Emmerdale fans were quick to point out a flaw in an episode after character Charity discovered some CCTV footage.
Liv was convinced she'd been attacked by Noah, waking up covered in bruises and bite marks on the soap.
Gabby also discovered a disturbing voicemail from Liv, where she could be heard asking Noah to 'get off' her and leave her alone.
READ MORE: Yorkshire heatwave update as Met Office says UK heading for one of hottest ever summer s
Aaron flew off the handle and accused Noah of assaulting Liv, but Charity was determined that her son couldn't have done what he was being accused of.
Despite that Liv and Aaron were determined to go to the police but as they were about to leave Charity and Noah burst in with a CCTV clip which showed what really happened.
In the clip Liv could be seen beating Noah up as he tried to help her and could be heard telling him to get off her.
Liv was left stunned by the footage and pleaded with Noah to forgive her.
But lots of viewers spotted a problem with the video as several questioned what CCTV footage had sound.
redbay37 said: "What cctv has sound??"
Colin White said: "Sound on the cctv?"
Joe Bloggs Junior said: "I can't believe they have CCTV footage that clear.....what cameras are they using?"
Download the YorkshireLive app to customise the news that matters to you and get the latest updates first.
