Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Entertainment
Gareth McLean

Do we really need Law & Order: London?


Law & Order: Sun Hill ... ITV's The Bill. Photograph: Steve Peskett

As not quite everyone is back to work this week, there is still a strange feeling of limbo in the air. It is, one imagines, a bit like being on bail. This being the case, it's all too easy for one's mind to wander down neural pathways overgrown and neglected by the gardener of the brain. See! There's one there - an extended metaphor going nowhere. I have also been exercised by the following:

1. What will happen to the marvellous blog, lateshowwritersonstrike.com when they go back to work? If they go back to work.

2. Why do the I Am Legend posters look like eye tests?

3. What will the rumoured Law & Order: London be like? And why?

Apparently, ITV is in advanced talks with NBC about a British version of Dick Wolf's mighty American franchise. Kudos - the producers of Spooks and Hustle who can do wrong, unless you count The Amazing Mrs Pritchard and E4 teen drama, Nearly Famous - are to co-produce the show which will be the first non-American English language version of any L&O show. A 13-part series is expected next year, signalling another move towards longer runs for British series and the abandonment of the six-parter.

Spin-offs from successful shows are hardly new and there have been rumours of a CSI episode set in London ever since its executive producer, Carol Mendelsohn, floated the idea back in 2005 I myself would favour a Clapton Scene Investigation but only so I could lobby for a walk-on part.

But Law & Order? How boring. Being totally precinct-bound and formulaic beyond measure, I think we can do without one set in sunny Wimbledon or wherever. Would we even swallow a British cop show done like an American one, when we're so used to our own, more genteel variety? The Bill has improved immeasurably lately - and next week has an impressive story featuring Katy Cavanagh as a Myra Hindley-esque killer - but it's not quite up to American standards just yet. And surely part of the appeal of US cop drama is its otherness?

I'm all for importing the ambition, storytelling slickness and production values of US shows to British drama but couldn't we do that without copying an American format - especially one as rigid as L&O? Besides anything else, the L&O franchise isn't the all-conquering behemoth it once was. While Special Victims' Unit thrives (yay!), Criminal Intent was recently relegated to cable. Somewhat typically, you might say, Britain's jumping on the bandwagon just as it grinds to a halt.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.