Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Liverpool Echo
Liverpool Echo
National
Lauren Wise

'Covid denier' made sheep noises at people queuing for tests

A 'coronavirus denier' made sheep noises at people as they queued for tests and told them " Covid is a fake".

Paul Miranda, 50, also filmed people at Bootle Town Hall on Monday as they waited in line for a coronavirus test at the walkthrough centre.

He made a 'baa' sound at people to suggest they were sheep and called one man, who had lost four relatives to coronavirus, a "stupid fat c***".

A judge today branded his behaviour as "a complete and utter disgrace" as he faced three charges of harassment at Liverpool Magistrates' Court.

Lionel Cope, prosecuting, read statements from three victims, Daniel Bethel, Frances Loughran and Cedric Loughran, who were simply trying to get a coronavirus test.

Reading from Mr Bethel's statement Mr Cope said: "I pulled up to the centre - I didn't know he was filming me. I asked him twice not to film me and he went 'What are you going to do?'".

Miranda also filmed car registration numbers and Mr Bethel said: "He was following me calling me a stupid fat c***.

"I lost four relatives to coronavirus. I didn't want this filmed or to be disturbed."

Mr Bethel had "swiped" at Miranda, but claimed he wasn't trying to assault him, but to get him to stop filming.

Ms Loughran said Miranda was "hassling staff and making comments about coronavirus being a lie" and said she "noticed he was standing very close to people".

Receive newsletters with the latest news, sport and what's on updates from the Liverpool ECHO by signing up here.

The court heard Miranda also "said baa" which Ms Loughran "took that to say we were sheep".

Ms Louhgran said the incident made her "feel anxious" and "very intimidated".

Mr Cope, reading her statement, said: "I was very intimidated so I just put my head down and tried to walk away."

As he filmed people he told them "You're going to be on YouTube".

Miranda also shouted "Why are you getting a test?" and asked "Why are you here? Covid is fake."

Mr Loughran, responding to the comments, replied that people had been advised to get tests even if asymptompatic to which Miranda said: "It's just a conspiracy".

In a statement Mr Loughran said: "He was trying to have his own little protest".

The court heard Miranda, of Wordsworth Street, Bootle, has not been before the courts for the last 20 years.

He admitted three charges of intent to cause harassment, alarm or distress.

Joe Woodyatt, defending, explained that Miranda had been walking past the test centre at the time.

He said: "He didn't have any intention of going to harass people.

"When walking past the centre he got into a discussion with one of the security guards and it was here that he then started to get agitated and angry."

Mr Woodyatt told the court Miranda is remorseful stating "he wholeheartedly apologises".

He said: "He really wants to stress he is really very sorry for his behaviour and accepts what he did was out of order."

Mentioning Mr Bethel's "swipe" he said: "He felt this was more of an attempted assault on his person which further upset him."

Mr Woodyatt said: "He can't explain why he was saying what he was saying about the pandemic."

He explained that Miranda has a sister who has just come out of an Intensive Care Unit (ICU) having contracted coronavirus.

At this comment Deputy District Judge Vincent McDade said: "How can he say it's a hoax and on the other hand his sister has just come out of ICU?"

The court heard Miranda does not suffer from any diagnosed mental health issues but has "some sort of PTSD".

Mr Woodyatt stressed that Miranda claimed "there won't be any repeat of any such behaviour".

Judge McDade, sentencing, said: "This city is in the grip of one of the most serious pandemics in 100 years.

"For you to go around abusing people in the centre, people who are genuinely concerned about their health and the health of their relatives, is a complete and utter disgrace.

Enter your postcode in the interactive tool below to read news in your area

"Then to say it's a hoax when your sister has come out of an ICU having had the virus - I really don't understand your logic."

Miranda was given credit for his guilty plea and the judge took into account that his last conviction was around 20 years ago.

Miranda was handed a two-week curfew which will run from 9am to 5pm.

After sentencing Miranda asked to address the court, and said: "I'm not a Covid denier, I just want the court to understand that.

"I don't know what set me off to say them things, I don't believe in them."

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.