Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
World
Adam Withnall

India election: Violence in West Bengal and Kashmir mars second day of world's biggest vote

Sporadic violence and some disappointing turnouts have marred the second day of voting in India’s mammoth general election.

The worst clashes were seen in West Bengal, where rival party activists came to blows, a candidate’s car had its windows smashed and a number of electronic voting machines (EVMs) were broken.

Unlike on day one of the vote, no one was reported to have been killed in the violence. But the clashes, on a day when only three of the state’s 42 constituencies were contested, are likely to lead to increased security measures in the coming weeks.

The clashes in Chopra, Darjeeling meant that scores of people were unable to reach the polling station. Ajay V Nayek, a police official, said across the state polling was “overall peaceful”, and that those who were turned away were later escorted by security forces to cast their ballots.

More than 155 million people were eligible to vote across the 13 states where polling took place on Thursday, and turnouts varied hugely across the country.

In Srinagar, Kashmir, where separatists had called for a boycott of the election, just over 12 per cent of those eligible had cast their votes by 3pm, with only a few hours left before polling closed. That compared to some seats where the number was well over 70 per cent.

A police official told Reuters there had been “at least 40” separate incidents of stone-pelting directed at the security forces, who are ubiquitous in the valley at the best of times and were on high alert for the day’s voting.

Police deployed tear gas and baton charges in downtown Srinagar as protesters tried to disrupt the vote, officials said. At most polling booths, armed security personnel and election officials vastly outnumbered voters.

Away from those hotspots, however, the day’s voting appeared to pass without serious incident. In Manipur, voters complained that chief minister N Biren Singh turned up in the afternoon and jumped the queue - reportedly skipping past some people who had been waiting since 7am.

And at a Delhi press conference to announce a BJP candidate for a later phase, a protester pelted the ruling party’s spokesman and MP GVL Narasimha Rao with shoes. Rao immediately dismissed his assailant, who was bundled out by security, as being “Congress-inspired”.

Here’s the run-through of the day’s election events, as they happened.

Welcome to The Independent's live blog from India, where voting is under way in the second phase of the country's epic, six-week general election.
More than 155 million people are eligible to vote today in 97 constituencies across 13 states.
 
It is the second of seven phases in the election, designed to spread out the logistical and security challenges of conducting a democratic exercise in a country with more than 900 million eligible voters.

The focus today will be on the southern states of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, with #TNElection2019 already the top trend across India on Twitter.

All of Tamil Nadu's 39 seats, and half of Karnataka's 28, will be decided today. 

The south is a key region where the main opposition Congress party and its allies need to win big if they hope to have any chance of ousting Narendra Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

"If the non-BJP parties perform well in these two states, then they would still be having a chance of forming a non-BJP government at the centre," Sanjay Kumar, director of the Centre for the Study of Developing Societies in Delhi, told Reuters.

It's still early in the day, but some of the main political leaders in the seats at stake today have already been casting their ballots.
 
Among the first was the chief minister of Tamil Nadu, Edappadi K Palanisamy, a member of the regional AIADMK party in alliance with the BJP.
 
 
In Karnataka, the BJP leader and union government Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman voted in Bangalore South.
 
 
And in Puducherry, Chief Minister V Narayanasamy was pictured casting his vote at a polling station earlier. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Rahul Gandhi has tweeted to all those voting today, to promote Congress's Nyuntam Aay Yojana, or NYAY scheme, offering a minimum income guarantee to the poorest people in the country.
 
The Indian election is a huge logistical undertaking, and some polling stations are equipped to higher standards than others.
 
According to Times of India, this "model" polling station in Srirangapatana has two wheel chairs for voters to use, a ramp, drinking water provided and no-queue voting for senior citizens. 
 
 
 
Meanwhile in Bhagalpur, Bihar, pictures from the ANI agency tell a different story of access for the elderly...
 
 
 
  
 
 
Srinagar, the biggest city in Jammu and Kashmir state, goes to the polls today amid extremely tight security.
 
Mobile internet services have been cut off in much of the Kashmir valley since last night, in what authorities described as a precautionary measure. 
 
Picture feeds showed some people turning out to vote but, with separatist leaders calling for a boycott of the election, the Associated Press in Srinagar reported that most polling stations in the Srinagar and Budgam areas of Kashmir looked deserted, with more armed police, paramilitary soldiers and election staff present than voters.
 
 
 
 
In southern Karnataka, both the BJP and Congress are hoping to make up seats, with the expectation that Mr Modi is unlikely to be able to repeat the near clean sweep he achieved across northern states in 2014.
 
But it's also true that the BJP's Hindu-first agenda has struggled to take root to the same extent in the southern states.

Critics say such divisive election rhetoric is a threat to India's secular foundations.

"Communal polarisation is obviously the biggest issue for me," said Rakesh Mehar, who voted in Karnataka's capital, Bengaluru. "And the growing intolerance in the country is what worries me the most."

While it is being seen as a referendum on Mr Modi's first five years in office, this election is not just about what is going on with the central government.

Voters in Bengaluru, once a sleepy retirement town that has been transformed into India's technology hub, said they wanted lawmakers who would fix infrastructure problems such as traffic congestion and poor water management.

"We have been voting every time expecting a change but nothing has come so far. People are talking about national issues," Manjunath Munirathnappa told Reuters. "But only when they fix the local issues will there be progress in the nation."

 
One of the big talking points in the days before the election began on 12 April was the controversial planned release of a Bollywood biopic about the prime minister, entitled PM Narendra Modi.
 
The Election Commission of India eventually decided that the film, which was seen as being positive about Mr Modi's life story, risked undermining the "level playing field" of the elections and ordered it and any other elements of "hagiography" not be released until after voting was over.
 
The film's producers complained, however, and the Supreme Court on Monday ordered the commissioners to at least watch the film before taking a decision.
 
That viewing is understood to have taken place yesterday, and the commission must now deliver its new ruling to the apex court no later than Friday. 
 
It raises the prospect that, if the commission changes its mind, the film could hit cinemas before the third day of voting on 23 April. The film, starring the self-confessed Modi fan Vivek Oberoi in the lead role, traces the prime minister's rise from being the son of a tea seller to leader of the nation.
Narendra Modi has been speaking this morning at a large rally in his home state of Gujarat.
 
With Srinagar in Kashmir voting under extremely tight security today, Mr Modi talked at length on the subject of national security. It's the one issue his strategists at the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) have been pushing more than any other since the turn of the year.
 
The Modi administration came in for some criticism in the wake of the Pulwama bombing that killed 40 armed police in Kashmir in February, with questions raised over whether more could have been done to stop the attack.
 
Speaking just now, Mr Modi defended his government's record, saying that "terrorism had been contained to only two-and-a-half districts" in Kashmir, and that no bombings had been seen outside these areas during his five years in power.
 
Mr Modi also harked back to a 2016 incident where India claimed to have carried out targeted ground operations within Pakistan-administered Kashmir after a militant attack on an Indian army base in Uri, Jammu and Kashmir.
 
He compared it to what he described as Congress's failure to act after the 2008 Mumbai attacks.
 
"Congress did not do any thing after the Mumbai attack. What did Modi do after Uri? I killed them by going in to their home with a surgical strike," he told the rally.
 
The Independent travelled to one of the "two-and-a-half" districts referred to by Mr Modi, Pulwama, last month. There, the family of the Pulwama bomber defended his actions, calling it a reaction to the excesses of Indian security forces in the region and a part of the separatist struggle. India says the militancy in Kashmir is fuelled by neighbouring Pakistan, which has armed and trained fighters in the past. 
 
 
 
Chennai has been voting under particularly tight security measures today, and as of 11am turnout was the lowest in the state in Central Chennai seat, at just over 22 per cent.
 
It comes after there were deadly clashes on the first day of voting, last Thursday 11 April, in the neighbouring southern state of Andhra Pradesh.
 
The Times of India reported there was a very high police presence in crowded central urban neighbourhoods like Triplicane and Royapettah.
 
Voters reportedly struggled to find their nearest polling booth, after polling agents were told they could not set up shop more than 100m from a police station, in case of violence.
 
So far just about the only report of clashes comes from West Bengal, where pictures show damage to the windscreen of Communist Party of India - Marxist (CPM) candidate Raiganj Mohammad Salim's vehicle in Islampur.
 
The party's leadership claims workers from the rival national party Trinamool Congress (TMC) were behind the attack.
 
 
 
Voting has been postponed in the Vellore seat in Tamil Nadu following the seizure of Rs 110 million (£1.22m) in unaccounted cash allegedly from the home of a local opposition politician, Kathir Anand. 

His party accused federal tax authorities of raiding the homes and offices of party leaders running against Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Hindu nationalist party. The governing party in the state, All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (AIADMK), is an ally of Modi's party. 

The Election Commission said that authorities had recovered 2 billion rupees (£22m) from leaders, workers and supporters of various political parties in the state in the past month. They suspect the money is for buying votes. 

 
There has been a minor incident during a news conference at the BJP's main headquarters here in Delhi, where a member of the audience threw a shoe at the party's spokesman.
 
GVL Narasimha Rao was speaking to announce the Hindu nationalist Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur as the party's candidate for Bhopal.
 
He was in the process of denouncing Congress for bringing "false cases" against Hindu activists like Ms Thakur - accused over a 2008 terrorist bomb attack.
 
The man who threw the shoe was immediately bundled out of the news conference by security personnel, video of the incident shows. According to the Press Trust of India, the man identified himself as a doctor.
 
After the shoe flew across the stage, Rao immediately suggested it was the act of a "Congress-inspired person". 
Here's an ANI clip of the shoe-throwing incident:
 
Unemployment and jobs creation is perhaps the single most important issue for voters at this election, according to pollsters.
 
Leaked official jobs figures came out in January, with the country already in full election mode, showing that unemployment was at a 45-year high. The government was accused of suppressing the numbers but claimed the report was not yet ready for publication.
 
On Wednesday, a new report came out with further damning statistics on the matter. Compiled by the Azim Premji University and titled 'State of Working India', it says that at least five million men lost their jobs between 2016 and 2018, roughly correlating with Narendra Modi's controversial policy of demonetisation.
 
"This analysis applies to men only. When we take women into account, the number of jobs lost will be higher," the report states.
 
The report said that overall unemployment rate in India was around 6% in 2018, double what it was in the decade 2000-11. 
 
It's more bad news for the government which, since January, has sought to make national security the number one election issue instead.

 
 
   
There are more reports now of violence in West Bengal, following the news earlier that a candidate for CPI(M) had his car attacked by rival workers.
 
In Chopra in Darjeeling, police clashed with a group of protesters who alleged that the Trinamool Congress (TMC), the ruling party in the state, was not allowing them to vote.
 
Officials said the agitators threw projectiles at riot police and were met with tear gas shells and baton charges.
 
Also in Chopra, reporters said there were clashes at a polling station between TMC and BJP workers, during which some of the electronic voting machines (EVMs) were smashed. 
 
Darjeeling is one of only three hotly contested seats in West Bengal voting today. It has been held by the BJP in the past two terms, in what is otherwise a state dominated by regional parties. 
 
Vivek Oberoi, the lead actor in the Modi biopic which had its released suspended by the election commission, has been speaking to reporters.
 
Earlier, we brought you the news that the commissioners had been ordered to watch the film and reconsider whether it would prejudice the vote.
 
Here's what Mr Oberoi told reporters:
  
Turnout is low in Srinagar even by the standards of the Kashmir valley, where separatists have called a boycott at this and past elections. Officials said just 5.7 per cent of the electorate had turned out by 3pm. For comparison, many seats across the country had passed 30 per cent turnout by 11am.
 
And there have been dozens of minor clashes there too, between anti-election protesters and police. 
 
Officers of the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), India's armed police presence in Kashmir, have been deployed in many thousands to try and safeguard the vote.
 
Police have deployed tear gas to disperse some protests, the Reuters news agency reported. "There has been stone pelting by protesters in at least 40 places," said one senior police officer.
 
Stone-pelting has become a weekly ritual in Srinagar, a show of protest against the security forces that usually takes place after Friday prayers.      
 
The state of Jammu & Kashmir is currently operating under governor's rule and is due a local election to restore a state government, but it was deemed too insecure to carry out state election in tandem with the general election at this time.
There may be some violence in Darjeeling but across West Bengal, turnout has been OK.
 
With three more hours of voting to go, turnout in the seat of Jalpaiguri - which is reserved for "scheduled" (traditionally downtrodden) caste candidates, was up at 71.32 per cent.
 
In Darjeeling, it was 63.14 per cent while in Raiganj it was 61.84 per cent. 
 
The state average stands at 65.43 per cent, still with some way to go to reach the 82 per cent turnout of 2014.
 
In 2014, the national average was just over 66 per cent - that was comfortably the highest turnout in India's history. 
One of the most closely-watched seats in today's election is being contested in Bangalore South, between the prominent Congress leader BK Hariprasad and the BJP's youngest election candidate, 28-year-old Tejasvi Surya.
 
The selection of Surya, a charismatic young local BJP activist and member of the party's social media organising unit in Karnataka, raised eyebrows. Bangalore South had been a relatively safe seat for the BJP for the late Union minister HN Ananth Kumar, who held it from 1998 until his death last year. Some BJP leaders had wanted the candidacy to go to Mr Kumar's wife.
 
Surya was up early to vote and posted a video of himself afterwards, nominating three others to get out and cast their ballots and pass on the nomination, thereby creating a chain reaction.
 
 
 
 
If he wins, Surya would not quite be the youngest Indian MP in history. That accolade was bestowed upon Dushyant Chautala, who was just 26 years and one month old when he was elected to represent Hisar in Haryana in 2014.
 
It hasn't all been smiles and selfies from Surya, however. Last year he tweeted "call me a bigot, communal fanatic or whatever", before going on to complain that the BJP had lost elections because the Muslim vote had "consolidated", and calling for the BJP to "really become a Hindu party".
 
Appeals to voters that are seen as stoking race, religion or caste divisions are a violation of Indian election rules.
 
Surya also briefly won an injunction against many major Indian news outlets, banning them from publishing any "derogatory" news about him, after allegations of sexual harassment emerged on Twitter. The injunction was lifted after an appeal. 
 
  
   

Please allow a moment for the live blog to load.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.