Love Island 2020 islander Ollie Williams announced to the villa during Wednesday's episode that he had decided to quit the show.
Following show backlash over photos that emerged revealing Ollie was a trophy hunter, proudly posing beside animals he had killed, Ollie quit the series.
However it was said to be down to the islander realising his feelings for an ex outside the villa, that made him depart.
Viewers were left unconvinced, due to the huge attention an even a petition from fans asking for him to be removed.
But something about Ollie's exit scene in particular aroused suspicion that something wasn't right.
As Ollie said his goodbyes to the boys and girls, he headed off to the bedroom to pack his suitcase.
After hugging it out with his tearful co-stars, he made his way to the door to exit the villa.
It's then that he pulled his suitcase out the door and headed down the path, leaving the villa forever.
Except fans were quick to notice he was still in his beach shorts and without shoes on when he exited.
Ollie hadn't bothered to get changed and put clothes or shoes on, given he was heading off somewhere else.
Fans felt this was odd, taking to Twitter to confess they believed something did not add up.
One viewer said: "Anyone else confused why Ollie left #loveisland without getting dressed or putting his shoes on? Just curious.."
Another agreed: "Where’s he off to with no shoes and top on?"
A third added: "Why isn't Ollie putting on any clothes to leave? Is it the rules that they only wear swimming costumes at all times?"
This was echoed by a fourth fan who said: "Is Ollie not gonna put some clothes on before he leaves?"
Love Island airs every night at 9pm on ITV2.
