100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
Luckin 2.0? Freefalling Cloopen Flags Potential Irregularities, Spooking Investors
Key takeaways: •      Cloopen said it formed an independent special committee to look into employee misconduct and transaction irregularities discovered…
Facing Double Whammy in India, Will Xiaomi Look Home for Comfort?
Key Takeaways: Xiaomi has been accused of tax evasion in India, though the company claims its activities complied with local laws…
Texhong Eyes Vietnam in World of Diversifying Supply Chains
Key Takeaways: Texhong is preparing to launch a major facility in Vietnam that will sharply boost its fabric production to…
Amid Slowing Sales at Home, Innovent Biologics Stumbles Overseas
Key takeaways: Innovent Biologics terminated a plan to sell its bevacizumab biosimilar in North America with a local partner after…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
A Peek Into The Markets: US Stock Futures Higher; Crude Oil Surges Over 1%
Pre-open movers
Equities steady after a week of inflation-fed worries
Recap: Global stocks regained some ground on Friday after a turbulent week triggered by concerns over surging inflation, aggressive rate…
Get all your news in one place
Latest World news:
NRA convention explained: What to know about this year’s meeting
The convention comes after a gunman killed 19 children and two teachers at a primary school in Uvalde, Texas.
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Anger as police revise key details of Texas school shooting
Officials investigating the Uvalde mass school shooting have revised details about the initial police response.
Russian Proxies Claim Control of Key Town in East Ukraine
Russia's separatist proxies in eastern Ukraine claimed full control of the important battlefield town of Lyman on Friday, and Ukraine…
VIDEO: Day 91: Pro-Russia Militiamen Fire Leaflets Over Ukraine Urging Troops To Surrender
This footage shows how militiamen load pro-Russia propaganda leaflets into projectiles and then blast them over Ukrainian-held territory.
As Biden Leaves Asia, North Korea Launches ICBM, Other Missiles
North Korea test-fired three ballistic missiles, including what appeared to be an intercontinental ballistic missile, hours after U.S. President left…
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Turkey Keeps Up Pressure on Sweden, Finland
Turkey’s foreign minister says Sweden and Finland must now take “concrete steps” to alleviate his country’s security concerns to overcome…
‘These are innocent babies’: grief, loss and love as Uvalde struggles under a heavy cloud
The Texas school killings have touched nearly everyone in the small town, from friends and neighbors to shopkeepers and coaches

New China Accounting Scandal Flies Under the Radar. And Where There's Smoke …

By The Bamboo Works

By Doug Young

A high-flying Chinese Starbucks imitator called Luckin (OTC:LKNCY) made global headlines around this time two years ago, tumbling from grace after admitting to massively cooking its books. Now, a much lower-profile, but similar, scandal is brewing at a Chinese cloud services company called Cloopen (NYSE:RAAS), which is saying as much as 10% of its sales in last year’s second quarter and up to 20% in the third quarter may have been faked by rogue employees.

All this comes as the U.S. and China are hammering out an agreement that would give the U.S. securities regulator access it has long sought to the audit records of U.S.-listed Chinese companies. China has previously banned such access, but seems to realize giving it to the U.S. is ultimately in everyone’s interest by forcing Chinese companies to be more honest about their business.

That raises the interesting question of whether we may see more of these scandals emerge as a bilateral information-sharing deal draws closer.

The answer could quite possibly be “yes.” In the case of Luckin and now Cloopen, external pressures were the catalyst that ultimately uncovered the accounting fraud, rather than any internal checks. In Luckin’s case the company launched an internal investigation after an anonymous report alleged the faked sales. The company ultimately admitted to faking around $300 million in sales in 2019, equal to roughly 40% of its sales for that year.

In Cloopen’s case, the company was alerted to similar fraud by its auditor, the China arm of global giant KPMG, which recently resigned the account as a result of the matter. The amounts are much smaller here but still significant, with Cloopen saying that 5% to 10% of its second-quarter revenues last year and 15% to 20% of its third-quarter revenues may have been bogus. That would translate to roughly 80 million yuan in faked sales, bringing the company’s previously reported 40-50% growth for both quarters down to the 15-35% level.

This kind of temptation to inflate sales isn’t uncommon in China, where growth is an obsession and bosses often announce their lofty goals to staff, who then sometimes do whatever it takes to reach those goals. In the past, these companies’ auditors, often China arms of big global accounting firms, could quietly look the other way when they suspected potential misdeeds. That’s because they could hide behind the Chinese ban on sharing their records with the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), the body that works with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on fraud investigations.

Now that these auditors know they may soon need to take greater responsibility for their audits of Chinese companies, many may become more aggressive in their checks before signing off on such audits. That could help to restore investor confidence in U.S.-listed Chinese companies in general. But it could also result in more cases like we’ve just seen with Cloopen, where an auditor raises the alarm over practices that it might have quietly overlooked in the past.

Doug Young is the editor in chief at Bamboo Works

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
Luckin 2.0? Freefalling Cloopen Flags Potential Irregularities, Spooking Investors
Key takeaways: •      Cloopen said it formed an independent special committee to look into employee misconduct and transaction irregularities discovered…
Facing Double Whammy in India, Will Xiaomi Look Home for Comfort?
Key Takeaways: Xiaomi has been accused of tax evasion in India, though the company claims its activities complied with local laws…
Texhong Eyes Vietnam in World of Diversifying Supply Chains
Key Takeaways: Texhong is preparing to launch a major facility in Vietnam that will sharply boost its fabric production to…
Amid Slowing Sales at Home, Innovent Biologics Stumbles Overseas
Key takeaways: Innovent Biologics terminated a plan to sell its bevacizumab biosimilar in North America with a local partner after…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
A Peek Into The Markets: US Stock Futures Higher; Crude Oil Surges Over 1%
Pre-open movers
Equities steady after a week of inflation-fed worries
Recap: Global stocks regained some ground on Friday after a turbulent week triggered by concerns over surging inflation, aggressive rate…
Get all your news in one place