Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Politics
Chris Baynes, Lizzy Buchan, Peter Stubley

Brexit: John Bercow says there is 'arguable case' government has committed contempt by failing to publish legal advice

Theresa May is facing a constitutional crisis after six opposition parties joined forces to accuse the government of contempt of Parliament over its failure to publish its full Brexit legal advice.

The Commons Speaker, John Bercow, said there was "an arguable case" that the government had committed contempt, after he was asked by Labour, the SNP, the Liberal Democrats, Plaid Cymru, the Green Party and the DUP to begin proceedings.

Earlier, Attorney general Geoffrey Cox admitted the UK could be locked into a customs backstop under the prime minister’s Brexit blueprint.

Mr Cox confirmed that neither the UK nor EU would be able to unilaterally end the Northern Irish backstop arrangement if it came into force, in an address to MPs.

It also comes as The Independent’s petition calling for a Final Say referendum on Brexit was delivered to Downing Street, after more than a million people backed the campaign.

See below for live updates:

We're wrapping up our live politics coverage for today. Thanks for reading.

Here are the key points from a day which has left Theresa May facing a full-blown constitutional crisis:

Commons Speaker John Bercow has told MPs he believes there is an "arguable case that a contempt has been committed" by the government over its failure to publish its full Brexit legal advice. 

Nicola Sturgeon, who held talks with Theresa May today, has urged the prime minister to change course to avoid an "utterly disastrous" no-deal Brexit.

The Scottish first minister said a "workable alternative" will be urgently needed if  "the PM's deal is defeated in the Commons, as is widely expected".

She added the SNP would join other parties in calling for an extension Article 50 process and would propose an amendment to the meaningful vote later this week".

Downing Street said the prime minister had spoken to Ms Sturgeon about support for the government's Brexit deal from "from fishermen, farmers and business leaders".

Ms May "urged the first minister to listen to these voices in their support of the deal as opposed to risking a no-deal Brexit or going back to square one of negotiations", a spokesman added.

Geoffrey Cox has now finished taking questions after more than two-and-half hours. The Speaker, John Bercow, notes notes he looks "relieved".

John Bercow says he has only just seen the letter calling for the government to be held in contempt and intends to come to "rapid decision", possibly tonight or "at the earliest opportunity".

Cox says he will also write to the speaker tonight with submissions from the government.

Geoffrey Cox says the government was wrong not to oppose a motion last month which called for publication of his final and full Brexit legal advice.

Asked if he was consulted about whether to opposite it, he says he was not.

Labour peer Charlie Falconer, the former lord chancellor and justice secretary, has accused the attorney general of "fundamentally misstating the Constitution":
 

Here's the opposition parties' letter, calling for the government to be held in contempt, in full:

 

Labour's Chris Byrant says he has even less sympathy Geoffrey Cox after today's proceedings. Surely the government has to "bow the knee to Parliament" sometimes, he suggests.

Cox says the House has no power to demand documents which are not official. 

Labour's Chris Williamson says the attorney general could be expelled from Parliament if found in contempt. Is he happy to take that risk?

Geoffrey Cox says he understands MPs' concerns and is "truly sorry" but says it would be against the public interest to publish the advice while Brexit negotiations are ongoing.

Theresa May is facing a full-blown constitutional crisis after opposition parties joined forces to accuse the government of contempt of Parliament, writes The Independent's political correspondent Ben Kentish.

Here's his full story: 

Six opposition parties have written a joint letter to the speaker asking him to launch contempt proceedings against the government over its failure to publish its Brexit legal device. 

The letter is signed jointly by MPs from Labour, the SNP, the Lib Dems, the DUP, Plaid Cymru, and the Greens.

Shadow Brexit secretary, Labour's Keir Starmer, said: "The government has failed to publish the Attorney General's full and final legal advice on the Brexit deal, as was ordered by Parliament.

"We have been left with no option but to write to the Speaker of the House of Commons to ask him to launch proceedings of contempt."

Ex-Brexit secretary David Davis and former Brexit minister Suella Braverman have both delivered scathing verdicts of the legal advice.

Mr Davis said: “The legal summary document is worse than we feared: the backstop customs union is indefinite, the UK would be a rule taker and the European Court is in charge of our destiny, rather than the sovereign UK Parliament.  This is not Brexit.

“This only reinforces what I’ve been saying for weeks: the legal advice must be published in full so that the House of Commons can debate this properly.”

Ms Braverman said: "With very little time until the historic vote on the deal, it is only proper that MPs are fully aware of the legally implications of what they are deciding upon.

"The duty that we owe our constituents and the country demands that we should go into this vote with our eyes wide open. Withholding the advice will keep parliament in the dark and this can't be right."

Mr Cox bellowed "there is nothing to see here" as he defended the decision not to publish the full Brexit legal advice.

After Labour veteran Harriet Harman raised concerns, Mr Cox said he could not take a step which he "firmly and truly believes would be contrary to the public interest".

He went on: "I ask the House to understand that it is only that consideration that is motivating me and this government in declining at this stage to break the convention that applies to both sides of the House when they are in government.

"There is nothing to see here."

Conservative former chancellor Ken Clarke thanked the Attorney General for addressing "paranoia and conspiracy theories" around the Northern Ireland Protocol and providing a "perfectly sensible" solution to the border problem.

Mr Cox responded: "I make no bones about it - I would have preferred to have seen a unilateral right of termination in this backstop.

"I would have preferred to have seen a clause to exit if negotiations had irretrievably broken down.

"But I'm prepared to lend my support to this agreement because I do not believe that we're likely to be entrapped in it permanently."

SNP home affairs spokeswoman Joanna Cherry, a QC, asked whether there was anything to prevent the backstop becoming a permanent arrangement.

Geoffrey Cox agreed there was nothing in law to stop this but such an agreement based on Article 50 would be "highly vulnerable to legal challenge" and therefore, in his legal opinion, unlikely.

He said: "If negotiations irretrievably broke down it would de facto become permanent and it would therefore fall to be seriously challenge-able in the Court of Justice of the European Union for being invalid.

"That legal certainty by itself is sufficient to promote the EU to do a deal with us."

Geoffrey Cox says, with typical rhetorical flourish, that he has "wrestled with" the decision to support this plan, "as I am a unionist". However he says the divergence is as much an instrument of pain to the EU as the UK.
 
He was responding to a question from Nigel Dodds, of the DUP, who said it was "deeply unsatisfactory" that the UK parliament would not be able to get out of the arrangements, leaving it reliant on lawyers.
Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.