Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Daily Mirror
Daily Mirror
Politics
Dan Bloom & Talia Shadwell

Conservative Robert Buckland skewered over Tory punch 'lie' in car crash interview

The Justice Secretary was skewered during a live TV interview over false claims that a Tory aide was punched by a Labour activist.

Robert Buckland was warned "there is no untruth that can’t be told" by the Tories as host Nick Robinson told him: "Is there no institution safe when the Prime Minister’s in trouble?

"He attacks the courts, he misleads the Queen, he attacks Parliament, he attacked Channel 4 last week, now it's the BBC. Anything to get into power."

He appeared on BBC Radio 4 and BBC Breakfast this morning in a bid to get the Conservative election campaign back on track following Monday's day of disaster.

It began when the Prime Minister repeatedly refused to look at a photo of a sick four-year-old boy lying on an overcrowded A&E floor during a live TV interivew.

There were then protests outside Leeds General Infirmary as Health Secretary Matt Hancock visited the boy's family in a damage control exercise.

A Tory aide was allegedly punched by a Labour activist - but video footage later revealed this to be a "bare-faced lie" and the aide simply walked into a protester's outstretched arm.

Mr Buckland agreed “it might be some accidental contact", calling it a "very confusing and fluid scene."

He then went on to accuse the protesters of staging an "orchestrated" confrontation, blaming them for what he called a "public order incident."

Dan Walker grills Robert Buckland on BBC Breakfast (BBC)

“It seems like some sort of public order incident," he told the BBC. "People are shouting. people are trying to get out of the way of that to avoid a confrontation.”

Mr Buckland continued, saying it “wasn’t an acceptable scene” and accused the protesters of going to the hospital "to create some sort of scene."

He added: "I’ve got to ask the question - how  does that advance democratic debate? Surely it's far better that we have a reasonable debate... rather than people gesticulating and shouting at the Health Secretary and his team outside what is after all a hospital, which should be a place of safety and tranquility."

The justice secretary insisted the PM's response was normal (BBC)

The Justice Secretary insisted that Boris Johnson's response to being shown the picture of young Jack Williment-Barr was not "painful", as BBC Breakfast host Dan Walker suggested.

Mr Buckland said of the incident: “Well look I mean elections are really difficult things - you know, things will happen in elections, unpredictable events.

"I don’t think he was forced into it. I think when he looked at it, the reaction was clear and unforced and natural and the apology was forthcoming and fulsome.

"And I think that response and the response that we’ve shown in the hours since and the action that the Health Secretary took shows that we were taking this matter incredibly serious  - as we would take with any matter related to our National Health Service.”

Mr Buckland was also lambasted by Radio 4’s Today programme in a a cringe-worthy interview just minutes before his Breakfast interview disaster.

Interviewer Nick Robinson asked him: “Let’s turn to the PM’s character.

"What does it say about a man who is so determined not to address the case of a little boy on a hospital floor that he pockets a reporter’s phone in mid-interview rather than look at it?”

Mr Buckland said there were always moments where “you’re suddenly sprung with something and it's difficult to know exactly what is happening”.

Robert Buckland saw nothing wrong in Boris Johnson's reaction to the sick boy photo (BBC)

Mr Robinson retorted: “Come off it Mr Buckland! It was the front page of a national newspaper.”

Mr Buckland said “he clearly hadn’t seen the photograph.”

But the host pressed on: “I don’t think that’s clear at all, I’m sorry. I was with him yesterday and every time he was asked about the photograph he tried to change the subject and list a series of statistics about the NHS. He was determined not to talk about it.”

Mr Buckland said: “But he did talk about it, and he did express sorrow and regret for what he saw and an apology.

“What happened to this young lad was not acceptable.”

But Mr Robinson moved on to the punch saga.

Matt Hancock is heckled outside of Leeds Hospital

“Why did Tory press officers brief the media wrongly, inaccurately, that the Health Secretary’s aide was punched by a Labour activist when he hadn’t been?”

Mr Buckland said: “I don’t know who briefed what to whom.”

Mr Robinson said: “Laura Kuenssberg, Robert Peston, all of these people, very high profile journalists were told by people they trust that this happened and when the video emerged it had not happened.”

Mr Buckland repeated his claims that the protesters had created a scene: “What I saw was a very confusing scene of public disorder. People who had clearly organised themselves to come along, create trouble and mischief… people were shouting and gesticulating.”

Yet Mr Robinson concluded: “You see, what it looks like to many people is you will do anything in this campaign, there is no untruth that can’t be told.

“And in addition the Prime Minister decided just to drop the suggestion that the BBC might lose its source of funding.

“I wonder Mr Buckland, is there no institution safe when the Prime Minister’s in trouble? He attacks the courts, he misleads the Queen, he attacks Parliament, he attacked Channel 4 last week, now it's the BBC.

“Anything to get into power.”

Mr Buckland said “that’s a really unfair criticism” and that the PM was responding to “genuine concern on the doorsteps” about the cost of the licence fee.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.