Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Manchester Evening News
Manchester Evening News
Sport
George Smith

Gary Neville explains why Manchester United should not appeal Casemiro's red card

Former Manchester United captain Gary Neville believes the club would be taking "too big a risk" if they attempt to have Casemiro's red card from Saturday's 2-1 win over Crystal Palace overturned.

The Brazilian, who has been outstanding since joining the Reds from Real Madrid last summer, was dismissed with 70 minutes on the clock after a coming together with Palace midfielder Will Hughes. The 30-year-old appeared to grab the former Derby County ace by the neck in the middle of a melee that broke out following Jeffrey Schlupp's rough challenge on Antony.

VAR took a close look at the incident and ordered on-field referee Andre Marriner to go over to the pitchside monitor and review it. The angle Marriner was shown offered strong evidence that Casemiro had got his hands wrapped around Hughes' neck.

READ MORE: United are about show if they have learned valuable Casemiro lesson

However, an alternative angle, which was released later, showed Casemiro had got hold of Hughes' shirt collar. He was dismissed for violent conduct, meaning he will miss each of United's next three Premier League fixtures.

Manager Erik ten Hag, speaking after the game, confirmed that United will "think about" appealing the decision. However, if unsuccessful in their efforts, Casemiro's ban could be stretched to four matches, ruling him out of the Carabao Cup final against Newcastle United at Wembley on February 26.

With that in mind, Neville does not believe United should risk the possibility of having the midfielder's ban extended, insisting they should be able to cope in back-to-back clashes with Leeds United and a home tussle against Leicester City without him.

Neville, speaking on his Sky Sports podcast, said: "He'll never get off. It's too big of a risk.

"They could risk another game and they could increase it so they won't appeal it. I think they'll feel they can get through the three games.

"It'll be difficult for Ten Hag because he's been the most important player for Manchester United, he's held the ball well in midfield and Eriksen is obviously out as well."

Casemiro was sent-off against Crystal Palace on Saturday. (Michael Regan/Getty Images.)

Reviewing the incident that led to Casemiro being sent-off, Neville added: "I thought it was harsh but I thought Erik ten Hag summed it up perfectly when he said he 'took a risk'. If you put your hands one someone's throat, even if it's just one of them you can kind of protect yourself, but I think once you put two you've got an issue. And he's basically taken a risk.

"He's fantastic at winning the ball back and he's always on the front foot, but he takes chances. (Casemiro is the sort of player that) makes a thousand fouls and never gets booked. Fabinho and Rodri are the same. Fernandinho. They're brilliant at it.

'They're outstanding at making sure a foul is not a yellow card - but he's just been done a couple of times now. Even at the end of that scuffle, he ends up having a play with Will Hughes, but when you freeze it, it doesn't look great. It looks like he's strangling him."

Win a pair of tickets to the Premier League or Women's Super League match of your choosing! Enter by clicking here!

READ NEXT:

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.