Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Radio France Internationale
Radio France Internationale
World
Jan van der Made

Is the Communist party's old guard tiring of Xi's iron grip on China?

China's President and Communist Party Chief Xi Jinping helps his predecessor Hu Jintao during the session of the Party Congress, Beijing, Great Hall of the People, 16 October 2022. © AFP / Noel CELIS

By rooting out his opponents through merciless "anti-corruption" campaigns and supressing all forms of criticism, Chinese leader Xi Jinping now seems to be untouchable. Thousands of delegates are set to rubber-stamp his bid to rule for a historic third term as they meet for the five-yearly Congress. But between the lines, instances of dissent are visible.

Chinese President Xi Jinping doubled down on his policies at the opening of the Communist Party Congress on Sunday, pledging continuity on cornerstones of his decade in power as he seeks to secure a historic third term.

Since coming to office, Xi has transformed China by personalising and centralising power, cracking down on corruption and dissent, pushing a more assertive foreign policy and promoting domestic self-reliance in technology and the economy.

If picked as party leader for another five-year term as expected, Xi is almost certain to be elected president at the annual meeting of China's National People's Congress in March.

Xi and the party's other top brass are likely to be unveiled on 23 October, the day after the Congress closes.

With his tenure for life, Xi radically altered China's course set by Deng Xiaoping and his Open Door policy in 1978.

Deng, who suffered miserably under the one-man dictatorship of Mao Zedong, shifted the CCP's focus from the hyper-communist "class struggle" to "economic construction" which in practice meant that the Communist party started to rapidly lift control over things like private ownership, stock markets and foreign investment.

Screenshot of the front page of the People's Daily of 17 October 2022 announcing the opening of the 20th Congress of the Chinese Communist Party. © Screenshot People's Daily

Deng's limits were tested with the 1979 Democracy Wall and the 1989 Tiananmen people's movement, which he cracked down on, showing that no one could attack the supremacy of the Communist party.

Still Chinese citizens were much freer than they ever had been under Mao Zedong, whose policies included devastating campaigns like the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution.

Propagand poster from the Cultural Revolution (1966-1976) when Mao Zedong was China's undisputed leader. Critics inside and outside China fear that current leader Xi Jinping's course will lead to a new era of complete obedience to the supreme leader. © Chinese Posters

What Deng did succeed in was to radically cut out the notion of "personality cult".He stressed "collective leadership" when he stepped down from all top functions (apart from the one of Chairman of the Central Military Commission) and designed a politburo standing committee consisting of people who had an equal amount of power.

Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev, right, gestures as he chats with senior Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping during their meeting on Tuesday, May 16, 1989 at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing. ASSOCIATED PRESS - Boris Yurchenko

After Deng's death, Jiang Zemin became China's supreme leader, but only in name: he shared power with his Prime Minister (Zhu Rongji) and the politburo.

Chinese President Jiang Zemin (L) together with Premier Zhu Rongji during a departure ceremony at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing 03 June 2002, prior to Jiang's departure for Almaty, the Kazakh economic capital, to attend the Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia (CICA). Ahead of the anniversary of the 1989 Tiananmen democracy protests, Jiang has reiterated vows to maintain one-party rule and dismissed Western-style democratic reforms. AFP

China's leadership became more collective under Hu Jintao, who took over at the 18th party congress in 2002, and ruled rather consistently supported by his Prime Minister, Wen Jiabao, while not succumbing to the temptations of becoming a dictator.

Chinese President Hu Jintao (L) talks with Premier Wen Jiabao after the closing session of the annual National People's Congress (NPC) at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on March 13, 2009. "The global financial crisis continues to spread and get worse," Premier Wen Jiabao said in his annual work report read out before the assembled legislature inside the Great Hall of the People to the west of Tiananmen Square. AFP

Xi Jinping changed all that when he forced the central committee to change the constitution opening the road for him to become dictator-for-life.

No criticism is tolerated and the party congress is designed to be a "show of unity" among party ranks, but small details show that the old guard is far from happy with Xi's current attempts to equal Mao Zedong's status of China's "Great Helmsman."

Close observation of members of the old guard indicate that they are not happy. Among the "Presidium" of the party congress are former Party Secretaries Jiang Zemin and Hu Jintao, former Prime Ministers Zhu Rongji and Wen Jiabao, and other heavyweights such as former politburo member Li Ruihuan and the oldest: the 105-year old party stalwart Song Ping.

In footage of the congress, Li Ruihuan seemed to be the only one not applauding Xi Jinping but merely nodding his head - which may be explained as a slight rebuke to the paramount leader.

Some of the others look clearly unhappy, but it is impossible to say if they are upset about Xi's speech of if they feel generally uncomfortable.

After all, they are in their late eighties or mid-nineties and have to sit through hours of endless speeches before they can relax.

For the moment, an unhappy expression may be the only way to express disagreement for the ageing party members. Starting from 2015, Xi started to curtail the retirees, starting with a remark in the official People's Daily saying that “once people leave, the tea cools down” while urging them to “adjust their mentality” to backstage status.

Xi managed to break through a tradition that had an informal council of elder party members - so-called "immortals" - to pull the strings behind the scenes. This was the case in Deng's time, when he had to compromise between different factions representing different political preferences, ranging from reformists to conservatives.

Rare sign of protest

Meanwhile, the Chinese population itself had been under increasingly tight control. A vast army of cyber police is monitoring the slighest form of dissent, imposing "bans for life" on social media accounts if people are found guilty.

Lockdowns of entire cities under the pretext of Covid-19 may have contributed to a complete abence of any form of political protest.

The only overt sign of protest seems to have been organised by one single person who unfurled a large banner over the Sitong overpass in Beijing's northern Haidian district, reading "We want food, not PCR tests. We want freedom, not lockdowns. We want respect, not lies. We want reform, not a Cultural Revolution. We want a vote, not a leader. We want to be citizens, not slaves.”

The man was quickly apprehended, the banner removed, but it was shared by millions on China's social media before the cyber police could remove the references.

On 13 October 2022, just days before the opening of the key 20th Congress of China's Communist Party, a lone activist unfurled a banner protesting Party Secretary Xi Jinping's policies, at the Sitong Bridge, Haidian District, Beijing. © Twitter
Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.