Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Business
Angela Monaghan (until 2.45) and Nick Fletcher

Shock US jobs report as payrolls growth lowest for more than 5 years - as it happened

Times Square, New York City
Times Square, New York City. Photograph: Robert Harding World Imagery / A/Alamy

Fed should be cautious on rate hike, says central bank's Brainard

The poor US jobs figures only add to the concerns about the country’s economy, which may still be too weak for a rate rise.

That is the view expressed by Federal Reserve governor Lael Brainard in a speech in Washington. She said the non-farm payroll numbers suggested that the US labour market had slowed, and added that any rate rise should also wait until it was clearer that China and Europe are doing better, and the UK’s referendum on EU membership was out of the way. She said:

Recognising the data we have on hand for the second quarter is quite mixed and still limited, and there is important near-term uncertainty, there would appear to be an advantage to waiting until developments provide greater confidence.

Prudent risk-management would suggest the risks from waiting until the totality of the data provides greater confidence in a rebound in domestic activity, and there is greater certainty regarding the “Brexit” vote, seem lower than the risks associated with moving ahead of these developments.

On that note, it’s time to close for the evening. Thanks for all your comments, and we’ll be back next week.

US energy companies added 9 oil rigs last week, bringing the total rig count up to 325 according to the latest Baker Hughes report. This is only the second time this year the rig count has gone up, and then it was only one rig in the middle of March. It comes as oil hit $50 a barrel despite this week’s Opec meeting failing to agree an output ceiling.

The number of gas rigs fell however, making a total increase of four rigs:

Updated

European shares rattled by poor US jobs numbers

The disappointing non-farm payroll numbers gave a shock to investors who were expecting a calm end to the week, sending stock markets sharply lower, hitting the dollar and prompting a spate of bond buying.

There was a two way pull between those who saw the job figures as positive, in that they would prevent the US Federal Reserve from raising interest rates this month, and those who worried about the signs of a weak US economy. By the close of trade in Europe, the former had regained some ground and markets recovered from their worst levels. Indeed UK shares, supported by rises in commodity companies as oil held fairly steady during the day, managed to end up in positive territory. The final scores showed:

  • The FTSE 100 finished up 24.02 points or 0.39% at 6209.63
  • Germany’s Dax dropped 1.03% to 10,103.26
  • France’s Cac closed down 0.99% at 4421.78
  • Italy’s FTSE MIB fell 1.53% to 17,495.09
  • Spain’s Ibex ended 1.74% lower at 8801.6
  • In Greece, the Athens market added 1.48% to 648.63

On Wall Street, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is currently down just 39 points or 0.23%.

Back with the US jobs:

Friday rating agency update:

S&P said:

We expect the new minority government in Ireland to keep pursuing open and proactive economic policies and continue fiscal consolidation. Thanks to rapid nominal GDP growth, we expect net general government debt to decline to below 80% of GDP in 2017.

We are therefore affirming our ‘A+/A-1’ sovereign credit ratings on Ireland. The stable outlook balances our view of upside potential for the ratings if Ireland’s fiscal position continues to improve against risks associated with external factors such as a potential Brexit, or weaker global demand.

Updated

Bond prices rose and yields fell as investors looked for havens after the shock US jobs numbers.

In the UK, 30 year yields fell to 2.084% after the US data, the lowest level since February 2015. Germany’s 10 year Bund yield fell to 0.073%, its lowest this year.

The poor jobs numbers following various hawkish comments from US Federal Reserve members make chair Janet Yellen’s speech on Monday evening a potentially tricky affair. David Morrison, senior market strategist at Spread Co, said:

Over the last month it became apparent that the US Federal Reserve was unhappy that the market refused to price in the prospect of a summer rate hike. Consequently, over the past few weeks we saw a confusion of Fed Heads come out to declare that their conditions for monetary tightening were being met. Some were claiming that two, three or even four rate hikes were possible in 2016 – a ludicrous proposition given the few windows available due to the US Presidential Election, let alone the uncertain outlook for the US and global economies.

This constant barrage of hawkishness pressed the markets to sharply cut the odds on a summer rate hike. This led to a rally in the dollar together with a nasty and protracted sell-off in precious metals. That’s all been reversed now thanks to today’s payroll release.

On Monday evening (17:30BST) Yellen is scheduled to speak about the economic outlook and monetary policy. It will be very interesting to hear what she has to say in the light of the jobs data. We can’t blame the Fed for weak data. But we can take them to task for their relentless effort to tell the market it was pricing financial assets incorrectly. The US Federal Reserve exerts too much influence over the markets these days and many investors will now believe that the Fed has taken them for a ride. Yellen is going to find it very difficult to winch back credibility for the central bank now.

Yellen hinting at summer rate rises last week at Harvard.
Yellen hinting at summer rate rises last week at Harvard. Photograph: Brian Snyder/Reuters

A week ago Federal Reserve chair Janet Yellen was at Harvard suggesting a summer interest rate rise could on the cards. Now, after the poor jobs figures, maybe not:

The disappointing US services sector data which followed quickly on from the poor jobs numbers provides another reason for the Federal Reserve to leave rates unchanged this month, says James Smith at ING Bank:

After May’s non-farm payrolls plummeted, the ISM Non-manufacturing came crashing back down to 52.9 from 55.7, much lower than expected. Aside from supplier deliveries, the other main components that contribute to the headline recorded fairly sizable falls (employment and business activity), particularly new orders, where the size of the month-on-month drop was the largest since November 2008. This is especially concerning, given that in theory it sets the precedent for (or “leads”) future business activity.

Although the ISM surveys are perhaps not the most central part of the Federal Reserve Open Market Committee reaction function, the magnitude of the fall means that it will probably feature in the debate over near-term policy. Indeed, given that the US recession story has faded away over recent weeks, it is possible that the combination of today’s weak non-farm payrolls figure and the drop in the ISM Non-manufacturing prompts the debate to resurface to some degree over coming weeks. Either way, it is another reason for the FOMC to leave rates unchanged in June, with focus now on Chair Yellen’s speech on Monday to see how the latest data will affect policy in coming months.

Still, US factory orders were more or less in line with expectations:

Updated

US service sector growth slows

More signs of weakness in the US economy, this time from two surveys of the service sector.

First the ISM non-manufacturing PMI fell from 55.7 in April to 52.9, well below the consensus forecast of 55.5. The new orders index at 54.2, down from 59.9, was the lowest since February 2014.

And the final reading of the Markit services PMI for May came in at 51.3, down from 52.8 in April. The index is marginally higher that the first estimate of 51.2 for May.

Meanwhile the Markit composite index - manufacturing and services - fell from 52.4 in April to 50.9.

Here’s a chart showing the jobs numbers:

Non farm payrolls
Non farm payrolls Photograph: Bureau of Labor Statistics

And unemployment rate

Unemployment rate
Unemployment rate Photograph: Bureau of Labor Statistics

Joey Lake, US analyst at the Economist Intelligence Unit, said:

The jobs report was bad, bad, bad: there is no positive spin to it. Not only was May a particularly weak month, the worst in almost six years, but revisions dragged previous months lower. The unemployment rate declined to 4.7% but that is because of a fall in the labour force participation rate: not what we want to see happening. Overall, the job market has added an average of 116,000 jobs/month over the past three months, a substantial slowdown from the 229,000/month averaged in 2015.

What is the reason? The Verizon strike certainly weighed on the May numbers, so we can expect a bounce back in June. And as the US approaches full employment, the rate of job creation was always going to slow. This does not seem to be indicative of a broader economic slowdown: in April consumer spending rose by 1%, the largest monthly increase since 2009.

The labour market slowdown will make the Federal Reserve reconsider its next move. It reduces the chance of a June rate increase and makes it more likely the Fed will wait until July, after the Brexit vote, which will also reduce the political risk from abroad.

More reaction to the disappointing jobs figures.

CEBR added its voice to those suggesting a US rate rise in June was now off the table. Senior economist Alasdair Cavalla said:

[The report] does support our assessment that now is still too early for another rise. The main factor slowing down growth in the US is exports, which is precisely where the impact of tightening will fall most heavily in the form of a stronger dollar. Fed officials have explicitly highlighted a potential Brexit as another downside risk likely to stay its hand in June. This comes on top of a still fragile global economic environment. Today’s news suggests there may be more to worry about than thought. A good year economically is thought to favour incumbent governments; the risk of a protectionist and isolationist administration by the end of the year is hardly going to give firms the reassurance they need to hire and invest. In the absence of any meaningful inflationary threat, raising interest rates in such an environment would be incomprehensible.

And:

And here’s a possible explanation for the shock figures:

Updated

The weaker than expected US jobs numbers have also sent European markets lower.

Germany’s Dax is now down 0.8% while France’s Cac is 0.78% lower. The FTSE 100 is just managing to stay in positive territory, up 4.5 points.

The dollar has fallen to a two week low on the basis that the figures make a June rate rise unlikely now, despite the previous hints to the contrary from various Fed members. The dollar index dropped by more than 1% while the euro rose 1.3% and sterling hit a three day high of 1.4544.

US markets open lower

Wall Street sign

Wall Street is down in early trading following those horrible payrolls numbers - the worst in almost six years.

  • Dow Jones: -0.3% at 17,780
  • S&P 500: -0.2% at 2,101
  • Nasdaq: -0.3% at 4,958

Investors will be weighing up whether it’s plain bad news (weak employment market) or good bad news (US rate hike delayed because of weak employment market).

Updated

The biggest increase in jobs was in the healthcare sector, with 46,000 jobs added in May, while employment in professional and business services was up by 10,000.

Mining, manufacturing and construction were among the sectors where jobs fell.

Economists said a US rate hike in June - previously considered a strong possibility - was now unlikely because of the unexpectedly weak payrolls.

Paul Ashworth, chief US economist at Capital Economics:

The 38,000 increase in non-farm payrolls in May, which is still only 73,000 if we adjust for the 35,000 striking Verizon workers, means that a June rate hike from the Fed is now very unlikely.

In addition, the gains in the preceding two months were revised down by a cumulative 59,000. A July hike is still possible, but it would require clear evidence of a rebound in June’s payroll figures (and a UK vote to remain in the European Union).

That sound you hear is Fed Chair Janet Yellen furiously re-writing her speech that she is scheduled to give on Monday.

James Smith, economist at ING:

Over recent weeks, the blocks appeared to have been gradually falling into place for another rate hike from the Fed, but the latest labour report has potentially put a large spanner in the works.

In our opinion, this may well put the final nail in the coffin for a June hike, with confirmation of this potentially coming from Chair Yellen’s speech on Monday.

Donald Trump has given his verdict on the shockingly weak payrolls numbers:

May’s US jobs numbers were always going to be affected by a strike among Verizon workers, but they do not account for such a huge drop in payrolls (to 38k).

As Jana Kasperkevic from the Guardian’s New York office explains:

A strike by 40,000 Verizon workers impacted the numbers, the labor department said, and without the strike the number of jobs added would have been 72,000, which is still less than a half of expect job growth.

Looking at the detail of the US jobs numbers, wage growth was in line with expectations at 0.2% in May.

The unemployment rate eased to 4.7% from 5% in April, although the drop was partly explained by people who stopped looking for work and were therefore no longer classed as unemployed.

From the US Labor Department report:

In May, 1.7m persons were marginally attached to the labor force, little changed from a year earlier. (The data are not seasonally adjusted.) These individuals were not in the labor force, wanted and were available for work, and had looked for a job sometime in the prior 12 months.

They were not counted as unemployed because they had not searched for work in the 4 weeks preceding the survey.

Among the marginally attached, there were 538,000 discouraged workers in May, essentially unchanged from a year earlier. (The data are not seasonally adjusted.)

Discouraged workers are persons not currently looking for work because they believe no jobs are available for them.

Manufacturing payrolls fell by 10,000 after rising by a (downwardly revised) 2,000 a month earlier.

US futures dropped after the shock payrolls figures.

On the one hand, it makes the prospect of a rate rise at the FOMC’s June meeting less likely. But on the other, it suggests the labour market in the world’s largest economy is weaker than assumed.

Here is the full story from our US team.

This is a huge miss on US jobs, as companies dramatically slowed their hiring in May.

Payrolls rose by just 38,000 in May, the slowest rate of growth since September 2010.

This should get the member’s of the Fed’s rate-setting FOMC scratching their heads...

US payrolls sharply lower than expected

Breaking: US non-farm payrolls have come in way below expectations.

There were 38,000 jobs added in May, compared with expectations of a 164,000 increase.

April’s number has been revised down too - to 123,000 from an earlier estimate of 160,000.

More soon....

Updated

Earlier, there were some disappointing eurozone retail sales figures.

Instead of the expected 0.3% month on month rise in April, sales were flat due to falls in Germany and Belgium in the wake of the Brussels terror attacks. This follows a 0.6% fall in the overall eurozone figure in March.

The year on year rise in April was 1.4%, below forecasts of a 1.9% increase. The figures could point to slower GDP growth in the second quarter, analysts believe.

The rise in the FTSE 100 today means after a volatile few months, the index is more or less back where it began the year.

Connor Campbell, financial analyst at Spreadex, has this take on the markets:

Having started the day strong a far better than expected services PMI (at 53.5 against the 52.5 forecast) ensured the FTSE continued to grow this Friday, the UK index rising by nearly 1%.

While not quite as enthusiastic as the FTSE, the Eurozone indices nevertheless pushed forth with a near half a percent rise this Friday despite a fairly dismal morning for data.

Unsurprisingly the Dow Jones couldn’t quite join in with Europe’s rebound this Friday morning, the index’s futures resolute in their flatness ahead of this afternoon’s jobs report.

With June’s Fed meeting less than a fortnight away today’s non-farm number is arguably the most important since last December.

An update on how the other major markets in Europe are doing:

  • Germany’s DAX: +0.6% at 10,266
  • France’s CAC: +0.5% at 4,487
  • Spain’s IBEX: -0.03% at 8,955

The FTSE 100 is up 1% or 62 points at 6,248. It is the biggest riser among the major European indices.

Investors are no doubt relieved that the UK services PMI did not deliver a nasty shock, but markets are also being boosted by the resilience of oil prices.

Brent crude is hovering just above $50 a barrel despite the stalemate at Thursday’s Opec meeting in Vienna.

In a couple of hours we will have May’s non-farm payroll report from the US, which always has the potential to move markets. Economists polled by Reuters are expecting payrolls to jump by 164,000, following a 160,000 rise in April.

CMC’s Michael Hewson:

European markets have got off to a positive start ahead of this afternoon’s keenly awaited US jobs data.

Investors could do with some good news this week given that we’ve seen declines every day this week for the FTSE 100, despite the fact that the oil price looks on course for its fourth successive week of gains, with Brent prices looking to gain a foothold above $50 a barrel.

It is expected that the US economy will have added 160k new jobs in May, while the unemployment rate is expected to drop to 4.9%.

If the jobs number drops sharply to 130k or anywhere near that - quite possible given the Verizon strikes and the slowdown in manufacturing hiring - then any prospect of a move in rates in June, already seen as fairly low could well diminish further.

Updated

JP Morgan boss: Brexit could mean 4,000 UK job losses

Jamie Dimon, the chief executive of JP Morgan, is the latest business leader to issue a dire warning on the potential consequences of Brexit.

Addressing the bank’s staff in Bournemouth, alongside the chancellor and remain campaigner George Osborne, Dimon said:

I think it would be a terrible deal for the British economy and jobs.

I don’t know if it means 1,000 jobs [would go at JP Morgan], 2,000 jobs, it could be as many as 4,000 jobs. And they would be jobs all around the UK.

I don’t want you to worry about it but when you vote you should be thinking about something like this.

Charles Evans, president of the Chicago Federal Reserve has been speaking in London about the possible timing of US interest rate hikes.

He said there was a “reasonable case” for delaying rate rises until core inflation reaches the Fed’s 2% target.

On current forecasts, that wouldn’t be until 2018.

However, Evans said that as things stood, it was likely the Fed would vote for two rate hikes before the end of 2016, taking borrowing costs to a range between 0.75% and 1%.

Speaking at the Global Interdependence Center in London, he said:

Frankly, I’m really of two minds at the moment, and I expect to take this quandary with me into the next FOMC meeting.

On the one hand, under the committee’s current approach to renormalizing policy, I think it may be appropriate to have two 25 basis point moves between now and the end of the year.

I see the value in making small and gradual adjustments to the fed funds rate as the data improve and confirm my positive baseline outlook for the US. And this is my base-case view of appropriate policy.

On the other hand, if I think outside of the baseline, I also think that a reasonable case can be made for holding off increasing the funds rate until core inflation actually gets to 2% on a sustainable basis.

BHS collapse: Sir Phillip Green accused of 'lamentable behaviour'

Philip Green and model Kate Moss
Philip Green and model Kate Moss

In other UK news, Sir Philip Green has received more criticism over BHS - the high street retail chain he sold for £1 last year that has now collapsed with the loss of 11,000 jobs.

Simon Walker, the head of the Institute of Directors accused Green of a “lamentable failure of behaviour” that risked “deeply damaging” the British business world as a whole.

He told BBC radio 4:

Sir Philip Green is a very high-profile business leader. He is the person who is on the front page with Kate Moss on his arm and who has a £100m superyacht and so on.

When someone like this ends up behaving like this, people think that’s how business is, and it’s not. The majority of business leaders are people who are more likely to have mortgaged their homes to keep their company going than to own this kind of lavish thing.

Read our full story here.

Green will face questions by MPs on 15 June over his role in the demise of BHS.

Here is the breakdown of how UK services companies felt their businesses were being affected by the looming possibility of Brexit...

services brexit

Markit’s chief economist, Chris Williamson, was not overly cheered by the better-than-expected services PMI number for the UK.

He says that taking into account all the data for the second quarter so far, growth is on course to halve between April and June, following 0.4% growth in the first quarter.

The PMI surveys show that the pace of economic growth remained subdued in May, as Brexit worries exacerbated existing headwinds. The data so far indicate that the second quarter is likely to see the economy grow by just 0.2%.

Growth has collapsed in manufacturing and construction, leaving the economy dependent on the service sector to sustain the upturn, though even here the pace of expansion has remained frustratingly weak so far this year.

The detail of the PMI survey showed that UK services sector companies took on workers at the slowest rate in more than three years.

The better-than-expected UK services PMI should come as a relief to investors.

A weaker number for May would have started to build a more worrying picture of how the UK economy is performing in the second quarter.

The big fear is that if Britain votes to leave the EU when it goes to the polls on 23 June, the UK will slide back into recession at a time when the economy is not fully healed following the last crisis.

In May’s PMI, Markit asked UK services companies an additional question:

“Please state the extent to which the issue of the UK’s potential exit from the EU is currently affecting your business.”

Of those taking part in the survey, 28% said a potential Brexit was having a detrimental impact on business, while 9% said it was having a strongly detrimental impact.

On the flip side, 51% said it was having no significant effect.

UK services sector grows in May

Breaking: The UK services sector grew at a faster rate than expected in May.

The headline index on the Markit/CIPS PMI increased to 53.5 from 52.3 in April. Economists were expecting a smaller rise to 52.5. Anything above 50 indicates expansion.

So Italy let the side down on an otherwise positive set of services PMIs for the eurozone.

Chris Williamson, chief economist at Markit, said combined with the manufacturing surveys published earlier in the week, the latest PMIs suggested the eurozone economy was moving along at a sluggish pace.

He suggested the growth of 0.5% achieved in the first quarter would not be sustained into the second:

The final PMI numbers for May have come in slightly ahead of the earlier flash readings, but still point a eurozone economy which seems unable to move out of low gear.

The survey data are signalling a GDP rise of 0.3% in the second quarter, suggesting the growth spurt seen at the start of the year will prove frustratingly short-lived.

Eurozone services sector grows

The eurozone’s services sector expanded at the fastest rate in three months in May, boosted by growth in Germany, France, Spain and Ireland.

The headline index measuring activity on the Markit PMI survey edged up to 53.3 last month from 53.1 in April.

Employment in the eurozone’s services industry increased for a nineteenth month, with jobs created at the fastest rate in Germany and Ireland.

Italy’s services sector fared less well than its neighbours in the single currency bloc, with the headline index pointing to a contraction in activity in May.

European markets open higher

All major indices are higher this morning after Wall Street closed up last night.

Investors are holding their nerve so far. There were no nasty shocks on Thursday from the European Central Bank’s meeting of the governing council in Vienna, where all policy measures were left on hold.

European markets rose on Friday morning

Spanish services sector shows strength

Activity in Spain’s services sector grew at an accelerated pace in May according to the Markit PMI survey.

The headline index increased to 55.4 from 55.1 in April. It was better than the 53.5 forecast by economists, and will no doubt be a source of relief for investors following weaker manufacturing numbers earlier in the week.

Andrew Harker, senior economist at Markit and author of the PMI report, said:

Following on from Wednesday’s disappointing Spain manufacturing PMI numbers, the latest services data are something of a relief, with growth in activity and new business ticking up slightly.

The figures provide hope that the sector will be able to successfully weather headwinds such as a weak global environment and domestic political instability and remain in growth territory in the near-term at least.

Oil prices hover above $50

Brent crude oil has edged higher this morning, up 0.3% at $50.2 a barrel.

It appears that a stalemate at Opec’s meeting in Vienna on Thursday - where Tehran refused to support a plan by Riyadh and others to freeze their crude output - has been partially offset by the latest US stockpiles data.

US crude stockpiles fell 1.4m barrels last week, reducing supplies for a second week according to the figures from the Energy Information Administration.

The Agenda: services PMIs and US payrolls

UK services sector accounts for more than three quarters of the economy
UK services sector accounts for more than three quarters of the economy Photograph: Alamy

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

It’s all eyes on the service sector this morning as the PMI reports for May are published for the UK and the eurozone.

In the UK, the Markit/CIPS report will be closely watched by investors looking for clues on how the wider economy is doing in the second quarter.

Economists are predicting the monthly survey will paint a stable picture of the the sector, which accounts for more than three quarters of the UK economy.

The headline index is predicted to rise to edge up to 52.5 in May from 52.3 in April, where anything above 50 signals an expansion in activity.

If the number comes in below that, investor nerves - already shot in the run up to the EU referendum - are likely to rise.

As Michael Hewson chief market analyst at CMC Markets, puts it:

We’ll get further colour on whether the UK economy has hit a partially self-inflicted slump brought about by all the hysteria surrounding the upcoming referendum vote.

A poor number here could well raise concerns about a potential negative quarter for the UK economy, in the process increasing speculation about a possible rate cut by the Bank of England.

What was that about a possible DIY recession?

Also coming up.....

We will get the eurozone services PMIs, and this afternoon the closely watched non-farm payrolls report will be published in the US.

Will the jobs report make the Fed more likely or less likely to raise US interest rates in the near future? We will bring you all the reaction.

Updated

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.