Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
World
Archie Bland

Monday briefing: Israel’s strategy is changing. Can it keep the US behind it?

Palestinians at the hospital in Khan Younis mourn relatives killed by Israeli’s renewed offensive.
Palestinians at the hospital in Khan Younis mourn relatives killed by Israeli’s renewed offensive. Photograph: Fatima Shbair/AP

Good morning. In the first stage of Israel’s war with Hamas, Palestinian civilians were urged to flee the north of the Gaza Strip and find refuge in safer areas in the south. After the collapse of the weeklong truce on Friday, it is the south that has faced the brunt of Israel’s attacks.

The focal point of Israel’s airstrikes and artillery fire for the last few days has been Khan Younis, the second largest city in the region. People have been ordered to evacuate the city, and now the Israel Defence Forces say that they have expanded ground operations “across all of the Gaza Strip”. An hour ago, Unicef spokesman James Elder described a sleepless night “of utterly relentless bombardments” in Khan Younis. There have also been reports of clashes between Hamas and Israeli troops a mile from the city.

Israel says it is taking unprecedented steps to prevent civilian casualties. As the onslaught intensifies, a new question hovers over the conflict: is Israel doing enough to keep its key western allies – especially the US – behind it?

Today’s newsletter, with the Guardian’s Dan Sabbagh in Jerusalem, is about the next phase of the war in Gaza: Israel’s plan of attack, the diplomatic limits on its freedom to operate, and what it means for the Palestinians being asked to evacuate again. Here are the headlines.

Five big stories

  1. UK politics | Labour will not “turn on the spending taps” if it wins the next election, Keir Starmer will say on Monday, bolstering the view of some of his senior MPs that he is preparing to sign up to austerity-style public sector cuts. The Labour leader will use a speech on the economy to warn that Britain is in its worst economic state in more than half a century.

  2. Cop28 | The president of Cop28, Sultan Al Jaber, has claimed there is “no science” indicating that a phase-out of fossil fuels is needed to restrict global heating to 1.5C. In remarks during a live online event last month that scientists described as “verging on climate denial”, Al Jaber claimed a phase-out of fossil fuels risked “taking the world back into caves”.

  3. Immigration | Ministers are deliberately hiding the mounting costs of the Rwanda deportation scheme from the public, the head of an influential parliamentary watchdog has told the Guardian, as insiders expect a new deal with the African country to be signed off within days.

  4. India | A Sikh activist in Birmingham complained that Indian police were verbally harassing him by phone and threatening his family in Punjab months before his sudden death in June, a Guardian investigation has found. Avtar Singh Khanda’s family have called his death suspicious, but British authorities have said that there is no reason to suspect foul play.

  5. UK news | Glenys Kinnock, the senior Labour politician and wife of the former leader Neil Kinnock, has died aged 79. Her family called her “a proud democratic socialist” who campaigned “for justice and against poverty all her life.”

In depth: ‘The window of opportunity is closing for Israel’

Palestinians flee from east to west of Khan Younis, Gaza Strip, on Saturday.
Palestinians flee from east to west of Khan Younis, Gaza Strip, on Saturday. Photograph: Fatima Shbair/AP

The seven-day ceasefire in Gaza that saw the release of 105 Israeli hostages and 240 Palestinian prisoners now seems a very long time ago. Ismael al-Thawabteh, the director general of the government media office in Hamas-run Gaza, said yesterday that more than 700 Palestinians had been killed in 24 hours, while the health ministry said later that 316 had been killed “in the past hours”. The heaviest attacks have been in and around the city of Khan Younis, in the south of the strip.

People in areas to the south-east of the city have now been told by the Israeli military to leave, apparently paving the way for a ground incursion. “As soon as the truce ended, it was clear that the focus would now be on the south, and Khan Younis in particular,” Dan Sabbagh said. “That is where Israel believes Hamas’ leadership to be hiding out.” Israel’s political and military leadership argue that if they can kill senior Hamas commanders, they will take a significant step towards forcing the organisation’s collapse.

In the first phase of the conflict, Israel’s attacks produced limited diplomatic pressure from its allies; most significantly, the US placed few practical limits on its support, though it decried the loss of civilian life. Now it is taking a firmer line on the avoidance of civilian casualties. But it is not yet clear how deeply that will impact Israel’s strategy.

***

What is the US saying about the new phase of the war?

“Israel arguably has a higher tolerance for international condemnation of its actions than almost any other country,” Dan said. The only country with the leverage to seriously affect its actions is the United States. And in the last few days, US public statements have taken on a new tone.

On Thursday, US secretary of state Antony Blinken was reported to have told Israel’s war cabinet that it may only have weeks to complete its plan to defeat Hamas in Gaza. In a press conference, he said that he had “underscored the imperative – for the United States – that the massive loss of civilian life and displacement of the scale that we saw in northern Gaza not be repeated in the south.” That warning was echoed by US vice-president Kamala Harris and defence secretary Lloyd Austin over the weekend.

“There is a sense that the window of opportunity is closing for Israel,” Dan said. “It is clearly having to frame its strategy in a way that keeps the US on board.” But more consequential than US public statements will be whether it backs them up with concrete actions. On Friday, the Wall Street Journal reported (£) a surge in US arms supplied to Israel since the war began, with tens of thousands of bombs and shells including heavy “bunker busters” provided on top of billions of dollars’ worth of existing annual support for its military operations. “One question is whether the military support continues in spite of the political narrative,” Dan said.

***

Have US warnings led to a change in Israel’s strategy?

Israel has devised a new map which subdivides Gaza into hundreds of small blocs, which it is using to announce its evacuation orders. Israel points to that initiative as evidence of its desire to protect civilians by focusing on the most precise areas possible and giving people time to flee by announcing them ahead of its attacks. By Sunday, residents of 34 of the blocs, all of them in and around Khan Younis, had been told to depart for safer territory. Israel’s minister of strategic affairs Ron Dermer called that approach “unprecedented”, adding: “If we wanted to do it fast, we’d harm a lot more civilians.”

But that system has come under heavy criticism from agencies and aid workers on the ground, who say that a map accessed via a QR code on social media posts and leaflets dropped into Khan Younis will be of little use to those without access to reliable internet services – or electricity to charge their phones. Rohan Talbot, advocacy director at the charity Medical Aid for Palestinians, said that it amounted to nothing more than a “macabre game of Battleships”. There have been reports of bombing outside the designated areas.

“One problem is whether enough time is being given to civilians to escape,” Dan said. “The bombing started on Friday more or less as the leaflets were dropped. So there is some scepticism about whether this is truly a different strategy.” Fundamentally, he added, critics of Israel’s approach say that “whether you cut the cake into large pieces or small pieces, it amounts to the same thing. They ask where civilians are supposed to go to be safe.” Many have already fled from the bombardment in the north, and may fear that wherever they head next will also be targeted. “People who fled to Khan Younis can’t go back to the north, where large areas are a wasteland anyway,” Dan said. “The safe spaces in the south are being reduced too.”

Nonetheless, the US signalled on Sunday that it viewed the grid approach as evidence that Israel was taking its stance seriously. “We believe they have been receptive to our messages here of trying to minimise civilian casualties,” US national security council spokesperson John Kirby told ABC yesterday, pointing to the map as evidence. “There’s not a whole lot of modern militaries that would do that … to telegraph their punches in that way. So they are making an effort.”

***

What does all this mean for Palestinian civilians?

The Israeli maps feature large arrows pointing residents of the targeted areas around Khan Younis in the general direction of humanitarian shelters and a so-called “humanitarian zone” towards the coast, where the IDF has previously said that “international humanitarian aid will be provided as needed”. But there are urgent questions about whether there will be any real measure of safety when aid supplies are already drying up under the pressure of vast numbers of displaced people.

The UN humanitarian agency, OCHA, said on Saturday that about 1.8 million Palestinians have already been internally displaced – close to 80% of the Gaza Strip’s population. (It added that “obtaining an accurate count is challenging”.) The UN’s high commissioner for refugees, Filippo Grandi, told the BBC that people in Gaza are being “pushed more and more towards a narrow corner of what is already a very narrow territory”. And despite an increase in aid being allowed into Gaza during the pause, the supplies are still dwarfed by the need, Dan said.

“This is already a very severe humanitarian crisis,” he added. “But it is at risk of getting even more severe. Shelters are already badly overcrowded – there’s one in Khan Younis designed for 1,000 people where there are now 35,000, with 600 people to every toilet. There is anxiety that there will not be enough fuel to run desalination plants that provide a lot of people with drinking water. And there has been no real opportunity in the last week for aid agencies to do a serious needs assessment for different areas.”

If a ground offensive now develops in the south, civilians will nonetheless have little alternative but to run again. Some are deeply sceptical that doing so will save their lives. Halima Abdel-Rahman, a widow and mother of four who has already fled her home for Khan Younis, told the Associated Press she would no longer listen to evacuation orders. “The occupation tells you to go to this area, then they bomb it,” she said. “The reality is that no place is safe in Gaza.”

What else we’ve been reading

Saoirse-Monica Jackon in The Doll Factory.
Saoirse-Monica Jackon in The Doll Factory. Photograph: Buccaneer TV/Buccaneer TV/Parmount
  • Saoirse-Monica Jackson took the world by storm in 2018 when she debuted as Erin Quinn in Channel 4’s sitcom Derry Girls. Five years later, her career is going from strength to strength. Tim Lewis’s interview captures some of her magic. Nimo

  • In between avoiding eye contact with Tom Cruise and turning down an indecent proposal from Warren Beatty, Jill Goldston had a long career as the “world’s most prolific film extra”. She talks to Ellen E Jones. Clare Longrigg, acting head of newsletters

  • If you think you’ve got the world’s worst job, think again. For the Guardian’s Experience column, Jozz Little tells her story of being paid to be bedbug bait. Nimo

  • How do you turn a favourite dish into a powder that can be baked into potato chips? Amelia Tait goes in search of the weird, secretive world of crisp flavours. Clare

  • Saudi Arabia has spent hundreds of billions of dollars on giant, wildly ambitious “gigaprojects” that span culture and construction. Rowan Moore finds out why. Nimo

Sport

Dejan Kulusevski celebrates his late goal against Manchester City.
Dejan Kulusevski celebrates his late goal against Manchester City. Photograph: Martin Rickett/PA

Football | Dejan Kulusevski’s stoppage time equaliser stunned champions Manchester City to steal a 3-3 draw for Spurs in Sunday’s late Premier League matchup. Elsewhere, Liverpool beat Fulham 4-3 after Trent Alexander-Arnold’s dramatic winner and Bournemouth and Aston Villa drew 2-2 after Ollie Watkins’ 90th-minute header rescued a point for Villa.

Cricket | England were thwarted by West Indies as they attempted to turn the page on the disappointment of the World Cup, losing a thriller despite setting a record ODI score at the Sir Vivian Richards Stadium in Antigua. Shai Hope’s superb 109 not out off 83 balls, with support from Romario Shepherd’s 48 from 28 balls, got West Indies over the line with seven balls to spare.

Snooker | Ronnie O’Sullivan repelled the determined challenge of Ding Junhui to become the oldest winner of the UK Championship in York, 30 years after he claimed his first title at the tournament at the age of 17. O’Sullivan, 48 on Tuesday, sealed a record-extending eighth UK crown but said afterwards: “I’d rather sit on my bed and watch a bit of Netflix”.

The front pages

Guardian Front Page 04 December 2023
Guardian Front Page 04 December 2023 Photograph: Guardian

The Guardian leads with “Starmer: Labour will not ‘turn on spending taps’ if it wins election”, saying the speech will likely raise fears of public sector cuts should the party win the next election. In the Mirror it’s “Thatcher backlash hits Starmer” on what the paper describes as ‘fury’ after the Labour leader reportedly praised the former Conservative prime minister. In the i the headline is “Tories losing voters to Farage amid anger over high migration”, as the Express has the headline “Don’t write us off! Tories plan for election battle”.

The Times reports that the “Economy pays heavy price as UK gets fatter”. The paper covers new analysis suggesting that Britain’s obesity problem could affect reported government plans to get the sick back to work.

In the Financial Times it’s “EU budget wrangles threaten pledge of €50bn war lifeline for Ukraine”. The Telegraph looks at the BBC with the headline “Sunak to block BBC licence fee increase”. The Mail takes the line “PM warns BBC over biggest licence fee increase for 40 years”, reporting Rishi Sunak has told the broadcaster to cut costs.

Today in Focus

Journalists react after two Palestinian colleagues were killed in an Israeli strike in Gaza City, 10 October 2023
Journalists react after two Palestinian colleagues were killed in an Israeli strike in Gaza City, 10 October 2023. Photograph: Haitham Imad/EPA

Why is the Israel-Hamas conflict so deadly for journalists?

More reporters are said to have been killed in this conflict than any in decades. Jonathan Dagher, from Reporters Without Borders, discusses what it means for public understanding of the region

Cartoon of the day | Edith Pritchett

Edith Pritchett / the Guardian
Edith Pritchett / the Guardian Illustration: Edith Pritchett/The Guardian

Sign up for Inside Saturday to see more of Edith Pritchett’s cartoons, the best Saturday magazine content and an exclusive look behind the scenes

The Upside

A bit of good news to remind you that the world’s not all bad

A white rhino from Phinda private game reserve in South Africa is released in Akagera national park in Rwanda, November 2021.
A white rhino from Phinda private game reserve in South Africa is released in Akagera national park in Rwanda, November 2021. Photograph: Gael Ruboneka Vande Weghe/African Parks

A herd of 2,000 endangered white rhinos (15% of Africa’s entire population) living in captivity are to be returned to the wild. The rhinos, bred by a South African multimillionaire, have been bought by conservation NGO African Parks, which plans to release them into protected areas.

Donovan Jooste, the NGO’s rhino rewilding project manager, said: “They have massive ecological value, the ability to maintain and shape landscapes … as well as economic value, for tourism, and community value. It’s a massive undertaking, but the end vision is a massive win.”

Sign up here for a weekly roundup of The Upside, sent to you every Sunday

Bored at work?

And finally, the Guardian’s puzzles are here to keep you entertained throughout the day – with plenty more on the Guardian’s Puzzles app for iOS and Android. Until tomorrow.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.