Let’s be honest, everyone has a junk drawer. But me? I have a whole junk cupboard. My cupboard under the stairs, to be precise. And while I’ve tried on many occasions to part ways with the clutter and junk that lives under there, none have been quite as effective as the 5-second decluttering rule.
Yep, I’m no stranger to the many decluttering methods out there, but I often find that they’re best used when they’re room or area-specific. For example, I swear by the Project 333 decluttering method for my wardrobe, and the four-box decluttering method was ideal for sorting out the junk that was underneath my bed. But I struggle with my under-the-stairs junk cupboard because it’s a whole cacophony of random stuff.
We’re talking shoes, cleaning products, coats, and just about anything else that doesn’t have a proper ‘home.’ I even have a shelving system within the cupboard full of spare batteries, pens, and random screwdrivers. So, I hoped that the 5-second decluttering rule would help me finally part with my junk (while also keeping the things I need), and I was pleasantly surprised by the results.
What is the 5-second decluttering rule?
It can often be hard to get rid of emotional clutter - whether that’s old photographs or the old stationery that you’re weirdly attached to, even though you never use it anymore. But the 5-second decluttering rule aims to help you declutter everything with a split, 5-second decision.
So, you pick up the item, and decide whether you want to keep it or not in 5 seconds or less. This can also help you declutter a house fast, and this instinctual decision is something that Shannon Murphy, Professional Organiser and Founder of Simpl Living Co, wholeheartedly believes is the key, as it gives us all less time to second-guess ourselves.
She says, ‘Effective decluttering should be rooted in gut instinct. So often, we override that initial feeling and start finding reasons to keep something, even when we know deep down we no longer want, need, or use it. I really believe that if something isn’t a definite yes, then it should be a no, and this rule applies just as much when decluttering as it does when making purchasing decisions.’
Of course, decluttering this way doesn’t mean that you immediately have to get rid of these things. It may be that you simply need to give it a proper home, and there are so many other ways to get rid of items after a declutter that you could re-use them, sell them, or donate to family and friends so they stay close.
How I used the 5-second decluttering rule
Although I know I’m lucky to have under-the-stairs storage, it’s also the biggest storage space I have downstairs, which means it becomes a dumping ground for everything that doesn’t have a dedicated home. And as it’s largely filled with practical things - rather than emotional items - I decided that it was the perfect space to try out the 5-second decluttering rule. Plus, I haven’t had any luck with decluttering it before.
So, I pulled everything out of the cupboard (which is always the worst part of decluttering, right?) and laid it out on the floor, before picking up each item one by one and making a quick, 5-second decision as to whether I wanted to keep it. I even used my egg timer to make sure I didn’t take any longer than that.
Some of the decisions were easy, especially when it came to decluttering my cleaning products, as I had so many products that were either empty or out of date - so they went straight into the bin. I also managed to get rid of old shoes I hadn’t worn in years in about a second, too.
There were some decisions that took me a bit closer to the 5-second limit, but overall, I found the whole process extremely cathartic, and I've never been so ruthless. It was the perfect decluttering method for my junk cupboard, and in the end, I was left with about half of what I had originally. I didn't even second-guess my decisions, either, which is what I usually do.
Then, to finish, I followed the steps to organise a junk drawer to turn my chaotic cupboard into something a little more practical. And it worked a treat.
The downsides of the 5-second decluttering rule
However, it's worth noting that the 5-second rule may not suit everyone - or even every area of the house. This is especially true if you want to lean into your emotions when decluttering, rather than pushing them to the side.
Lesley Spellman and Ingrid Jansen, who run The Declutter Hub, warn, ‘The biggest problem we see is that it encourages speed over thought. If you’ve got clutter that’s been in your home for years - especially things with memories or emotional attachment - you simply can’t make those decisions in five seconds.’
They add, ‘And if you do, you might end up regretting it later. Our methods support more sustainable, emotions-based decluttering; giving yourself the time and space to be considered, rather than rushing to make a decision under unnecessary pressure.’
So, if you’re going to try out the 5-second decluttering rule for yourself, it’s probably best that you focus on areas of the house that don’t have too many emotional items in them - like your kitchen cabinets, bathroom storage areas, or your junk drawers or cupboards.
Shannon also adds, ‘I’d also say it also works best when you’re feeling energised and mentally clear, not at the end of a long decluttering session when decision fatigue has set in.’
5-second decluttering rule essentials
If you don't already have an egg timer at your disposal, this one has over 40,000 impressive reviews on Amazon. Anyone else getting GBBO vibes?
I always find storage boxes with lids - like these ones - are always so much better than those that don't have them. They're way more stackable this way, so a lot easier to store in smaller spaces.
If your 5-second decluttering rule adventures have you venturing into your drawers, I cannot recommend drawer organisers more. This set comes with 25 of them in a wide range of sizes.
Now I've streamlined the number of batteries and smaller practical bits I need to keep, I'm on the hunt for a more aesthetic storage solution for them. This one from Dunelm has caught my eye.
I love labelling things, and a label maker is one of the best decluttering products you can have in your locker when trying out the 5-second decluttering rule.
Shoes are the biggest problem in my under-the-stairs cupboard, as even the ones that I haven't decluttered are taking up too much space. So, I'll be buying some of these to halve that.
So, will you be giving the 5-second decluttering rule a whirl?
