The Colts and Falcons faced off in Germany on Sunday morning to kick off the day’s NFL Week 10 action. It wound up a fairly entertaining game and went to overtime following a game-tying field goal by Indianapolis with fewer than 30 seconds remaining. The Colts wound up victorious thanks to another monster Jonathan Taylor performance capped off by his game-winning touchdown in OT, but it didn’t go down without a truly bizarre snafu from the officiating crew.
As always, there was a coin toss to start overtime that determined who got the ball first. The referees allowed Indianapolis to make the heads or tails call; they were right and the Colts were therefore able to choose whether to kick or receive first, opting to receive. The broadcast then went to commercial.
Upon the game’s return, the announcers revealed the mistake: it turns out the referees managed to screw up the coin toss. The game was played in Germany but the Colts were technically the home team. Which meant Atlanta should have made the call on the coin toss, not Indy. This mistake was rectified while the commercials played and when viewers tuned back in, it was the Falcons who were receiving the OT kickoff, not the Colts.
And, according to Adam Amin, Blakeman screwed up the coin toss to begin overtime. They had to reflip! https://t.co/ZIB2TCEre3 pic.twitter.com/8A0QgnUlUG
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 9, 2025
It isn’t the craziest mistake to make in context of Atlanta playing a “home” game in Europe. But how often do you see referees mess up the coin toss? There aren’t many factors at play.
The error left the NFL world baffled and they let the officiating crew have it on social media.
Re flipping the coin toss during an advert break because you got it wrong. The NFL ladies and gentlemen
— Magee_316 (@JakeMartinMagee) November 9, 2025
I guess the jet lag really got to these refs. The bad spots, the mess after the grounding call, re-doing the coin toss, wow pic.twitter.com/igbw0DZ1J7
— 𝙇𝙪𝙠𝙚 𝙑𝙚𝙧𝙠𝙖𝙢𝙥 📸 (@LukeVerkamp) November 9, 2025
Bro how do you mess up the coin toss
— Barstool Indy (@barstoolindy) November 9, 2025
WAIT THEY RE-DID THE COIN TOSS????
— sarah (@fangirlfornfl) November 9, 2025
they re did the coin toss ??? I DO NOT WANT THE BALL FIRST
— H U N C H O (@HunchoGambles) November 9, 2025
It didn’t end up making a big difference. The Falcons were unable to score with their first possession and Taylor walked the Colts down the field to score the walk-off TD. But it’s a pretty brutal mistake to make in a big spot.
The Colts move to 8-2 with the win, while the Falcons are sitting at 3-6 without their first-round pick next season.
More NFL on Sports Illustrated
This article was originally published on www.si.com as NFL World Baffled by Colts-Falcons Referees’ Bizarre Mistake During OT Coin Toss.
