side of history." https://t.co/hGjla0XsST pic.twitter.com/gpkMHCoI8B
— ABC News (@ABC) December 18, 2019
“We didn’t ask for this,” Lewis said. “Our nation is founded on the principle that we do not have kings, we have presidents, and the Constituion is our compass.”
Lewis asserted the House had “a mission and a mandate to be on the right side of history.” The Georgia Democrat predicted future generations would ask this question: “What did you do?”
Updated
All Republicans expected to vote 'no' on impeachment
Republican congressman Francis Rooney, who had said he was open to supporting impeachment, has officially announced he will vote “no” tonight, virtually ensuring every House Republican will oppose the resolution.
Its official: Francis Rooney is a NO on impeachment. Expect unity from gop on vote tonight pic.twitter.com/lTmzZJElxQ
— Alana Abramson (@aabramson) December 18, 2019
“Based on the limited evidence provided to the House of Representatives, the President’s behavior, while inappropriate, was neither criminal, nor does it rise to the level of justifying impeachment,” Rooney said in a statement explaining his decision.
A Republican congressman, Bill Johnson, just used his floor speech to hold a moment of silence for the 63 million Americans who backed Trump in 2016, whose votes are supposedly being ignored in the impeachment inquiry.
.@RepBillJohnson used his time to hold a moment of silence for the House to "pause for a moment and remember the voices of the 63 million American voters the Democrats today are wanting to silence."
— Ben Siegel (@benyc) December 18, 2019
(All Republicans in the chamber stood up, Democrats remained seated.)
Of course, that 63 million figure is almost 3 million votes fewer than Hillary Clinton received in 2016.
Congressman Justin Amash, who left the Republican Party over his opposition to Trump and has become a vocal supporter of impeachment, has asked Democrats for two minutes to deliver a floor speech.
A senior Democratic aide says that Rep. Justin Amash has asked for time to speak, and will be given two minutes to talk on the impeachment debate and will speak soon.
— Siobhan Hughes (@siobhanehughes) December 18, 2019
Adam Schiff used his floor speech to detail the allegations against Trump and warn that Congress would set a dangerous precedent if members did not vote to impeach him.
“If the president’s conduct isn’t impeachable, then nothing is impeachable,” Schiff said.
The intelligence committee chairman also quoted Alexander Hamilton’s warning of a leader who is “unprincipled in private life, desperate in his fortune, bold in his temper,” who would “throw things into confusion” and “may ride the storm and direct the whirlwind.”
Schiff takes over from Nadler to oversee Democrats' floor speeches
Adam Schiff, the Democratic chairman of the House intelligence committee, has taken over from Jerry Nadler to oversee Democrats’ floor speeches in the impeachment debate.
“I rise to support the impeachment of Donald J Trump,” Schiff said upon taking the floor.
The handoff from Nadler to Schiff indicates we are halfway through the floor debate, with three hours remaining.
Nadler and Gohmert clash on the floor
Congressman Louie Gohmert, a fervent defender of Trump’s, used his floor speech to peddle baseless claims against Ukraine.
Rep. Louie Gohmert: "This country's end is now in sight. I hope I don't live to see it." https://t.co/FksAmxCiem pic.twitter.com/UkxVg1A1Ka
— CBS News (@CBSNews) December 18, 2019
When the floor was turned over to Jerry Nadler, the judiciary committee chairman said, “I’m deeply concerned that any member of the House would spew Russian propaganda on the floor of the House.”
Gohmert could be heard shouting back at Nadler from the floor, but his objections were drowned out by congresswoman Diana DeGette, who is presiding over the debate, banging her gavel.
Gohmert then walked over to Nadler and appeared to be angrily confronting him, although Nadler said few words in response.
Congressman Will Hurd, a retiring Republican who was once viewed as a potential impeachment supporter by Democrats, used his floor speech to condemn the “rushed process” of the inquiry, so his “no” vote is secured.
It’s still unclear how many votes will be needed to pass the articles of impeachment because the number depends on how many members participate in the vote, as a Fox News reporter noted.
B) The nbr to impeach is organic, depending on how many members vote. But, we should wait until the measures cross the 216 vote threshold since there are 431 members in the House. 213-214 may be the magic nbr. Official total is what the chair announces. Not what's on the screen
— Chad Pergram (@ChadPergram) December 18, 2019
On a historic day for America …
In a matter of hours, Donald Trump faces an impeachment vote in the House. This vote marks the latest twist in one of the most turbulent presidencies in US history.
But the challenges to American democracy do not end today. Over the last three years, much of what we hold dear has been threatened – democracy, civility, truth. The need for a robust, independent press has never been greater.
2020 promises to be an epic year – and could define the country for a generation. With your help we will continue to provide fact-based reporting that offers public scrutiny and oversight.
We’re asking our US readers to help us raise $1.5m by early January to support our journalism. We hope you’ll consider making a year-end gift.
We also want to say a huge thank you to everyone who has supported the Guardian in 2019. You provide us with the motivation and financial support to keep doing what we do.
Speaker Nancy Pelosi has spent much of the afternoon sitting on the House floor, listening to members’ speeches about the impeachment resolution.
Pelosi has sat in the back of the chamber for some time now. Occasionally a representative will stop by a chat for a few moments. For awhile she sat alone, now she's been joined by a staff member.
— Sarah D. Wire (@sarahdwire) December 18, 2019
But for the most part she has sat silently and listened to the speeches.
Julián Castro didn’t qualify for the Democratic presidential debate in Los Angeles this week, but the former housing secretary is still making stops in LA. This morning, he took a tour of Skid Row with activists and talked with homeless people about the worsening crisis in California.
His visit comes as Trump has repeatedly threatened to launch some kind of police crackdown on homeless people living on the streets of LA and San Francisco.
“The administration has decided to take an approach of essentially criminalizing people who are homeless,” Castro said. “This is the wrong thing to do ... The administration is going backwards.”
@JulianCastro won’t be at the debate in LA tomorrow but he is here talking with homeless folks living at Skid Row. pic.twitter.com/fTP7TnzPpk
— Sam Levin (@SamTLevin) December 18, 2019
“We cannot accept criminalizing poverty,” he said. “That is morally wrong.”
Castro visited the Downtown Women’s Center at Skid Row, which is the epicenter of the housing crisis in southern California.
“The stereotype of homelessness is a single man, but we know that doesn’t reflect the reality out there today. Unfortunately there are many women and children and families,” Castro said.
As he walked through tent encampments with a trail of reporters tagging along, some living on the street ran up to shake his hand and give hugs.
“You need to get us housing, that’s what y’all need to do!” one person shouted at Castro.
“Stop filming and help us!” said another.
Castro and senator Cory Booker both failed to qualify for the final debate of the year, which will take place in LA on Thursday night.
The White House appears to be delivering Trump’s six-page letter to Nancy Pelosi to Senate offices, along with a pair of Christmas cards.
True story: there is a White House staffer going around the Senate delivering to each office, as a package, the incoherent, scathing Pelosi letter AND...wait for it...a giant 16x12 White House Christmas card (along with, implausibly, a second smaller Christmas card).
— Chris Murphy (@ChrisMurphyCT) December 18, 2019
What a day. pic.twitter.com/y8gZuQbipl
Trump sent the furious letter to Pelosi yesterday, calling impeachment an “unprecedented and unconstitutional abuse of power by Democrat Lawmakers, unequaled in nearly two and a half centuries of American legislative history.”
Democrats and Republicans each have about an hour and 45 minutes left in their debate time, meaning three and a half hours of debate remain before members will turn to a vote on the articles of impeachment.
Some House Democrats are reportedly urging speaker Nancy Pelosi to withhold the articles of impeachment against Trump in the hope of gaining leverage in a Senate trial.
The Washington Post reports:
The notion of impeaching Trump but holding the articles in the House has gained traction among some of the political left as a way of potentially forcing Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) to conduct a trial on more favorable terms for Democrats. And if no agreement is reached, some have argued, the trial could be delayed indefinitely, denying Trump an expected acquittal.
The gambit has gained some traction inside the left wing of the House Democratic Caucus this week. Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-Ore.) said Wednesday, as his colleagues debated the impeachment articles on the House floor, that he has spoken to three dozen Democratic lawmakers who had expressed some level of enthusiasm for the idea of ‘rounding out the record and spending the time to do this right.’ ...
Republicans have scoffed at the notion of the House withholding the articles, noting it hardly counts as leverage to deny the GOP the ability to remove a president that the party wants to keep in place. Some aides further argued that withholding the articles would only fuel Republican arguments that Democrats are engaged in a partisan abuse of the Constitution.
Giving an interview in the White House briefing room, senior Trump adviser Kellyanne Conway accused Nancy Pelosi of making the impeachment inquiry “personal,” claiming the House speaker threw a “hissy fit” when she met with the president in the cabinet room.
.@KellyannePolls says @SpeakerPelosi has made impeachment very personal and says she has left meetings at the White House in a “hissy fit”. pic.twitter.com/pv4lgcss5H
— Jeff Mason (@jeffmason1) December 18, 2019
Congressman Mike Kelly has just compared today’s impeachment vote to Pearl Harbor, predicting Dec. 18 would be “another date that will live in infamy,” referring to FDR’s famous quote about Dec. 7, 1941.
Kelly’s comparison adds to a growing list of inappropriate references Trump’s Republican allies have made to lament the president’s impeachment, including the crucifixion of Jesus and the Salem witch trials.
At least two more House members, Democrat Jose Serrano and Republican John Shimkus, will not be present for today’s impeachment vote, slightly lowering the threshold needed to approve the articles of impeachment.
Statement from Rep Jose Serrano (D-NY) on missing the impeachment votes today: pic.twitter.com/5nkVumWW9D
— Alex Moe (@AlexNBCNews) December 18, 2019
Stmt from GOP Rep Shimkus on missing today’s votes:
— Alex Moe (@AlexNBCNews) December 18, 2019
"Long before today’s votes were scheduled, my wife Karen and I made arrangements to visit our son Joshua in Tanzania where he’s serving in the Peace Corps."
Full stmt below: pic.twitter.com/mdrRMEpZCa
But it’s still unclear whether Democratic congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard, who is running for president and missed this morning’s procedural votes, will participate.
Gabbard, who has been harshly critical of some of her presidential primary opponents, called for Trump’s censure yesterday, and it’s unclear how she will vote on the articles of impeachment if she appears on Capitol Hill.
House members were just told a little more than four hours remain in the impeachment debate, so the chamber appears to be on schedule for a final vote between 7 p.m. and 8 p.m. E.T.
Little more than four hours of debate to go (you'll notice that this does not mean four hours on the clock, since it's taken roughly 2.5 hours to conduct the first 2 hours)
— Jeremy Herb (@jeremyherb) December 18, 2019
Republican congressman Barry Loudermilk just made a comparison between the Trump impeachment inquiry and the trial of Jesus in the Bible, shockingly arguing Pontius Pilate was more fair to Jesus than Democrats have been to the president.
Rep. Loudermilk: "When Jesus was falsely accused of treason, Pontius Pilate gave Jesus the opportunity to face his accusers." pic.twitter.com/HqlRYFMIaN
— Josh Marshall (@joshtpm) December 18, 2019
Updated
Congressman Steve Chabot, the Republican lawmaker who just warned Trump’s impeachment would set a dangerously low standard going forward, was an impeachment manager during Bill Clinton’s presidency.
Rep. Steve Chabot (R-Ohio), who just spoke on House floor against the impeachment resolution, was a Bill Clinton impeachment trial manager in 1999: pic.twitter.com/Unvdr9UoSl
— Greg Giroux (@greggiroux) December 18, 2019
Two other former Clinton impeachment managers, congressman Jim Sensenbrenner and senator Lindsey Graham, also still serve in Congress.
Several thousand Trump supporters are standing in line, waiting to get in to the venue for his Michigan campaign rally tonight despite that it’s -4 with the wind chill. Not surprisingly, the crowd’s opinions on impeachment were firmly pro-Trump.
“Its a shitshow. Its been a waste of time from the start. The Democrats want to overturn the election and they can’t, so they’re wasting everyone’s time,” said Debra Schulz from Kalamazoo, who had a Trump-Pence flag draped around her shoulders.
“Did you watch the hearings? They didn’t present any evidence. It was all speculation and hearsay. There’s nothing there,” said Mike Ostafin from Ceresco.
Steve King, the Republican congressman who was stripped of his committee assignments over his comments about white nationalism, just delivered his floor speech criticizing the impeachment inquiry.
The Iowa lawmaker made the dubious argument that Trump could not have abused his power by pushing for an investigation into Joe Biden because the former vice president is not actually his political rival.
King argued Biden was competing against “21” other Democratic presidential candidates and “running third in the polls,” so Trump’s request for an investigation was therefore not inherently political.
On a historic day for America …
In a matter of hours, Donald Trump faces an impeachment vote in the House. This vote marks the latest twist in one of the most turbulent presidencies in US history.
But the challenges to American democracy do not end today. Over the last three years, much of what we hold dear has been threatened – democracy, civility, truth. The need for a robust, independent press has never been greater.
2020 promises to be an epic year – and could define the country for a generation. With your help we will continue to provide fact-based reporting that offers public scrutiny and oversight.
We’re asking our US readers to help us raise $1.5m by early January to support our journalism. We hope you’ll consider making a year-end gift.
We also want to say a huge thank you to everyone who has supported the Guardian in 2019. You provide us with the motivation and financial support to keep doing what we do.
Congressman Cedric Richmond tried to appeal to the reputations of his Republican colleagues in his floor speech, arguing Trump was not worthy of the loyalty his party is showing.
The Louisiana Democrat warned the president would not stand by Republican lawmakers “past the next tweet or next week.”
Here is the full text of Clay Higgins’ floor speech, in which the Republican congressman criticized the Democrats supporting impeachment by referring to them as “the same socialists who threaten unborn life in the womb.”
Here's Rep. Clay Higgins's floor speech, forever memorialized into the Congressional Record: pic.twitter.com/DFDz391CTc
— Matt Fuller (@MEPFuller) December 18, 2019
Updated
Meanwhile, over in the Senate, senior White House adviser Kellyanne Conway is attending the Republican caucus lunch and working hard to prevent defections in the likely event of an impeachment trial.
Inside the Senate GOP lunch, Kellyanne Conway has just started presenting various polling on impeachment to Senate Republicans, making the case that the tide has turned against impeachment in recent weeks
— Seung Min Kim (@seungminkim) December 18, 2019
There was just a bizarre moment on the House floor, as judiciary committee chairman Jerry Nadler reminded his Republican colleagues that Mike Pence would become president if Trump were impeached, not Hillary Clinton.
This ackowledgement was met by laughs and cheers on the Republican side of the aisle.
Nadler just briefly spoke up during ongoing debate, saying he wanted to remind the GOP colleagues that if Trump is removed from office, "the new president will be Mike Pence, not Hillary Clinton." Some laughs and then some cheers from the Republican side of the floor.
— Addy Baird (@addysbaird) December 18, 2019
Congressman Chris Stewart, a Republican member of the House intelligence committee, warned Trump’s impeachment would set a precedent for future presidents.
“The next president, I promise you, is going to be impeached,” Stewart said in his floor speech. “If you set this bar as being impeachable, every president in our future will be impeached.”
Rep. Chris Stewart: "If you set this bar as being impeachable, every president in our future will be impeached" https://t.co/FksAmxCiem pic.twitter.com/BQpNU7KiKt
— CBS News (@CBSNews) December 18, 2019
Congressman Clay Higgins attracted Republican applause and Democratic scorn for his floor speech, which was accompanied by a poster showing the results of the 2016 election by acreage.
“They call us deplorables,” Higgins said. “They fear our faith, they fear our strength, they fear our unity, they fear our vote, and they fear our president.” He added, “Our republic shall survive this threat from within.”
But commentators pointed out Trump actually lost the popular vote in 2016, taking some of the air out of Higgins’ argument.
Rep. Clay Higgins says what Democrats fear is "the true will of the American people," while showing a map of the acreage Trump won in 2016.
— Ezra Klein (@ezraklein) December 18, 2019
Donald Trump got nearly 3 million fewer votes than Hillary Clinton. I don't think it's Democrats who fear the will of the people.
Congressman Hakeem Jeffries, whose name has been floated as a possible impeachment manager, pledged that Democrats would impeach Trump to send a message about the Constitution.
“We will impeach Donald John Trump,” Jeffries said on the House floor. “And we will clarify that, in America, no one is above the law.”
Jeffries’ remarks were followed by those of Republican Tom McClintock, who referred to abuse of power (one of the articles of impeachment) as a “made-up crime.”
On a historic day for America …
In a matter of hours, Donald Trump faces an impeachment vote in the House. This vote marks the latest twist in one of the most turbulent presidencies in US history.
But the challenges to American democracy do not end today. Over the last three years, much of what we hold dear has been threatened – democracy, civility, truth. The need for a robust, independent press has never been greater.
2020 promises to be an epic year – and could define the country for a generation. With your help we will continue to provide fact-based reporting that offers public scrutiny and oversight.
We’re asking our US readers to help us raise $1.5m by early January to support our journalism. We hope you’ll consider making a year-end gift.
We also want to say a huge thank you to everyone who has supported the Guardian in 2019. You provide us with the motivation and financial support to keep doing what we do.
Jerry Nadler, the chairman of the House judiciary committee, asked G.K. Butterfield, who is now presiding over the impeachment proceedings, how much time remains in the debate.
Butterfield conferred with House officials and confirmed that more than five hours remain, so there will be a lot more debate to come.
Nadler is informed there are only 156.75 minutes of debate remaining for Democrats and 157 for Republicans. that's just over five hours total
— Tom McCarthy (@TeeMcSee) December 18, 2019
Afternoon summary
Here’s where this historic day stands so far:
- The House is currently debating the articles of impeachment against Trump, with a final vote expected between 7 p.m. and 8 p.m. E.T. tonight.
- House speaker Nancy Pelosi opened the six hours of debate by accusing Trump of violating the Constitution and urging members to honor their oath of office.
- Two House Democrats -- Collin Peterson and Jeff Van Drew, who has signaled he intends to switch parties -- joined Republicans in opposing procedural motions to advance the impeachment debate.
The blog will have much more coming up, so stay tuned.
A senior Trump campaign official said the president’s team is “very excited” that the impeachment vote may be finalized as Trump takes the stage tonight for his campaign rally in Battle Creek, Michigan.
The Trump Campaign is “very excited” that the impeachment vote looks like it will be taking place just as he takes the stage at his Michigan rally tonight. A senior campaign official says “it will be a remarkable split-screen moment and we will use it to great effect.”
— Ben Tracy (@benstracy) December 18, 2019
The impeachment vote will likely occur between 7 p.m. and 8 p.m. E.T. tonight, and Trump is scheduled to start his rally at 7.
House judiciary committee Jerry Nadler criticized his Republican colleagues’ remarks on the floor, saying he has heard them say everything “except a defense of President Trump’s conduct, which is indefensible.”
Nadler then turned the floor over to congressman Ted Deutch of Florida. There is still more than five hours of debate left to go.
Moments after the White House claimed Trump would be “working all day” and would only catch “some” of the impeachment debate, the president again tweeted about the proceedings, accusing Democrats of executing an “ASSAULT ON AMERICA.”
SUCH ATROCIOUS LIES BY THE RADICAL LEFT, DO NOTHING DEMOCRATS. THIS IS AN ASSAULT ON AMERICA, AND AN ASSAULT ON THE REPUBLICAN PARTY!!!!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 18, 2019
Trump has a light public schedule today before leaving for his Michigan campaign rally, allowing the president to tweet more than 40 times by noon.
So far today, President Trump has tweeted at least 45 times - about impeachment, Ukraine, Pelosi, Schiff, Comey, FISA/Carter Page, Joe Biden, the DOJ IG's report, and more. He's been repeatedly retweeting and quoting allies who have backed him throughout the impeachment process.
— Ben Gittleson (@bgittleson) December 18, 2019
Speaking at an event in Michigan before the president’s campaign rally tonight, Mike Pence slammed the impeachment inquiry as a “disgrace” and accused Democrats of trying to reverse the 2016 election.
“What’s happening on Capitol Hill today is a disgrace,” the vice president said, according to the pool report. “The truth is they are trying to impeach this president because they know they can’t defeat this president. ...
“They’re pushing this partisan impeachment because they know they can’t stop you from giving president Donald Trump four more years in the White House. ... Tonight after a sham investigation, do-nothing Democrats are going to vote on a partisan impeachment seeking to oveturn the willl of the American people.”
Asked about Trump’s light schedule today before he leaves for his Michigan campaign rally, the White House said he would be “working all day” and might watch “some” of the floor debate on the impeachment resolution.
“The President will be working all day,” press secretary Stephanie Grisham said in a statement. “He will be briefed by staff throughout that day, and could catch some of the proceedings between meetings.”
Congressman Jim Sensenbrenner, one of only 14 Republicans who were in the House during Bill Clinton’s impeachment, just spoke on the floor to denounce the impeachment inquiry.
There are 55 current U.S. House members (41 D, 14 R) who were serving in the House when it voted to impeach Bill Clinton in December 1998
— Greg Giroux (@greggiroux) December 18, 2019
They include Jim Sensenbrenner (R-Wisconsin), who just spoke on House floor. Sensenbrenner was a Clinton impeachment trial manager in 1999. pic.twitter.com/dm4vlBwf3A
Congressman Doug Collins, the top Republican on the House judiciary committee, is now speaking on the floor, slamming impeachment as a baseless, partisan stunt.
“This is not a solemn occasion,” Collins said, mocking the words of speaker Nancy Pelosi. “They’ve been wanting to do this ever since the election.”
Collins repeated his words from yesterday’s rules committee hearing, saying, “The clock and the calendar are terrible masters.”
The Georgia Republican argued his Democratic colleagues only cared about getting political revenge on Trump. “They do not care about facts,” Collins said.
As Nancy Pelosi concluded her remarks to kick off debate on the impeachment resolution, the House speaker was met with a standing ovation from the many Democratic members present for her speech.
Speaking on the House floor, Nancy Pelosi reiterated the accusations against Trump and urged members to honor their oath of office in today’s impeachment vote.
The House speaker argued the president had “violated the Constitution” and had left Democrats with “no choice” but to impeach.
“If we do not act now, we are derelict in our duty,” Pelosi told the chamber, where most of her Democratic caucus was present to hear her remarks.
Updated
Pelosi kicks off impeachment debate
The debate on the articles of impeachment has officially begun, and House judiciary committee Jerry Nadler began by deferring to speaker Nancy Pelosi.
The House speaker opened the debate by reciting the pledge of allegiance and emphasizing the oath members take. “The republic for which it stands is what we are here to talk about today,” Pelosi said.
She then repeated the Benjamin Franklin quote she has pointed to throughout the impeachment inquiry to justify the investigation: “A republic if we can keep it.”
The House clerk, Joe Novotny, has just finished reading the articles of impeachment against Trump, and members will now have six hours to debate the resolution.
The articles concluded “Wherefore, President Trump, by such conduct, has demonstrated that he will remain a threat to the Constitution if allowed to remain in office, and has acted in a manner grossly incompatible with self-governance and the rule of law. President Trump thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or profit under the United States.”
The House clerk is now reading the articles of impeachment against Trump on the floor, after which House members will have six hours to debate the resolution before tonight’s vote.
If the debate goes according to schedule, which (again) is a big assumption, the vote should take place around 7:30 p.m. E.T.
House adopts impeachment 'rule,' clearing the way for debate
The House has adopted the “rule” outlining the procedures for today’s debate on the impeachment resolution, with all but two Democrats (Collin Peterson and Jeff Van Drew) backing the motion.
🚨 .... THE HOUSE has easily cleared a procedural hurdle, setting up impeachment debate and vote today. The vote was 228-197.
— Jake Sherman (@JakeSherman) December 18, 2019
Members will now have six hours to debate the impeachment resolution itself, split eqaully between the majority and the minority.
House votes to end debate on impeachment rule
House Democrats successfully approved a motion to end debate on the “rule” outlining procedures for today’s impeachment proceedings, clearing the way for a vote on the rule itself.
U.S. House voted 229-197 to "order the previous question" (end debate) on the rules that would govern floor debate on the articles of impeachment resolution.
— Greg Giroux (@greggiroux) December 18, 2019
D 228-2 (Peterson, Van Drew)
R 0-195
Amash (I) yes
Next vote is on adopting the rules resolution. https://t.co/bhkobytZrP
Two Democrats join Republicans in opposing procedural motion
Two House Democrats – Collin Peterson of Minnesota and Jeff Van Drew of New Jersey, who has signaled he itnends to switch parties after the impeachment vote – joined Republicans in opposing a procedural motion to end debate on the “rule” outlining procedures today.
Van Drew dodged reporters’ questions yesterday when asked about switching parties, but he is expected to cast his votes today as a Democrat, helping Republicans to claim bipartisan opposition to impeachment.
But with the exceptions of Peterson and Van Drew, every House Democrat backed the procedural motion, proving how unified the caucus is on impeaching Trump.
Updated
Congressman Jeff Van Drew, the Democratic lawmaker who has signaled he will switch his party affilation to Republican over his opposition to impeachment, has arrived on the House floor after missing this morning’s procedural votes.
.@CongressmanJVD, making his first appearance on the floor today, is now chatting with his soon-to-be-former colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle (though he would not confirm definitively yesterday that he was switching parties).
— Rebecca Kaplan (@RebeccaRKaplan) December 18, 2019
Collins confirms she is running for re-election
As House members vote on the “rule” outlining procedures for today’s impeachment proceedings, some campaign-related news is also unfolding.
Senator Susan Collins said in a letter to supporters this morning that she is running for reelection, confirming widespread expectations the Maine Republican would seek a fifth term.
“The fundamental question I had to ask myself in making my decision was this: in today’s polarized political environment, is there still a role for a centrist who believes in getting things done through compromise, collegiality, and bipartisanship?” Collins said in the letter. “I have concluded that the answer to this question is ‘yes,’ and I will, therefore, seek the honor of continuing to serve as Maine’s United States Senator.”
Time & time again, Senator Collins has shown that she puts Trump and McConnell ahead of Mainers.
— Sara Gideon (@SaraGideon) December 18, 2019
Now she's officially running for a fifth term – help us defeat her in 2020: https://t.co/COv597v6kD #mepolitics #MESen pic.twitter.com/2P0rHuFgYj
But Democrats have argued Collins has lost her centrist reputation by siding with Trump on controversial issues, such as the confirmation of Supreme Court justice Brett Kavanaugh.
Sara Gideon, the speaker of the Maine house and the frontrunner in the Democratic primary to face off against Collins, said in a statement that the longtime senator is no longer the centrist lawmaker the state has repeatedly elected.
“When Sen. Collins took office 22 years ago, she might have been different from other people in Washington, but it doesn’t seem that way anymore,” Gideon said. “These days, Sen. Collins seems more focused on serving the special interests that fund her campaigns than the Mainers who elected her.”
Updated
House begins vote series on debate procedures
Debate has now concluded on the “rule” outlining procedures for today’s impeachment proceedings, and House members have moved on to a vote series to adop the rule.
Lawmakers are now wrapping up the debate over the ground rules for today. A vote is expected in the next few minutes. It will serve as a decent proxy of where the final votes will fall today on the articles of impeachment.
— Nicholas Fandos (@npfandos) December 18, 2019
Democratic congressman Joe Kennedy used his floor speech to explain to his children why he intended to vote in favor of impeaching the president. “Dear Ellie and James: This is a moment that you’ll read about in your history books,” the Massachusetts lawmaker said.
Dem. Rep. Joe Kennedy addresses his children in remarks on impeachment: "Dear Ellie and James: This is a moment that you'll read about in your history books. Today, I will vote to impeach the president of the United States. And I want you to know why." https://t.co/YXG96ICVqo pic.twitter.com/S3Sd39n5uV
— ABC News Politics (@ABCPolitics) December 18, 2019
As the president lashes out against Nancy Pelosi, some commentators have started recirculating this 2008 video, in which Trump commends Pelosi and suggests she should have tried to impeach George W. Bush.
“When [Pelosi] first got in and was named speaker, I met her,” Trump told CNN host Wolf Blitzer at the time. “And I’m very impressed by her. I think she’s a very impressive person, I like her a lot.”
Trump continued, “But I was surprised that she didn’t do more in terms of Bush and going after Bush. It just seemed like she was really going to look to impeach Bush and get him out of office. Which personally I think would have been a wonderful thing.”
Trump argued Bush should have been impeached for the “lies” he told before invading Iraq.
Trump has already tweeted a few dozen times this morning to slam the impeachment inquiry and speaker Nancy Pelosi as debate continues on the House floor.
Will go down in history as worst Speaker. Already thrown out once! https://t.co/Q6N2EVlp9j
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 18, 2019
The president has nothing on his public schedule this morning until he leaves for his Michigan campaign rally at 4:25 p.m. E.T., so more tweets will likely be forthcoming as the House takes up the articles of impeachment.
Speaker Nancy Pelosi is sitting on the House floor as debate continues on the “rule” outlining procedures for today’s proceedings.
Speaker Pelosi is here, sitting near the back of the chamber on the Democrats side. She's wearing black and shuffling through some papers as she watches the debate.
— Heather Caygle (@heatherscope) December 18, 2019
The vote on the “rule” should take place in about ten minutes. Once it is adopted, members will be given six hours to debate the impeachment resolution itself, split evenly between the majority and the minority.
Congressman Jeff Van Drew, the Democrat who has signaled he will switch his party affiliation to Republican over his opposition to impeachment, did not vote in this morning’s procedural motions.
Jeff Van Drew didn't vote on this or on the earlier Republican motion to adjourn.https://t.co/QbCQUsDiKbhttps://t.co/etpdKVkNmj
— Greg Giroux (@greggiroux) December 18, 2019
Now underway, debate on the rule providing for consideration of the impeachment resolutionhttps://t.co/DTxZXcbiGb
House Republicans are trying to introduce more procedural motions to delay the vote, suggesting that debate on the articles of impeachment should be six hours longer than scheduled and that memebers should be made to cast votes manually, but Democrats have rejected the proposals.
Republicans try more procedural moves, asking that votes on the impeachment articles be cast manually, by standing up and speaking, rather than electronic voting; and urging 12 hours of debate, rather than 6. Both requests failed when Democrats refused to accept them.
— Michael D. Shear (@shearm) December 18, 2019
Congressman Jim Clyburn, the House majority whip, delivered a floor speech outlining Democrats’ argument for impeachment.
“Today we have a president who seems to believe he is a king or above the law,” the longtime South Carolina lawmaker said.
NOW: Democrats beginning their impeachment speeches with Rep. Jim Clyburn, D-SC, the number 3 Democrat in the House, as well as the highest-ranking African-American in Congress.
— Lisa Desjardins (@LisaDNews) December 18, 2019
And known as a good orator.
Just outside the US Capitol, pro-impeachment protesters have found some fun, holiday-themed ways of expressing their displeasure with the president.
Outside the Capitol , Santa giving interviews about why Trump should be impeached pic.twitter.com/SoJ79FsccP
— Erica Werner (@ericawerner) December 18, 2019
Walking to the House floor, Nancy Pelosi would only tell reporters she felt “sad” about today’s proceedings, echoing reports that the speaker has intstructed her Democratic caucus to treat today as a solemn occasion.
Walking to House floor, Speaker Pelosi says she’s feeling “sad” about today but wouldn’t comment further, saying she will be speaking on the floor.
— Katherine Faulders (@KFaulders) December 18, 2019
The sadness of today’s vote may be the only point of agreement between House Democrats and Republicans, as Tom Cole, the top Republican on the rules committee, made a similar comment on the floor.
GOP Rep. @TomColeOK04: "This is a very sad day."
— Ben Siegel (@benyc) December 18, 2019
"Unlike in 1998, the decision to have this vote is not the result of a bipartisan process or an open or fair process."
The Republican minority whip, Steve Scalise, tried to raise a point of order, but Diana DeGette, the Democratic congresswoman presiding over today’s debate, ruled it to be out of order.
GOP No. 2 @SteveScalise is now raising a point of order objecting to the Rule and the underlying articles, alleging a "violation of minority rights"
— Nicholas Fandos (@npfandos) December 18, 2019
The speaker pro tem appears to be ruling this out of order.
Debate has now begun on the “rule” establishing procedures for today’s impeachment proceedings.
'Rule' establishing procedures for impeachment proceedings called up for debate
Congressman Jim McGovern, the Democratic chairman of the House rules committee, has introduced the “rule” that will establish parameters for debate on the impeachment resolution.
House members will now have an hour to debate the rule before voting on the proposal, so it’s looking like an 11 a.m. E.T. vote before discussion can turn to the impeachment resolution itself.
The motion to table Kevin McCarthy’s resolution condemning Adam Schiff and Jerry Nadler has succeeded, hopefully clearing the way (finally) for an hour of debate on the procedures for today.
True to form, the House of representatives is already behind schedule for today’s impeachment proceedings.
Just to make clear … the House has not begun the hour of rule debate that was supposed to be ending just about now.
— Jake Sherman (@JakeSherman) December 18, 2019
House just started a 15-minute vote to table a GOP procedural resolution. Dems will win this vote, but itll take time
The optimistic estimate that the final vote on articles of impeachment would take place by 7:30 p.m. E.T. is feeling more unlikely by the minute.
The Democratic majority leader, Steny Hoyer, has now introduced a motion to table Kevin McCarthy’s resolution condemning Adam Schiff and Jerry Nadler for their handling of the impeachment inquiry, triggering another 15-minute vote.
It appears Republicans are trying to delay the inevitable for as long as possible in the hope of forcing Democrats to take some uncomfortable votes before the all-important vote on articles of impeachment later tonight.
These procedural motions could disrupt the optimistic timeline of concluding today’s proceedings by 7:30 p.m. E.T., but they will not affect the end result. The day will end in Trump’s impeachment no matter how many technical maneuvers Republicans deploy.
Kevin McCarthy is calling for a vote on a resolution condemning the Democratic chairmen of the intelligence and judiciary committees, Adam Schiff and Jerry Nadler, for their handling of the impeachment inquiry. This will also be rejected by the Democratic majority.
HAPPENING NOW → Chairmen Adam Schiff and Jerry Nadler have abused their power. I am calling for a vote on a privileged resolution to condemn their actions. pic.twitter.com/UaMfXBnGlg
— Kevin McCarthy (@GOPLeader) December 18, 2019
Well, not so fast. The Republican minority leader, Kevin McCarthy, is now offering a parliamentary question before the House begins debating the rules for today’s proceedings.
Updated
The Republican motion to adjourn before taking up the articles of impeachment has been defeated, clearing the way for debate to begin on the procedures for today’s historic proceedings.
House judiciary committee chairman Jerry Nadler is on the floor today, having returned from a last-minute trip to New York yesterday to attend to a family medical emergency.
Nadler’s absence from Washington yesterday meant that congressman Jamie Raskin, a former constitutional law professor, presented the Democrats’ argument for impeachment before the House rules committee.
A House Democratic aide provided more context on why congresswoman Diana DeGette, a Colorado Democrat who has served since 1997, is presiding over today’s debate.
Why is @RepDianaDeGette presiding? A senior democratic aide tells NBC News: Rep. DeGette is a master at presiding. She is our toughest Speaker Pro Tem and has been preparing for this role for this specific debate for weeks.
— Alex Moe (@AlexNBCNews) December 18, 2019
Democratic congresswoman Diana DeGette is currently presiding over the House proceedings, but speaker Nancy Pelosi will take over when members vote on the articles of impeachment later tonight.
Pelosi will also deliver a floor speech tonight, which is a rarity for House speakers.
Once the motion to adjourn is defeated, House members will likely begin one hour of debate on the procedures adopted by the rules committee to set parameters for today’s proceedings.
Freedom Caucus Chair Andy Biggs made a motion to adjourn to stop wasting time on impeachment. The House is now taking a roll call vote on the Republican motion to adjourn. This will be killed by Democrats and then likely the one hour of debate on the rule will begin.
— Alex Moe (@AlexNBCNews) December 18, 2019
As expected, House Republicans have put forth a motion to adjourn before considering the articles of impeachment, which will almost certainly be defeated.
GO BIGGS OR GO HOME: @RepAndyBiggsAZ is kicking off the GOP’s procedural gambits today, forcing a vote on a motion to adjourn before the impeachment debate begins.
— Melanie Zanona (@MZanona) December 18, 2019
House convenes for today's impeachment proceedings
The House has now convened for today’s proceedings, which will conclude with final votes on the two articles of impeachment against Trump.
House Republicans are expected to introduce a number of procedural motions, which could delay the final vote, but Democrats will be able to defeat those proposals with their majority power.
Republicans are expected to quickly move for the House to adjourn. That will require the first roll call vote of the day, and Democrats will defeat it.
— Nicholas Fandos (@npfandos) December 18, 2019
The House will convene in about 10 minutes to begin today’s proceedings, which will include several hours of debate on the impeachment resolution, but protesters have already gathered on Capitol Hill.
The final vote on impeachment isn't expected until tonight but protesters are already out on the Capitol lawn, it is going to be a long and chilly day
— Kelsey Snell (@kelsey_snell) December 18, 2019
Congressman Adam Schiff, the chairman of the House intelligence committee who has been intensely criticized by Trump and his allies, encouraged his colleagues to “honor their oath” in today’s impeachment vote.
President Trump abused his power to cheat in the next election, then obstructed Congress to cover it up.
— Adam Schiff (@RepAdamSchiff) December 18, 2019
The only question is: Will Members honor their oath to uphold the Constitution?
History will remember the vote we take today. #DefendOurDemocracy
Nancy Pelosi has designated Democratic congresswoman Diana DeGette to serve as speaker pro tempore and preside over the House debate on the impeachment resolution.
Speaker Pelosi has asked me to serve as speaker pro tempore and preside over the House for today’s impeachment debate.
— Rep. Diana DeGette (@RepDianaDeGette) December 18, 2019
This is a sad and somber moment in our nation’s history and the responsibility to preside is something I won't take lightly.https://t.co/ZIprrgZzO4
DeGette, a Colorado lawmaker who has served in the House since 1997, said of the honor, “This is a sad and somber moment in our nation’s history and the responsibility to preside over this important debate is something I will not take lightly.”
Updated
The timing of today's vote
Following a marathon hearing yesterday, the House rules committee adopted debate procedures for today’s impeachment vote, which will likely not be finalized until this evening.
According to the rules passed by the committee, House members will have six hours to debate the impeachment resolution, split evenly between the majority and the minority.
The House is set to start today’s business at 9 a.m. E.T., but they have to take care of some housekeeping and formally adopt the rules before debating the actual impeachment resolution.
Assuming everything runs on time, which is a hefty assumption where the House of representatives is concerned, the final vote could come sometime between 6:30 and 7:30 p.m. E.T.
Trump is scheduled to start his campaign rally in Battle Creek, Michigan, at 7 p.m. E.T., which means he could be on stage when he becomes only the third president in US history to be impeached.
Trump lashes out against Democrats and acknowledges likely impeachment
Trump has nothing on his public schedule today until he leaves for a Michigan campaign rally at 4.25 pm ET., and the president is already lashing out against his critics over Twitter.
Trump acknowledged the House would almost certainly impeach him, but he insisted he had done “NOTHING WRONG” and warned of the effect today’s vote would have on future presidents. “Say a PRAYER!” Trump wrote.
Can you believe that I will be impeached today by the Radical Left, Do Nothing Democrats, AND I DID NOTHING WRONG! A terrible Thing. Read the Transcripts. This should never happen to another President again. Say a PRAYER!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 18, 2019
The request for his supporters to pray for the country is noteworthy, given that Trump sent a letter to Nancy Pelosi yesterday criticizing the House speaker for saying, “I pray for the President all the time.”
“Even worse than offending the Founding Fathers, you are offending Americans of faith by continually saying you pray for the President when you know this statement is not true, unless it is meant in a negative sense,” Trump wrote in his furious letter.
Updated
House expected to impeach Trump today
Good morning, live blog readers!
We have arrived. Today, the House of Representatives is expected to impeach Donald Trump, making him only the third president in US history to receive this ignoble honor.
The outcome of today’s House vote is all but certain, as a majority of members have said they intend to vote in favor of impeachment.
However, once they do, the case will move on to the Republican-controlled Senate, where Trump has already been guaranteed a much more favorable audience. Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell said yesterday he would not be an “impartial juror” in the trial to determine whether to remove Trump from office, calling impeachment a “political process.”
Even though the Senate trial will likely end in acquittal, nearly all the House Democrats from more conservative districts have said they plan to vote “yes” today, framing the issue as a matter of duty.
Democratic congresswoman Elissa Slotkin, whose Michigan district backed Trump by 7 points in 2016, wrote in an op-ed earlier this week, “Over the past few months, I’ve been told more times that I can count that the vote I’ll be casting this week will mark the end of my short political career. That may be.
”But in the national security world that I come from, we are trained to make hard calls on things, even if they are unpopular, if we believe the security of the country is at stake. There are some decisions in life that have to be made based on what you know in your bones is right. And this is one of those times.”