Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Chronicle Live
Chronicle Live
National
Phil Cardy & Kristy Dawson

Mum of murdered Nikki Allan to sue police for 'mistakes' after waiting over 30 years for justice

The mum of a murdered seven year-old has vowed to watch her killer face justice this week – but wants to sue the police for "mistakes" that left him on the loose for more than 30 years.

Nikki Allan was bludgeoned with a brick and stabbed 37 times by David Boyd in Sunderland in October 1992. However the 55-year-old child killer was not convicted until Friday – three decades after he took the little girl’s life.

Sunday Mirror reports how Nikki’s mum Sharon Henderson has vowed to watch Boyd face justice when he is sentenced at Newcastle Crown Court on Tuesday.

Read more: Murdered Nikki Allan's mum refuses to accept police apology for failings with investigation

The 56-year-old said: "He should never be let out, I just wish there was still the death penalty.

"I couldn't sit through the whole trial, I was told some of the details were so bad it would be better if I left.

"But I will be there this week. I won't look him in the eye. I can't even bear to look at the man.

"I thought I was brave for all those years when I was fighting for justice. I always said I wanted to look him in the face and tell him what I thought of him.

"But how do you look at someone who murdered your bairn in the face?"

Boyd murdered Nikki after luring the youngster to a derelict building in the city, known as the Old Exchange.

Sharon says there were "too many failures, too many mistakes" in the murder investigation carried out by Northumbria Police.

She said: "I’ve known a lawyer for years and we’re looking at taking legal action against the police. They need to be held to account.

"I’m angry. The police knew he’d committed crimes before in the 1980s, and they would have taken a statement off him when Nikki was killed. But they didn’t put the pieces together."

Sharon Henderson at home in Sunderland (Newcastle Chronicle)

In 1992 Boyd was 25 and lived three doors away from Nikki’s grandparents. His girlfriend at the time was the little girl’s babysitter.

Sharon said: "They had a baby in a pram at their flat and all the kids, including my Nikki, used to talk to the baby in the buggy. She was familiar with him and his girlfriend."

She believes Boyd should have been a suspect from the very start.

Sharon said: "On day one, after Nikki was murdered, they should have looked at him. “When someone is killed, the first people the police look at is family, then the people they know or trust. Why didn’t they haul him in?"

In 1986, eight years before he killed Nikki, Boyd was convicted of breaching the peace – after he approached four children aged eight to 10, grabbed one and asked for a kiss.

Nikki Allan (PA)

Seven years after the murder, in 1999, he was convicted of indecently assaulting a nine-year-old girl.

Sharon said: “He was on their files and lived nearby. How did they miss him? His first crime was in the 80s. They should have gone to him first.

"When he assaulted that poor girl, why didn’t they make the link then?"

The force has apologised to Sharon’s family as well as a man falsely accused of killing Nikki – neighbour George Heron, who was prosecuted but cleared of murder in 1993.

Assistant Chief Constable Alastair Simpson said: "I am truly sorry for mistakes that were made in the 1992 investigation and I am sorry for the length of time it has taken to get justice for the family.

"I cannot imagine the impact on them over the...last 30 years."

Sharon wants the force to launch a full investigation into Boyd’s activities. She said: "The police should be looking at where he’s worked, where he’s travelled, where he’s been on holiday.

"You don’t do something like that, kill a little bairn, and just stop.

"He stole Nikki’s life and I know he’s lived his thinking he’d got away with it. But I’m more concerned about how he lived his life.

"There will be more victims out there."

Boyd was finally arrested in 2018 after police relaunched the murder investigation and found new forensic evidence – traces of his DNA on tragic Nikki’s shorts and T-shirt.

During his three-week trial, Boyd tried to explain it by saying he had spat from the balcony of his flat while Nikki was playing below.

But the jury at Newcastle Crown Court didn't believe him – and took just 90 minutes to find him guilty.

Sharon, who has three other daughters, said "life went downhill" when they lost Nikki but the family keep each other strong.

She said: "I’ve got four grandchildren and they’ve brought us happiness. We are all there to support each other."

Read more:

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.