Ederson
Came to Manchester City's rescue several times with standard saves, but when it came to his one difficult save, he let it sneak in at his near post. 5
Kyle Walker
His pace perhaps saved City from a mauling, but his crossing was again sub-standard. 5
John Stones
His tendency to stand off and let others deal with it is costing City - he needs to take charge of situations more. 5
Fernandinho
Great when City are in control and knocking the ball around, but is no centre back when faced with counter-attacking teams. 5
Angelino
Given the runaround by James, and was a spectator as Martial weighed up his shot for the goal. 4
Rodri
Tried desperately to gain the kind of steady control City needed, but his defensive qualities are hampered by a lack of recovery pace. 5
Kevin De Bruyne
All too hurried from City's usual playmaker, although his cross for Jesus was a rare piece of measured, calm creativity. 6
David Silva
Just not sharp enough to find his way around, or through, a packed United defence, despite the odd moment of class. 5
Bernardo Silva
Ineffective against a weak United left-hand side, and his hooking to make way for Mahrez was inevitable. 4
Gabriel Jesus
One difficult chance from De Bruyne's cross, but he was starved of supply - still put in a good shift. 5
Raheem Sterling
Given a hard time of it by Wan-Bissaka and constantly sought the extra touch you rarely get in a derby. 5
Subs
Nicolas Otamendi
(for Stones 59) Good header late on. 6
Riyad Mahrez
(for Bernardo 65) Unable to change it. 5
Ilkay Gundogan
(for Rodri 85) Came on late but made no difference. 5
Not used: Bravo, Cancelo, Mendy, Foden
