Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Politics
Shehab Khan, Samuel Osborne

Brexit: EU negotiator and Council chief tell Theresa May deal is not open for renegotiation

The EU's chief Brexit negotiator told Theresa May time was too short to find an alternative to the Irish border arrangement agreed in their Brexit deal and said the divorce deal was not open for renegotiation.

Michel Barnier told France's RTL radio the two-year divorce negotiations had looked for an alternative to the "Irish backstop", designed to ensure the border between Ireland and Northern Ireland remains free of border posts.

"No one, on either side, was able to say what arrangement would be needed to ensure controls on goods, animals and merchandise without having a border," Mr Barnier said. "We have neither the time, nor the technologies."

After a relatively successful night for Ms May during which the government defeated a number of attempts by MPs to secure control of the Brexit process, she will now have the Herculean task of convincing EU leaders to reopen talks. 

MPs approved an amendment tabled by Sir Graham Brady by 317 votes to 301 to accept Ms May’s Brexit deal as long as an alternative to the backstop could be found.

But the response from Europe was united and blunt.

"The Withdrawal Agreement is not open for renegotiation," European Council president Donald Tusk tweeted in what he said was a message to Ms May.

"Yesterday, we found out what the UK doesn't want. But we still don't know what the UK does want."

Jeremy Corbyn has said Labour MPs who defied the whip in yesterday’s votes “will be dealt with”, as he holds talks with Ms May on how the Brexit negotiations should move forward. 

Mr Corbyn met with the prime minister to discuss how a conensus could be reached on the Brexit negotiations only weeks after he had rejected Ms May’s initial invitiation.

Follow how the day at Westminster unfolded

Welcome to The Independent's coverage of the day's political events.
Quick recap of what happened last night: 
 
  • Theresa May defeated a number of attempts by MPs to secure control of the Brexit process.
  • Government secured a key victory whereby MPs will accept Ms May's Brexit deal as long as an alternative to the backstop could be found. 
  • MPs did however vote to take no-deal off the table.
  • Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn agreed to meet with Theresa May to hold Brexit talks. 
  • EU leaders ruled out reopening the negotiations. 
Jeremy Corbyn has been accused of backtracking after initially refusing to meet Theresa May while no-deal remains a possibility. 
 
Barry Gardiner, the shadow international trade secretary, is refuting these accusations. 
 
Speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today he said: 
Jeremy always said that all she needed to do at this stage, she didn't need to actually physically remove it, she didn't need to pass legislation, she just needed to accept that that was the will of the House and that would be what happened.

Parliament yesterday explicitly said that they did not want no deal to happen and the Prime Minister, when it came to the summing-up after the debate, accepted that that was the will of the House.

She has said she will be coming back in two weeks' time, she hopes, with something from Europe, but there will be another opportunity at that stage if she has run down the clock further, for a legislative vehicle to then be put in place by Parliament to avoid no-deal."

If you need a catch up on yesterday's events, here is overnight lead from our Political Editor Joe Watts:
 

Theresa May was just given another chance to save her Brexit deal

May is now on a collision course with EU leaders who are adamant there can be no reopening of the withdrawal agreement
BREAKING NEWS: Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has accepted an invitation from Theresa May for talks on Brexit after Prime Minister's Questions.
Brexit secretary Stephen Barclay is on BBC Radio 4 this morning. Here's a brief summary of what he said: 
  • Britain will leave with no-deal if nothing is agreed by 29 March but this will be disruptive 
  • Alternatives to the backstop will be explored 
  • Theresa May will be meeting with Jeremy Corbyn later today
The head of the CBI has warned that British businesses are likely to accelerate their planning for a no-deal Brexit following the vote in parliament on Tuesday night that ordered the prime minister to renegotiate the divorce deal.
 
Carolyn Fairbairn said she did not think any company would have taken reassurance from the events on Tuesday, when lawmakers signalled they did not want to leave the European Union without a deal,

NHS trusts could "quickly run out of vital medical supplies" should the UK crash out of the European Union without a deal, a hospital boss has claimed.

Dr David Rosser, chief executive of the University Hospitals Birmingham (UHB) NHS Foundation Trust, said the service could face a "completely unprecedented challenge" despite central stockpiling.

The points were raised in a memo to the UHB board of directors last week after being asked to draw up details on readiness for a no-deal Brexit.

In the memo, Dr Rosser said:
In terms of the potential for major operational impact and severe and widespread risks to patient safety, by far the greatest concern is the availability of medicines, devices and clinical supplies.

Whilst we have not seen large scale departures so far, it is quite likely that an even more hostile public atmosphere towards Europe in the event of no deal, combined with a further fall in sterling against the euro and other currencies, would affect staff morale and potentially decisions to stay and work in the UK.

"It is difficult to prepare detailed predictions or plans for such unpredictable concerns, however it is difficult to see any scenario whereby a no deal or other chaotic Brexit does not significantly impact our ability to safely treat our patients."

Michel Barnier speaking in Brussels this morning said:

The position of the European Union is very clear.

It has been expressed yesterday by president (Donald) Tusk and president (Jean-Claude) Juncker will make a statement to the parliament this afternoon."

MEP Philippe Lamberts, who sits on the influential Brexit Steering Committee at the European Parliament has said that no deal is 'lesser of two evils'
 
Last night, Jon Stone, our man in Brussels, wrote about how the EU took less than 10 minutes to reject MP's demands to bin the backstop:

EU takes less than 10 minutes to reject MPs’ demand to bin Irish backstop

Spokesperson says withdrawal agreement is still not up for renegotiation
 
Asked if he thought Theresa May could secure a new deal with the EU in the next 
fortnight, Mr Barclay said:
The vote was last night, the PM will be meeting with the leader of the opposition later today, there is an ongoing process... we are working hard in the national interest."
From our Parliamentary Sketch Writer: 
Rob Merrick, our Deputy Political Editor outlines some concerning news for Theresa May. 
 
The EU would apparently settle for a no-deal Brexit than abandon the backstop.
 

EU would rather no-deal Brexit than abandon Irish backstop, Theresa May told

Prime minister also warned that renegotiation would backfire on UK – by reopening controversies over Gibraltar, fishing and the Brexit 'divorce bill'
Yesterday Jeremy Corbyn was criticised for not giving way to one of his own MPs, Angela Smith. 
 
After making several attempts to intervene and failing, Michael Gove made an active effort to point her out. 
 
She has been on Today this morning, explaining what she thinks happened.

Ms Smith told Today that she had Tory chief whip Julian Smith's note that was waved at Mr Corbyn during the incident. She said she was keeping it for "posterity".

"It actually says 'Angela wants a second referendum' and I think that is the reason why my leader potentially did not want to take my point.

My point would be that given that we have had the vote of confidence it is looking increasingly likely that the renegotiation of the deal is going to prove very difficult - Theresa May has chosen to go with the backstop and go with the ERG group rather than develop a consensus with the Commons.

On that basis I think the leader of the Labour Party needs to move to the next stage in party conference policy and adopt the People's Vote as party policy and pursue it now with all vengeance in Parliament."

The European Parliament is set to debate the state of play on the UK’s withdrawal from the EU today at around 14.30 UK time, one day after the vote in the UK‘s House of Commons.

Here is yesterday's sketch from Tom Peck - Theresa May has taken back control of Brexit - trouble is, she still has no idea what to do with it

Sketch: Theresa May has taken back control of Brexit – trouble is, she still has no idea what to do with it

There is no spice worth adding to the events themselves. No salt can augment the terrifying umami of such base inadequacy
 
A round up from yesterday - which amendments passed yesterday:
 

Please allow a moment for the liveblog to load



The Independent has launched its #FinalSay campaign to demand that voters are given a voice on the final Brexit deal.

Sign our petition here

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.