Love Island fans are convinced that bombshell Teddy actually wanted to choose Sharon - but was stumped when Hugo chose her first in a dramatic recoupling last night.
Usually, the bombshells have first dibs on the islanders - but for some reason Teddy was the last boy to pick between Rachel and Faye, who he ultimately saved.
Donning their detective hats, fans mused: "Think Teddy wanted to pick Sharon. If he had chosen before Hugo, Faye might’ve gone home."
In a series of seemingly odd decisions, Aaron saved Kaz - despite there being no hint of romance while Hugo stunned fans by saving Sharon, even though she screamed at him in a testy row earlier in the week.
The arrangement meant financial consultant Teddy had to choose between Rachel and Faye and it was the 26-year-old estate agent that clinched the deal.
In a steamy statement Teddy said he wanted to get to know Faye "intimately" however viewers were confused after he admitted to having a sexual attraction to 29-year-old Rachel.
Rachel had previously remarked: “Obviously the claws are going to come out, we’re competing for this guy.”
But in the end Teddy plumped for Faye who had made him laugh since their first date in the villa.
"I’m buzzing, he’s fit," Faye said. "But at the same time I’ve lost one of my best friends in here," she added of Rachel.
Teddy later said: "It was such a hard decision, but I had to go with my heart because she wowed me."
However, Kaz admitted that she very much still had her eye on Teddy and said she was disappointed that she wasn't in a couple with him.
"Teddy’s not ruled out," she said, but she said something completely different to Faye as they spoke to one another in the garden.
Following her exit, Rachel admitted that she felt it was her time to go.
Asked if she was surprised at being dumped, Rachel replied: "Not at all. I wasn’t in a friendship couple that was strong enough for me so it was my time."
She also confirmed whether or not she thinks anyone in the villa is playing a game, saying: "Right now, no, but they are all definitely capable. The last two days people are starting to do things that didn’t match their personality when they went in."
Rachel said she would love the chance to go back into the villa before the series ends, just so that she can stir things up.
"Honestly, I would beg to go in. If you want to send me back in at any point, I’d do it," she said.
"I’d be unapologetic, strong and forthright. I would definitely go back in and be ready to stir the pot until the pot broke."
