Jamie Carragher and Gary Neville agreed on eight on their eleven as they picked their Team of the Season so far.
Manchester City and Liverpool have set the pace, with Chelsea not far behind but there have been outstanding individual performances up and down the league.
Mohamed Salah, Diogo Jota and Phil Foden were the front three for both pundits.
The Egyptian especially is enjoying a phenomenal season in front of goal for the Reds.
Declan Rice made both midfields whilst Carragher and Neville also named the same four defensive players.
Trent Alexander-Arnold and Joao Cancelo were the full-backs with Liverpool stalwart Virgil van Dijk and Chelsea's Antonio Rudiger, who could soon depart Stamford Bridge, at the heart of the back four.
Have Your Say! Which of Neville and Carragher's teams do you prefer? Tell us in the comments here.
After that though is where the disagreements started.
Neville opted for Alisson as his No 1 whilst Carragher went for Arsenal's Aaron Ramsdale in between the sticks.
The former United man went for a 3-4-3 formation and named Ruben Dias as his third centre-half.
City's midfield linchpin Rodri then completed a midfield pair.
Neville said on Sky Sports : "I think Rodri has been absolutely incredible this year at City. Underrated, under appreciated.
"Someone who does the job week in, week out and the improvement in him is massive.
"Rice alongside him, those two, with the three at the back and I just thought the two full-backs, it is unlucky on (Andy) Robertson, but I just thought Cancelo and Alexander-Arnold have lit up this league from full-back."
Carragher though was quick to take issue with, what he thought, was a glaring omission.
"How the hell have you not put Bernardo Silva in your team?" he questioned.
The former Liverpool man inevitably had put the Portuguese star as one of his midfield three.
City's No 20 has scored seven times in the league this season, as many as anyone in his team, as he continues to grow in influence.
Neville replied saying: "I just haven't put him in my team".
Crystal Palace's on loan star Conor Gallagher was picked alongside Bernardo and Rice in Carragher's XI.
Neville later added on his midfield selection: "I think Rodri and Declan Rice have been the two best central midfield players and I've played a different system, I wanted to get three centre-backs in."
Gary Neville's XI: Alisson, Dias, Van Dijk, Rudiger, Alexander-Arnold, Rodri, Rice, Cancelo, Salah, Jota, Foden
Jamie Carragher's XI: Ramsdale, Alexander-Arnold, Van Dijk, Rudiger, Cancelo, Gallagher, Rice, Bernardo, Salah, Jota, Foden
