100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
SAS soldier tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial Afghan killed in Darwan was an insurgent spotter
Person 11, called as a witness by Roberts-Smith, tells court Ali Jan a threat to Australian troops and legitimately killed
Woman who says Ben Roberts-Smith punched her sustained an injury in a fall earlier on same night, defamation trial hears
Person 17 does not contest she fell down stairs, but in evidence given to defamation trial in March says Roberts-Smith…
SAS witness denies Afghan teen murdered
A retired SAS soldier denies Ben Roberts-Smith murdered a terrified adolescent Afghan prisoner in the Federal Court defamation trial the…
SAS soldiers told commander that Ben Roberts-Smith not ‘fit and proper person’ to receive Victoria Cross, defamation trial hears
Serving SAS major, called as witness by Roberts-Smith, tells court two groups of colleagues raised concerns about awarding of medal,…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
SAS soldier tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial he felt hurt by best man who made murder allegation against him
Former comrade denies in court that he and Roberts-Smith killed handcuffed Afghan man Ali Jan as alleged by newspapers in…
YouTube videos of Ben Roberts-Smith trial cut after sensitive information exposed
The Federal Court will no longer upload regular YouTube videos of the high-profile defamation case of war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith,…
Get all your news in one place
Latest National news:
Police commanders take up new positions across Hunter
Most of the Hunter region's police commanders who were due to move amid a shake-up of local top brass have…
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Scene one, take two: Capital Film Festival launches second inaugural program
The inaugural program includes Emma Thompson's latest film, an offering from Luke Hemsworth and a satirical horror movie filmed in…
Liberal party should forgo ‘entitled’ Kooyong voters, says their own state Liberal MP
Tim Smith, who is retiring in November, says Coalition needs to ‘stop obsessing with the woke causes of inner-urban elites’…
Rare Works By Wurundjeri Artist William Barak Will Return To Vic, But They Had To Be Bought
The art was bought thanks to crowdfunding by the Wurundjeri Woi Wurrung Cutural Heritage Corporation, plus a last-minute donation by…
Three Knights Adam O'Brien thinks Brad Fittler should consider for NSW
O'Brien believes Brad Fittler should consider the three forwards.
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Two more Canberra schools turn to remote learning
Two more schools have switched some students to remote learning as staffing shortages continue.
Peter Dutton, a ferocious partisan, is now trying to walk both sides of the street
Dutton has a delicate task ahead if he becomes Liberal leader. If he tacks too far right, he could easily…

Captive Afghan teenage boy allegedly shot in the head, Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation trial hears

By Ben Doherty
Ben Roberts-Smith
Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation trial against three newspapers has heard testimony from a former comrade regarding the fate of an Afghan teen boy. Photograph: Dan Himbrechts/AAP

A missing photograph of a prisoner, which should have been marked “GB2”, has dominated evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation trial on Thursday, with allegations before the federal court that “GB2” was a terrified captive teenage boy shot in the head by Roberts-Smith.

A retired SAS comrade, anonymised before the court as Person 11, has been called by Roberts-Smith to give evidence in his defamation action against three Australian newspapers, whom he says defamed him in a series of reports that alleged he committed war crimes, including murder.

The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies any wrongdoing.

On his third day in the witness box, the questioning of Person 11, a close friend of Roberts-Smith’s, focused on a November 2012 SAS mission to Fasil, in Afghanistan’s southern Uruzgan province.

Under cross-examination, Person 11 was shown photographs of three prisoners, allegedly taken from a Toyota Hilux ute interdicted by Australian troops on a road through the village. The prisoners – known as Pucs for “person under control” – have tape on the back of their clothing giving details on where they were arrested including VEH for “vehicle”, RD for “road”, and, on one man’s tape, “driver”.

The three men are marked with the callsign of the soldiers who detained them – Gothic Bravo. The men are marked GB1, GB3, GB4. Their photographs – front and back – were taken at the Australian base at Tarin Kowt.

Person 11 told the court he did not recognise the men in the pictures.

Nicholas Owens SC, acting for the newspapers, told the court there was “no picture of GB2 in existence”, because the second prisoner detained from the Hilux never made it to the Australian base.

Owens showed Person 11 a photograph of a young Afghan man who had been shot dead, his body lying next to an AK47.

Person 11 said he had never seen the young man alive, nor did he recognise the photograph of his body.

Owens put it to Person 11 that the young man was GB2, and that he had been pulled from the car by Australian soldiers, detained, and handed over to Person 11 and Roberts-Smith during the raid on Fasil.

“Mr Owens I don’t recognise these individuals nor do I recall having Pucs handed over to me,” Person 11 replied.

Owens alleged the young man was taken into a compound by Roberts-Smith, who then shot the man with his pistol.

“I reject that, Mr Owens.”

Owens said: “I want to put it to you that the reason there is no photograph of the second Puc from Gothic Bravo is that he was murdered by Mr Roberts-Smith in the compound.”

Person 11: “I disagree with that.”

Owens said the AK47 next to the young man’s body was a “throw-down”: a piece of compromising equipment placed on or near the body of a deceased person as a post-facto justification for an illegitimate killing.

Person 11 denied Australian troops ever engaged in the practice of using throw-downs.

Roberts-Smith has consistently denied the allegation he murdered a young prisoner at Fasil. Giving evidence last year, he told the court the account was “baseless”, and the event could not have happened because he never fired his pistol in combat in Afghanistan.

I never had to engage with my pistol,” he said.

Roberts-Smith also rejected assertions he used “throw-downs”. He maintained all of his actions in Afghanistan abided with the Australian troops’ rules of engagement, and the Geneva conventions.

Another Australian soldier on the Fasil mission has earlier given evidence in the newspapers defence that Roberts-Smith told him he had murdered the young man.

Anonymised as Person 16, the soldier said he had arrested two of the four men inside the vehicle, including the young man.

“I made him out to be late teens … not a fully beard, a bit chubby, and shaking in terror.”

Person 16 told the court he handed the two prisoners over to Roberts-Smith, and about 15 minutes later, Roberts-Smith said over the troops’ radio network “two EKIA”. EKIA is an initialism for “enemy killed in action”.

In the days after the mission, Person 16 said he saw Roberts-Smith at the SAS’s Camp Russell within Australia’s Tarin Kowt base, and asked him: “What happened to that young fella who was shaking like a leaf?”

Roberts-Smith allegedly replied: “I shot that cunt in the head. Person 15 told me not to kill anyone on the last job. So I pulled out my 9mm, shot the cunt in the side of the head, blew his brains out. It was the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen.”

Roberts-Smith told the court the account was untrue and that the conversation never happened.

In his opening address to the court last year, Roberts-Smith’s barrister, Bruce McClintock SC, described the Fasil allegation against Roberts-Smith as “beyond ridiculous” and “insane”. “It’s Colonel Kilgore on ice,” he said, referencing the Vietnam war film Apocalypse Now.

“While the three fighting-age males were arrested and taken to Tarin Kowt, the adolescent boy was released,” McClintock told the court.

Person 11 has concluded his evidence. The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
SAS soldier tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial Afghan killed in Darwan was an insurgent spotter
Person 11, called as a witness by Roberts-Smith, tells court Ali Jan a threat to Australian troops and legitimately killed
Woman who says Ben Roberts-Smith punched her sustained an injury in a fall earlier on same night, defamation trial hears
Person 17 does not contest she fell down stairs, but in evidence given to defamation trial in March says Roberts-Smith…
SAS witness denies Afghan teen murdered
A retired SAS soldier denies Ben Roberts-Smith murdered a terrified adolescent Afghan prisoner in the Federal Court defamation trial the…
SAS soldiers told commander that Ben Roberts-Smith not ‘fit and proper person’ to receive Victoria Cross, defamation trial hears
Serving SAS major, called as witness by Roberts-Smith, tells court two groups of colleagues raised concerns about awarding of medal,…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
SAS soldier tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial he felt hurt by best man who made murder allegation against him
Former comrade denies in court that he and Roberts-Smith killed handcuffed Afghan man Ali Jan as alleged by newspapers in…
YouTube videos of Ben Roberts-Smith trial cut after sensitive information exposed
The Federal Court will no longer upload regular YouTube videos of the high-profile defamation case of war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith,…
Get all your news in one place