Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Comment

It's the sugar coating that kills us

In examining the pandemic of obesity in rich countries (Comment, last week), Will Hutton overlooks sucrose, the addictive 'empty calorie' that Cuban anthropologist Fernando Ortez once described as a 'favoured child of capitalism'. Mankind lived without the white stuff for millennia. Only with modernity and the unrelenting pursuit of wealth did this slave crop establish itself as the mother of agribusiness and mass consumption.

Three-quarters of the sugar we eat is consumed indirectly: sucrose is a hidden but ubiquitous additive even in savoury foods, enhancing palatability and what the food industry calls 'good go-away'.

Parents faced with a shortage of time and the formidable pester power of children, are easy prey to the powerful sugar lobby and its twin, the fast food and drink industry. We all need to become dedicated sugar-busters.
Ron Noon
Liverpool John Moores University

Will Hutton speaks of obese people as victims of modern society, but I think this is too easy. Despite pressures of modern life, one can make the effort to control diet and exercise: it just requires discipline. In North America and Britain, a large number of people are over-indulgent and lazy in their eating and leisure habits. Huge servings at US restaurants are legendary.

In Switzerland, where I live, and in neighbouring France, one does not see the abundance of overweight people Will Hutton refers to. Europeans tend to take the question of healthy eating more seriously, despite hectic Western lifestyles. Are we really condemned to eat junk food? We can wake up a bit earlier to prepare a healthy sandwich or salad for lunch. We can resist sedentary lifestyles. We can turn off the TV and go for a walk or to the gym. We can teach our children to cook healthily.

Instead of condemning 'great economic and social forces' for generating obesity, we need to take more control of our own lives.
Anne Hobson
Geneva

Will Hutton has just discovered that food has been made into a commodity and that people have no control over their time. That's capitalism, the system Hutton has defended on the grounds that there is no alternative. He should acknowledge the consequences of the premises he defends, or question the premises.
David Murray
London NW8

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.