Just four people on floors above where Flight 175 hit Twin Towers survived: Two are ‘brothers for life’

By Nathan Place
Associated Press

Of all the 9/11 survivor stories, one of the most unbelievable belongs to two men: Brian Clark, a Canadian businessman whose office was struck by one of the planes, and Stanley Praimnath, the man whose life he saved.

On 11 September, 2001, Mr Clark was at work on the 84th floor of the World Trade Center’s South Tower. At 9:03am, Flight 175 struck floors 77 to 85 of the building, with Mr Clark’s office at the top of the impact zone.

“Our room just got rocked, just destroyed in a second,” Mr Clark told the Associated Press ten years later. “And it was for the next 10 seconds after that immediate impact – that was the only 10 seconds of the day that I was afraid. Terrified, in fact.”

There were three staircases in front of Mr Clark. On an impulse, he started heading down Stairway A. He had no idea that was the only staircase that hadn’t been destroyed.

On the 81st floor, a woman heading upstairs stopped Mr Clark and the co-workers who had followed him. She told them to turn back, because she’d seen fire and debris lower down. Her advice was to head to the roof, where she hoped a helicopter would rescue them.

The woman headed up, and Mr Clark’s group stayed in the stairwell, debating what to do. Then Mr Clark heard a sound.

“I got distracted by a banging noise inside the 81st floor, and I strained to listen to what I thought was a voice,” he said. “‘Help! Help! I’m buried! Is anybody there? I can’t breathe!’”

Mr Clark left the group and headed toward the voice. Amid the debris, he saw a hand sticking out through a hole in a wall, waving up and down. Mr Clark shone his flashlight into the hole, and saw two eyes staring back at him.

This was Stanley Praimnath, a Fuji Bank employee who had seen Flight 175 approach and ducked under his desk just before the impact. Miraculously, the desk shielded him as his office collapsed.

Flight 175 explodes on impact with the South Tower of the World Trade Center on 11 September, 2001 (Getty Images)

Now Mr Praimnath was trapped behind a wall. Mr Clark grabbed his hands and pulled. After several tries, he managed to heave him over the top.

Mr Praimnath was overcome with gratitude.

“He gave me a big kiss,” Mr Clark later remembered, laughing uncomfortably. “I said, ‘Uh, I’m Brian.’ He said, ‘I’m Stanley! We’ll be brothers for life!’”

The two men headed back to the staircase. By this time, the rest of Mr Clark’s group had headed upstairs, hoping for a rescue that never came. None of them would survive.

Mr Clark and Mr Praimnath headed the other way, beginning the long journey down 80 floors to the bottom. Eventually they encountered some smoking debris, but were able to move it aside.

At 9:55am, they finally reached the ground floor. As they left the building, a firefighter told them to run, because debris was falling on the street. They followed his instructions.

When they were a couple of blocks away, Mr Praimnath looked behind them.

“He said, ‘You know, I think that building could come down,’” Mr Clark recalled. “And I said, ‘There’s no way! That’s a steel structure…’”

Before he could finish his sentence, the South Tower began collapsing. Though they didn’t know it at the time, Mr Clark and Mr Praimnath had escaped just four minutes before the collapse. Of all the people in the floors above where Flight 175 crashed, only four survived. Mr Clark and Mr Praimnath are two of them.

Looking back years later, Mr Clark still can’t explain why he’s alive.

“There are hundreds, if not thousands, of unanswerable questions: Why me? Why not somebody else? Why them?” he told AP. “I have been given a gift. I take no credit for it. I’m just fortunate.”

Smoke looms over Manhattan after the collapse of the World Trade Center on 11 September, 2001 (AP)

What is inkl?

Important stories

See news based on value, not advertising potential. Get the latest news from around the world.

Trusted newsrooms

We bring you reliable news from the world’s most experienced journalists in the most trusted newsrooms.

Ad-free reading

Read without interruptions, distractions or intrusions of privacy.