Summary
That’s it from the liveblog for today. Here’s a recap:
- Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, testified that Donald Trump withheld military aid to pressure Ukraine to investigate Joe Biden and the 2016 election. Taylor contradicted ongoing insistence from Trump and his allies that there was no quid pro quo.
- Democrats signaled that the Taylor testimony was a turning point, indicating that the inquiry will be speeding up in the coming days.
- Trump and his allies, continued to insist on the president’s innocence. Republican lawmakers took to the House floor, reiterating claims that the inquiry was unfair and unethical.
- Democrats and Republicans condemned Trump’s statements comparing the impeachment inquiry to a “lynching”.
- The US envoy to Syria testified that he wasn’t consulted on the decision to withdraw US troops.
- Russia won joint control of formerly Kurdish territory in Syria
Bill Taylor leaves Capitol Hill after nine-hour-long deposition
Bill Taylor does not respond to questions as he leaves Capitol Hill following a deposition that lasted 9+ hours pic.twitter.com/FtQYNrNpo4
— Jeremy Herb (@jeremyherb) October 22, 2019
Meanwhile... Pelosi creates petition to condemn Trump
Here’s what Trump has done *just this week*:
— Nancy Pelosi (@TeamPelosi) October 22, 2019
- He called the constitutional ban on profiting from the presidency “phony.”
- His Administration has defied lawful subpoenas and document requests.
- He stood by his shakedown of a foreign government and called it “perfect.”
Even as House Republicans rally behind Trump and seek to discredit the impeachment inquiry, Pelosi is promoting a public petition to condemn Trump.
There’s no real purpose for such a petition — but it’s a sign that Pelosi is sticking with her impeachment strategy despite Republican attacks.
Republicans take to House floor and speak out against impeachment
Several Republican representatives are speaking out against the impeachment inquiry, repeatedly calling it a sham, echoing language from the president, his press secretary, and his associates.
Republicans including minority leader Kevin McCarthy are once again arguing that the inquiry is invalid because the House has not taken a vote to open it. Speaker Nancy Pelosi has said that there is no rule or regulation requiring such a vote.
Trump held two days of meetings with House Republicans over the weekend at Camp David, signaling that the White House is working hard to ensure support as evidence mounts in favor of impeachment.
Under Chairman Schiff and the Dem majority, the most basic responsibilities of the committee have been neglected.
— Kevin McCarthy (@GOPLeader) October 22, 2019
Instead, the House Intelligence Committee is using its time and resources to run a sham impeachment inquiry in secret.#StopTheSchiffShowhttps://t.co/Othy2TMJYn
Republican lawmakers are taking advantage of time allotted for one-minute speeches this evening to reiterate their loyalty to Trump.
“The facts will exonerate our president,” said Mark Meadows of North Carolina.
“Instead of wasting valuable time with this baseless inqurity there is so much more we could and should be doing,” said Tim Whalberg of Michigan.
Schiff's impeachment scheme is being conducted in secret behind closed doors. He's shutting out Republican Members.
— Steve Scalise (@SteveScalise) October 22, 2019
This is a joke. The American people deserve complete transparency and access to the real facts, and @realDonaldTrump deserves due process!#StopTheSchiffShow pic.twitter.com/DxUOov2IFZ
One after another, Republicans repeated claims that the impeachment inquiry was illegitimate and unfair.
Updated
White House: Bill Taylor testimony was 'triple hearsay'
Insisting “there was no quid pro quo”, the White House press secretary, Stephanie Grisham, said in a statement: “Today was just more triple hearsay and selective leaks from the Democrats’ politically-motivated, closed-door, secretive hearings.”
She also said the inquiry was “a coordinated smear campaign”.
.@PressSec releases a statement on the Taylor testimony: pic.twitter.com/TWsQsy1i8G
— Phil Mattingly (@Phil_Mattingly) October 22, 2019
Updated
Biden campaign weighs in on Bill Taylor testimony
“Trump is so desperate not to love to Joe Biden that he threatened to withhold vital military assistance,” said Biden’s campaign manager Kate Bedingfield in a statement.
“The president has betrayed his office,” the statement reads.
Joe Biden’s campaign weighs in on Bill Taylor’s testimony. pic.twitter.com/6cgJGVGU1n
— Sahil Kapur (@sahilkapur) October 22, 2019
Trump to Netanyahu: ‘You are great!’
Trump wished Netanyahu a happy birthday, calling him “one of my closest allies”, in a letter sent on Monday, after the Israeli prime minister announced his failure to form a coalition government.
“You are great!” Trump added, in a handwritten note next to his signature.
According to Axios, Netanyahu’s office released the letter to show that he still had strong ties with Trump, who remains popular in Israel.
Updated
Syria envoy said he was not consulted on US troop withdrawal
James Jeffrey, the special envoy to Syria, said he wasn’t consulted on the Trump administration’s decision to withdraw troops. In a testimony before the Senate foreign relations committee, he said “I personally was not consulted before the decision.”
He defended the administration, saying that Barack Obama and George W Bush both acted in Iraq without consulting him while he worked as an ambassador and a chargé d’affaires, respectively.
“In my current job, I feel that my views, through Secretary Pompeo have been brought repeatedly and frequently and, I think in many cases, effectively,” he said.
But lawmakers were incredulous.
“Professionally are you indifferent to not being consulted about the matter that is in your lifelong expertise?” asked Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia. “Whether you mind it or not, I mind not being consulted.”
Updated
Democrats say Bill Taylor testimony signals 'sea change' in impeachment inquiry
Bill Taylor’s testimony – which contradicts claims by the president, his chief of staff and his and his associates – “is a sea change”, said the Democratic representative Stephen Lynch of Massachusetts. “I think it could accelerate matters,” he said.
The Democratic representative Debbie Wasserman Schultz of Florida said: “I do not know how you would listen to today’s testimony from Ambassador Taylor and come to any other (conclusion) except that the president abused his power and withheld foreign aid”
Meanwhile, other Democrats, including those running for president, have reiterated their support for a speedy impeachment.
I'll say it again: This is corruption, plain and simple. Donald Trump must be impeached. https://t.co/ZZH4J3DY0t
— Elizabeth Warren (@ewarren) October 22, 2019
Updated
That’s it from me today. My west coast colleague, Maanvi Singh, will take over the blog for the next few hours.
Here’s where the day stands so far:
- Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, testified in House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry that he was told Trump was holding up military aid to Ukraine until the country’s president publicly announced investigations into Joe Biden and the 2016 election – contradicting Trump’s repeated denials of a quid pro quo.
- Trump sparked outrage by comparing the impeachment inquiry to a “lynching”.
- The anonymous author of a 2018 New York Times op-ed who claimed to be part of an internal White House “resistance” to Trump is now writing a book while maintaining anonymity.
- Russia has won joint control of formerly Kurdish territory in Syria, marking a crucial victory for Vladimir Putin after the withdrawal of US troops.
- The UK parliament rejected the Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s proposal to fast-track Brexit, virtually guaranteeing that Britain will not leave the EU by its set deadline at the end of the month. (Follow the Guardian’s UK politics live blog for more.)
Maanvi will have more on the news of the day, so stay tuned.
Updated
Bill Taylor also said in his opening statement to the House committees investigating impeachment that a National Security Council official, Tim Morrison, had offered a less than glowing assessment of Trump’s call with the Ukrainian president.
The acting US ambassador to Ukraine said: “Mr. Morrison told me that the call ‘could have been better’ and that President Trump had suggested that President Zelenskyy or his staff meet with Mr. Giuliani and Attorney General William Barr. I did not see any official readout of the call until it was publicly released on September 25.”
Morrison’s opinion is a far cry from Trump’s repeated assertions that his call with the Ukrainian president was “perfect” and included nothing improper.
A Washington Post reporter summarized the opening statement of Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, in this way:
Shorter Bill Taylor: President Trump insisted, over and over there was not a "quid pro quo." But there was a quid. Followed by a pro. And then, finally, a quo.
— Matt Viser (@mviser) October 22, 2019
Sondland said 'everything,' including military aid, tied to investigations, Taylor testifies
According to the opening statement of Bill Taylor, Gordon Sondland said that “everything,” including the release of military aid to Ukraine, was tied to the country’s president publicly announcing investigations into Joe Biden and the 2016 election.
Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, said to the House committees investigating impeachment: “Ambassador Sondland also told me that he now recognized that he had made a mistake by earlier telling the Ukrainian officials to whom he spoke that a White House meeting with President Zelenskyy was dependent on a public announcement of investigations – in fact, Ambassador Sondland said, ‘everything’ was dependent on such an announcement, including security assistance.
“He said that President Trump wanted President Zelenskyy ‘in a public box’ by making a public statement about ordering such investigations.”
Taylor says he was planning to resign if Ukraine aid not released
Bill Taylor said in his opening statement to the House committees investigating impeachment that he was preparing to resign in August over the delaying of military aid to Ukraine.
The acting US ambassador to Ukraine said that he had a conversation on August 22 with Tim Morrison of the National Security Council. Morrison indicated during the phone call that Trump was opposed to authorizing any military aid to Ukraine.
Taylor said: “As I had told Secretary [Mike] Pompeo in May, if the policy of strong support for Ukraine were to change, I would have to resign. Based on my call with Mr. Morrison, I was preparing to do so.”
In his opening statement to the House committees investigating impeachment, Bill Taylor said he was told by an official at the National Security Council that Trump had insisted the Ukrainian president himself publicly announce a probe into Joe Biden and his son.
The acting US ambassador to Ukraine said: “President Trump did insist that President Zelensky go to a microphone and say he is opening investigations of Biden and 2016 election interference, and that President Zelensky should want to do this himself.”
However, Taylor said that Trump had told Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, he was not seeking a “quid pro quo,” even as military aid to Ukraine hung in the balance.
At the risk of stating the obvious: if Trump demanded that the Ukrainian president make public announcements of investigations into Democrats before he would authorize the release of military aid, then his actions were the very definition of a quid pro quo.
Taylor expressed concerns about Giuliani's role in Ukraine
Bill Taylor said in his opening statement to the House committees investigating impeachment that he was concerned before accepting the role of acting US ambassador to Ukraine about Rudy Giuliani’s role in the country.
The longtime diplomat said: “I worried about what I had heard concerning the role of Rudolph Giuliani, who made several high-profile statements about Ukraine and U.S. policy toward the country.
“So during my meeting with Secretary [Mike] Pompeo on May 28, I made clear to him and the others present that if U.S. policy toward Ukraine changed, he would not want me posted there and I could not stay.”
After accepting the role, Taylor said he realized that Giuliani – along with Kurt Volker, Gordon Sondland and Rick Perry – controlled “an irregular, informal channel of U.S. policy-making with respect to Ukraine.”
Taylor said: “Although this irregular channel was well-connected in Washington, it operated mostly outside of official State Department channels.”
Taylor stands by text message in which he called potential quid pro quo 'crazy'
The Washington Post has published a copy of Bill Taylor’s opening statement to the House committees investigating impeachment.
In the 15-page statement, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine and longtime civil servant describes how he became “increasingly concerned” that the US-Ukraine relationship was being “fundamentally undermined” by withholding military aid for “domestic political reasons.”
Taylor added that he stood by his Sept. 9 text message to Gordon Sondland and Kurt Volker, in which he said it would be “crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign.”
It remains unknown whether the senior Trump administration official who is writing a book about being part of an internal “resistance” is still employed by the White House.
This is certainly unprecedented, but one key question is unanswered: is this person STILL in the Administration? A White House official declined to comment on the news of the book, or to speculate on the identity of Anonymous. https://t.co/LUPRFkE785
— Eamon Javers (@EamonJavers) October 22, 2019
According to CNN, the literary agency representing the author declined to comment on whether the person still worked in the administration.
Anonymous 'resistance' op-ed author penning book
Here’s another piece of news that the president will surely hate: The anonymous author of a 2018 New York Times op-ed that described a “resistance” inside the government to help control Trump is now writing a book.
The Washington Post reports:
The book, titled, ‘A WARNING,’ is being promoted as ‘an unprecedented behind-the-scenes portrait of the Trump presidency’ that expands upon the Times column, which ricocheted around the world and stoked the president’s rage because of its devastating portrayal of Trump in office.
The column described Trump’s leadership style as ‘impetuous, adversarial, petty and ineffective,’ and noted that ‘his impulsiveness results in half-baked, ill-informed and occasionally reckless decisions that have to be walked back.’ ...
The forthcoming book will list the author as ‘Anonymous.’ Although the person does not reveal their identity in the book, they will discuss the reasons for their anonymity, according to people involved in the project.
Taylor reportedly contradicts Sondland's testimony
Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, reportedly directly contradicted the testimony of Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, in his opening statement to the House committees investigating impeachment.
Wow -- > Bill Taylor’s testimony totally contradicts Amb. Sondland’s claim that he recalls “no discussions” with anyone at the State Department or White House about Biden or his son. Taylor says Sondland heard about Biden directly from Trump:https://t.co/mkmJWgSbjz pic.twitter.com/7xXzBJAd5E
— John Hudson (@John_Hudson) October 22, 2019
Several House Democrats involved in the investigation are already calling for Sondland to be called back to testify and answer for the discrepancies between the two men’s accounts.
Democratic Rep. Stephen Lynch said there were “inconsistencies” in testimony and “factual assertions.”
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) October 22, 2019
“I would be extremely surprised and dumbfounded if Chairman Schiff didn’t ask for him to come back,” Lynch told me, referring to Sondland.
https://t.co/Si2gXP6neO
Taylor reportedly says he was told military aid was contingent upon public announcement of investigations
Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, said in his opening statement to the House committees investigating impeachment that he was told military aid to Ukraine was contingent upon public announcements of investigations into Democrats, according to the Washington Post.
The Post reports:
Upon arriving in Kyiv last spring he became alarmed by secondary diplomatic channels involving U.S. officials that he called ‘weird,’ Taylor said, according to a copy of his lengthy opening statement obtained by The Washington Post.
Taylor walked lawmakers through a series of conversations he had with other U.S. diplomats who were trying to obtain what one called the ‘deliverable’ of Ukrainian help investigating Trump’s political rivals.
Taylor said he spoke to Ambassador Gordon Sondland, the U.S. envoy to the European Union.
‘During that phone call, Amb. Sondland told me that President Trump had told him that he wants President [Volodymyr] Zelensky to state publicly that Ukraine will investigate Burisma and alleged Ukrainian interference in the 2016 election,’ Taylor said in the statement.
Former Vice President Joe Biden’s son Hunter had been a board member of Burisma, a large Ukrainian gas company.
McConnell says he and Trump never discussed Ukraine call, contradicting the president
Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader, denied ever telling Trump that his Ukraine call was “perfect,” as the president has claimed. Asked whether Trump was lying, the Kentucky Republican replied: “You’d have to ask him.”
A couple weeks ago, @realDonaldTrump said that @senatemajldr told him that his call w/President Zelensky was “perfect” and “innocent”. But when I asked McConnell about that just now, he said he never spoke to the President about it. So was Trump lying? “You’d have to ask him.”
— Nancy Cordes (@nancycordes) October 22, 2019
McConnell also offered some muted criticism of Trump’s use of the word “lynching” to describe House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry, calling it “an unfortunate choice of words.”
Senate Majority Leader McConnell on President Trump's comparison of the impeachment effort against him to "a lynching":
— NBC News (@NBCNews) October 22, 2019
“Given the history in our country, I would not compare this to a lynching. That was an unfortunate choice of words.” pic.twitter.com/3zEDZzwv9y
Russia wins joint control over formerly Kurdish territory in Syria
There are major news developments happening away from House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry today. Russia and Turkey have just announced a plan to jointly control formerly Kurdish territory in Syria, marking a major victory for Vladimir Putin.
The New York Times reports:
[O]n Tuesday, President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia played host to President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey, for more than six hours of talks on how they and other regional players will divide control of Syria, a land devastated by eight years of civil war.
The negotiations ended with a victory for Mr. Putin: Russian and Turkish troops will take joint control over a vast swath of formerly Kurdish-held territory in northern Syria, in a move that cements the rapid expansion of Russian influence in Syria at the expense of the United States and its Kurdish former allies.
Under the terms of the agreement, Syrian Kurdish forces must now retreat more than 20 miles from the border, abandoning land that they had controlled uncontested until earlier this month — when their protectors, the American military, suddenly began to withdraw from the region.
Two Democratic members of the House oversight committee, Gerry Connolly of Virginia and Raja Krishnamoorthi of Illinois, suggested that Gordon Sondland may have to appear again before congressional investigators to respond to Bill Taylor’s testimony.
Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, testified in the impeachment inquiry last week and insisted in a September text message to Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, that there was “no quid pro quo” involved in the delaying of military aid to Ukraine.
Rep. Connolly to reporters just now: “Speaking for myself, I think Gordon Sondland may very well have to come back.”
— Sam Brodey (@sambrodey) October 22, 2019
.@CongressmanRaja after hearing Bill Taylor testimony today: “Mr. Sondland is going to have some explaining to do”
— Scott Wong (@scottwongDC) October 22, 2019
The Republican members of the House committees investigating impeachment have not been as forthcoming as their Democratic counterparts about Bill Taylor’s testimony.
However, even their subdued comments seem to speak volumes about what the acting US ambassador to Ukraine has said behind closed doors.
GOP more tight-lipped than Dems. Jordan praises the effectiveness of the GOP counsel, and Zeldin questioned whether Dems who though Taylor was damning actually sat through other depositions.
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney) October 22, 2019
So far, none have suggested Taylor’s testimony is exculpatory for Trump, even when asked
Taylor reportedly describes White House efforts to secure investigations in exchange for military aid
Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, reportedly told House impeachment investigators that the Trump White House attempted to tie investigations of the president’s political rivals to the country’s military aid.
Politico reports:
Taylor prompted sighs and gasps when he read a lengthy 15-page opening statement, two of the sources said. Another person in the room said Taylor’s statement described ‘how pervasive the efforts were’ among Trump’s allies to convince Ukrainian officials to launch an investigation targeting former Vice President Joe Biden and another probe centering on a debunked conspiracy theory regarding the 2016 election.
Taylor also described the extent to which military assistance to Ukraine and a potential White House meeting with Trump and his Ukrainian counterpart were tied to those investigations, the source added.
The Twitter account for Merriam-Webster Dictionary is once again weighing in on Trump’s latest controversy, this time reacting to his use of the term “lynching” to describe House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry.
📈‘Lynch’ is our top search today. Even in a metaphorical context, it still evokes a long and painful history of racist violence. https://t.co/zDXeq4Ke0c
— Merriam-Webster (@MerriamWebster) October 22, 2019
The dictionary’s Twitter account has previously mocked the president for his use (and often misuse) of certain words. When Trump appeared to confuse a hyphen and an apostrophe last month, the dictionary tweeted out this helpful reminder.
For those looking up punctuation early on a Friday morning:
— Merriam-Webster (@MerriamWebster) September 27, 2019
A hyphen is a mark - used to divide or to compound words.
An apostrophe is a mark ' used to indicate the omission of letters or figures.
Mnuchin and Kushner reportedly plan to attend Saudi investment conference
In some non-impeachment news, treasury secretary Steven Munchin and Jared Kushner reportedly plan to attend a Saudi investment conference a year after avoiding the event due to outrage over the killing of dissident journalist Jamal Khashoggi.
The New York Times reports:
The Treasury Department confirmed that Mr. Mnuchin will be participating in the Future Investment Initiative gathering in Riyadh. Jared Kushner, President Trump’s son-in-law and senior adviser, will also be attending the conference, alongside Brian H. Hook, the State Department’s special envoy overseeing Iran policy and Avi Berkowitz, an aide to Mr. Kushner, according to people familiar with the matter.
Mr. Mnuchin is expected to participate in a moderated discussion at the event. He initially planned to attend last year, but reversed that decision as global outrage mounted over the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, a Washington Post writer, whose killing in Turkey was orchestrated by the Saudi government.
According to CNN, Bill Taylor told the House committees investigating impeachment that Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, listed a desire for Ukraine to launch investigations into Democrats as one potential reason why military aid to the country was delayed.
Taylor said that he and Sondland spoke by phone about why the aid was frozen, and Sondland cited the need for Ukraine to open an investigation among other reasons, according to the sources
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) October 22, 2019
The source said Sondland was only speculating when he referenced the political investigations into the 2016 election and Burisma.
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) October 22, 2019
Representative Stephen Lynch, a Democratic member of the House oversight committee, said that Bill Taylor took “extensive notes” about his communications while serving as acting US ambassador to Ukraine.
Amb. Taylor “indicated that he kept extensive notes on all of his correspondence,” Rep. Stephen Lynch says of testimony, without discussing details. “He’s a meticulous public servant.”
— Ben Siegel (@benyc) October 22, 2019
A number of Democrats sitting in on Taylor’s closed-door appearance said that the longtime diplomat was the most important witness to testify in the impeachment inquiry yet.
Lots of Dems, like Lieu, say Taylor’s testimony was explosive. Rep. Espaillat said this was the most important witness so far. Unanimity among Ds on this point so far.
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney) October 22, 2019
Here’s where the day stands so far:
- Bill Taylor is testifying behind closed doors in House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry against Trump. The acting US ambassador to Ukraine said in a text last month that he thought it was “crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign.”
- Trump was lambasted by many Democrats (and a much smaller number of Republicans) for comparing the impeachment investigation to a “lynching.”
- A new poll found that half of Americans support impeaching Trump and removing him from office, marking a 13-point increase since late April.
The blog will have plenty more coming up, so stay tuned.
Updated
Another Democratic member of the House foreign affairs committee, Andy Levin of Michigan, described Bill Taylor’s testimony as “very troubling.”
Levin said of the acting US ambassador to Ukraine’s comments: “All I have to say is that in my 10 short months in Congress – it’s not even noon, right – and this is my most disturbing day in Congress so far. Very troubling.”
Meanwhile, one of Levin’s colleagues defended Taylor’s reputation against potential smears from Trump’s allies.
Ambassador Bill Taylor is a graduate of West Point. He served in Vietnam with the 101st Airborne. He is an American patriot. He understands duty, honor, country. https://t.co/aT4YV3ATeR
— Ted Lieu (@tedlieu) October 22, 2019
Updated
Meanwhile, representative Mark Meadows, a Republican member of the House oversight committee and a close ally of Trump’s, joked that Bill Taylor’s interview could go on for much longer.
Asked how much longer today’s Taylor deposition will go, @RepMarkMeadows tells us: “y’all have plans for the weekend?”
— Sam Brodey (@sambrodey) October 22, 2019
The acting US ambassador to Ukraine started his testimony for House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry about three hours ago.
The opening statement from Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, to the three House committees leading the impeachment inquiry solicited “sighs and gasps,” according to a Politico reporter.
New: Per source in the room, Bill Taylor’s opening statement was 15 pages long and prompted “a lot of sighs and gasps.”
— Andrew Desiderio (@AndrewDesiderio) October 22, 2019
The opening statements from Maria Yovanovitch, the former US ambassador to Ukraine, and Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, were quickly leaked to the press, so it’s likely the same will occur with Taylor’s statement.
A Republican senator, Susan Collins of Maine, condemned Trump’s use of the term “lynching” to describe House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry.
“Lynching” brings back images of a terrible time in our nation’s history, and the President never should have made that comparison.
— Sen. Susan Collins (@SenatorCollins) October 22, 2019
Collins’ tweet appears to be one of the most forceful criticisms yet from Republicans, as other GOP lawmakers have simply said that they did not “agree” with Trump’s usage of the term.
House Democrat describes Taylor's testimony as 'incredibly damaging' to Trump
Representative Ted Lieu, a Democratic member of the House foreign affairs committee, just emerged from the closed-door interview with Bill Taylor and said the acting US ambassador to Ukraine’s testimony was “incredibly damaging to the president.”
LIEU just emerged and described Taylor’s testimony as “incredibly damaging to the president.” Wouldn’t provide specifics. He said questioning of the witness has begun.
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney) October 22, 2019
CNN reported earlier today that Taylor intended to use his testimony to fill in some of the gaps surrounding his 9 September text message, in which he said it was “crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign.”
Updated
Michael Steele, a former chairman of the Republican National Committee who has repeatedly criticized Trump in the past, denounced the president’s use of the term “lynching” to describe House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry.
Steele also chastised Lindsey Graham after the South Carolina senator echoed Trump’s use of the term and said the impeachment probe is “a lynching in every sense.”
@realDonaldTrump and @LindseyGrahamSC this is a lynching. Trump this is not happening to you and it’s pathetic that you act like you’re such a victim; but it did happen to 147 black people in your state Lindsey. “A lynching in every sense”? You should know better. pic.twitter.com/RQNQaOaLsd
— Michael Steele (@MichaelSteele) October 22, 2019
However, Graham does not appear to be changing his stance at all, insisting that the inquiry is a “political lynching” and refusing to comment on the racist implications of Trump’s comment.
“If [the word] lynching bothers you, I’m sorry... it’s literally a political lynching,” Sen. Graham tells reporters. I asked him to reflect on the racial dynamics of the word and he sharply dismissed the question.
— Robert Costa (@costareports) October 22, 2019
Representative Eric Swalwell, a Democratic member of the House intelligence committee, said in a tweet that Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, asked Trump at one point: “What do you want from Ukraine?”
Reality check: The Ambassador called you and asked broadly, “what do you want from Ukraine?” With a guilty conscience, you repeated, “no quid pro quo.” Problem: He didn’t ask you if there was a quid pro quo. You just happened to know there was one. https://t.co/Tf9WWjS3JL
— Rep. Eric Swalwell (@RepSwalwell) October 22, 2019
Sondland testified in House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry last week and may have shared this detail with the investigating lawmakers behind closed doors, but the transcript of his appearance has not been publicly released.
After Bill Taylor said in a text message last month that he thought it was “crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign,” Sondland replied: “Bill, I believe you are incorrect about President Trump’s intentions. The President has been crystal clear no quid pro quo’s of any kind.”
However, reports later emerged that Sondland only sent his “no quid pro quo” message after speaking to Trump.
The King Center, which honors the life of civil rights leader Martin Luther King, just tweeted out these facts about lynching after Trump used the term to describe the impeachment inquiry.
“More than 4400 African American men, women, and children were hanged, burned alive, shot, drowned, and beaten to death by white mobs between 1877 and 1950.” ~@MemPeaceJustice https://t.co/qGmK6VFwCw#LynchingMemorial #Lynching @realDonaldTrump @POTUS
— The King Center (@TheKingCenter) October 22, 2019
White House defends Trump's description of impeachment inquiry as 'lynching'
A White House spokesperson defended Trump’s use of the word “lynching” to describe the impeachment inquiry by arguing that the president was not making a historical comparison.
.@hogangidley45 on lynching tweet: "the president has used many words, all types of language, to talk about the way the media has treated him" and "the president wasn't trying to compare himself to the horrific history in this country at all"
— Justin Sink (@justinsink) October 22, 2019
This explanation seems highly questionable, given that the word “lynching” has almost exclusively been applied to the thousands of people (most of them African American) who were murdered in the late 19th and early 20th century.
It seems virtually impossible that Trump is unaware of this history, particularly given that the Senate passed a bill last year to make lynching a hate crime. The president has not yet signed the legislation.
notably, there was a unanimous Senate voice vote last year which defined lynching as part of a bill that would have officially made it a hate crime (which the president has not signed): https://t.co/o4bpXMWI44 pic.twitter.com/vAY0e43k9I
— Edward-Isaac Dovere (@IsaacDovere) October 22, 2019
Updated
Taylor was subpoenaed for his testimony, House official confirms
Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine who is currently speaking to House members for Democrats’ impeachment inquiry against Trump, was reportedly subpoenaed for his testimony.
In light of an attempt by the State Dept to direct Ambassador Taylor not to appear for his scheduled deposition + efforts by the State Dept to also limit any testimony that does occur, the House Intel Cmte issued a subpoena to compel his testimony this morning per official
— Alex Moe (@AlexNBCNews) October 22, 2019
Other officials who have spoken to the three House committees leading the inquiry have similarly been subpoenaed – including Taylor’s predecessor, Maria Yovanovitch.
Senator Tim Scott, the only African American Republican serving in the Senate, offered this muted criticism of Trump’s use of the term “lynching” to describe the impeachment inquiry.
Sen TIM SCOTT on Pres Trump comparing the impeachment inquiry to a lynching: “There’s no question that the impeachment process is the closet thing to a political death row trial, so I get his absolute rejection of the process. I wouldn’t use the word lynching.”
— Frank Thorp V (@frankthorp) October 22, 2019
Jimmy Carter hospitalized for second fall in a month
In some news far from Washington, former president Jimmy Carter, 95, has been hospitalized for the second time this month due to a fall in his Georgia home.
The AP reports:
Carter Center spokeswoman Deanne Congileo described the fracture as minor. Her statement said that the 95-year-old was in good spirits at the Phoebe Sumter Medical Center after falling on Monday evening, and that he was looking forward to recovering at home.
This is the third time Carter has fallen in recent months. He first fell in the spring and required hip replacement surgery. Carter fell again this month and despite receiving 14 stitches, traveled the next day to Nashville, Tennessee to rally volunteers and help build a Habitat for Humanity home.
Carter is the oldest living former president in U.S. history. He and 92-year-old Rosalynn recently became the longest married first couple, surpassing George and Barbara Bush, with more than 73 years of marriage.
Updated
At least one of Trump’s allies on Capitol Hill, House minority leader Kevin McCarthy, said he did not agree with the president’s use of the term “lynching” to describe the impeachment inquiry.
The California Republican said: “That’s not the language I would use. ... I don’t agree with that language, pretty simple.”
.@GOPLeader McCarthy asked about @realDonaldTrump's "lynching" tweet. "That's not the language I would use." pic.twitter.com/irkWvxRD5E
— Cameron Joseph (@cam_joseph) October 22, 2019
Meanwhile, several House Democrats warned that Trump was simply trying to spark indignation to distract from the testimony of Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine who said it was “crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign.”
Don’t take your eye off the ball family. A major witness is testifying today and he’s using a predictable play to try to distract & divide. We see right through him. https://t.co/nLoxQOMd6I
— Ayanna Pressley (@AyannaPressley) October 22, 2019
One of Trump’s closest congressional allies, senator Lindsey Graham, echoed the president’s use of the term “lynching” to describe the impeachment inquiry.
Lindsey Graham tells reporters the impeachment process is “a lynching in every sense,” backing up Trump’s tweet this morning
— Geoff Bennett (@GeoffRBennett) October 22, 2019
Graham has been very critical of Trump’s decision to withdraw US troops from northern Syria, and the South Carolina senator said in a recent interview that he would be open to considering evidence in connection to the president’s possible removal from office.
However, it appears that (for now at least) Graham is standing by Trump in slamming the impeachment inquiry in the most controversial terms possible.
Despite widespread outrage to Trump’s “lynching” tweet, at least one of his congressional allies did not raise much concern about the president invoking centuries of violence against African Americans to criticize the impeachment inquiry.
Asked if President Trump's tweet comparing the impeachment inquiry to "a lynching" is appropriate, Rep. Jim Jordan told @mkraju, “The president is frustrated.”
— Kaitlan Collins (@kaitlancollins) October 22, 2019
As the acting US ambassador to Ukraine testifies behind closed doors on Capitol Hill, more House Democrats expressed outrage at Trump for comparing the impeachment inquiry to a “lynching.”
From an Illinois congressman:
You think this impeachment is a LYNCHING? What the hell is wrong with you?
— Bobby L. Rush (@RepBobbyRush) October 22, 2019
Do you know how many people who look like me have been lynched, since the inception of this country, by people who look like you. Delete this tweet. https://t.co/oTMhWo4awR
A Texas congresswoman called it a “disgrace”:
Rep Veronica Escobar said Trump’s lynching tweet “was shocking” and says he doesn’t understand history and says it’s incredibly disrespectful to the country. It was awful, she added.
— Alex Moe (@AlexNBCNews) October 22, 2019
The chairwoman of the congressional black caucus argued that the tweet fits a pattern of Trump using the most vile language possible when he feels cornered:
CBC Chairwoman Karen Bass told me of this “lynching” tweet that she believes it is consistent with Trump’s pattern of throwing out “racial bombs” to give “red meat” to his base when his back his against the wall. https://t.co/iVhOTHq0yp
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) October 22, 2019
A CNN reporter similarly suggested that the tweet was Trump’s way of trying to distract from the many controversies he is facing at home and abroad right now:
Trump knows what a lynching is & what it means in this country.
— Abby D. Phillip (@abbydphillip) October 22, 2019
And the fastest way to create a cycle of controversy is to invoke the county’s deepest & darkest racial wounds for his own ends.
It should be called out, but let’s stay focused on the facts. https://t.co/wHM5NiPELC
Taylor to reportedly provide timeline of his work in Ukraine
In his closed-door testimony, Bill Taylor reportedly intends to describe the events leading up to his text messages about a potential quid pro quo in the delaying of military aid to Ukraine, but he is not looking to issue his own statement.
CNN reports:
Taylor, who is testifying before the three House committees leading the Democratic impeachment inquiry, will lay out the reasoning behind his different WhatsApp text messages in his opening statement Tuesday, [a source familiar with his testimony] said. Taylor plans to include a chronology of events, according to the source, dating back to June, when Taylor assumed the post as ambassador, through October. ...
Taylor will not be bringing any new documents to the committee, he will just be referencing those that have already been made public, the source said. ...
Taylor, as the current acting ambassador to Ukraine, is in a difficult and delicate position testifying Tuesday, the source said. Taylor’s view is that he is there to speak to committee and answer their questions, and he’s not looking to issue his own statement publicly. ...
Taylor plans to return to Ukraine on Wednesday, the source said. He wants to keep his job, and thinks it is important work.
Updated
Acting US ambassador to Ukraine arrives for impeachment testimony
Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, has arrived on Capitol Hill to testify in House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry against Trump.
The longtime diplomat wrote in a text last month to Kurt Volker, the former US special envoy to Ukraine, and Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, that it was “crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign.”
House Democrats hope Taylor can shed light on whether Trump held up military aid to Ukraine specifically to pressure officials there to investigate Joe Biden.
Half of Americans say Trump should be removed from office, new poll finds
Half of Americans believe that Trump should be impeached and removed from office, according to a CNN/SSRS poll released this morning.
The results showed that 50 percent of Americans would support Trump’s removal, compared to 43 percent of Americans who would oppose it. That level of support marks a 13-point increase since late April, following the release of special counsel Robert Mueller’s redacted report.
In comparison, CNN’s polling never surpassed 30 percent when measuring support of Bill Clinton’s impeachment, a Bloomberg News reporter noted.
It’s still early in the process but one thing is already clear — the politics look nothing like the Clinton impeachment, despite how much that fear has haunted Democrats all year.
— Sahil Kapur (@sahilkapur) October 22, 2019
Reactions are rolling in to Trump’s description of the impeachment inquiry as a “lynching,” and they are unsurprisingly furious.
From the president of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law:
A lynching?! 4,743 people were lynched in the US between 1882 - 1968, incl. 3,446 African Americans. Lynchings were crimes against humanity and an ugly part of our nation’s history of racial violence and brutality
— Kristen Clarke (@KristenClarkeJD) October 22, 2019
Sickened to see Trump’s gross misappropriation of this term today pic.twitter.com/L8Oi9m8xRk
From an Atlantic staff writer:
Trump has inspired multiple acts of racist violence and his referring to impeachment as a “lynching” is risible. But worse will be his toadies adopting this inversion of past and present, with the nation’s most powerful racist as a *victim* of racist violence, as a talking point. pic.twitter.com/EaXx3bUUUQ
— *Palpatine voice* UNLIMITED DADPUNS🍝 (@AdamSerwer) October 22, 2019
Representative Jim Clyburn, Democrats’ House majority whip and a former chairman of the congressional black caucus, urged Trump to “know the history of that word.”
Clyburn on Trump calling impeachment investigation a “lynching”:
— Laura Barrón-López (@lbarronlopez) October 22, 2019
“That is one word that no president ought to apply to himself.”
“I’m not a just a politician...I’m a product of the South. I know the history of that word.”
Trump calls impeachment inquiry 'lynching' as key witness prepares to testify
Good morning, live blog readers!
It is a big day in House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry against Donald Trump. Bill Taylor, the acting US ambassador to Ukraine who took over the the post after the ouster of Maria Yovanovitch, is expected to testify at 9:30 a.m. E.T., and he could provide critical information on whether military aid to the country was held up over Trump’s demand for an investigation into the Democrats.
In a September 9 text message to Kurt Volker, the former US special envoy to Ukraine, and Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the EU, Taylor wrote: “As I said on the phone, I think it’s crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign.”
A number of House Democrats believe that Taylor’s testimony could provide a smoking gun on the question of whether Trump tried to pressure a foreign power to investigate one of his political rivals, Joe Biden.
The president is clearly worried about Taylor’s testimony, if his morning Twitter feed is any indication. Trump lashed out against the investigation in a series of tweets, even referring to the probe as a “lynching.”
So some day, if a Democrat becomes President and the Republicans win the House, even by a tiny margin, they can impeach the President, without due process or fairness or any legal rights. All Republicans must remember what they are witnessing here - a lynching. But we will WIN!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 22, 2019
Trump’s use of a term that invokes centuries of racist violence against African Americans will certainly incense many Democrats, and it will may also frustrate some of the congressional Republicans who privately say they are growing tired of defending the president’s most controversial comments and decisions.
Here’s what else the blog is keeping its eye on:
- Trump will have lunch with secretary of state Mike Pompeo at 12:45 p.m. E.T.
- Fortune will continue its Most Powerful Women Summit in Washington, where Trump’s former homeland security secretary, Kirstjen Nielsen, will be interviewed at 2:35 p.m. E.T. Nielsen’s expected appearance has set off controversy, given her instrumental role in the migrant family separation crisis.
- House Republican leadership will hold a press conference at 10 a.m. E.T.
That’s all still coming up, so stay tuned.