Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Politics
Adam Forrest, Samuel Osborne, Chris Baynes, Benjamin Kentish, Tom Barnes

Brexit news - live: Tory MP quits in disgust after Commons votes to reject every single suggested way forward

MPs have rejected all alternative Brexit options put forward in indicative votes as one Tory MP quit seconds after results were announced claiming the party “refuses to compromise”.

The Commons turned down options to pursue a Common Market solution, a second referendum and the revocation of Article 50. A Customs Union proposed by Ken Clarke was rejected by just three votes.

Moments after the vote took place, Tory MP Nick Boles resigned the party whip claiming his colleagues “refuse to compromise”. His Common Market 2.0 proposal had been defeated 261 votes to 282, with 228 Conservatives voting against.

Please allow a moment for the live blog to load...

Welcome to The Independent's live coverage of today's political events.
 
MPs are set to take back control of the Brexit agenda in a new attempt to find an alternative to Theresa May's deal in a series of "indicative votes".
 
They are also due to debate a Revoke Article 50 petition, which became the best-supported proposal in the history of the House of Commons and Government's e-petitions website.
Ms May spent the weekend fending off Conservative divisions over Brexit, amid speculation she could call a snap general election if her fourth attempt to pass her deal fails.

Conservative divisions deepen over Brexit plan as cabinet minister warns Theresa May of 'national crisis'

'If parliament is... voting in favour of a softer Brexit, then I don’t think it’s sustainable to ignore parliament’s position'
Over six million people have signed a petition calling on the government to halt the Brexit process. 
 
The Revoke Article 50 petition, to be debated by MPs today, is the best-supported proposal in the history of the House of Commons and Government's e-petitions website.

Rejecting the often-repeated claim EU withdrawal is the "will of the people", it calls for the revocation of the Article 50 letter informing the European Council of the UK's intention to leave.

The letter can be withdrawn by the UK unilaterally, without the need for EU agreement, leaving Britain free to continue as a member on its current terms.

The petition quickly passed the 100,000-signature threshold needed for it to be debated in parliament, with the official committee revealing nearly 2,000 signatures were being completed every minute at one point.

A 2016 petition calling for a second EU referendum should the winning vote and turnout not reach a certain threshold had been the most signed petition, at almost 4.2 million.

The Revoke Article 50 petition also passed another proposal which sought to prevent Donald Trump from making a state visit to the UK, which had 1.9 million sign-ups.
Theresa May's chief whip has said her government should have claimed a softer Brexit was inevitable after it lost its majority in a 2017 election, the BBC has reported.

Julian Smith was also strongly critical of a lack of discipline among senior ministers, the broadcaster said.
 
Mr Smith said when it failed to get a majority in the 2017 election, "the government as a whole probably should have just been clearer on the consequences of that. The parliamentary arithmetic would mean that this would be inevitably a kind of softer type of Brexit."

He said he had seen ministers "sitting around the cabinet table... trying to destabilise her [May]."
The Democratic Unionist Party has insisted it will continue to vote against Ms May's Brexit deal.

The party's Brexit spokesman Sammy Wilson told the BBC: "The implications for Northern Ireland are far, far too serious.
 
"First of all, it would take us away from the country that we fought to stay part of.
 
"And secondly, it would break us away from the economy on which we are dependent.
 
"Because, of course, the GB economy is the most important economy given where we export our goods and bring our goods from."
Business minister Margot James has agreed with Tory chief whip Julian Smith's assessment that the government should have accepted that losing its majority at the 2017 election "inevitably" meant there would need to be a "softer type of Brexit"...
 
Tory grandee Ken Clarke will table a motion proposing that the UK join a customs union with the EU after Brexit when MPs take part in the second round of "indicative votes" tonight.
 
The same motion was defeated by just six votes during the first round of indicative votes last week, fuelling speculation that it is likely to win a majority tonight.
 
Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today, Clarke admits that there is now "a huge risk" of the Conservative Party splitting but says MPs need to embrace compromise and "isolate" those who hold "totally fanatical views" on Brexit.
 
 
 
The EU is running out of patience with Britain over Brexit, the president of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, has warned.

Jean-Claude Juncker warns EU's 'patience coming to an end' over Brexit

European Commission chief says he wants parliament to make clear ‘which way they want to follow now’
Liz Truss, the chief secretary to the Treasury, has disagreed with Tory chief whip Julian Smith's claim that the government should have pivoted to a softer Brexit when it lost its majority at the 2017 general election.
 
She told BBC Radio 4's Today:
 
"If you look at the parliamentary arithmetic now, it's not clear that something like a customs union actually commands support - in fact, the prime minister's deal got more votes than a customs union got, it got more votes than Common Market 2.0 got.
 
"So it's not clear to me that going softer is the way to command support. There have already been indicative votes and the customs union has failed to pass muster on several occasions already."
 
The UK joining a customs union would be "incredibly problematic", she added, saying she would "very strongly argue against that".
 
Full story: Tory chief whip Julian Smith attacks cabinet ministers for 'worst example of discipline in British political history' 
 

Tory chief whip attacks cabinet ministers for 'worst example of discipline in British political history'

Julian Smith also suggests softer Brexit was inevitable after PM gambled away Tories' majority at 2017 snap election
With potential successors to Ms May beginning to jostle for her position following her announcement she will quit once she has finally delivered on Brexit, transport secretary Chris Grayling has suggested the next leader should be a senior figure who campaigned for Brexit.

He indicated the younger generation of contenders - which includes Dominic Raab, Liz Truss and Matt Hancock - should wait until after the next general election due to take place in 2022.

"The next two or three years are going to be very tough because the European stuff is not going to go away," he told The Daily Telegraph.

"We have got to negotiate a free trade agreement, sort out where we are, but also as we get into the 2020s, we are going to have to pass the torch to a new generation.

"Is the person who takes us through the next two or three years and sorts out Brexit and gets the sort of hard time that Theresa has had, the same person who we want to be leading us into the 2027 general election?"
Here are the motions that have been tabled for MPs to vote on during tonight's "indicative votes". They won't all be selected, however, with Commons speaker John Bercow expected to choose only three or four - significantly fewer than the eight he selected last week.
 

Motion A - John Baron (Conservative ) - Seeks to amend the withdrawal agreement to give the UK a unilateral right to exit the controversial Northern Ireland backstop.

Motion B - John Baron (Conservative) - Calls for a no-deal Brexit on 12 April if no Withdrawal Agreement can be agreed by the Commons.

Motion C - Ken Clarke (Conservative) - Requires any Brexit deal to include a commitment to negotiate a "permanent and comprehensive UK-wide customs union with the EU".

Motion D - Nick Boles (Conservative) - Would see the UK remain in the single market and negotiate a "comprehensive customs arrangement" until a wider trade deal could be agreed. Dubbed "Common Market 2.0."

Motion E - Peter Kyle (Labour) - Says any Brexit deal approved by the Commons should be put to a confirmatory referendum.

Motion F - Graham Jones (Labour) - Would requires a public referendum to be held on whether to leave the EU without a deal.

Motion G - Joanna Cherry (SNP) - Says the government must give MPs a vote on whether to opt for no-deal if no withdrawal agreement can be agreed. If this is voted down, ministers would have to revoke Article 50.  

Motion H - George Eustice (Conservative) - Would see the UK remain in the single market but not a customs union. 

Conservative Eurosceptic leader Jacob Rees-Mogg has said he is "very concerned" that Theresa May will agree to try to negotiate a customs union with the EU.
 

He told LBC:

"My concern is that the prime minister is more concerned to avoid a no-deal Brexit than anything else.

"And therefore I am very concerned that she could decide to go for a customs union tacked onto her deal."

Germany's deputy foreign minister, Micheal Roth, has described Brexit as a "big shitshow".
 
He said:
"Brexit is a big shitshow - I say that now very undiplomatically.
 
I don’t know if William Shakespeare could have come up with such a tragedy, but who will foot the bill?"
 
In an astonishing attack on UK government ministers, he said 90 per cent of the cabinet had “no idea how workers think, live, work and behave” and said senior politicians would not suffer from Brexit because they were “born with silver spoons in their mouths [and] went to private schools and elite universities”.
Jacob Rees-Mogg has been criticised after sharing a video promoting the leader of Germany's far-right AfD party 
 

Tory racism storm deepens as Jacob Rees-Mogg promotes video of German far-right leader

Parts of AfD have been put under state surveillance in Germany for neo-Nazi links
Labour MP David Lammy has led criticism of Jacob Rees-Mogg for sharing a video of the leader of Germany's far-right AfD party...
 
The Independent Group's Heidi Allen was visibly emotional during an appearance on the BBC's Victoria Derbyshire Show
 
The MP became tearful after being shown an old clip of her speaking in the House of Commons about her experience of having an abortion. 
 
She said:
 
"I still get upset seeing that - sorry.
 
It brings back memories. I'm not saying it was a hard thing to say publicly, because that's my job - I have to be strong and I have to say things that need saying, but you compromise your own private space by doing that."
 
Asked if she thought that speaking publicly about her abortion was the right thing to do, she added:
 
"From the overwhelming support that I received from women and men right across the UK, particularly in Northern Ireland, which of course is what the debate was centred around, it was absolutely the right thing because it gave then a fighting chance."
Former prime minister Gordon Brown has said the Labour Party under Jeremy Corbyn has "let the Jewish community down"
 

In a video for the Hope Not Hate campaign group, he said:

"The Labour Party has always had a long, proud and noble tradition of standing up against all forms of prejudice and racism.
 
"But in the last few years it has let the Jewish community down.
 
"They should never have allowed legitimate criticism of the current Israeli government to act as a cover for the demonisation of the entire Jewish people."

He added:

"The message to the Jewish community should be clear and unequivocal: 'You will never walk alone and we will never walk on by on the other side. We must never tolerate intolerance.'

"Solidarity means standing up with those who are under attack and that is why I am joining as an affiliated member. I urge all my colleagues to do the same.

"Tackling antisemitism and racism and fighting for equality is not a diversion nor a distraction from our purpose as party - it is our purpose as a party.

"We will never allow evil to triumph over good and neither will the British people."

Guy Verhofstadt, the European Parliament's Brexit co-ordinator, has described Britain's exit from the EU as a "tragic reality" and urged MPs to "find a compromise and stop this chaos".
 
 
 
Jacob Rees-Mogg has denied supporting Germany's far-right AfD party, despite tweeting a video of its leader discussing Brexit.
 
Asked about the row during a phone-in on LBC, the prominent Brexiteer said:
 

"I'm not supporting the AfD, but this is a speech made in the Bundestag of real importance because it shows a German view of Brexit.

"And it is saying to the Germans, 'Look, you're paying for this, you're going to pay more for this' and Angela Merkel has tied herself up in knots with the French to the disadvantage of the Germans.

"And I think it's important people know that this is a strand of German political thinking.

"I don't think retweeting is an endorsement of things that other people stand for - it's just pointing out that there's something interesting that is worth watching."

Public splits between rival cabinet ministers had deepened earlier in the day ahead of the key votes.

Tory chief whip Julian Smith said the government should have accepted earlier that it would “inevitably” need to settle on a softer Brexit, but Liz Truss, the chief secretary to the Treasury, said such an outcome would be “incredibly problematic”.  

Mr Smith also hit out at his cabinet colleagues, saying they were the “worst example of ill-discipline in cabinet in British political history”.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.