Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Politics
Guardian readers

'Corbyn is an albatross': readers on the local election results

Is Jeremy Corbyn to blame for Labour’s weak local election results?
Is Jeremy Corbyn to blame for Labour’s weak local election results? Photograph: Neil Hall/Reuters

Labour has suffered serious losses in local elections across England, Wales and Scotland, with the Conservatives making significant gains. Though Labour managed to win mayoral elections in Liverpool and Manchester, it lost out to the Tories in Tees Valley, a traditional Labour heartland.

Meanwhile, Ukip is facing a near wipeout of its council seats, with the Conservaties the main beneficiaries.

Thousands of readers have been discussing the implications of the results in the comments of our politics live blog. Below, we share a selection of their views.

Labour needs to be honest with itself

I had hoped against hope that I would be coming here this morning to say that I was wrong, that the electorate had embraced Corbyn and that we had done well in the local elections. Everything I have learned and understood about politics over the many years of my involvement told me otherwise but I hoped.

To say that I'm bitterly disappointed would be an understatement, but I'm not surprised. Labour now faces a very tough five weeks until the GE which, if we are being honest with ourselves, is going to be as bad as these results if not worse. Today is a bad day. To say otherwise is to be dishonest with ourselves.

Corbyn is an albatross

Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn leaves his home on 5 May, with his party suffering setbacks in the local elections.
Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn leaves his home on 5 May, with his party suffering setbacks in the local elections. Photograph: Carl Court/Getty Images

I see this as more of a commentary on the how the nation views the leaders. Brexit obviously plays a part but not as much as many suppose: that will be the issue come June. Many moderate Labour supporters have long realised, Corbyn is an albatross around the party’s neck, it’s just a shame that so many of his supporters have bought-in to his cult-like status. All they’ve ended up doing is letting the party, and the people they want to help, down.

Ukippers return to the establishment

So ultimately, those kippers who complained about elites ruling the country end up voting conservative?

A bad day for the Lib Dems

Arguably the biggest losers here are the Liberal Democrats, whose pro-EU spiel really hasn't worked.

I suspect Crosby may have played a blinder here. It's becoming pretty clear that the only hope of stopping the Tories and avoiding a repeat of today's outcome in a few weeks time, will be the 'progressive alliance' some have been calling for - the 'coalition of chaos' the Conservatives have been warning against.

This suggests a general election landslide

Heaven help the UK. If this is any indication of the General Election results, we're in trouble. Whoever's in power, a large majority or a landslide is bad news - it results in the Government failing to be held accountable. And with discussions as important as Brexit going on, we can't afford that.

Labour in Scotland only have themselves to blame

Scottish Tory Leader Ruth Davidson with candidate Mark Brown at the local elections at Meadowbank Stadium in Edinburgh.
Scottish Tory Leader Ruth Davidson with candidate Mark Brown at the local elections at Meadowbank Stadium in Edinburgh. Photograph: Andrew Milligan/PA

Going by current results in Scotland, the Conservatives are now the face of the Union. It'll be SNP v Tory up here now and Labour only have themselves to blame for having nothing of substance to say on the independence issue. I blame Scottish Labour for this more than Corbyn (not that his leadership is completely blameless), they need to sort themselves out.

The bigger winner was apathy

The Tees Valley mayoral election was the lowest of low key. There has been no canvassing here where I live, and I only received only one leaflet, the one from the Labour candidate.
OK, the Conservative candidate has won, but with just a 21% turnout the biggest winner up here has been apathy.

We need a progressive alliance

Please Labour: look at these results, have a long hard look at yourself and realise that you are losing voters. There's still time to change tack before the GE. The argument of JC supporters that he is popular at a local level has just been shown to be false. If you cling to it then 8 June could be catastrophic.
And to all the parties that are not UKIP/Conservatives: please take the idea of a progressive alliance seriously.

Labour should be wiping the floor with the Tories

In 2013 Labour gained 291 seats in local elections. The opposition should be wiping the floor with a Tory party giving us hard brexit, cuts to public services, hospital closures and longer nhs waiting times. Instead they are losing seats and the blame should lay firmly at the door of Corbyn, McDonnell and Abbott. They are the ones the electorate have no faith in and who are leading Labour to electoral disaster.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.