Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
World
Jon Henley

Don't judge a job applicant by their degree

A question of degree: maths whiz Carol Vorderman only got a third.
A question of degree: maths whiz Carol Vorderman only got a third. Photograph: ITV/Rex Features

Pity poor Desmond. And woe indeed is Thora. These days, only Geoff and, at a pinch, Attila will do.

It was reported this week that more than three-quarters of all graduate employers won't consider anyone with less than an upper-second-class degree. With more than 70 applicants for every vacancy, against 30 before the downturn,, 76% of firms surveyed said a 2:1 was a minimum requirement. A decade or so ago it was 54%.

This is not good news for anyone who emerges from university, as I did, with what then was known, with an affection born of more optimistic economic times, as a drinker's degree: a lower second. (Even more admirable, obviously, because it was reserved for the truly dedicated dosser, was a gentleman's or third-class degree.)

These days, degrees have different names, derived from rhyming slang: a 2:2, it seems, is a Desmond, after archbishop Tutu; a third is a Thora, after the actor Thora Hird, or a Douglas, after the former Tory foreign minister; a first is a Geoff for the footballer, or a Damien for the artist; and a 2:1 a Billy after the wrestler Billy Gunn, or an Attila, after the Hun.

More alarmingly, though, they actually seem to matter. Once, if you weren't merely idle or ignorant, a third-class honours degree was practically a guarantee of greatness: WH Auden, Lewis Caroll, AA Milne; Stanley Baldwin, Sir Alec Douglas-Home; more recently, David Dimbleby, Christopher Hitchens, Hugh Laurie.

Even Carol Vorderman, a proud member of the "Nines Club" at Cambridge (she got a third in each of her three years of studies) later presented Countdown and became David Cameron's maths tsar – neither, I'm sure you agree, a negligible achievement.

Now it seems you need a 2:1 or better even to get an interview with Marks & Spencer. This is unfair. As Michael Morpurgo, another genius with a gentleman's degree, puts it apropos of teaching: "The class of a degree may be useful as part of the selection process, but only as part of the process. It is aptitude ... that is far more important."

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.