Love Island fans were all left asking the same question after tonight's controversial dumping.
The Islanders were still reeling at the start of the latest edition of the popular ITV2 dating show after the announcement that two more Islanders would be leaving the villa.
Tyler, Dale, Jake, Abigail, Mary and Kaz were all vulnerable to being evicted after receiving the fewest votes from the public.
READ MORE: Who is Aaron Simpson and how old is the professional footballer?
It was up to the remaining contestants to choose who was set to leave and the boys deliberated who was going to exit first.
When the boys made their minds up over who was leaving, Love Island fans couldn't believe who stepped up to make the announcement.
Each of the girls up for eviction have been a part of dramatic couplings with Toby Aromolaran - who has come under fire for how quickly his head has been turned by new additions to the Island.
And fans on Twitter were questioning why they picked the semi-professional footballer to reveal Abi was set to leave the Island.
One user said: "Toby having to announce it is awful lmaooo."
Another tweeted: "Not Toby dumping one of his many women"
A third added: "Imagine them getting Toby to pick between his three girls."
A fourth commented: "Toby having to pick from the three out of four girls he’s been with."
A fifth said: "Toby's actually having to pick his favourite ex"
Love Island continues tomorrow at 9pm on ITV2 and ITVHub
Want to find out the latest news in your area? Enter your postcode on our In Your Area page here
