Cartoonists and commentators displayed solidarity with French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo after the attack on its office in Paris on Wednesday, in which 12 people, including 10 journalists, have been confirmed dead.
David Pope, cartoonist at the Canberra Times, posted this moving tribute:
Can't sleep tonight, thoughts with my French cartooning colleagues, their families and loved ones #CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/LqIMRCHPgK
— David Pope (@davpope) January 7, 2015
Cartoonist @plantu of Le Monde posted this, which translates as “Wholeheartedly with Charlie Hebdo.”
De tout coeur avec Charlie Hebdo. pic.twitter.com/8KwTipn3Wp
— PLANTU (@plantu) January 7, 2015
Magnus Shaw, a British writer, tweeted this cartoon of Charlie Brown, from the long-running comic strip Peanuts:
A terrible day for all cartoonists. #JeSuisCharlie pic.twitter.com/Ksbl89WLsE
— Magnus Shaw (@TheMagnusShaw) January 7, 2015
Indian cartoonist Satish Acharya tweeted this:
The little weapon! #CharlieHebdo #cartoon pic.twitter.com/VFFZD2f8Rz
— Satish Acharya (@satishacharya) January 7, 2015
Egyptian cartoonist Cheb Makhlouf published this illustration:
Egyptian cartoonist @makhlouz publishes this illustration, in solidarity with the fallen at #CharlieHebdo. pic.twitter.com/sXVWOhhrWG
— Jonathan Guyer (@mideastXmidwest) January 7, 2015
Brazilian cartoonist Carlos Latuff published this tribute:
#CharlieHebdo #ParisShooting pic.twitter.com/H4IJlNpFKc
— Middle East Monitor (@MiddleEastMnt) January 7, 2015
Dutch cartoonist Ruben Oppenheimer posted:
#CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/15O4YC2KWg
— Ruben L. Oppenheimer (@RLOppenheimer) January 7, 2015
Yannick Lemay from Québec, Canada, posted:
#jesuischarlie #charliehebdo pic.twitter.com/KEEpqGEKko
— ygreck (@ygreck) January 7, 2015
From a Spanish cartoonist:
Spanish caricaturists: "And this is our gun" #CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/bwugTPh0Al
— Paris P. Tuzun (@paristuzun) January 7, 2015
This strong image was posted by Philippe Henchoz:
Le crayon est une arme dont les fascistes, fondamentalistes et autres totalitaristes ont peur. #CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/cAsotPrNQ8
— Philippe Henchoz ن (@Philippe_VLG) January 7, 2015
A tribute from Belgium-based newspaper De Standaard:
Solidair met #CharlieHebdo - http://t.co/buPxo988Dk - cc @RLOppenheimer pic.twitter.com/fKlL1mRjPv
— De Standaard (@destandaard) January 7, 2015
French website Le Plus posted shared this cartoon:
#CharlieHebdo C'est la liberté qu'on assassine >> http://t.co/uvDK3N9Co3 pic.twitter.com/L81TX1Qwnr
— Le Plus (@leplus_obs) January 7, 2015
Artist Tomi Ungerer tweeted this cartoon with the caption, “No freedom without freedom of press”:
Solidarité avec #ChalieHebdo pic.twitter.com/3DWVu9bwg2
— Tomi Ungerer (@TomiUngerer) January 7, 2015
French illustrator Martin Vidberg tweeted:
Comment dessiner aujourd'hui ? Comment ne pas dessiner aujourd'hui ? pic.twitter.com/cNtJY6e7MK
— Martin Vidberg (@Vidberg) January 7, 2015
Columbus Dispatch cartoonist Nate Beeler posted his cartoon originally published in 2010:
RIP #CharlieHebdo cartoonists. My toon from 2010: pic.twitter.com/ahyyrlN57s
— Nate Beeler (@natebeeler) January 7, 2015
Cartoonist Loïc Sécheresse, from Paris, tweeted this vivid cartoon:
7 janvier 2015 / January 7, 2015 #CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/Bs6LpzeZGl
— Loïc Sécheresse (@loicsecheresse) January 7, 2015
Indian cartoonist Neelabh Banerjee tweeted:
Horrible attack.Cartoonists across the world are uniting against bloodshed and violence. @ibnlive @cnnbrk pic.twitter.com/QtTe9INeU9
— Neelabh Banerjee (@NeelabhToons) January 7, 2015
This caroon was posted by Stephen Strydom, from South Africa:
"this is not a religion" #IamCharlie #CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/d2cWyrDPSC
— stephen strydom (@stephen_strydom) January 7, 2015
Julien Fabro of Piwee, a French creative site, posted:
Des illustrateurs rendent hommage en dessin aux victimes de #CharlieHebdo > http://t.co/qBlHu5RAia pic.twitter.com/CZ7iIkxUeb
— Julien Fabro (@julienfabro) January 7, 2015
French cartoonist Gilles Roussel tweeted:
#CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/ay6ugiyvnd
— -Boulet- (@Bouletcorp) January 7, 2015
French graphic designer Jean Jullien posted:
I am devastated by what just happened in France. #CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/IxEbScqYFh
— jean jullien (@jean_jullien) January 7, 2015
Journalist Gilles Klein shared this cartoon from French newspaper Le Télégramme :
#CharlieHebdo : l'hommage de notre dessinateur Nono (Le Télégramme, Britanny) pic.twitter.com/r10I7RdMAS
— Gilles Klein (@GillesKLEIN) January 7, 2015
US Journalist Seth Fiegerman posted this cartoon from Indy Star:
This cartoon pretty much says it all #CharlieHebdo http://t.co/BrvOZKJspU pic.twitter.com/GwAbVMXYgn
— Seth Fiegerman (@sfiegerman) January 7, 2015
Lucille Clerk posted this to Instagram:
And finally, a cartoon by Washington Post cartoonist Ann Telnaes:
Washington Post cartoonist @AnnTelnaes on #CharlieHebdo. http://t.co/kwtvbInWJC pic.twitter.com/Ipk9Q6y0RA
— Anup Kaphle (@AnupKaphle) January 7, 2015
On social media, many expressed their support for the magazine by publishing its cartoons, including Charlie Hebdo’s controversial front cover “Charia Hebdo”, showing a cartoon depicting the Muslim prophet Muhammad.
The front cover below, which has also been widely tweeted, has the caption “Love is stronger than hate” and was published six days after the magazine’s offices were firebombed in 2011.
Six days after Charlie Hebdo’s offices were firebombed, their front cover was this. “Love is stronger than hate.” pic.twitter.com/7YInU4Cc00
— SimonNRicketts (@SimonNRicketts) January 7, 2015
On social media many retweeted the last post from the magazine’s official account, which was sent just hours before the attack. The cartoon is of Isis’s self-styled leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, with a caption reading: “Best wishes. To you too, al-Baghdadi.”
Meilleurs vœux, au fait. pic.twitter.com/a2JOhqJZJM
— Charlie Hebdo (@Charlie_Hebdo_) January 7, 2015
A French games developer pointed out that the cartoon in this week’s issue of the magazine attacked alleged anti-Muslim writer Michel Houellebecq.
Irony is that this week's cover of Charlie Hebdo is an attack against Islamophobe writer Houellebecq pic.twitter.com/9NjY5B8QWo
— Katharine (@haikus_by_KN) January 7, 2015
Many commentators also posted a satirical New Yorker cartoon by Robert Mankoff on the issue of freedom of speech, which was first published in September 2012.
A world without satire would look like this. Cartoon from the New Yorker 2012. pic.twitter.com/a6NmgyGF3H
— Noreena Hertz (@noreenahertz) January 7, 2015
Another Middle East-themed Charlie Hebdo cartoon, asking readers for funds. "It's certain he can't rely on Qatar!" pic.twitter.com/EYaSkQfrfF
— DavidKenner (@DavidKenner) January 7, 2015
An account that reacts to news by posting in the style of Tintin tweeted this image, by Belgian cartoonist Georges Remi:
#CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/REnwvn2WiN
— Le Petit XXIe (@lepetitXXIe) January 7, 2015
User Thierry Puget, @titi1960, tweeted the image below, which was widely shared by those wanting to express solidarity with the victims of the attack. Within an hour after news of the shooting broke, the hashtag #JeSuisCharlie began trending on Twitter worldwide:
#JESUISCHARLIE pic.twitter.com/4fkcjH0yaz
— Thierry Puget (@titi1960) January 7, 2015
Media organisations, including Germany’s Bild (below), also shared the photo:
#JeSuisCharlie #CharlieHebdo pic.twitter.com/etjVN897lW
— BILD (@BILD) January 7, 2015
Officials used this picture to express their solidarity, including the US embassy in Paris:
US Embassy in Paris changes Twitter pic to #JeSuisCharlie @USEmbassyFrance pic.twitter.com/amZEARKIHq
— Donie O'Sullivan (@donie) January 7, 2015
- This article was amended on 8 January 2015. A cartoon attributed to Banksy was in fact by Lucille Clerk. This has been changed