Update: Britain’s FTSE 100 has hit a new six-month closing low.
The blue-chip index just closed 80 points lower at 7,067, a drop of 1.1%.
Recession fears dragged the market down, with mining companies, and financial stocks leading the sell-off.
Summary
Time for a quick recap
Financial markets remain volatile today, as fears of an economic downturn hit stock prices and drive bond prices to new record highs.
Shares fell sharply in parts of Asia, with Australia suffering its worst day of 2019.
In London, the FTSE 100 has tumbled to its lowest level since the end of February - down 80 points at pixel time, with mining companies and banks among the top fallers.
European markets also hit six-months lows, as concern grows that Germany could be sliding into recession (it shrank in the last quarter).
America’s bond yield curve inverted for the second day running, with 10-year Treasury bills trading at a lower yield than 2-year T-Bills. Some experts see as a clear warning sign of a recession, although others disagree.
Retail sales have beaten expectations in both the UK and the US, calming some fears of a slowdown.
After a nervy start, the Dow Jones industrial average is up 60 points -- having shed 800 points in an alarming selloff yesterday.
The US-China trade war has flared up again. Beijing spooked investors by announcing it would impose counter-measures in response to America’s plan to raise tariffs on $300bn of Chinese goods. But officials also spoke about meeting US half-way in search of a deal.
Donald Trump, though, has insisted that any breakthrough will be on Washington’s terms.
He’s also weighed in on the Hong Kong protests:
If President Xi would meet directly and personally with the protesters, there would be a happy and enlightened ending to the Hong Kong problem. I have no doubt! https://t.co/eFxMjgsG1K
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) August 15, 2019
Updated
Pound strengthens
Elsewhere in the markets, sterling has hit its highest level this week.
The pound has gained three-quarters of a cent, to $1.2122. Traders are citing efforts to prevent a no-deal Brexit, as MPs try to stop Boris Johnson crashing the UK out of the EU at the end of October.
On one hand, you have Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn trying to persuade Conservative rebels to vote against their own government in a no-confidence vote.
On the other, the opposition Liberal Democrats are resisting Corbyn’s advances, and proposing a unity government led by someone else.
The pound’s strength is helping to push the FTSE 100 down -- the index has recovered some of its early losses, but is still down 80 points at 7068, down 1%.
After its worst day of 2019, Wall Street has just opened cautiously.
The main stock indices are slightly lower, with traders keeping their powder dry while recession worries rage.
The Dow Jones industrial average has dipped by 28 points, or 0.1%, having slumped by 800 points on Wednesday (its fourth biggest points loss ever, although much less dramatic in percentage terms).
Technology stocks are also weakening a little, pushing the Nasdaq a little lower (like the Dow, it lost 3% yesterday).
Trump: Must have China deal on our terms
Newsflash: Donald Trump has now weighed in, saying that the US-China trade deal has do be done “on our terms”.
That’s pushing back against Beijing’s call for a compromise “half way”.
TRUMP SAYS U.S.-CHINA TRADE DEAL HAS TO BE A DEAL ON 'OUR TERMS' -SYNDICATED RADIO INTERVIEW -Reuters News
— Jeremy Taieb (@JeremyTaieb) August 15, 2019
Lori Calvasina, head of US equity strategy at RBC, thinks Trump is being too ambitious.
Given the clashes in Hong Kong, Beijing can’t afford to look weak over trade, she says on Bloomberg TV.
Less good news: US factory output declined by 0.4% in July, new data show.
That’s a little worse than expected, and follows a 0.6% gain in June.
It could be a sign that American manufacturers are struggling.
Mohamed A. El-Erian, chief economic adviser at insurance giant Allianz, has dismissed talk that America could be heading into recession as “silly”.
But he also warns that the stock markets will be more volatile in the months ahead, even though the strength of US consumer spending could insulate the US economy from problems overseas.
Here’s a clip from CNBC:
"People have to understand the distinction between the economy and all this silly talk about us going into a recession this year. We're not," says @elerianm
— Squawk Box (@SquawkCNBC) August 15, 2019
Here's his explanation: pic.twitter.com/dRo3zzY3nd
US retail sales stronger than expected, calming nerves
Just in: US retail sales were stronger than expected last month, calming fears of an imminent recession.
American shoppers spent 0.7% more in July than in June, beating expectations of a 0.3% rise.
As in the UK (see earlier post), internet shopping provided a big boost -- again, Amazon Prime Day is a likely reason.
The percent of total retail sales at non-store retailers (meaning mostly web-based stores) is beginning to rise at a much faster clip: pic.twitter.com/NbLq7bhLnO
— Michael McDonough (@M_McDonough) August 15, 2019
Today’s big data batch should quell the recessionistas for a day or two: better retail sales, Philly #Fed & productivity. Estimates of current quarter #GDP should go up a few tenths. However, these figures in general aren’t forward-looking so #Powell & Co should look past this
— Joseph A. LaVorgna (@Lavorgnanomics) August 15, 2019
It’s hard to keep track of all the maneuvers in the US trade war.
But helpfully, the Peterson Institute’s Chad Brown has explained America’s latest move - to impose higher tariffs on clothing, shoes and technology products made in China:
1 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
Trump just mapped out his latest plan to impose tariffs on roughly $300 billion of Chinese imports over this fall.
My latest looks in depth at the tariff and trade datahttps://t.co/Oo8nK6Z3Ga
2 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
On September 1, Trump will hit China with a 10% tariff on a new set of $112 billion of imports.
These tariffs will target a lot of clothing and shoes. These sectors are mostly untouched by Trump's tariffs to date... pic.twitter.com/07pWKVllts
3 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
On December 15, Trump will hit China with 10% tariffs on ANOTHER new set of $160 billion of imports.
These tariffs will hit a lot of toys and consumer electronics - iPhones, Fitbits, video game consoles. These sectors have also been mostly untouched by Trump's tariffs. pic.twitter.com/H65y892naS
4 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
Note the interesting TIMING, by the two product lists:
(1) The import surge for the December holidays shopping is usually *IN OCTOBER* each year.
By choosing Dec 15 for the first tariffs on smartphones, toys and video games, Trump may avoid THAT consumer backlash... pic.twitter.com/Pc1809ebwf
5 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
Note the interesting TIMING, by the two product lists (cont):
(2) A smaller import surge for back-to-school shopping is IN AUGUST each year.
Sept 1 for tariffs on clothes & shoes - remember the June 29, G20 decision to delay tariffs? - avoids THAT consumer backlash... pic.twitter.com/l2v8qGsns4
6 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
Interestingly, timing the tariff rollout to avoid the consumer backlash is an implicit recognition that AMERICAN CONSUMERS are likely to bear the tariff burden - through higher paid prices
(it may not be borne by Chinese firms, through lower received prices, after all) pic.twitter.com/mqWHwW0TAD
7 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
...overall, Trump has sharply INCREASED US tariffs on China:
• Jan 1, 2018: 3.1%
• Sept 23, 2018: 12.4%
• May 10, 2019: 18.3%
• Sept 1, 2019: 20.0%
• Dec 15, 2019: 21.4% pic.twitter.com/YMwRvvWFR5
8 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
Even more important for these next two rounds of tariffs is the MASSIVE increase in scope of PRODUCT COVERAGE.
Share of US imports from China covered by special tariffs:
• Jan 1, 2018: 8.1%
• Sept 23, 2018: 50.6%
• Sept 1, 2019: 68.5%
• Dec 15, 2019: 96.8% pic.twitter.com/1qxJXdfqbZ
9 of 9/
— Chad P. Bown (@ChadBown) August 14, 2019
The REALLY bad news?
President Trump may be settling in. There are new plans to impose lots more tariffs, and no plans to roll back any of them.
ENDS/https://t.co/Oo8nK6Z3Ga
Wall Street isn’t even open yet, but the futures market has been pretty darn lively - hit by recession worries and trade war tensions.
S&P Futures & the S&P, Intraday: (volatile morning so far) pic.twitter.com/yvLJvM4tQu
— Michael McDonough (@M_McDonough) August 15, 2019
Are investors living on a prayer today? Looks like China comments about hoping US will "meet halfway" on trade talks are lifting futures. pic.twitter.com/w3pklCMSkR
— Paul R. La Monica (@LaMonicaBuzz) August 15, 2019
China: Hope to meet US half-way
Newsflash: China has now made some more conciliatory comments about the trade war with the US.
The Ministry of Finance has said that it hopes to meet America “half-way” to resolve the dispute, and that presidents Xi and Trump are in touch through phone calls and letters, as well as their recent meeting at the last G7 summit.
Here’s the Q&A with China’s MOFCOM that moved futures
— Carl Quintanilla (@carlquintanilla) August 15, 2019
(via @onlyyoontv) pic.twitter.com/E9CpWiDtsU
This is helping the markets to recover some ground - European stock markets are now a little higher again, and Wall Street is tipped to recover some ground too. What a day!
How might China retaliate against the US’s latest tariffs on $300bn of its exports?
It can’t simply respond in kind. China only bought $120bn of goods from America in 2018, and has already imposed tariffs on them, in response to earlier US sanctions.
Beijing could raise its existing tariffs, I suppose but that would badly hurt Chinese consumers and companies (who would pay the tariff).
Instead, policymakers could use non-tariff measures. It could allow the yuan to fall in value, or cut off purchases from America altogether in favour of other countries (Brazilian soybeans, anyone?).
The nuclear option, as Eleanor Creagh of Saxo Bank points out, would be to stop buying US government debt. That would shake the markets, as China has been such a huge buyer of US Treasuries.
China already stated potential for countermeasures 2 weeks ago ... as below 🇨🇳 running out of imports to tariff...non tariff retaliation would be next escalation - RE restrictions, Yuan deval, license restrictions, diverting demand from US goods + nuclear option UST #TradeWar https://t.co/M9zGlsMvOl
— Eleanor Creagh (@Eleanor_Creagh) August 15, 2019
Ironically, such a move might drive down the prices on US debt, pushing up yields and ending the yield curve inversion.....
Oil is continuing to slide today, hit by fears of a global downturn.
Brent crude has dropped by 2.5% to just over $58 per barrel.
It was already a rough day in the markets, even before China ratcheted up the trade war tensions:
Hold onto your hats, folks. The Dow Jones industrial average is now tipped to lose more than 200 points when trading begins, a drop of 0.8%.
That’s on top of yesterday’s 800-point slide.
August has been a torrid month for the markets, and we’re only halfway through it!
Britain’s FTSE 100, for example, has fallen by over 7% in the last two weeks - from 7,586 points to just 7028 right now (down another 120 points today!).
The Footsie is still up 5% this year, so it’s not disastrous. Plus, August is notoriously volatile (liquidity is lower as investors take their holidays).
Fund manager Brent Carlile thinks China’s threat is a response to Donald Trump’s decision to delay tariffs on Chinese-made consumer goods until December.
That concession is meant to protect US consumers from pre-Christmas price hikes - but could also look like weakness from the White House.
Markets are paying attention to comments this morning from China's Finance Ministry saying will have to take countermeasures to #US moves which violated Osaka #G20.
— Brent Carlile (@BrentCarlileFX) August 15, 2019
Why now? #Trump blinked, emboldening #China. US folded w/ pocket Kings. China had offsuit 7-9. Big error lost face
Crumbs. Shares in Europe’s banking sector are down 1.2%, hitting their lowest level since 2012 - when the eurozone debt crisis was raging.
Mining companies are among the top fallers in London, dragging the market deeper into the red.
The FTSE 100 is now down 92 points at 7056, its lowest level since the end of February.
Anglo American are down 5.7% and Glencore has lost 4.5%. Demand for coal, copper and iron ore will all decline if a trade war creates a global downturn.
Financial stocks are also suffering from recession fears, with Royal Bank of Scotland and Standard Life Aberdeen both losing 3.5%.
One for the chartists out there:
FTSE testing key multi-month support around 7060 pic.twitter.com/W9lseb1N8F
— Neil Wilson (@marketsneil) August 15, 2019
President Trump could retaliate to China’s threatened retaliation by imposing higher tariffs on all Chinese imports, suggests Jasper Lawler of London Capital Group.
Currently, the US is planning to levy a 10% tariff on the $300bn of Chinese goods that isn’t already being taxed. That kicks in next month, although some consumer goods will be spared until December.
China say "US Violates Xi-Tump Consensus With New 10% Tariff"
— Jasper Lawler (@jasperlawler) August 15, 2019
China smelling blood after US backed off with tariff delay, and perhaps warning shot about suggested meeting over Hong Kong protests
25% US tariffs on all China imports the likely the eventual Trump response
Ouch! The Stoxx 600 index of Europe’s top listed companies has hit its lowest level since February, down another 0.7% today.
China’s threatened retaliation is a slap in the face to Donald Trump.
Yesterday, the US president claimed that Beijing was keen to make a deal, and even suggested a personal meeting with Xi Jinping to help resolve the protests in Hong Kong.
Good things were stated on the call with China the other day. They are eating the Tariffs with the devaluation of their currency and “pouring” money into their system. The American consumer is fine with or without the September date, but much good will come from the short.....
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) August 14, 2019
..deferral to December. It actually helps China more than us, but will be reciprocated. Millions of jobs are being lost in China to other non-Tariffed countries. Thousands of companies are leaving. Of course China wants to make a deal. Let them work humanely with Hong Kong first!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) August 14, 2019
I know President Xi of China very well. He is a great leader who very much has the respect of his people. He is also a good man in a “tough business.” I have ZERO doubt that if President Xi wants to quickly and humanely solve the Hong Kong problem, he can do it. Personal meeting?
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) August 14, 2019
I think we can expect a sharp response once @realDonaldTrump wakes up.....
Neil Wilson of Markets.com says the threat of a deepening US-China trade war has spooked investors, wiping out the early recovery in Europe.
This was always a very precarious bounce and it has died a quick death. Like a 1990s England Test top order it couldn’t even make it to lunch. Let’s see where we’re at by stumps.
European indices rolled over into the red to hit day lows as a series of news flashes indicated further worries about trade, with China saying the US has violated past agreements with the 10% tariffs and that Beijing will have to take countermeasures.
Any retaliation from Beijing could encourage America to hit back hard, Wilson adds:
This does not bode well and may encourage Trump to react – there is a chance he could bring forward all the tariffs to September 1st.
Countermeasures suggests China is not interested in the delay to tariffs – and may have sniffed a weakness in the US position and is keen to exploit it. Retaliation by China means escalation in tensions, and diminishes the chances of a positive outcome in the near term.
Risks are still to the downside. As ever, though, only a tweet away.
Updated
FTSE 100 hits five-month low as trade fears return
European stock markets are sliding sharply, following Beijing’s threat to impose new trade sanctions on the US.
In London, the FTSE 100 has tumbled by 1%, losing 69 points to 7078 points - on top of the 103 points lost yesterday. That’s its lowest point since March.
The German DAX has hit a new five-month low too, and there are losses in France and Spain too.
The prospect of Beijing retaliating to America’s latest tariffs is also dampening the mood in New York. Wall Street had been expected to rally after yesterday’s slump - but that putative recovery is fizzling out.
Here's how U.S. equity futures reacted to China saying the U.S. is violating the Xi-Trump consensus https://t.co/iTLgi5ONTG pic.twitter.com/4aSoQtjJ3p
— Bloomberg (@business) August 15, 2019
Here’s Reuters’ take on Beijing’s pledge to retaliate in the ongoing trade war with America.
China has to take necessary counter-measures to the latest U.S. tariffs on $300 billion of Chinese goods, the finance ministry said on Thursday.
The ministry also said the U.S. tariffs violate a consensus reached by leaders of two countries and get off the right track of resolving disputes via negotiation.
The United States said early this month it would slap duties on $300 billion of Chinese goods from Sept. 1, which would effectively cover all of China’s exports to the United States.
But President Donald Trump backed off part of the plan on Tuesday, delaying duties on some of the items on the list such as cellphones, laptops and other consumer goods, in the hopes of blunting their impact on U.S. holiday sales. Tariffs will still apply to those products from mid-December.
China accuses US of violating trade consensus
NEWSFLASH: China has launched a fresh attack on America over the trade war, giving investors another reason to panic.
The Chinese finance ministry has accused the US of violating the consensus drawn up between Donald Trump and Xi Jinping.
Specifically, Beijing is unhappy that America announced a new 10% tariff on $300bn of China’s exports this month. This move undermines efforts to resolve the trade dispute, it says.
In a worrying development, China says it will have to proceed with “countermeasures”, suggesting it will further escalate the trade war.
This is a blow - only on Tuesday, Trump backtracked and decided to delay some of the new tariffs until December, to avoid driving up the price of computer game consoles and mobile phones.
*CHINA SAYS WILL HAVE TO TAKE COUNTERMEASURES ON U.S. MOVES
— Joshua Mahony (@JMahony_IG) August 15, 2019
*CHINA: U.S. ACTION VIOLATES CONSENSUS REACHED IN OSAKA MEETING
All eyes on USDCNH here... pic.twitter.com/GvzGcqkz48
Updated
Deutsche Bank analyst Jim Reid is so excited about the inversion of the US yield curve that he’s broken off from his holiday to explain why (in his view) it’s a very serious warning sign.
He points out that every US recession since the 1950s has followed an inverted yield curve (where two-year US bonds are trading at higher rates than 10-year bonds).
That’s because such an usual situation shows that ‘animal spirits’ (or investor confidence) is waning. Central bankers have, in the past, slashed interest rates to support growth and delay a recession, but it doesn’t always work.
Reid explains:
Every inversion since 1956 has seen a recession follow. Although the median length of time to a recession is 17 months, credit spreads have pretty much exclusively widened from the point of inversion onwards.
Of those 2 of the 9 recessions since the 1950s took more than 2 years to materialise after the first inversion though. The first in the mid-1960s (took nearly 4 years) was due to a Fed policy error where the Fed didn’t raise rates as expected (they actually cut) with inflation rising. The curve re-steepened and only inverted again as the Fed reversed course and hiked a few quarters later. The recession soon followed the subsequent inversion. The second, following the May 1998 inversion, took 34 months until a recession arose but the inversion was relatively brief and occurred just prior to the Russian/LTCM crisis where the Fed rapidly cut 75bps thus re-steepening the curve. The Fed then raised rates again from 1999 and the curve re-inverted in early 2000, around a year before the actual recession.
So, the conclusion is that the Fed has successfully acted before to delay the inversion turning into a recession but only on 2/9 occasions. Given that the market already prices in 65bps of cuts before year end it feels like they might need to out-pace that to make it 3 out of 10 where they’ve delayed the recession.
Updated
Online spending boosts UK retail sales
Just in: UK retail sales grew last month, as consumer shrugged off Brexit uncertainty and fears that Britain’s economy is weakening.
Retail sales rose by 0.2% in July, the Office for National Statistics says, better than the 0.2% decline which the City expected.
Non-store retailing (such as internet shopping), surged by 6.9% during the month, and was 12.7% higher than a year ago.
That may be due to Amazon’s Prime Day, its regular summer sale. This year, other retailers jumped on the bandwagon with their own price reductions, in a bid to win sales.
The ONS also found that Britain’s battered department stores grew their sales by 1.6%, after a six-month slump.
Department store sales increased for the first time this year with a month-on-month growth of 1.6% 🛍️
— Office for National Statistics (@ONS) August 15, 2019
This was following six consecutive months of decline https://t.co/IItccpaQ7i pic.twitter.com/1VsYb71Cex
Food sales fell year-on-year, though -- perhaps because 12 months ago Brits were gorging on barbecued burgers during the July heatwave.
This July’s food store sales are down by 0.5%, compared with the same month last year 🥫 🥕
— Office for National Statistics (@ONS) August 15, 2019
This could be in part due to 2018’s prolonged heatwave and special events like the FIFA World Cup ⚽ https://t.co/QFDmkBVf1z
European bank shares are down this morning, hit by anxiety that Germany could be sliding into recession (possibly followed by the US next year, if the yield curve is to be believed).
Ouch! Deutsche Bank shares drop below €6 as German 10y yields hit fresh low at -0.65%. pic.twitter.com/NVtrnlA4Ld
— Holger Zschaepitz (@Schuldensuehner) August 15, 2019
The Financial Times is also concerned by the surge in bond prices, saying:
A sharp rally in government bonds set fresh records on Thursday, with the yield on 30-year US government bonds falling below 2 per cent for the first time as investors sought safety amid growing fears over the global economy.
Traders have dumped riskier assets such as stocks and crude oil and moved into perceived “havens”, including bonds, sending their yields lower. On Wednesday a closely watched metric in the US government bond market turned negative, raising new recession concerns. That indicator, the yield curve, remained inverted in Thursday morning trading in London.
In a new sign of the flight into bonds, the 30-year US Treasury bond yield dropped 5 basis points to 1.9776%, its lowest level on records that go back to the 1970s and the first time it has fallen below 2% https://t.co/XKEiyLWjPw pic.twitter.com/VOtjhwil7P
— Financial Times (@FinancialTimes) August 15, 2019
Anxiety over the global economy sent Japan’s stock market to a six-month low today.
Our new friend, the US inverted yield curve, is being blamed (although it isn’t an infallible recession indicator) .
Norihiro Fujito, senior investment strategist at Mitsubishi UFJ Morgan Stanley Securities Co, says:
“The yield curve inversion prompted more investors to become concerned about the growth outlook,”
Nikkei falls to 6-month low on worries about global economy https://t.co/rud3Spghzk
— The Mainichi (Japan) (@themainichi) August 15, 2019
The UK government bond yield curve has also inverted for the second day running.
That’s because the rate of return on 10-year British gilts has dropped to 0.451%, below below the two-year bond which is yielding 0.455%.
As with America’s Treasuries, that shows investors are accepting a lower rate of return for longer-term lending than shorter-term lending.
Does that mean Britain is plunging into recession? Not necessarily. As economist Rupert Seggins points out, the UK yield curve has been an unreliable forecaster of economic trends. It did invert before three recessions, but also inverted on four other occasions when a recession wasn’t looming.
UK yield curve inversions (2 year Gilt rate higher than 10 year Gilt rate) have been pretty much 50/50 as a recession signal since 1970. Preceded 3, falsely signalled 4 and was late to the party once. Usually tied to some major domestic or global event though. pic.twitter.com/IIrFVY7Q4x
— Rupert Seggins (@Rupert_Seggins) August 15, 2019
2. Unsurprisingly, the UK yield curve often moves similarly to the US', but post crisis the two have tracked almost identically, barring a brief split following the Trump tax cuts. pic.twitter.com/6Vw6MA7J7Z
— Rupert Seggins (@Rupert_Seggins) August 15, 2019
Another important point is that Britain can borrow very cheaply right now -- perhaps for growth-boosting infrastructure programme?
Updated
UBS: Yield curve fears are overblown
Mark Haefele, chief investment officer at UBS Global Wealth Management, is urging us all not to get obsessed by the inversion of the US yield curve.
He points out that the tumble in longer-dated borrowing costs won’t have much economic impact on its own --it’s mainly an indicator of market sentiment. And, he argues, it doesn’t mean shares are about to crash.
Haefele explains:
The length of time the yield curve is inverted, and how much is inverted, matter. If Fed rate cuts successfully steepen the curve comfortably into positive territory, this brief curve inversion may be a premature recession signal.
Neither does a yield curve inversion indicate it is time to sell equities. Since 1975, after an inversion in the 2-year/10-year yield curve, the S&P 500 has continued to rally for nearly two years, and has risen by 40% on average until hitting a bull market peak.”
Energy and financial stocks are down in London this morning, a sign that traders are pessimistic about growth prospects
European markets open higher
And we’re off!
European markets are open, and inching higher in early trading.
The Stoxx 600 index, which contains a broad sweep of EU companies, has risen by 0.3% -- hardly a major recovery from Wednesday’s 1.8% tumble.
But in London. the FTSE 100 has dropped by 14 points to 7,132, back towards yesterday’s lows. Traders are nervous, following the losses in Asia overnight and the 3% plunge on Wall Street last night.
Alex Kuptsikevich, financial analyst at FX Pro, fears that investors could talk themselves into a crisis:
The most dangerous thing in this situation is that market fears of recession could end up fuelling further demand for safe havens, further intensifying the anxiety of stock markets.
Recession fears are also driving investors into German government debt - another safe haven (even though Germany may be sliding into recession).
The yield on German 30-year bonds has fallen below minus 0.2% for the first time ever.
That negative bond yield means asset managers are prepared to pay for the privilege of lending to Berlin, and not get their money back until 2049. Hardly a sign of optimism in the global economy.
[Reminder: Bond yields, a broad measure of the interest rate on a bond, fall when prices rise].
Updated
US yield curve inverts again
Morning all. City traders are bracing for another volatile session, after European stock markets hit their lowest levels in six months yesterday.
Alarmingly, the US yield curve is inverting again this morning, suggesting investors are worried that a recession is looming.
The yield (rate of return) on America’s 10-year Treasury bills has fallen below the yield for the 2-year bond for the second day running. Investors are now getting just 1.57% on the ten year, or 1.58% on the two-year bond.
That’s worrying -- longer-dated bonds ought to trade at a higher yield, to compensate for the extra risk of lending money for longer, and for the erosion of inflation.
US yield curve remains inverted for the second day....
— The Market Ear (@themarketear) August 15, 2019
As many experts have been racing to tell us, an inverted yield curve has been a reliable indicator that a recession is looming (although it can take more than a year to arrive).
Investors are certainly piling into US government debt, looking for a safe place to store their money.
That’s why the yield on American 30-year government bonds plunged below 2% for the first time ever. That’s an astonishingly low return on your investment - basically matching America’s inflation rate.
US government still letting people store their money with the world's most powerful institution for 30yrs, for free in real terms! Unbelievable deal. pic.twitter.com/ldMMLITeMH
— Mike Bird (@Birdyword) August 15, 2019
Updated
Summary
I’m about to hand over to my colleagues in London but here’s what you need to know on a day when concerns about recession in the US, Germany and China have plagued markets in Asia.
- Asian stocks have fallen across the board although losses were not as bad as in Wall Street on Wednesday.
- The Nikkei was down 1.2% in the afternoon while the Shanghai Composite is off 0.4% and the Hang Seng is flat.
- The biggest falls were in Australia where the ASX200 has lost almost 3%, wiping around A$60bn off the value of shares.
- Oil has continued to tumble. Brent crude has lost another 0.6% to $59.12 a barrel, after shedding 3% on Wednesday. US crude was down 0.4% at $55.03.
- Gold rose 0.3% to $1,521.00 per ounce and is close to its highest since April 2013.
- The yield on 30-year US treasuries has fallen below 2% for the first time ever in another sign that interest rates are set to remain lower for longer.
- Some analysts pushed back a bit on fears that the inverted US bond yield curve seen on Wednesday – and which sparked the 800-point fall in the Dow – is as crucial as some believe.
- Futures trade points to a positive start in London and New York later.
Thanks for joining me.
Updated
Australian market closes down 2.85%
Ouch. The ASX200 suffers its worst day since February 2018. It’s down 2.85% at 6,408. Around A$60bn removed from values.
Updated
The Australian market is now off 2.9%, or 187 points, at 6.408 points, but we’ll know the full damage when trading closes in a few minutes. It’s easily the worst performer in Asia Pacific where traders have reduced losses in Hong Kong and Shanghai. Japan is down 1.2%.
Meanwhile, European markets are opening in an hour.
Updated
UK/European opening calls
In Australia the ASX has slumped by 2.8%, a real bloodbath for a market that hit an all-time high just a couple of weeks ago.
The AMP economist Shane Oliver has been looking at today’s employment figures and he reckons the signs aren’t that great going forward.
...Aust jobs leading indicator continues to point to slowing jobs growth ahead and an upwards drift in unemployment... pic.twitter.com/NOpXHj5O8F
— Shane Oliver (@ShaneOliverAMP) August 15, 2019
..ratio of employment to working age pop in Aust is strong. Only issue is that participation has gone up too and there are more part time relative to full time jobs than desired... pic.twitter.com/WArorhVk3D
— Shane Oliver (@ShaneOliverAMP) August 15, 2019
..so unemployment + underemployment remains very high. As long as this remains the case its hard to see a pick up in wages growth. Even in the US where U6 is 7% wages growth is still only around 3%yoy pic.twitter.com/Q1rb2yWbzM
— Shane Oliver (@ShaneOliverAMP) August 15, 2019
And our own Greg Jericho has weighed in:
Not surprising that the seas adj underemployment rate bounced back up after last month's pretty bizarre fall.
— Greg Jericho (@GrogsGamut) August 15, 2019
But the trend rate is now looking rather less good and makes the task of getting it to a rate that will see wage growth improve that much harder pic.twitter.com/qVsWYBZDNH
Updated
No blog is complete without a word from Holger.
Stocks spooked as bond mkts scream recession. Asia equities follow Wall St slide, but off lows as 800point drop in Dow seems overdone & US Futures bounce. Bonds push higher w/US 10y yields at 1.55%, US Inversion deepens w/US2s10s spread at -0.3bps. Oil extends drop. Bitcoin <$10k pic.twitter.com/wiWt7KjuD7
— Holger Zschaepitz (@Schuldensuehner) August 15, 2019
Oops! US 30y yields drop below 2% for first time in history as bond mkts scream recession. pic.twitter.com/KHTtyRdNvc
— Holger Zschaepitz (@Schuldensuehner) August 15, 2019
Updated
Dutch economy to grow 1.4% next year
The Dutch economy seems in pretty good shape and will grow by 1.4% in 2020. But that is slower than expected because exports have been hit by weakening growth in Germany, Brexit and US trade policies, the country’s forecasting body CPB has said.
Growth in 2019 is expected to be a bit stronger than earlier expected at 1.8%, after a 2.6% expansion last year.
That compares favourably with GDP data from Germany yesterday which showed the powerhouse economy contracting by 0.1% in the June quarter.
Updated
Looking beyond Australia, Stephen Innes of Valour Markets in Singapore has written a note to clients in which he says the Fed will now be forced to cut rates again and possibly “much more profoundly than they expected”. China’s central bank could also come to the party with another stimulus package.
The steep falls in Asian markets on Thursday show that shell-shocked traders are “hoping for the best on the policy front but positioning for the worst on the economic backdrop”.
Surely the world’s central bankers are not going to allow President Trump tariff threats to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. Not yet, anyway. Not while there’s still some monetary firepower left in their arsenal.
The Fed, now out of necessity alone will need to adjust policy much more profoundly than they expected. While the threat of addition tariffs will make Beijing more accommodative to easing as policymakers have numerous avenues and a high degree for flexibility to respond. Suggesting that mainland’s accommodative policies including infrastructure, fiscal and monetary measures will be aggressively dialled up in coming months. Even as trade tensions alternate between simmer and boil, a PBOC and Fed policy deluge could go a long way to establishing risk sentiment.
Australian shares down 2.7%
Whether it’s boom or gloom, the Australian stock market is being smashed at the moment.
The benchmark ASX200 is down 2.7% today, a fall of 179 points to 6,416. That’s a loss of more than A$50bn on this morning’s opening prices and it could be the worst day since 25 October last year when shares fell 2.8% on the day.
Telcos are down heavily after the poor Telstra numbers earlier and tech losses on Wall Street. Energy stocks are also being hammered because of the falling oil price.
Afternoon Update: #ASX200 Sector Performance #ausbiz #markets pic.twitter.com/7hoqyBPzHL
— Bell Potter (@Bell_Potter) August 15, 2019
ASX 200 shows little response to the better than expected employment growth in July, with the Index remaining within sight of session lows #ausbiz #ASX200 pic.twitter.com/rfXjnbVPGa
— CommSec (@CommSec) August 15, 2019
How good is Donald Trump. #asx #asx200 pic.twitter.com/XP33i0XtTd
— reb of melbourne (@GutterTwits) August 15, 2019
Updated
Australia: is it boom or gloom?
The Australian jobs figures from earlier have, as usual, produced some difference of opinion.
In the bullish camp is Craig James, the chief economist at Commsec. He notes that overall employment has risen for the 33rd time in 34 months, up by 41,100 jobs in July against predictions of 14,000. Full-time jobs rose by 34,500 with part-time jobs up by 6,700. James writes:
What is the definition of a strong job market? We would contend that it is one where employment is rising, more people are participating in the job market and where the jobless rate remains historically low. Australia has a strong job market. While the jobless rate in Australia is higher than the US, UK and New Zealand, in Australia job growth remains strong and more people are drawing down a wage. Retailers want to see more people with jobs because that converts to more opportunities to sell their goods and services.
If you’re not sure, you’ll find a note of scepticism from the UBS economist George Tharenou who doesn’t think that it’s game, set and match for the Great Australian Economy just yet. He still thinks the RBA will cut rates agin in October and February.
While jobs rebounded, our labour demand index at a 5-year low still suggests a drop ahead to ~1¼% y/y; & wages remain soft amid higher unemployment. Given the RBA will “monitor …the labour market closely & adjust monetary policy if needed” – & weak hours support our Q2 GDP forecast of 0.5% (1.4% y/y), below mkt (0.6%) & RBA (¾%) – we still expect rate cuts in Oct & Feb, with trade wars raising the risk of more.
Updated
Traders in Tokyo are back from their lunch and the Nikkei is on the slide. It’s down 1.55% to 20,333. The Hang Seng has slipped as well and is up just 0.03%.
And London is now on course to slide into the red when it opens this morning. And the Dax30 in Frankfurt. The Dow is still on the dancefloor though and looking at a modest bounce of 30 points or 0.13%.
Summary
I’m taking a quick break so here are the main developments so far today:
- Asian stocks have fallen on Thursday – and recovered a bit after the bloodbath on Wall Street overnight.
- The Nikkei was down 1.2% in the morning session but the Hang Seng is up 0.5% after a weak start. Shanghai is down 0.75%.
- Not so good in Australia where the ASX200 is off 2.23% despite some encouraging employment figures.
- Oil has continued to tumble. Brent crude was down 37c, or 0.6%, at $59.11 a barrel by 0300 GMT.
- The yield on 30-year US treasuries has fallen below 2% for the first time ever in another sign that interest rates are set to remain lower for longer.
- Analysts have pushed back a bit on fears that the inverted US bond yield curve seen on Wednesday – and which sparked the 800-point fall in the Dow – is as crucial as some believe.
- Futures trade points to a positive start in London and in New York later today.
Updated
One factor in the pickup in Asian shares could be a reassessment of the risks of the celebrated inverted bond yield curve.
Several analysts and experts, including the former Federal Reserve bosses Alan Greenspan and Janet Yellen, have pointed out that structural market change means that the inverted yield curve might not be as important or reliable as it once was.
Kerry Craig, a global markets strategist at JP Morgan Asset Management, told Reuters that investors should also take note of how significantly markets had changed in the last decade, which meant a yield curve inversion might not be the harbinger it once was.
Yield curve inversion is flashing a warning sign – investors should check their portfolios are resilient. But it’s not a reason to panic or to lean into the sell-off.
David Bassanese of Betashares in Sydney points out that:
Current yield curve inversion is unusual compared to history as it’s not associated with a high real Fed funds rate (average of past 5 recession episodes 3.2%). Currently the real rate is around zero. That either means the curve is providing a false signal (due to a structural flattening) or the “neutral” real Fed funds rate has fallen a lot and even a near-zero level (as at present) is restricting the economy. The latter is clearly US President Trump’s claim. My view is that the yield curve is structurally flatter and not providing a signal of recession... as confirmed by still positive indicators such as US jobless claims.
And Stephen Koukoulas, the independent Australian economist, thinks it’s all a bit of “blabber” that a sharp cut in interest rates won’t fix. As he observes, that puts him in the same camp as Trump.
Trump is right on the Fed: The Fed needs to cut to 0.5% (or less) & do it soon - the boost to the economy will be material.
— Stephen Koukoulas (@TheKouk) August 14, 2019
The blabber on the yield curve fails to note that aggressive Fed cuts will fix the issue. It's not like the issue has crept up on them
Inverted yield curves are merely a reflection of bond market vigilantes pricing in a policy error of the central bank - nothing more or less.
— Stephen Koukoulas (@TheKouk) August 15, 2019
The central bank can address the concerns but cutting interest rates like freaks
Simple
Updated
Hong Kong is back in the black
The Hang Seng index has climbed into positive territory. It is now up 0.5% at 25,430 points. Losses on the Shanghai Composite are just -o.5%. What a time to be alive.
Hang Seng market red to green.
— Christian Fromhertz (@cfromhertz) August 15, 2019
This is some good news & yet see no headlines or alerts#inverted pic.twitter.com/vomjqpf7nQ
Analysts at UBS in Sydney have given up on a near-term resolution of the US-China trade war and have downgraded their forecasts for the two big economies. It also means a downgrade for industrial commodities such as iron ore and coal, and a boost for gold.
Here they are:
Our investment thesis heading into the back half of 2019 was predicated on a resolution to the trade war, but unfortunately this appears to have been short lived. As a result of increased tariffs, albeit somewhat delayed, this has lead to our economists downgrading US and Chinese growth for H2 19 and 2020. In light of this we have downgraded our industrial commodity forecasts and lifted gold.
On the bright side (if that’s the way you see it), the weakness makes another round of Chinese stimulus more likely. It’s the old “bad news is good news” paradigm, folks:
Continuing trade tensions are a headwind to global growth, but could prove positive for China stimulus.
Updated
House prices rose 0.6% in China last month, the 51st consecutive month of gains, according to Reuters calculations based on national bureau of statistics (NBS) data released today.
The gains are good news for the Chinese economy after some terrible data yesterday which showed industrial production falling to a 17-year low.
Despite all the gloom, the markets are beginning to recover some ground. The Nikkei is now off just 1.3% compared with 2% earlier, and the Hang Seng is in the red by just 0.45% after hitting -1.4% earlier. Shanghai is still on -1%.
In line with that improvement the FTSE100 and the Dow Jones are both seen opening in the black later today, according to IG Markets futures trading.
Australia is looking more off colour, however, with the ASX200 in Sydney slipping -2.28% to 6,445 points. It wasn’t long ago that it reached an all-time high of 6,875 points.
Australia at risk from global turmoil, bank deputy says
Guy Debelle, the deputy governor of the Reserve Bank of Australia, has given a speech this morning about what the global turmoil means for Australia and, not surprisingly, it’s not good news.
Speaking at a risk conference in Sydney, he said Australia – which has not had a recession for 28 years – benefited greatly from the “rules-based global order”. But the threats to that from the US-China trade war were bad news for the economy.
There were risks for household consumption but signs that house price falls were levelling out provided more optimism.
If this is the case, the drag from declining wealth and turnover will dissipate. Housing market conditions may even start to support consumption growth again in the period ahead.
Updated
US 30-year bond yields sink below 2% for first time
It’s all happening now!
The yield on 30-year US treasury bonds has slumped below 2% for the first time this morning. The 30-year yield extended its sharp overnight slide and hit a record low 1.991% in Asian trade on Thursday.
30-year US Treasury yield dips below 2% for the first time ever.https://t.co/S2qS6gFMbh pic.twitter.com/T9CN1dadwz
— Tracy Alloway (@tracyalloway) August 15, 2019
Concerns about the global economy is driving investors into the relative safe haven of government bonds. That drives up the price of bonds but reduces the yield.
Updated
Shanghai Composite down 1.3%
Trading has started in mainland China as well and the Shanghai Composite is off 1.1%, easing earlier losses.
It follows the decision by the People’s Bank of China to set the yuan slightly higher this morning. It also announced that it was lending 400bn yuan ($56.90bn) to financial institutions via its one-year medium-term lending facility, with an unchanged interest rate at 3.3%. It rolls over a bunch of loans worth 383bn yuan and adds more cash, Reuters reports.
The bank also injected a net 30bn yuan into money markets on Thursday.
Updated
Australian unemployment stays at 5.2%, Aussie dollar spikes
Unemployment stayed at 5.2% in July, according to seasonally adjusted figures from the Australian Bureau of Statistics released a few minutes ago. But the market was cheered by stats that showed 41,000 jobs were created last month against a forecast of 14,000.
The Aussie dollar picked up 0.4% to US67.75c.
https://t.co/e0cl5ktHIh AUD/USD jumps 30 pips on the upbeat Australian jobs report
— FxBook (@FxBookLTTG) August 15, 2019
Hong Kong opens down 1.4%
The Hang Seng index has opened down 1.4% this morning. That’s a fall of 365 points today and it takes the index below 25,000 to 24,945.
The Hang Seng been battered by concerns about the growing political crisis in the city – the deepening fears about a slowdown in the Chinese economy won’t help.
Help is at hand though. Donald Trump is offering a trade deal to Xi Jinping if he can sort the mess in Hong Kong “humanely”.
Updated
China sets yuan slightly higher
China’s central bank has set the yuan higher this morning at 7.0268 against the US dollar, compared with 7.0312 the day before.
In other words, Beijing is willing to see the yuan strengthen a little. (The lower the number, the stronger it is against the greenback). In the grand scheme of things that will be seen as a small olive branch to Washington, which last week accused Beijing of wanting to manipulate the yuan downwards and force cheaper goods on the world.
#PBOC raised #Yuan's fixing by 44 pips to 7.0268 per USD, vs 7.0312 one day earlier.
— YUAN TALKS (@YuanTalks) August 15, 2019
Updated
The losses seem to be easing in Japan, where the Nikkei is now down 1.76% for the day. But Australia’s ASX200 is now off a hefty 2.1%, not helped by a bad result for the telco Telstra.
It has reported a 40% fall in profits this morning thanks to the mounting cost of rolling out the country’s national broadband network, or NBN. Its shares are down nearly 2% and, as one of the biggest companies on the market, that makes a difference.
Updated
Oil continues to fall
The cocktail of economic news and data has been bad for the price of oil. Brent crude is down 39 cents, or 0.7%, at $59.09 a barrel this morning, after falling 3% in the last session.
US crude was down 28 cents, or 0.5%, at $54.95 a barrel, having dropped 3.3% in the previous session.
The falls have increased expectations that Saudi Arabi and other Opec oil-producing nations will cut production to force prices back up. That’s bad for their national coffers though and the Saudis, who are fighting a war in Yemen, have been reluctant to cut.
Crude oil prices getting closer to recent support levels...but companies that either produce it or provide related services appear to be discounting in 2016 lows based on current valuations 🤔 pic.twitter.com/Qs9UgLoFPh
— Lava Creek Capital Management, LLC (@LavaCreekVOS) August 15, 2019
Michael McCarthy, chief market strategist at CMC Markets in Sydney, notes that although the bond market was the trigger for the trauma on stock markets in the past 24 hours, not every inversion in the US curve has led to a recession. But he says that might not be enough to prevent a rush for the exits amid a delicate geopolitical position:
Markets were in no mood for subtlety, and the damaging moves may provide their own rationale for more selling. The sell-off comes despite a better than forecast US earnings season. More than 90% of SPX500 companies have reported. Aggregate earnings are up around 2%, beating forecasts of a negative quarter.
He also said poor earnings result in Australia, especially from the telco giant Telstra, would keep the pressure on stocks down under:
Australian company results could add to market pressures. Telstra reported a 40% drop in profit, worse than forecast. Optimistic messages around the introduction of the 5G spectrum may not be enough to stem investor displeasure. Other misses include Blackmore’s, Cleanaway, Treasury Wine Estates and Super Retail. Both Sydney Airports and QBE Insurance delivered earnings above expectations, and funeral group Invocare surprised with a 7.5% lift.
Updated
So what is an inverted bond yield curve?
A major factor in yesterday’s selloff was the inverted US bond yield curve – not helped by recession warnings from Germany and China. It is a very reliable predictor of recession and preceded all six of the previous US recessions.
It’s not often it becomes a topic for everyday conversation. So in case you get stuck next to the water cooler and feel like making some small talk, here’s a quick explainer.
In normal times, investors would expect a higher return, or yield, for buying longer-term government bonds. Conversely, the shorter-term bonds, such as two-year bonds, give you less return.
But as you can see in the theoretical chart below, the normal curve turns the other way, or inverts, when the yield on longer-term notes falls in relation to shorter-term. It indicates that investors see trouble ahead ...
It looks more like this in the real world:
But I am skeptical of this chart showing banks tightening loan standards when the yield curve inverting. Did banks tighten because of upside down interest rates or because they saw the same things bond traders saw that inverted the curve? pic.twitter.com/CIkS171rIr
— John Carney (@carney) August 15, 2019
You can go for the PhD level with this column from our economics editor, Larry Elliott:
Updated
In Japan the Nikkei index is down 2.1% this morning. Stocks are suffering amid the fears of a global downturn but are also being pushed down because the value of the yen is rising. The Japanese currency is a “safe haven” asset and goes up in times of crisis – rather like gold and the Swiss franc which are both also up today.
A higher yen is bad news for Japan’s export-reliant big manugfacturers, hence the falling stock market.
Here’s Junichi Ishikawa, senior foreign exchange strategist at IG Securities in Tokyo:
When volatility rises, dollar/yen becomes strongly correlated with [US] treasury yields, so the currency pair has more room to fall. I expect other safe havens to rise. The mood is downbeat, because of the trade war and bad economic data.
'Turbulence will continue,' Australian stock market boss says
Market turbulence will continue over coming months, the chief executive of the Australian Stock Exchange says.
As the benchmark ASX200 took a 2% hit in early trading this morning, the ASX chief executive, Dominic Stevens, said the 2020 financial year would see “elevated volatility” because of the geopolitical situation and the changing expectations for interest rates.
My colleague Ben Butler writes that with rates at record lows the market expects further cuts in coming months as the Reserve Bank tries to boost Australia’s sluggish economic growth.
But while markets around the world may be melting down, it’s been a good year for the ASX. It said this morning that profits after tax had risen 10.5% in the year to 30 June, to $492m. Shareholders in the market operator will reap the benefits, trousering dividends for the year totalling 228.7c a share – up 5.7% on last year’s payout – plus a special dividend of 129.1c a share from the sale of ASX’s stake in technology company Iress.
Updated
Australia opens down 1.8%, Japan off 1.9%
Trading has started in Asia with steep falls – as expected – in Australia and Japan.
Asia begins lower after the sell-off on Wall St. where US indices fell around 3% and the DJIA posted its worst performance YTD amid recession fears after weak data from China and Germany, as well as the US yield curve inversion; ASX 200 (-1.2%), Nikkei 225 (-1.9%), KOSPI (closed)
— RANsquawk (@RANsquawk) August 15, 2019
Good morning/evening ... wherever you are in the world, welcome to the Guardian’s business live blog which is starting early today before what’s expected to be a turbulent day on the financial markets.
My colleague Graeme Wearden covered all the action in the UK, Europe and the US on Wednesday and you can catch up on his blog here.
But in the meantime here are the main points:
- Wall Street suffered huge losses after an inversion in the US bond yield curve sparked fears of an imminent recession.
- The Dow Jones plunged 800 points, or 3%, its fourth largest decline in history. The S&P500 and Nasdaq were also down heavily.
- Fears were compounded by GDP figures in Germany pointing to a recession there and data in China showing industrial production was down 17% in July.
- The numbers sent European markets down, with the FTSE100 off more than 100 points.
- Oil slumped on fears of a global downturn.
- Donald Trump lashed out at the Fed chairman, Jerome Powell, calling him “clueless”.
Here’s our news wrap of yesterday – and I’ll have today’s opening scores in a few minutes when trading starts in Sydney.
Updated