Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Chronicle Live
Chronicle Live
Sport
John Gibson

Newcastle's opening day visit of Nottingham Forest evokes memories of 'The Game That Never Was'

They will be sitting together at a round table just inside the door of the Moncur Suite brought together once again to witness a special opener to a new season.

Forty-eight years ago this trio of ex-Magpies took part in the most famous match between Newcastle United and Nottingham Forest ever staged at St James Park.

It went down in history as The Game That Never Was because the Football Association decreed that it should be wiped from the record books and played again.

READ MORE: 'Are you seriously presenting that to me?' - The bid to bring 'phenomenon' to Newcastle United

Bob Moncur and Frank Clark were in United's defence that epic afternoon en route to Wembley and the 1974 FA Cup final while Malcolm Macdonald led the attack. Come Saturday afternoon they will be together again, interested spectators on the sidelines of the frantic action.

United incredibly 'won' their sixth round tie 4-3 after being 3-1 down and reduced to 10 men but a pitch invasion resulting in an eight minute hold up saw the FA rule that it must be replayed on a neutral ground.

Moncur, David Craig, Terry McDermott, and John Tudor all had their goals erased from their Newcastle record - Moncs complained that while he notched high profile goals (like the Fairs Cup final) he hardly got enough to afford to give up genuine strikes!

A 0-0 draw followed at Goodison and when the teams met for an exhausting third time at the same venue SuperMac decided the bragging rights.

Clark went on to forge a privileged place in Forest's history of course not just as a member of their first European Cup winning ensemble but also as a manager and chairman.

However he is not the oldest living footballer to wear the colours of both clubs. Dave Hilley, now a fit 83 year old and living in Gosforth, was a team-mate of Clark and Moncur when United won promotion as Second Division champions in 1965.

Hilley, a good pal who worked both as a schoolteacher and a journo on Tyneside, played 209 games for United before signing for Forest where he roomed with Jim Baxter (a testing thing in itself) and totted up nearly another century of appearances.

If The Game That Never Was has gone down in history as a unique occasion then another six years before in October of 1968 also stands alone because it too produced a not-to-be-repeated situation.

How? Well it was a top flight match that was actually played on a neutral ground. Why? Because fire had destroyed Forest's City Ground and so it was switched across the Trent to Notts County's Meadow Lane.

If that was not enough to make it different it also marked the tragic end to the career of Geoff Allen, Elliot Anderson's grandad, when he was only 24 years of age.

United triumphed 4-2 with teenagers Keith Dyson and Alan Foggon dramatically announcing their arrival early in the Fairs Cup winning season by both scoring after Allen had been fatally crocked inside the first quarter of an hour. It was just 27 days after Geoff had pulverised Feyenoord in Newcastle's first ever European match.

I saw both games against Forest which were unique in differing ways and Newcastle scored four each time. Should they wish to do so again before these old eyes then I will be more than happy!

READ NEXT

'The Big Newcastle United Forum' - How do you rate the current atmosphere inside St. James' Park?

Newcastle transfers state of play: Board assure Eddie Howe Magpies spending to hit £200m mark

'Worth the hype' - the inside view on why 'sky is the limit' for Elliot Anderson at Newcastle United

Newcastle United's Manchester City transfer warning amid chase for James Maddison

Roy Keane and Graeme Souness agree on Eddie Howe pressure and impact at Newcastle United

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.