Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Politics
Adam Forrest, Ashley Cowburn, Benjamin Kentish

Brexit news - LIVE: Parliament descends further into farce after debate abandoned due to leak, as MPs pile pressure on Corbyn over second referendum

A plan to prevent a no-deal Brexit and delay the date of the UK’s exit from EU is being debated by the Lords this evening, after squeaking through the Commons.

It came as Chancellor Philip Hammond said a second referendum was a “perfectly credible proposition” and indicated the government would be prepared to compromise on a customs union.

Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn's teams also met again after 11 Labour MPs, including four frontbenchers, urging their leader to insist on a second referendum in an open letter to The Independent.

Please allow a moment for the liveblog to load:

Good morning, and welcome to The Independent’s live coverage of the Brexit crisis on 4 April as talks between Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn are set to continue following the first “constructive” discussions on Wednesday.
If you missed it on Wednesday evening, here’s the chancellor Philip Hammond saying a second referendum remains a “credible” idea. 
 

Yvette Cooper’s European Union Withdrawal Bill (No 5) passed the Commons by 313 votes to 312 around 11.30pm last night, and will be debated in the Lords today.
 
Here’s our Political Correspondent Benjamin Kentish with all the details.
 

MPs back Brexit delay by one vote

Yvette Cooper's bill to allow MPs to vote on asking EU for new extension to Article 50 is narrowly approved by Commons
Cabinet minister Matt Hancock’s comments this morning provides yet more evidence No.10 will abide by the majority of MPs desire to avoid a no-deal Brexit.
 

Conservative grandee Ken Clarke said he has “never seen a bigger shambles” and called for a longer extension to Brexit.
 
“I think the EU would give us an extension – they would be very angry with us – but I think the EU too would suffer if they just patched something together in the next eight days because it got fed up with our inability to make a clear consensus policy,” he told the Today programme. 
If you’re just catching up with the dramatic late night vote in the Commons to avert a no-deal Brexit, here’s the moment it happened.
 
The House of Lords will start debating on Yvette Cooper’s bill to force the government to seek a Brexit delay to prevent a chaotic no-deal departure at 10.30am today. The aim is to debate the legislation, which needs the approval of the upper chamber to become law, in a single day.
Shadow attorney general Shami Chakrabarti said a second referendum was only a means of breaking a deadlock, and not an end in itself.
 
“It became part of our policy for the purposes of breaking deadlock, that’s the purpose of it, it’s not an end in itself. Obviously it’s a process thing, it’s not a substance thing,” the Labour spokeswoman told Today.
 
It won’t please the Labour MPs who view a second referendum very much as a substance thing – 11 of them, including 4 frontbenchers, wrote an open letter to The Independent making the case for a People’s Vote.
Philip Hammond had a quite a lot to say about the government’s position in his latest interview, including the suggestion a second referendum is still on the table. Here’s Tom Barnes with all the details.
 

Chancellor says second Brexit referendum is 'perfectly credible proposition'

Hammond appears to exert pressure on May, saying a new referendum 'deserves to be tested in parliament'
The health secretary Matt Hancock said a no-deal Brexit is now “very unlikely” as he suggested he could accept a customs union compromise.
 
He said that while he “profoundly” disagreed with Jeremy Corbyn on economic and security matters, he believed the only remaining way to get Brexit through was by seeking Labour votes.
 
“I would much prefer the Prime Minister's deal to a customs union, to be frank,” he told Today. “I want to deliver Brexit, I have spoken about the problems of a customs union and I don’t think it’s as good for the country. But I also want to deliver Brexit.”
 
Asked about the chances of a no-deal exit, Mr Hancock said: “I think that they are very unlikely because of the bill that the House of Commons passed last night.”
 
But Mr Hancock said he was “very, very strongly against” a second referendum – despite Philip Hammond describing it as a “perfectly credible” proposal.

An MP from the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) Sir Jeffrey Donaldson has said a customs union with the EU, as a "temporary staging post",  is something his party could possibly get behind. 

The remarks from the MP from the party which has repeatedly rejected Theresa May's Brexit agreement comes after the chancellor Philip Hammond also suggested that some kind of customs agreement is "clearly" going to be part of the solution to the impasse at Westminster.

A permanent customs arrangement is one of the key demands of Labour, and Jeremy Corbyn himself remains in talks with the prime minister.

Speaking to BBC Newsline, Mr Donaldson said: "We would have preferred a form of Brexit that enables the UK to negotiate new trade agreements with other countries.

"That's part of the reason for Brexit and maybe a customs union might be a temporary staging post towards that objective.

"We will wait to see what the Prime Minister brings before Parliament but we are very clear, we want a Brexit that delivers for all of the United Kingdom and that keeps the United Kingdom together - that is our objective."

With talk around Westminster over the possibility of a general election, the Conservative MP Johnny Mercer has used an interview with the Spectator magazine to offer his votes on any snap vote - and it's not great. 

He says the Tories will be "wiped out", adding: "We'll get top-sliced and bottom-sliced by those who don't want any Brexit - and those who want a Ukip version of Brexit. We'll just get left behind and Jeremy Corbyn will be prime minister."

Austrian foreign minister Karin Kneissl has said it is "very difficult to imagine" how an extension beyond the European elections is "feasible" ahead of the EU summit next Wednesday. 

"It remains to be seen what kind of cohesion is still available among the EU 27 - I'm not in a position to tell whether there really will be this unanimous readiness to accept," she told Radio 4's Today programme.

Brexit secretary Stephen Barclay is now taking questions in the Commons, after MPs last night narrowly passed an emergency bill to avert a no-deal scenario, by forcing Theresa May to seek a further extension to Article 50.

The legislation, proposed by Labour MP Yvette Cooper, instructs ministers to hold a House of Commons vote on a proposal to ask the EU for another extension to the Article 50 period. It was approved by MPs by just one vote.

The bill is designed to ensure that Britain does not crash out of the EU on 12 April – the date it is currently due to leave.

You can read more on Wednesday's late-night voter here:

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/brexit-no-deal-latest-theresa-may-jeremy-corbyn-article-50-yvette-cooper-a8853911.html

Cabinet ministers have openly clashed over the prospect for a new Brexit referendum after chancellor Philip Hammond suggested a fresh vote was a "perfectly credible" proposal.

Health secretary Matthew Hancock set himself against his cabinet colleague, saying he was "very, very strongly against" a Final Say vote to break the Brexit deadlock.

Mr Hammond risked Brexiteer fury when he said there was a "perfectly credible" case for a new referendum and signalled support for a move towards a softer Brexit.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/brexit-second-referendum-philip-hammond-matt-hancock-deal-eu-a8854151.html

In DExEU questions, Stephen Barclay, the Brexit secretary faces criticism from MPs over the possibility of Britain taking part in the European elections in May due to an extension of the Article 50 negotiating period.
 
One Conservative said it would amount to betraying those who voted leave at the referendum in 2016.

Robin Walker, the Brexit minister, is asked in the Commons whether government policy is still against a second referendum.

He confirms this is the case, and adds a fresh public vote "would create further division, and further uncertainty - we don't think it's the right way forward".

It's a remarkably different response than the chancellor Philip Hammond, who last night said there a second referendum is a "perfectly credible proposition"

A motion has been tabled in the House of Lords for Yvette Cooper's bill (against a no-deal Brexit) to be rushed through the second chamber in a single day - enabling it to become law by the end of play today.
 
The move was put forward by Labour's deputy leader in the Lords, Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town.
 

Labour's Stephen Timms says it is "inconceivable" the government could now pass a Brexit deal in time for the EU summit next Wednesday - fair to say that is a widespread opinion among in MPs in the Commons. 

But Brexit minister Kwasi Kwarteng attempts at offering an optimistic reply, saying he would not describe anything as inconceviable. 

A second Labour MP describes the Brexit frontbench as "zombie ministers". 

"First of all we're not zombies," replies Mr Kwarteng. "I'd like to confirm that to the House.

Shadow Brexit Keir Starmer asks his opposite number whether no deal will only happen if the House of Commons agrees to it.

Barclay replies and refers to the legislation passed last night preventing a no-deal Brexit. But he points out any extension to the negotiating period under Article 50 is at the discretion of the EU 27.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.