100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
‘Don’t touch this’: EU deplores UK threats to override Northern Ireland Protocol
‘Renegotiation is not an option,’ European Commission warns
Brexit: What is the Northern Ireland protocol?
Post-Brexit deal 'not working', says NI first minister
EU trying to punish UK for Brexit with NI Protocol – Rees-Mogg
Ireland’s Simon Coveney has instead insisted that the UK Government would be acting in an ‘anti-democratic’ way if it overrides…
Ireland warns UK against threats to Brexit protocol
Dublin (AFP) - Ireland's foreign minister on Wednesday said the UK risked a breach of international law if it scraps…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Northern Ireland protocol: UK and EU to hold crunch talks as deal hangs in the balance
On Wednesday, the Prime Minister said the Good Friday Agreement was more important than the Northern Ireland Protocol
Brexit: Liz Truss tells EU she has ‘no choice’ but to act on Northern Ireland protocol
European Commission expresses ‘serious concern’ over ‘unacceptable’ UK stance
Get all your news in one place
Latest Politics news:
Who is Peter Dutton? The ex-cop tipped to be the next leader of the Liberal Party
Former minister Peter Dutton is expected to run unopposed to be the next leader of the Liberal Party and, in…
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Calls for new innovation patents after old scheme abolished
There are fresh calls for a new innovation patent scheme to be launched by the federal government to help local SMEs…
Replacement theory isn't new – 3 things to know about how this once-fringe conspiracy has become more mainstream
The recent grocery store mass shooting in Buffalo, New York, is placing a spotlight on white supremacy.
What we know about mass school shootings in the US – and the gunmen who carry them out
When the Columbine High School massacre took place in 1999 it was seen as a watershed moment in the United…
‘Landmark’ Amazon shareholder push for greater tax transparency
Amazon will face a “landmark” shareholder vote pushing the global tech giant to provide greater tax transparency in Australia and…
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
AWS, with $626m in federal contracts, pays ‘negligible’ tax: Report
Amazon’s cloud business reported $600 million in revenue in Australia but paid only $16 million in tax in the 2020…
Eden-Monaro and Gippsland are next-door neighbours: why is one seat safe and the other marginal?
The recent federal election saw some close calls but few surprises in the regions, where wild electoral swings are rare.

How the UK may try to override the Northern Ireland Brexit protocol

By Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent
Union flag flying above a larger EU flag.
The Northern Ireland protocol was a key part of the Brexit agreement. Photograph: Jane Barlow/PA

The UK government is threatening to write new laws to allow it to unilaterally override parts of the Northern Ireland Brexit protocol due to concerns over “peace and stability”.

But what options are open to the UK, given the protocol was part of a legally binding international treaty co-signed with the EU?

Catherine Barnard, a professor of EU law at the University of Cambridge, thinks there are five options to consider.

Article 16 of the protocol

This is the most oft-cited set of clauses allowing for “safeguard measures” which could include a pause of the checks and controls on goods crossing the Irish Sea in the event of “serious economic, societal or environmental difficulties that are liable to persist” or in the event that there is “diversion of trade”.

In a statement earlier this week, the government said 200 retailers had stopped delivering to customers in Northern Ireland.

But while article 16 allows the UK to take “safeguard measures”, this has already effectively been put in place through earlier unilateral action to suspend the checks on many goods.

The section of the protocol also requires the UK to give the EU a month’s notice that it is invoking article 16 and the protective measures must be reviewed with the EU in the joint committee every three months.

As a negotiating tool, this is not strong. But it could score points among unionists and Brexiter backbenchers.

Article 4 of Section 7 (a) of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2018

This gives direct effect to the supremacy of the withdrawal agreement over domestic law. It covers all three elements in the agreement – the Irish border, citizens’ rights and the divorce bill.

To revoke it fully would be tantamount to walking away from the Brexit deal entirely.

Using Section 7 (a) would be very serious because it would mean removing the entire agreement which would remove citizens’ rights too. What the government could be looking at doing is just turning the agreement off in respect to anything to do with the Northern Ireland protocol.

Section 8 (c) of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2018

This enables the UK to implement updates to any EU directives in relation to the Northern Ireland trading arrangements without having to go through an act of parliament.

It results in what is known as “dynamic alignment” of British and EU laws in this limited geographical area of the UK. Revoking the provision would delight the unionists who have complained that the UK’s sovereign right to make its own laws for the entire country has been undermined by the protocol.

Section 38 (b) of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020

This is known as the Bill Cash clause, which recognises that the parliament of the UK is sovereign. While the clause has been frequently referred to in EU scrutiny committee hearings chaired by Cash, a veteran Eurosceptic, it has never been challenged. It is also seen as stating the obvious, and is unlikely to be the core of legal manoeuvres made by the foreign secretary, Liz Truss.

Article 62 of the Vienna Convention

Barnard thinks this is where Truss and the attorney general for England and Wales, Suella Braverman, could be focusing their legal arguments.

The 1969 pact does not allow a country to withdraw from an international treaty on the grounds of “a fundamental change of circumstances which has occurred with regard to those existing at the time of the conclusion of a treaty, and which was not foreseen by the parties, may not be invoked as a ground for terminating or withdrawing from the treaty”.

In any case all parties knew about the divisions in Northern Ireland and the Belfast Good Friday agreement includes mechanisms to respect all parts of the community.

Article 62 also warns that this “change of circumstances” could not be a reason for walking away from an international treaty if “the existence of those circumstances [which allegedly changed]” were an “essential basis” of the consent of the two sides.

As the protocol was all about protecting peace on the island of Ireland and ensuring no hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, this may not be a watertight ground for disapplying the treaty.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
‘Don’t touch this’: EU deplores UK threats to override Northern Ireland Protocol
‘Renegotiation is not an option,’ European Commission warns
Brexit: What is the Northern Ireland protocol?
Post-Brexit deal 'not working', says NI first minister
EU trying to punish UK for Brexit with NI Protocol – Rees-Mogg
Ireland’s Simon Coveney has instead insisted that the UK Government would be acting in an ‘anti-democratic’ way if it overrides…
Ireland warns UK against threats to Brexit protocol
Dublin (AFP) - Ireland's foreign minister on Wednesday said the UK risked a breach of international law if it scraps…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Northern Ireland protocol: UK and EU to hold crunch talks as deal hangs in the balance
On Wednesday, the Prime Minister said the Good Friday Agreement was more important than the Northern Ireland Protocol
Brexit: Liz Truss tells EU she has ‘no choice’ but to act on Northern Ireland protocol
European Commission expresses ‘serious concern’ over ‘unacceptable’ UK stance
Get all your news in one place