Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Politics
Independent US staff

Manafort trial - live blog: Jury deliberates for third day without verdict as Trump hits out at Mueller probe

The jury in the financial fraud trial of Donald Trump‘s former campaign chairman, Paul Manafort, are nearing the end of their third day of deliberations.

They have been pondering whether to convict Mr Manafort of up to 18 criminal charges related to bank and tax fraud and his failure to disclose overseas bank accounts. Mr Manafort denies all the charges against him. 

On Friday, the 12 jurors concluded their discussions without sending any notes to the judge other than saying when they would go home.

It came a day after they asked for a definition of “reasonable doubt” and clarification on the law governing the reporting of foreign bank accounts.

The trial is the first courtroom test of the Russia probe led by Special Counsel Robert Mueller, though the case doesn’t involve allegations of Russian election interference. 

Meanwhile, outside the courtroom and unrelated, The New York Times reports that federal authorities investigating whether President Trump’s former personal lawyer and fixer, Michael Cohen, potentially committed bank and tax fraud and have zeroed in on well over $20 million in loans obtained by taxi businesses that he and his family own. Prosecutors are said to be considering charges, possibly by the end of August.

The Cohen investigation was referred to the Southern District of New York by Mr Mueller. Mr Cohen's lawyers have not yet responded to a request for comment, but have declined to speak when asked by other media outlets.

Live Updates

13:49
Hello and welcome to our coverage of former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort's bank fraud trial.

We are still waiting for a verdict from the jury, who will continue deliberations today.
14:51
The jury should be reconvening any time now, with Judge TS Ellis having told told the jury to put the case out their mind over the weekend and not do any research into the trial.
15:16

Meanwhile, outside the courtroom and unrelated, The New York Times reports that federal authorities investigating whether President Trump’s former personal lawyer and fixer, Michael Cohen, potentially committed bank and tax fraud and have zeroed in on well over $20 million in loans obtained by taxi businesses that he and his family own. Prosecutors are said to be considering charges, possibly by the end of August.

The Cohen investigation was referred to the Southern District of New York by Mr Mueller.

15:17
Mr Cohen's lawyers have not yet responded to a request for comment on that story.
15:50
Among the questions that the jury have asked so far is to get Judge Ellis to define what is meant by "reasonable doubt" - as in the jury need to believe the charges are proved "beyond reasonable doubt" in order to convict.

The defense are said to have taken this as a good sign for Mr Manafort, although the prosecutors would likely make the same argument.
16:25

Another headline on Friday that might grab the attention of jurors was about Judge Ellis disclosing he had received threats related to the trial and was being protected by US marshals. The jury was not present when he made those remarks.

"In a high profile case, the general assumption is that some outside information may accidentally reach a jury, despite jurors' best efforts to avoid relevant news," said jury consultant Roy Futterman.

17:11
Just a reminder that Mr Manafort has a second trial coming up in mid-September. That trial, set in the District of Columbia, involves allegations he acted as an unregistered foreign agent for Ukrainian interests and made false statements to the US government.  

He has denied all those charges too.
17:30

Kevin Downing, Mr Manafort's defense attorney, just left the courthouse. On his way out, he answered a couple of questions, and said his client "feels good."

Here's the exchange:

Question: Any updates? 

Downing: "Well, the jury is still out deliberating."

Question: How confident do you feel?

Downing: “I feel good. Mr Manafort feels good." 

18:00
Meanwhile, Judge TS Ellis has held two sealed conferences with prosecutors and the defense today. One lasting 10 minutes, the other lasting seven minutes.

The record of each of those conversations will be unsealed after the trial is over.
18:25
Outside of the trial, Mr Trump has again taken aim at Special Counsel Robert Mueller's investigation in a number of tweets. The president has repeatedly called the probe a "witch hunt".
 
18:55
Judge Ellis has only one case on the docket for today. Here is some more on the the colourful judge that is presiding over the trial.
 
20:08
There is no doubt that the Manafort verdict will affect President Trump - whether he gets to laud a not guilty verdict, or not.

CNN's Chris Cillizza is calling the verdict part of a "critical moment" for Mr Trump's time in the White House.
20:46

A Manafort conviction would undermine efforts by Donald Trump and some Republican lawmakers to paint Robert Mueller's Russia inquiry as a political witch hunt, while an acquittal would be a setback for the special counsel.

In a break with convention, Mr Trump weighed in on the trial on Friday, calling the case against Mr Manafort at the federal court in Alexandria, Virginia, "very sad" and lauding his former associate as a "very good person."

20:52

The jury in the financial fraud trial of Paul Manafort are still currently deliberating.

21:46
Jurors would normally be let go for he evening at 5.30pm ET, so about 45 minutes from now.
22:14
Looks like Judge TS Ellis has been talking to the lawyers again - the third bench conference of the day.

The judge says the jury will deliberate until 6.15pm.
 
23:42
We end the day with no verdict, so the jurors will be back tomorrow at 9.30am ET.
23:45
With that we are ending our coverage for today. Thanks for reading.

Additional reporting by agencies

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.