Go to the chapter you're reading now
Ending
Lots of readers have been wanting to discuss the book’s ending, and to reflect about the whole novel – with some sharing selfies of their facial verdict. Some of their tweets:
#gdnwatchmanend not sure What to make of the love at the end. Fascinating book though. Blows the questions in mockingbird right open
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
@samjordison I think it was about acceptance even if people’s views are different from your own. I think. All a bit muddled at the end…
— Rob Chilver (@robchilver) July 16, 2015
Yes, I think I agree. (Also on board with the muddle.) #gdnwatchmanend https://t.co/dsU6OVQUT6
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 16, 2015
@samjordison #gdnwatchmanend I think she realized she doesn't have to agree with him to love him. Loved reading your tweets btw!
— Tom Laiso (@skinsiu13) July 19, 2015
#GdnWatchmanEnd Kill your idols! Only by looking at father through grown-up eyes can a girl see herself more clearly. pic.twitter.com/Q2jpBk2Rc1
— Leslie Everitt (@VibrantLibrary) July 17, 2015
Loved the abrupt ending. Left many thoughts simmering in my mind.. #GoSetAWatchman #GdnWatchmanEnd
— Josephine Elia (@JosephineElia) July 17, 2015
felt like a detective, hunting for Mockingbird echoes #GdnWatchmanEnd
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
'I see myself' 'I see two people' 'You mean the tomboy and the woman?' (p.201) #GoSetAWatchman #GdnWatchmanEnd
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
not sure I believe the 'missing manuscript' narrative surrounding publication but have enjoyed the fever and the fervour #GdnWatchmanEnd
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
#GdnWatchmanEnd Loved the book except the last chapter. Felt implication about staying with Hank weakened it.
— Catherine King (@Cking613) July 23, 2015
Some readers’ feedback after finishing the book was extremely positive:
#GdnWatchmanEnd. Nice, the perfect complement to Mockingbird... not so much about race but getting past the idealism of youth.
— Richard Hixson (@rhixs) July 15, 2015
#GdnWatchmanEnd Best book I've ever read. Most uncomfortable book I've ever read. Atticus is a flawed man but is an amazing father.
— furrawn (@_furrawn_) July 16, 2015
Updated
Chapter 18
Quite the bombshell from Uncle Finch in #gdnwatchman18 ... Harper Lee has kept some tricks up her sleeve.
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
'I've killed you, Scout. I had to.' Harper Lee talking? #GdnWatchman18
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
'you had to kill yourself, or he had to kill you to get you functioning as a separate entity' - psychoanalytic chat in #GdnWatchman18
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
Updated
Chapter 17
#gdnwatchman17 no atticus! No! You used to be so cool. What happened? pic.twitter.com/NRAA5j7rgK
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
'I remember that rape case you defended' - we all do, Scout, we all do #GdnWatchman17
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
Updated
Chapter 16
#gdnwatchman16 a big argument. Scout still mad as hell. Not going to take it any more...
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
Updated
Chapter 15
#gdnwatchman15 odd extended slapstick around false breasts. Seems quite old fashioned
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
'she applied Tangee Orange to her lips, combed her hair, and stuck down her cowlick with some of Jem's Vitalis' #GdnWatchman15
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
'Henry's blue serge Sunday pants were creased to painful sharpness' #GdnWatchman15
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
Echoes of Mockingbird in Hank's boxed camellias #GdnWatchman15
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
Updated
Chapter 14
Southern heritage rears its head in #gdnwatchman14 ... The parody of it here reads like some of the nonsense you still hear now
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
Jean Louise hopes she'll look 'comparatively speaking' as good as her uncle's ancient cat when she's old - loving this book! #Gdnwatchman14
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
'smart enough to want to know what the hell has happened to my father' #GdnWatchman14
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 17, 2015
#GoSetAWatchman suddenly gains pace after first 100 pages and steadily heads toward climax after part 5. Love Dr Finch!
— Jochen Klingler (@JochenKlingler) July 18, 2015
Updated
Chapter 13
#gdnwatchman13 some of the race talk is really upsetting. Harper Lee is angry!
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
Trademark Lee humour - 'their makeup would have put an Egyptian draftsman to shame' #GdnWatchman13
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
Jean Louise on taking Hester's head apart (p175) reminds me of Atticus's Mockingbird dictum about walking in someone's skin #GdnWatchman13
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
'what has happened in this family is not what you think. [...] everything I learned about human decency I learned here' #GdnWatchman13
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
'you may reach out and embrace all of Manhattan in sweet aloneness, or you can go to hell if you want to' #NewYork #GdnWatchman13
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
Updated
Chapter 12
#gdnwatchman12 it's becoming ever more clear that Atticus is a very different man to the one he used to be. He has changed. For the worse
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
#gdnwatchman12 that was some bleak moment with Calpurnia. Off...
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
Lee's strengths on display in dialogue ('clabber' 144, 'you look like pale blue sin' 145) and detail (Healy's blood on 155) #GdnWatchman12
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
Atticus's racism shown as part of his overall decrepitude - he spills the milk and has to use customised cutlery #GdnWatchman12
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
'You who called me Scout are dead and in your grave' #GdnWatchman12 #GoSetAWatchman
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
Scout's radar in the way Jean Louise picks up on Zeebo's wife's comment 'I don't want no man who don't enjoy his wife' #GdnWatchman12
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
chapter 12 my favourite so far - complexity and beauty of the writing, simple, exact detail no shying away from harsh issues #GdnWatchman12
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
Wish Lee had kept Jem alive - lovely character and useful as foil/sounding board, less need for Jean Louise's soliloquising #GdnWatchman12
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 16, 2015
Updated
Chapter 11
@samjordison: #gdnwatchman11 periods, kissing stories of incest. A long way from the innocence of Scout
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
'As Calpurnia's husky voice drove out her year's accumulation of terror, Jean Louise felt life return...' #GdnWatchman11
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
...'She heard sausages hissing in the kitchen, saw her brother's collection of sports magazines on the livingroom table...' #GdnWatchman11
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
...'smelled the bittersweet odor of Calpurnia's hairdressing' #GdnWatchman11
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
'When you love somebody like that, Miss Scout, why that's what you want to do' #GdnWatchman11
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
Cal is a literary hero. I understand the controversy but how do you not love seeing Scout grow up? #GdnWatchman11
— Samantha Laiso (@mrslaiso) July 17, 2015
Updated
Chapter 10
#gdnwatchman10 Jean Louise vomits up her disgust. Quite a literal moment...
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 15, 2015
#gdnwatchman10 … But that ref to watching from the balcony is poignant, given its significance in To Kill A Mockingbird
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 15, 2015
#gdnwatchman10 … Prompts the interesting question of whether Harper Lee had this scene in mind when she wrote the balcony scene in TKAMB?
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 15, 2015
@samjordison of course she did - watchman is the original draft of mockingbird
— Suw (@Suw) July 15, 2015
Well, there’s in mind and in mind. She’d taken the characters in v different directions (#gdnwatchman10) https://t.co/80d2wVKZ6h
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 15, 2015
A sentence like 'Dill had long since gone from her' gains its power purely from reader familiarity with Mockingbird... #GdnWatchman10
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
...nothing in Watchman to earn such a sentence, surely? #GdnWatchman10
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
Updated
Chapter nine
#gdnwatchman9 more exposition!
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
'She must now go into a world of femininity, a world she despised' #GdnWatchman9
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
Updated
Chapter eight
#gdnwatchman8 - Ouch. Bad Atticus! You've let yourself down, you've let Scout down... ugh...
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
Mockingbird in micro - and a reverse mirror image of the Atticus we know and love from that book #GdnWatchman8
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
#gdnwatchman8 Tom Robinson was found guilty in TKAMB, which contradicts the acquittal mentioned in this chapter. Did I miss something?
— feilding cage (@fcage) July 19, 2015
@fcage Nope, this is the kind of stuff that a brilliant editor encouraged Lee to change for TKAM.
— Jeffrey Zuckerman (@J_Zuckerman) July 19, 2015
#Gdnwatchman8 Scout's racist boyfriend quotes Emmett Till: "Bye Baby" 6 chapters after Scout references the Till Case. Fascinating.
— Daniel Greenstone (@Top5lists) July 14, 2015
Updated
Chapter seven
This chapter offers insights on the title’s origins – although it isn’t the clearest of explanations.
#gdnwatchman7 notable for explaining the theology behind the title. Kind of... pic.twitter.com/3LAviBc2MH
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
Jean Louise made a sincere effort to listen to what Mr. Stone’s watchman saw, but in spite of her efforts to quell it, she felt amusement turning into indignant displeasure and she stared straight at Herbert Jemson throughout the service.
Updated
Chapter six
#gdnwatchman6 Still getting background information. And some bawdy laughs about skinny-dipping...
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
#GdnWatchman6 sleeping with your eyes open during a lecture is an enviable skill, but isn't that what the back row is for? #GoSetAWatchman
— Inbar Kaminsky (@InbarKaminsky) July 15, 2015
Updated
Chapter five
This chapter has the first flashback to Scout’s childhood:
#gdnwatchman5 Heady childhood nostalgia in this one. Things really lift off when Dill, Jem and Scout are on the page.
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
Reunited with Dill, Scout, and Jem is like coming home to old friends. #GdnWatchman5
— Samantha Laiso (@mrslaiso) July 16, 2015
#gdnwatchman5 These scenes from childhood are definitely among the book’s strongest. Fascinating to see where TKAMB came from.
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 16, 2015
Not all readers agree:
#gdnwatchman5 I'm bored with the detailed stories from their childhood. also not sure how to interpret them given order of writing/narrative
— feilding cage (@fcage) July 19, 2015
In this chapter, while she’s riding the car, swimming in the river and admiring the night sky with her boyfriend Hank, Scout reflects beautifully about the experience of living away from home, in a big city, and the emotions of going back to visit:
When you live in New York, you often have the feeling that New York’s not the world. I mean this: every time I come home, I feel like I’m coming back to the world, and when I leave Maycomb it’s like leaving the world. It’s silly. I can’t explain it, and what makes it sillier is that I’d go stark raving living in Maycomb.
It would indeed be hard for her:
'What do ladies say to each other when they go visiting? I'd have to wear a hat. I'd drop the babies and kill 'em' #GdnWatchman5
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
Updated
Chapter four
#GdnWatchman4 interesting line about women wanting fathers rather than husbands. Could be significant later?
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 14, 2015
#GdnWatchman4 huh. pic.twitter.com/8PvVmqOqKD
— Marta Bausells (@martabausells) July 14, 2015
'She rubbed an imaginary crew cut' - Jean Louise still Scout at heart #GdnWatchman4
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
#GdnWatchman4 coffee drinking habits become emblematic of intimate knowledge. Sometimes coffee is just coffee☕️ #GoSetAWatchman #GdnWatchman
— Inbar Kaminsky (@InbarKaminsky) July 14, 2015
Updated
Chapter three
Scout lives! And Aunt Alexandra is ... well, she’s still Aunt Alexandra.
#Gdnwatchman3 "aunty why don't you go pee in your hat?" Scout lives!
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 13, 2015
But @samjordison 'she can never be vulgar as I am about to be' Scout's charm was that she rarely thunk before she spoke #GdnWatchman3
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
#gdnwatchman3 One thing not many people have picked up on so far is the meaning of “trash” in this and TKAMB. Class is a big issue as well.
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 16, 2015
#GdnWatchman3 "Alexandra was one of those people who had gone through life at no cost to themselves"
— Marta Bausells (@martabausells) July 14, 2015
'Alexandra Finch Hancock was imposing from any angle' etc - loved this description first time around #ToKillaMockingbird #GdnWatchman3
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
Sadly, we learn that Jem is not the only character that is gone...
#GdnWatchman3 Shit, Calpurnia is gone too.
— Marta Bausells (@martabausells) July 14, 2015
Although in her case, she simply is said to have “run off the place and not come back when she learned of Jem’s death.”
#gdnwatchman3 One thing not many people have picked up on so far is the meaning of “trash” in this and TKAMB. Class is a big issue as well.
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 16, 2015
Updated
Chapter two
A quieter one. Atticus appears, slightly grumpier than we know him – but stoical as ever – and there’s the first mention of “that Mississipi business” and the civil rights organisation NAACP. Great Scout:
“I don’t know anything about that bunch except that some misguided clerk sent me some NAACP Christmas seals last year, so I stuck ’em on all the cards I sent home.”
#gdnwatchman2 second chapter is quieter. A few jokes. Race problems come in at the end... Plot thickening.
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 13, 2015
#GdnWatchman2 @samjordison somehow feels like the calm before the storm. Interesting to see "that Mississippi business" mentioned. Hooked!
— Marta Bausells (@martabausells) July 14, 2015
A second cousin makes an entrance too:
#GdnWatchman2 #CousinEdgar is a whole other story 🙅 pic.twitter.com/3kEQ3rE1ms
— Marta Bausells (@martabausells) July 14, 2015
And we saw some great Scout-y scenes.
'Atticus raised his eyebrows in warning. He watched his daughter's daemon rise' #goScout #GdnWatchman2
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
What was the moment you enjoyed the most in this chapter?
Updated
Chapter one
Alright, let’s get stuck in! If by any chance you haven’t yet, you can read (or re-read) the opening chapter in our glorious interactive, where you can also listen to Reese Witherspoon’s narration:
Of course, one particular sentence has sparked most of the conversation:
Just about that time, Jean Louise’s brother dropped dead in his tracks one day, and after the nightmare of that was over, Atticus, who had always thought of leaving his practice to his son, looked around for another young man.
And just like that, we’re left heartbroken and with so many questions. We look forward to reading more about Jem in coming chapters.
I NEED TO TALK ABOUT JEM. http://t.co/K9LHzr8EFg #GoSetAWatchman
— Laura Seay (@texasinafrica) July 10, 2015
'Just about that time, Jean Louise's brother dropped dead' - Noooo! #GdnWatchman1
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
#GdnWatchman1 'Just about that time, Jean Louise's brother dropped dead in his tracks one day'. Could've broken that a little more gently!
— Laura Myatt (@mrslauramyatt) July 16, 2015
For other readers, the details surrounding the book’s publication made them wonder about plot points like this one:
#GdnWatchman1 Sequence of Watchman/Mockingbird makes me skeptical of details I normally would have wondered about.(Jem's death for example)
— feilding cage (@fcage) July 17, 2015
But just in general, what a beginning:
#gdnwatchman1 Atticus is old! Jem is dead! Scout has a boyfriend?! Already I feel less innocent
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 13, 2015
First chapter is good! #Gdnwatchman1 Enjoyed reading it again. Hope the rest equally fun. How long does it take to read a 270 page book?
— Sam Jordison (@samjordison) July 13, 2015
There are so many delightful details on this opening chapter – like the introduction of amusing Cousin Joshua, who looked like a “ratty Algernon Swinburne”:
#Gdnwatchman1 #CousinJoshua shows a lot of promise. In case you were wondering what Algernon Swinburne looked like: pic.twitter.com/foBA3BxYBI
— Marta Bausells (@martabausells) July 14, 2015
#Gdnwatchman1 #CousinJoshuaFanClub pic.twitter.com/hqUnFodIvv
— Marta Bausells (@martabausells) July 14, 2015
Some heavy signalling in the paragraph below: Scout, now a New York sophisticate (she sleeps in just pyjama tops!), with romantic memories of poor black settlements back home ...
"She grinned when she saw her first TV antenna atop an unpainted Negro house; as they multiplied, her joy rose." Hmmm. #gdnwatchman1
— Claire Armitstead (@carmitstead) July 14, 2015
'When she dressed, she put on her Maycomb clothes: gray slacks, a black sleeveless blouse, white socks, and loafers.' #GdnWatchman1
— hannah vincent (@hannahvincent22) July 15, 2015
Updated
The rules – and the fun
Rules
- Rule number 1: you do not talk ab... Just kidding.
- The hashtags to take part: let’s just repeat the hashtag rules. Add the number of the chapter to the hashtag #GdnWatchman. For example, to tweet about chapter 10, use the hashtag #GdnWatchman10.
- When you reach the end: Use the hashtag #GdnWatchmanEnd and tweet your general impression. A short video review with the tweet will really reach our hearts.
Points
Everyone reads at their own rhythm and we wouldn’t want to encourage competitiveness in what is such a personal experience. But we’re going to anyway.
- Sending at least a (valuable) tweet for each and every one of the 19 chapters will get you: 50 points
- A selfie that reflects your state of mind or opinion at the end of a chapter: 10 points
- A Vine that does the same: 20 points
- A short video with a quick review at the end of the book: 30 points
- The first reader who reaches the end after Sam (convincingly) will get: an extra 20 points
Prizes
We will be judging as best we can, unscientifically – we’re exhausted and also reading at high speed. The reader with most points at the end will get one of the following:
- The world-renowned legendary prize of the Books desk: a Guardian mug
- A selfie of the books team trying to replicate your selfie face or Vine
- Our unconditional admiration in the shape of a books-themed card signed by our Books team – full of our hopefully witty comments.
Updated
How it will work
- Hashtag rules: add the number of the chapter to the hashtag #GdnWatchman. For example, to tweet about chapter 10, use the hashtag #GdnWatchman10. When you finish the book, use the hashtag #GdnWatchmanEnd and tweet your general impression.
- We will be updating this page as more tweets come in. Jump to whichever chapter you’re reading now: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | end
- Comments underneath this piece: we’d like to encourage a similar policy – state the chapter you’re about to comment on at the top of your comment. However, you’re looking at the thread at your own risk!
- Points and prizes: we’ve added a bit of fun to this, and the more you engage – with pictures, Vines, videos, and whatever you have for us! – the higher of a score you will get. What are the prizes? Read on ...
Updated
What this is
It has now become usual for TV shows, political debates, movies and even podcasts, to be discussed on social media – especially Twitter – as they are broadcast or streamed. We have been wanting to do the same with books with you, our readers – and what better chance than Go Set a Watchman to kick this off? Except, of course, everyone reads at their own pace – which is why we have created a set of hashtags, each for a specific chapter, to strictly avoid our number one rule: no spoilers.
This discussion will happen on Twitter, hosted by our account @guardianbooks, and it will be followed here with added commentary over the next couple of weeks.
We know some of you have been battling the temptation of reading the first chapter, which we offered here on our site on Friday. Well, now you can finally plunge into the read of the whole book – as soon as you’ve got a hold of your copy, join us in discussing it!
Updated