It’s not news that the Green Bay Packers have built one of the NFL’s strongest rosters. They’re presenting a sky-high challenge for the New Orleans Saints in Week 1 as legit Super Bowl contenders, hoping to treat the black and gold as little more than a speed bump on their way to the playoffs.

But what if we could pick one player from Green Bay’s roster to instead join the Saints? Knowing the team’s strengths and weaknesses, which Packer would you want to go turncoat? To make it at least a little challenging (and more interesting), we took Aaron Rodgers off the board. Here are our staff picks this week: