Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Miami Herald
Miami Herald
National
Aaron Leibowitz

No more hotel vouchers for displaced and distressed Puerto Ricans in Florida

Scattered across a small coffee table in Richard Gonzalez's motel room this week were papers to keep him from becoming homeless. There was a resume in English that his daughter in Puerto Rico had made for him. There was a list of contacts for social service agencies. There was a piece of paper where Gonzalez had scrawled the phone numbers of a dozen apartments for rent.

But by Saturday morning, after finishing his 8 p.m. to 4 a.m. shift as a dealer at Seminole Casino in Hollywood, Fla., Gonzalez was preparing to check out of the Extended Stay America hotel in Fort Lauderdale, his bare-bones home for the past two months.

Gonzalez, 53, planned to drive north to Orlando, where his mother and brother have lived for several years. Like hundreds of American citizens from Puerto Rico who fled to Florida after Hurricane Maria last September, Gonzalez doesn't know what comes next. The money keeping a roof over his head is gone. The Federal Emergency Management Agency's hotel voucher program expired Saturday.

What Gonzalez does know is he's not moving back to Puerto Rico _ at least not yet. Asked what he will do after this weekend, Gonzalez, whose wife and adult daughter and son still live on the island, began to cry.

"I would like to go to Puerto Rico right now, but to what?" he said in Spanish, explaining that jobs there are nowhere to be found. "I tell my wife: 'What are we going to do? Without work, I can't do anything.'"

FEMA has extended the deadline of its voucher program, known as Transitional Shelter Assistance four times since October, sometimes with just a few days to spare. But now the agency has presented a final proposition: Accept a one-way plane ticket back to the island by Sunday, or find housing another way.

Most have chosen to stay. Of nearly 600 families in Florida who were part of the hotel voucher program Tuesday, only 44 had returned to Puerto Rico at FEMA expense, the agency said. The latest national statistics provided by FEMA show that, among almost 2,000 families who remained in hotels as of June 2, just 11 had flown home and 180 had expressed interest in doing so.

Luis DeRosa, president of the Puerto Rican Chamber of Commerce in Miami, which has been helping displaced families in the region, said FEMA was making a mistake by cutting off hotel aid.

"If you cut them off, where are they gonna go _ the street?" DeRosa said. "This is called forced homelessness by the federal government."

Most of the displaced families in Florida have landed in Osceola and Orange counties, in some cases occupying much of entire motels in Orlando and Kissimmee. Forty-six such families were still living in Miami-Dade county hotels this week, the third-most of any county in the state.

More than 7,000 families _ and over 19,000 people _ have participated in the voucher program nationally since Hurricane Maria devastated Puerto Rico nine months ago, wiping out its power grid and likely resulting in thousands of deaths. In the weeks that followed, FEMA was criticized for its slow response.

Since then, most families have managed to leave their hotels and move in with family members, find low-income rentals or return to Puerto Rico. But for the last enduring hotel occupants, affordable housing has seemed impossible to find.

"We already have an affordable housing crisis," said Gladys Cook of the Florida Housing Coalition, a Tallahassee nonprofit that pushes for affordable housing in the state. "When you have more people that have no resources that try to get into this system, it becomes more of a bottleneck."

Among those stuck is Ariana Colon, a 20-year-old mother who has a year-old son and another baby due in four months. Colon has been living at a Holiday Inn in Kissimmee, the fifth hotel in Central Florida that she and her boyfriend have occupied since December. Colon works a few hours a week at Burger King and her boyfriend works as a barber.

But it's not enough, Colon said. Landlords for one-bedroom apartments and studios have been asking her for three times the monthly rent upfront _ first and last month's rent plus a security deposit _ something she can't afford. And the waiting lists for designated low-income units are typically one to two years long.

Some landlords, Colon cited her son as a justification to turn her away. "They said it's too many people in one place," she said.

Before Hurricane Maria, Colon lived with her grandmother in Bayamon, near Puerto Rico's northern coast. Even though their home wasn't totally destroyed by the storm, the situation was desperate: Colon spent three days looking for baby formula.

She also saw government officials _ specifically, she says, Florida Gov. Rick Scott _ say on television that Florida had opportunities to offer for those who chose to come.

"We came here because the government itself said to us, 'Come here, there's jobs, there's places to stay,'" Colon said. "Once we got here, there was nothing."

Colon is discouraged, but, like Gonzalez, isn't budging.

"I came here and I'm willing to fight," she said. "I didn't come here just to get benefits. I don't want to feel like I came here for nothing."

In recent weeks, Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., has called for another extension of the voucher program, but his pleas have largely gone unrecognized. On Thursday, he made an unsuccessful last-ditch appeal to his fellow senators to compel FEMA to extend the voucher program.

He decried a perceived double standard, noting that the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development' Disaster Housing Assistance Program was activated after Hurricane Katrina in 2009 but not after Hurricane Maria.

"If it was good enough for the people fleeing New Orleans in Hurricane Katrina, why isn't it good enough for the people that are equally devastated now in Florida, having fled the deplorable conditions in their native island, our fellow U.S. citizens of Puerto Rico?" Nelson said.

FEMA has argued the DHAP program is less effective than its alternatives. One option, known as the direct lease program, gives some families the chance to move into vacant properties in Puerto Rico.

"DHAP is not necessary to house displaced disaster survivors," FEMA said earlier this month on its website. The direct lease program "provides the same housing option to disaster survivors as DHAP in a more efficient and cost-effective manner."

Another option, known as rental assistance, could help families whose homes in Puerto Rico are still deemed uninhabitable by FEMA. The money could be used toward rent, either in Puerto Rico or on the mainland.

But these options have provided no recourse to people like Gonzalez, who say they have done their best to find apartments are now at the edge of homelessness.

On Tuesday, Gonzalez drove an hour south from Fort Lauderdale to Miami Gardens for a meeting at Casa Refugio de Miami, led by officials from FEMA and the Puerto Rican government. Two days earlier, Gonzalez was encouraged by a phone call suggesting that the meeting might help him find a longer-term housing solution. But when he arrived, he said, he felt deceived.

"It was a sham," Gonzalez said. "It was just to ask those of us who are here to go back to Puerto Rico."

Gonzalez did leave the meeting with resources, including contact information for housing assistance programs in Puerto Rico and for anti-poverty nonprofits in Florida. But he said that when he tried calling three of the numbers, no one answered.

He likes his job at the casino. It's a position similar to the one he held back home, and he proudly notes that he was named employee of the month for June. In the long term, he sees room to advance there and make more money for his family.

That's all on hold for now.

"Here, the difficult thing is the apartments," Gonzalez said. "Where will I get help?"

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.