Asmir Begovic 8
Very encouraging first outing for the club's new goalkeeper who produced a couple of excellent saves. Saved two penalties in the shoot-out.....and scored one!
Seamus Coleman 6
Typically solid pre-season performance from the experienced club captain.
Mason Holgate 6
Used the ball well early on, with some raking passes. Steady otherwise.
Ben Godfrey 6
Given a workout in the 30 degrees heat as Millonarios favoured attacking down Everton's left.
Lucas Digne 6
Needing to play his way back to full fitness after the thigh injury he picked up in Euro 2020. Excellent cross to find Kean, though
Allan 7
Friendly game or competitive fixture, Allan plays one way. Won his fair share of tackles
Abdoulaye Doucoure 6
A second pre-season outing and still in need of more matches to rediscover the rhythm he had before injury struck in February.
Andros Townsend 8
Very lively first outing for Townsend who smacked the bar with a powerful effort from just inside the area
James Rodriguez 6
Got better as the first-half wore on but failed to dazzle in his first ever performance in front of Evertonians
Alex Iwobi 6
Saw quite a lot of the ball through his 70 plus minutes on the field but unable to make much use of it.
Moise Kean 6
Left to rue missing a good chance when he headed Digne's cross over the bar.
Substitutes
Jonjoe Kenny 6 (on for Coleman '46)
Typically, committed display from the Academy graduate. Got forward whenever he could. Produced a Panenka penalty in the shoot-out.
Andre Gomes 7 (on for Doucoure '46)
Played the through-ball which led to the penalty for Everton's equaliser. Bright in moments. Converted his penalty in the shoot-out.
Nathan Broadhead 7 (on for Kean '46)
Not an easy task playing as the lone striker but won the spot-kick from which the Blues levelled. Also had chances to score. Made no mistake with his spot-kick.
Sign up for the Liverpool ECHO daily Everton newsletter HERE
Anthony Gordon 7 (on for Townsend '46)
Visibly eager to take another opportunity to impress Benitez and helped Everton improve after the break. Spot-kick hit the bar.
Demarai Gray 8 (on for Rodriguez '46)
Confidently converted the penalty to draw Everton level after Broadhead was fouled. Repeated the trick in the shoot-out. Looked very comfortable in the No10 role.
Michael Keane 7 (on for Holgate '61)
Positioning was, typically, spot on as he helped shore up Everton's defence for the final half an hour. Scored in the penalty shoo-out.
Joe Anderson 6 (on for Lucas Digne '61)
Excellent first-team exposure for the young defender after he signed a new one year contract with the club. Converted his spot-kick.
Jean-Philippe Gbamin 7 (on for Allan '61)
The defensive midfielder was able to showcase some of his ability with the ball, in his cameo. Very cool penalty in the shoot-out
Lewis Gibson 6 (on for Godfrey '73)
More senior experience at Everton for the young defender who has returned from a tough season on loan. Confident penalty.
Tom Davies 6 (on for Iwobi '73)
Asked to play on the right-wing for the closing stages so needs to operate centrally to catch Benitez's eye. Scored in penalty.
Do you want an exclusive pre-season Everton preview - both in your inbox and through your letterbox? Head over here to find out more and secure your copy.
