Love Island fans have been left furiously speculating as to how Toby and Faye might have fallen out behind the scenes after the semi-pro footballer's admission last night.
During a cheeky game of Snog, Marry or Pie, Toby excitedly chose Faye as his target to slam his cream pie in her face.
After smacking her in the face with the pie, Toby celebrated as he punched the air, exclaiming: "Yes! Yes!"
Faye hit back: "Would taste better than kissing you, anyway!"
In the Beach Hut, Toby said: "It was my dream to pie Faye because she annoys me 24/7 in this place so I thought I could pie her. I was so happy."
And viewers were left with raised eyebrows as they speculated over what had gone down behind the scenes.
One tweeted: "Looool Toby and Faye lowkey hating each other... #LoveIsland."
While another commented: "Wait so there’s beef between Toby and Faye??? #LoveIsland."
A third wrote: "Toby's dead serious reaction to pie-ing Faye #LoveIsland."
"Toby is salty that Faye didn’t want him #LoveIsland," another joked.
One wrote: "TOBY TOOK THAT OPPORTUNITY TO PIE FAYE #LoveIsland."
It comes after it was announced during last night's show that viewers have the ability to vote for their favourite Islander.
Presumably, the Islanders with the fewest votes will be at risk of being dumped from the Island.
The fact that fans have the chance to vote for individual Islanders suggests that at least one couple could be split up if one of the Islanders is dumped.
Currently, Toby is coupled up with Chloe and the pair enjoyed a raunchy time in the Hideaway.
But some viewers were left feeling a little uncomfortable after their steamy night together.
Chloe and Toby received a unanimous vote from their fellow islanders who agreed that the couple should have a private night in the hideaway.
Dressed in very saucy outfits, the pair shared lots of steamy kisses before snuggling underneath the covers...
*Love Island airs weekdays at 9pm on ITV2
