Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Manchester Evening News
Manchester Evening News
Sport
Nathan Bliss

How Manchester United transfer target Sean Longstaff compares with Ander Herrera

After five seasons at Manchester United, midfielder Ander Herrera left the club on a free transfer at the end of last season, eventually ending up at French giants Paris-Saint Germain.

To fill the void left by Herrera, United are targeting Newcastle United midfielder Sean Longstaff this summer as they look to build a young squad filled with British talent.

Having already bought in winger Daniel James and full-back Aaron Wan-Bissaka, while also chasing a deal for Leicester City defender Harry Maguire, Longstaff is the player who Ole Gunnar Solskjaer wants as a central midfield option next season.

But, how does Longstaff compare with Herrera in terms of attributes? And, how different are their playing styles?

We used Football Manager to find out.

Sean Longstaff vs Ander Herrera

Current Ability: 120/200 vs 150/200

Potential Ability: 142/200 vs 156/200

Age: 21 vs 29

We used Football Manager 2019 to compare the two players and see who has the best attributes to play as a 'box-to-box midfielder', according to the game, which is a broad role, but will give us an overview of their best attributes.

(Football Manager 2019)
(Football Manager 2019)

Longstaff's attributes are on the left, with Herrera's on the right.

Here's how they compare.

Technical attributes

Dribbling: 12/9

Finishing: 13/10

First Touch: 13/15

Long Shots: 15/9

Passing: 14/15

Tackling: 13/14

Technique: 13/15

Sean Longstaff: 93

Ander Herrera: 87

According to Football Manager 2019, Longstaff has the better technical attributes for the box-to-box midfielder role, with the English midfielder having better dribbling, finishing and long shots than the Spaniard. Although, Herrera's passing, technique, tackling and first touch are slightly better.

Mental attributes

Aggression: 11/17

Anticipation: 11/18

Composure: 10/13

Decisions: 12/13

Off the Ball Movement: 14/12

Positioning: 11/14

Teamwork: 15/16

Work rate: 15/18

Sean Longstaff: 99

Ander Herrera: 121

Ander Herrera became a Manchester United leader (2019 Manchester United FC)

Mentally, Herrera's is significantly more developed, this is due to the age and experience difference between the two players, with Longstaff having only a season of senior football under his belt. When you consider how little football Longstaff has played compared to Herrera, he doesn't do too badly in comparison.

Physical attributes

Acceleration: 12/14

Balance: 13/12

Pace: 13/13

Stamina: 15/18

Strength: 9/11

Sean Longstaff: 62

Ander Herrera: 68

Ander Herrera formerly of United (Molly Darlington - AMA/Getty Images)

Physically, Herrera edges it, having better acceleration, stamina and strength than Longstaff, but the 21-year-old has time to develop these attributes.

Overall

Sean Longstaff: 254

Ander Herrera:  276

Overall, as you would expect, Herrera is the more complete midfield player of the two, but Longstaff is a lot closer than you would have thought, considering the fact that the Magpies midfielder is seven years younger.

The Toon midfielder is also a different profile of player to the 29-year-old, with Longstaff much more adept at finishing attacking moves, shooting from distance and dribbling, whereas Herrera is more defensive-minded.

Sean Longstaff of Newcastle United (2019 Ben Early)

If Longstaff continues to develop, either at Old Trafford, St. James Park or elsewhere, he could become a top quality midfield player, according to Football Manager 2019.

        
Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.