Apple recently released a new version of Creator Studio and, with it, a set of new app icons. So far, so unremarkable. But these icons are so confusing that Apple felt compelled to release a whole user guide to help you navigate them.
The guide exists because there are now two versions of each app – one via subscription, the other through a one-off payment – each with its own icon, and telling them apart is far from obvious. Following the style of the macOS Tahoe update, the new icons also abandon the expressive, image-led designs of old in favour of a uniform rounded-square format that mirrors iOS. The result is a homogenised look that strips each app of its individual personality. The new colour scheme doesn't help either: muted and dull against the vibrancy of the old one.
The fundamental principle of an icon is that you can read it at a glance. That's hard enough here, but the bigger problem is that these icons come as a suite, appearing side by side. Their mutual similarity and abstract style compound the confusion in a way a standalone icon might get away with.
Whether or not you prefer the old-style icons (I do), both are here to stay. Apple knew you'd be confused but, rather than design a more intuitive system, it handed you a manual. I'm sure the guide is meant to ease the transition and help you tell the two icon sets apart on the desktop – but it would be better still if they were distinct enough not to need one. What do you think?
It's a season for icon frustration: the response to Google's new app icons shows Apple isn't alone. Though we do love these parody Google icons – be sure to check them out!
