100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
A tug of war between survival and fitness: how chameleons become even brighter without predators around
Invasive species offer a rare research opportunity, as they often colonise new environments very different to their native habitat. One…
Border agents block rare and destructive beetle from entering US
This is the first time the species has ever been found at America’s borders, according to Customs and Border Protection
How to spot bark beetles and deadly fungus: the UK’s new tree-saving lab needs your help
Hi-tech laboratory launched to save trees from threats including oak processionary moth, emerald ash borer and citrus longhorn beetle
Boon for blooms as UK’s dry spring keeps plant diseases at bay
Exclusive: RHS says queries about diseases down 45% in good sign for May blooms such as lupins and iris
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Rare native plants ravaged by bushfires in Mallacoota make comeback in nursery sanctuary
Two-and-a-half years after the catastrophic Black Summer bushfires devastated the Victorian town of Mallacoota, a unique community nursery is helping…
The UK's worst Japanese knotweed hotspots revealed
Is the invasive species in your back garden? We map the areas most at risk from plant that costs the…
Get all your news in one place
Latest Environment news:
Neighbourhood green space is in rapid decline, deepening both the climate and mental health crises
The past 20 or so years of housing development in England and Wales has decimated community access to green space.…
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Climate change benchmarks all set records last year, report finds
Key data released Wednesday underscores how swiftly human activities are reshaping the climate.
Critical climate indicators broke records in 2021, says UN
World Meteorological Organization says extreme weather wreaked heavy toll on human lives
Canaries in the coal mine: why birds can tell us so much about the health of Earth
Following a deadly explosion in a Welsh coal mine in 1896, an engineer called John Haldane invented a type of…
How taking a closer look at your family tree can help you get to grips with climate change
Engaging people when it comes to climate change can be challenging. Climate conversations are often technical and dry, making it…
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Accidental discovery that scallops love ‘disco’ lights leads to new fishing technique
Scientists hail breakthrough that could maximise catches while reducing damage caused by fishing
Extinction obituary: the sudden, sad disappearance of the Christmas Island forest skink
Gump was the last lizard of her kind when she died in 2014, and her demise should be ‘a scar…

Could we learn to love slugs and snails in our gardens?

By Bethaney Turner, Associate Professor, Centre for Creative and Cultural Research, Faculty of Arts and Design, University of Canberra
Shutterstock

Before you squash or poison the next slug or snail you see in your garden, consider this: The British Royal Horticultural Society no longer classifies these gastropods as pests. Why on earth would a leading gardening organisation do that, you might wonder. After all, slugs and snails are usually seen as a problem, given their eagerness to devour the plants you’ve lovingly nurtured.

The issue is that they are part of nature. Slugs and snails play a key role in healthy ecosystems, acting to break down organic material as well as providing a source of food for blue-tongued lizards, frogs and kookaburras.

So can we learn to live with slugs and snails? Yes, if we reframe how we see these invertebrates. After all, the definition of “pest” is based on our perception and can change over time. By rejecting the “pest” status of many invertebrates and advocating planet friendly gardening, the horticultural society directly connects the local actions of gardeners to our global biodiversity crisis.

Their principal entomologist, Andrew Salisbury, has argued that “now is the time to gracefully accept, even actively encourage, more of this life into our gardens”.

This doesn’t have to mean letting them destroy your lettuces. Nature can help. Enticing lizards, frogs and birds to your garden can help control slugs and snails and boost biodiversity.

Kookaburra and magpie
Attracting birds like kookaburras and magpies to your garden can keep slugs and snails in check. Shutterstock

Are these ‘pests’ actually legitimate garden inhabitants?

Gardening increased in popularity during the pandemic. With widespread rainy weather across Australia’s east coast, gardeners are more likely to see – and potentially be annoyed by – slugs and snails.

So should Australian gardeners follow the UK’s example? Should we try to welcome all species into the garden? Responses to these questions typically describe slugs and snails as “pests”, invoke the idea of a native/non-native species divide or describe the perceived damage done by invasive species.

Let’s tackle the pest argument first. We define pests based on perception. That means what we think of as a pest can change. The garden snail is a good example. Many gardeners consider them a pest, but they are cherished by snail farmers who breed them for human consumption.


Read more: The pandemic's gardening boom shows how gardens can cultivate public health


By contrast, many scientists consider the concept of an invasive species to be less subjective. Australia’s environment department defines them as species outside their normal distribution (often representing them as non-native) which “threaten valued environmental, agricultural or other social resources by the damage it causes”. Even this definition, however, is a little rubbery.

In recent decades, researchers in the humanities, social sciences and some natural sciences have shown our ideas of nativeness and invasiveness also undergo change. Is the dingo a native animal, for instance, after being introduced thousands of years ago? Would it still be considered a native if it was introduced to Tasmania where it does not occur?

Despite these questions over their worth, the ideas of “pest” and “invasive species” have proven remarkably persistent in ecological management.

Red triangle slug on gum tree
Australia has a wealth of native land gastropods like this red triangle slug, found up and down the east coast. Shutterstock

What exactly are the slugs and snails we find in our gardens?

Australia has a huge diversity of land snails, with many species yet to be described. Many species are in decline, however, due to introduced predators and loss of habitat, and now require conservation efforts.

Does that include our gardens? Well, most snails and slugs found in gardens are considered non-native species which were introduced accidentally. The ability of snails to spread far and wide means these humble gastropods are listed on Australia’s official list of priority pests. We already have biosecurity measures in place to avoid unwanted introduction of new snail species.

The common garden snail, which hails from the Mediterranean, has now spread to every state and territory. But other species are still spreading, such as the Asian tramp snail on the east coast or the green snail, which is currently limited to Western Australia. So if we accept the existence of all kinds of snails and slugs in the garden, we could be undermining efforts to detect and control some of these species.

Asian tramp snail
The Asian tramp snail is regarded as a serious pest. Andrew Hardacre, Flickr, CC BY

While slugs and snails don’t usually seriously threaten our home gardens, some species are known agricultural pests. The common garden snail can cause major damage to citrus fruit and young trees, while slugs such as the leopard slug or the grey field slug can devastate fields of seedlings. The damage they can do means farmers and their peak bodies would feel uneasy about changing how we think of these land molluscs.

Some snails can also carry dangerous parasites like the rat lungworm or the trematode worm Brachylaima cribbi. These can hurt us, particularly if a snail is accidentally eaten, or if vegetables in the garden are contaminated. If we let snails move around unhindered, we could increase the number of infections. Pets and children are the most at risk.

So should we follow the UK’s example?

It is not straightforward to rethink how we view and respond to creatures typically considered pests in the garden. But it is worthwhile thinking this through, as it requires appreciating how humans and nonhumans are interdependent. And we can gain a better understanding of how our simple actions in our gardens can scale up to affect human and planetary health and well-being.


Read more: Urban gardens are crucial food sources for pollinators - here's what to plant for every season


The world’s ongoing loss of biodiversity and the steadily changing climate must inform how we relate to and care for the nonhuman life – from mycelium in the soil to gastropods – that enliven our gardens.

This does not mean everything must have an equal opportunity to flourish. But it does require us to pay attention. To observe, to wonder and to be curious about our entangled lives. This kind of attention could help us take a more ethical approach to the everyday life and death decisions we make in our patch.

What does that look like? By understanding gardens as interconnected natural and cultural spaces, we can work to limit our resident slug and snail population and promote biodiversity. A perfect way to start is to design a lizard, frog and bird friendly site.

The Conversation

Bethaney Turner has received funding for research into urban agriculture from the ACT Government.

Valerie Caron receives funding from Grain Research and Development Corporation to work on Cochlicella acuta, an invasive snail species and the Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment to work on other invertebrate invasive species.

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
A tug of war between survival and fitness: how chameleons become even brighter without predators around
Invasive species offer a rare research opportunity, as they often colonise new environments very different to their native habitat. One…
Border agents block rare and destructive beetle from entering US
This is the first time the species has ever been found at America’s borders, according to Customs and Border Protection
How to spot bark beetles and deadly fungus: the UK’s new tree-saving lab needs your help
Hi-tech laboratory launched to save trees from threats including oak processionary moth, emerald ash borer and citrus longhorn beetle
Boon for blooms as UK’s dry spring keeps plant diseases at bay
Exclusive: RHS says queries about diseases down 45% in good sign for May blooms such as lupins and iris
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Rare native plants ravaged by bushfires in Mallacoota make comeback in nursery sanctuary
Two-and-a-half years after the catastrophic Black Summer bushfires devastated the Victorian town of Mallacoota, a unique community nursery is helping…
The UK's worst Japanese knotweed hotspots revealed
Is the invasive species in your back garden? We map the areas most at risk from plant that costs the…
Get all your news in one place