Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Daily Mirror
Daily Mirror
National
Paige Ingram

Own-brand chocolate tubs ranked against Quality Street, Celebrations and Roses

Christmas wouldn't be the same without tucking into a box of chocolates.

Quality Street, Roses, Celebrations and Heroes selection tubs are often big hits in the festive season.

But supermarkets have their very own versions, which are just as good, if not better.

While a standard 650g Quality Street tub costs £3.50, you can pick up a  Sainsbury's 'Chocolate Treats' 650g tub for the same price.

Head to Morrisons and you'll find a 650g 'Our Big Selection' for £4.

Quality Street may have 12 choices, compared to Sainsbury's nine and M&S's ten, but quality can sometimes overrule quantity.

Essex Live decided to sample each supermarket's selection boxes and find out who is top of the chocs.

 

Milk Chocolate Fudge - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 6/10

Creaminess: 8/10

Chewiness: 7/10

Wrapping: 8/10

Chocolate design: 7/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 6 /10

Overall rating: 7/10

Fudge - Quality Street

Flavour: 7/10

Creaminess: 8/10

Chewiness: 5/10

Wrapping: 6/10

Chocolate design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 6/10

Overall rating: 6/10

Caramel Fudge - M&S

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 8/10

Chewiness: 2/10

Wrapping: 9/10

Chocolate design: 7/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 8/10

Overall rating: 8/10

Hazelnut in caramel - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 7/10

Creaminess: 8/10

Chewiness: 5/10

Wrapping: 3/10

Chocolate design: 4/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 8/10

Overall rating: 6.5/10

Hazelnut Whirl - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 3/10

Creaminess: 3/10

Chewiness: 0/10

Wrapping: 2/10

Chocolate design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 10/10

Overall rating: 3/10

The Purple One - Quality Street

Flavour: 9/10

Creaminess: 6 /10

Chewiness: 6/10

Wrapping: 10/10

Chocolate design: 9/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 6/10

Overall rating: 9/10

Hazelnut in caramel - M&S

Flavour: 5/10

Creaminess: 4/10

Chewiness: 4/10

Wrapping: 4/10

Chocolate design: 4/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 8/10

Overall rating: 5/10

Orange Creme - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 9/10

Creaminess: 10/10

Chewiness: 2/10

Wrapping: 8/10

Chocolate design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 2/10

Overall rating: 9/10

Orange Creme - Quality Street

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 9/10

Chewiness: 3/10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 2/10

Overall rating: 8/10

Chocolate Orange Crunch - Quality street

Flavour: 7/10

Creaminess: 4/10

Chewiness: 5/10

Wrapping: 9/10

Chocolate design: 10/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 7/10

Overall rating: 6/10

Orange Creme - M&S

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 8/10

Chewiness: 5/10

Wrapping: 8/10

Chocolate design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 4/10

Overall rating: 7/10

Strawberry Fondant Creme - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 7/10

Creaminess: 7/10

Chewiness: 4/10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate design: 7/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 8/10

Overall rating: 8/10

Strawberry Delight - Quality Street

Flavour: 6/10

Creaminess: 7/10

Chewiness: 4/10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate design: 7/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 7/10

Overall rating: 7/10

Strawberry Flavour Creme - M&S

Flavour: 5/10

Creaminess: 6/10

Chewiness: 4/10

Wrapping: 6/10

Chocolate design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 5/10

Overall rating: 5/10

Double chocolate Eclair - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 7/10

Chewiness: 9.5/10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate design: 6/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 7/10

Overall rating: 7/10

Coconut Eclair - Quality Street

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 3/10

Chewiness: 6/10

Wrapping: 8/10

Chocolate design: 7/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 5/10

Overall rating: 8/10

Butterscotch Eclair - M&S

Flavour: 7/10

Creaminess: 8/10

Chewiness: 10/10

Wrapping: 6/10

Chocolate design: 6/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 1/10

Overall rating: 7/10

Dairy Toffee - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 5/10

Creaminess: 6/10

Chewiness: 10/10

Wrapping: 8/10

Toffe Design: 3/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 0/10

Overall rating: 6/10

Toffee Penny - Quality Street

Flavour: 4/10

Creaminess: 4/10

Chewiness: 8/10

Wrapping: 7/10

Toffee Design: 4/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 0/10

Overall rating: 5/10

Toffee Finger - Quality Street

Flavour: 7/10

Creaminess: 7/10

Chewiness: 6/10

Wrapping: 6/10

Toffee Design: 5/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 6/10

Overall rating: 7/10

Cream Toffee - M&S

Flavour: 3/10

Creaminess: 2/10

Chewiness: 9/10

Wrapping: 3/10

Toffee Design: 4/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 3/10

Overall rating: 3/10

Chocolates that were unique to each tub

Salted Caramel - M&S

Flavour: 6/10

Creaminess: 7/10

Chewiness: 5/10

Wrapping: 6/10

Chocolate Design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 7/10

Overall rating: 5/10

Coffee Truffle - M&S

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess:9 /10

Chewiness: 5/10

Wrapping: 6/10

Chocolate Design:7 /10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 3/10

Overall rating: 8/10

Biscuit in Caramel - M&S

Flavour: 6/10

Creaminess: 6/10

Chewiness: 8/10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate Design: 6/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 7/10

Overall rating: 6/10

Milk Creme - M&S

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 9/10

Chewiness: 6 /10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate Design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 9/10

Overall rating: 9/10

Chocolate Fudge Brownie - Sainsbury’s

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 4/10

Chewiness: 9/10

Wrapping: 9/10

Chocolate Design: 6/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 7/10

Overall rating: 9/10

The lowdown on supermarket selection tubs chocs

The Green Triangle - Quality Street

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess:8 /10

Chewiness:5 /10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate Design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 0/10

Overall rating: 9/10

Milk Choc Block - Quality Street

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess:7 /10

Chewiness: 6/10

Wrapping: 3/10

Chocolate Design:4 /10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 0/10

Overall rating: 8/10

Caramel Swirl - Quality Street

Flavour: 8/10

Creaminess: 9/10

Chewiness: 3/10

Wrapping: 0/10 (it ripped)

Chocolate Design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 7/10

Overall rating: 8/10

Chocolate Caramel Brownie - Quality Street

Flavour: 7/10

Creaminess: 8/10

Chewiness: 4/10

Wrapping: 7/10

Chocolate Design: 8/10

Chocolate to filling ratio: 3/10

Overall rating: 6/10

After tasting each and every chocolate we are all feeling rather full, and the general consensus is that the M&S 'Big Selection' tub was by far the best.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.