Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
World
Massoud Hayoun

Muslim storeowner brutally beaten in New York City

A New York City Muslim storeowner has been brutally beaten in what police are investigating as a hate crime

The New York Police Department (NYPD) told The Independent that Florida-resident Piro Kolvani on Saturday attacked Sarker Haque, 53, who owns Fatima Food Market in the city’s Astoria neighborhood. Mr Kolvani was arrested shortly after the incident. 

The NYPD is investigating the alleged attack as a hate crime amid an apparent spike in similar Islamophobic attacks occurring in the wake of an attack by self-professed adherents of the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) killed 14 people last week in San Bernadino, California.  

Mr Haque told The Independent that Mr Kolvani entered his store and appeared to have been incensed by the cover of the New York Post, which on Saturday featured a photo of Tashfeen Malik, one of the San Bernadino shooters. “Massacre Woman Loved ISIS: Wife From Hell,” the cover reads. 

National media have criticized the Post for that and other covers that Muslim community advocates have said demonize Muslims in the wake of the attack. “Muslim killers,” a headline on a cover three days before Haque’s assault read. 

“I think the newspaper attracted him, to be honest,” Mr Haque said. 

The beating went on for six to eight minutes, Mr Haque said, before a long-time customer came to his aid and detained Mr Kolvani until the police arrived. 

“I never saw a situation like that. Not even after 9/11” Mr Haque said.

The New York branch of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) reached out to Mr Haque after he was released from hospital care Monday to assist him in dealing with law enforcement. 

For CAIR's New York director, Sadiya Khalique, its often difficult to get victims of Islamophobic incidents to report attacks. “Many people who contact us don't want to report because they don't want to relive the incident during questioning,” Ms Khalique told The Independent

The United States has seen a steady rise in Islamophobic attacks this year, CAIR says. The organisation’s national branch reported in July that the number of attacks on mosques had surpassed the total number for all of 2014. Ms Khalique says that despite what appears to be a surge in anti-Muslim crime nationwide, she has no New York City-specific statistics, and that the data is often misleading, precisely because many victims, who she says are traumatized by the assaults, choose not to come forward. 

Victims of Islamophobic hate crimes are often women, Muslim community advocates say, because they are more clearly indentified as Muslim when they wear headscarves. But NYPD hate crime data shows that men comprise a majority of hate crime victims. 

Ms Khalique wears a headscarf, or hijab. Despite being the head of a rights advocacy organisation, she fears for her safety, particularly in a climate where anti-Muslim rhetoric is an evermore common form of political discourse. On Monday, Republican presidential hopeful Donald Trump called to ban Muslims from entering the US. 

“For me, I am fearful that I might be next,” Ms Khalique said. “I wear a hijab and am visibly Muslim. And despite doing civil rights work, I am fearful. For me and for my mother and my sister.” 


A growing number of American Muslim children face bullying in local schools, she added. 

Last month, a Muslim elementary school student was brutally beaten by her fellow students and called “ISIS,” the abbreviation for the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria armed group. Police declined to file a police report against the alleged assailants, who will face a disciplinary hearing, according to new site RawStory.com. 

Ms Khalique, who aided the victim’s family, said that they will not pursue further legal action at this time.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.