100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
OPS tells Tamil Nadu to discuss with Centre to bring petroleum products under GST
CHENNAI: AIADMK coordinator O Panneerselvam on Wednesday urged Tamil Nadu chief minister M K Stalin to hold discussions with Union…
OPS tells Tamil Nadu CM to discuss with Centre to bring petroleum products under GST
CHENNAI: AIADMK coordinator O Panneerselvam on Wednesday urged Tamil Nadu chief minister M K Stalin to hold discussions with Union…
Panneerselvam urges Stalin to take steps to bring petroleum products under GST net
AIADMK leader wants CM to discuss the issue with Nirmala Sitharaman
Ministry mulls 5 baht diesel tax cut
The Finance Ministry is considering a proposal from government officials to cut the diesel excise tax by 5 baht per…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Fuel duty cut completely wiped out as diesel price hits new record high
It comes as Labour is calling for a windfall tax on the soaring profits of oil and gas giants as…
With falling real incomes and rising prices many people don’t believe the story of prosperity Scott Morrison is preaching
Australians facing rising interest rates and rising average tax rates have little to celebrate
Get all your news in one place
Latest National news:
How do you know when someone is growing large quantities of cannabis?
How do you know when a shed or property is being used to grow large quantities of cannabis?
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Stoking fear and hatred held the Coalition in power – finally Australia had enough
For the first time in a decade the logjam to change the country’s politics may be shifting
Labor increasingly likely to form majority government as Liberals descend into turmoil
Anthony Albanese and his senior leadership and economics team will be sworn in on Monday as PM-elect declares he wants…
Michael McCormack suggests Barnaby Joyce’s unpopularity in inner-city contributed to Coalition’s loss
Former Nationals leader says he was ‘very popular’ in inner city and that mixed messages on net zero emissions ‘didn’t…
Informer: Morrison bulldozed in the wrong direction, happy news for Biloela family
Confessing to a bad habit of "bulldozing" at the eleventh hour, and promising to change his ways, was not enough…
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
How Albanese’s practical pivot on climate paved the way for a Greens surge
Analysis: As Labor focused on opportunities for working people in the transition to renewables, the Greens mounted a formidable on-the-ground…
Kurt Mann's rolled ankle became a 'ticking time-bomb'
The 156-game utility has missed the Knights past four games.

Central govt’s fiscal policies fanned inflation, says Tamil Nadu FM

By Dilasha Seth, Gireesh Chandra Prasad
Palanivel Thiagarajan, finance minister, Tamil Nadu

Tamil Nadu wants a two-year extension of goods and services tax (GST) compensation beyond June 2022, even as it strives to improve state revenue receipts, Thiagarajan said. Edited excerpts:

With inflation on the rise, how can states and the Centre offer relief? 

Inflation is managed largely through monetary policy and to a lesser extent by fiscal policy at the Union level. At the fiscal level you are kind of manipulating variables that are only likely to have medium to long term consequences, and relatively few variables that can have immediate consequences, whereas, monetary policy by design has immediate consequences, whether it is liquidity ratios or money supply. If you do something wrong for a long time, may be you escape the consequences because the market and (economic) cycles are going your way for a while, but eventually you have to pay the piper. What we’re seeing now is bad fiscal policy by the Union government for many years, exacerbated by the RBI being too slow to move on monetary policy. While there are external factors beyond our control, including disruption in the supply chain, uncertainty and uneven recovery from the pandemic, I would point to profoundly bad policies by the government of India over the last eight years and the lack of timely action that we are doing now, which in my opinion is too late. They should have started reacting earlier, when they first saw the signs of inflation, months ago.

Is there still room for you to cut taxes on petrol and diesel?

The government’s view is that we stand ready to do what we can. However, personally, I say that it is atrocious and is equivalent to an emotional blackmail in the (Centre-state) relationship. The Centre raised duties by five-six times in petrol and by 10 times in diesel. Then you cut when there is a 200% rise in petrol and 500% rise in diesel prices compared to 2014 and once you start fighting the consequences of your actions, you ask that all states should cut taxes. I think that it is ludicrous. The Centre did all the raising (of taxes) and now it is asking us to do all the reductions. With the Centre having 90% powers and 10% with states, it is just a mockery of democracy and logic. Lastly, unless every state around Tamil Nadu cuts taxes, it could lead to arbitrage.

With GST collections touching record levels, would TN still press for a two-year extension of compensation?

If you take out seasonality in GST figures, every month should set a new record. If your economy grows by 8%, your GST revenues should grow by at least 8% or more. So every month is supposed to set a new record. The Tamil Nadu chief minister has already said that the GST compensation for states should continue for at least two years to cover the two years of the pandemic. The Centre says that extending the compensation is going to create a free rider problem. The argument is that it takes away the incentive for states to improve their collection. Our view is that the Centre has taken away all our powers of taxation in favour of GST Council. It is the Centre’s job to compensate us because you have not left us with enough tools or degree of freedom to do our job (to raise revenue). 

What do you mean by flawed fiscal policy?

One, on the taxation side, I think petrol and diesel taxation is just an artefact of a broader move away from progressive direct taxes. Such taxes almost always disproportionately affect the poor and the weak, whereas the income taxes by design can be progressive. Second, the Centre has not been as good in execution as they have been in making announcements. That includes the privatisation pipeline. The whole approach has been shambolic. It has led to relatively low valuations and thus has not created the kind of execution capability that is the hallmark of good outcomes.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
OPS tells Tamil Nadu to discuss with Centre to bring petroleum products under GST
CHENNAI: AIADMK coordinator O Panneerselvam on Wednesday urged Tamil Nadu chief minister M K Stalin to hold discussions with Union…
OPS tells Tamil Nadu CM to discuss with Centre to bring petroleum products under GST
CHENNAI: AIADMK coordinator O Panneerselvam on Wednesday urged Tamil Nadu chief minister M K Stalin to hold discussions with Union…
Panneerselvam urges Stalin to take steps to bring petroleum products under GST net
AIADMK leader wants CM to discuss the issue with Nirmala Sitharaman
Ministry mulls 5 baht diesel tax cut
The Finance Ministry is considering a proposal from government officials to cut the diesel excise tax by 5 baht per…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Fuel duty cut completely wiped out as diesel price hits new record high
It comes as Labour is calling for a windfall tax on the soaring profits of oil and gas giants as…
With falling real incomes and rising prices many people don’t believe the story of prosperity Scott Morrison is preaching
Australians facing rising interest rates and rising average tax rates have little to celebrate
Get all your news in one place