Colombia (4-3-3)
David Ospina Failed to stop Kane’s penalty in normal time and saved only one, from Henderson, in shootout. 6
Santiago Arias A solid performance but was not able to influence the game. Booked for a challenge on Kane. 6
Yerry Mina A towering presence in the heart of Colombia’s defence and scored his third goal of the tournament. 8
Davinson Sánchez An assured display from the defender and did well to block when Lingard broke clear in second half. 6
Johan Mojica The left-back was pinned back by Trippier’s runs and failed to support Lerma going forward. 6
Wilmar Barrios His distribution was poor and he headbutted Henderson in the chest, but got away with yellow. 5
Carlos Sánchez Shielded the defence well in his holding midfield role but lost his head and gave away the penalty. 5
Jefferson Lerma Struggled to get into the game on the left of midfield and was replaced after 61 minutes. 6
Juan Cuadrado Had to do a lot more defending than he had anticipated but scored in the shootout. 6
Juan Quintero Did not manage to make up for Rodríguez’s absence and miscued his best chance. Substituted. 6
Radamel Falcao Isolated up front against England’s back three. Booked for dissent but scored his penalty. 6
Subs Carlos Bacca (for Lerma 62) 7, Mateus Uribe (for C Sánchez 79) 6, Luis Muriel (for Quintero 88) 6, Cristian Zapata (for Arias 116) 6.
England (3-3-2-2)
Jordan Pickford The hero of the day and produced the save of the tournament from Uribe’s long-range shot. 9
Kyle Walker Nearly gave Colombia an equaliser after giving the ball away but Cuadrado missed with his shot. 6
John Stones The City defender looked assured when England were in the lead but a bit more stretched after that. 6
Harry Maguire A reassuring presence in defence and carried the ball out nicely. Seemed to lose Mina for equaliser. 8
Kieran Trippier Did not create as much as in previous games. Could he have stopped Mina’s header on the line? 6
Jordan Henderson A calming presence in the centre of midfield. Booked for clashing with Mina. Missed his penalty. 7
Ashley Young A solid performance by the wing-back. Looked lively going forward and defended well. Replaced. 6
Jesse Lingard Covered a lot of ground, always wanting the ball, but never had any clear goalscoring opportunities. 6
Dele Alli Looked half a yard off the pace and nothing quite came off for him on the night. Replaced by Dier. 5
Raheem Sterling Started brightly, making all the right runs, but faded as the game wore on. Came off for Vardy. 6
Harry Kane Worked hard. Converted England’s penalty in normal time and another one in the shootout. 7
Subs Eric Dier (for Alli 81) 6, Jamie Vardy (for Sterling 88) 7, Danny Rose (for Young 102) 6, Marcus Rashford (for Trippier 113) 6.
