Love Island's dramatic re-coupling on Thursday evening saw Abigail end up single after Toby strolled back into the main villa holding hands with Mary from Casa Amor.
Abigail had only recently partnered with Toby before he snuck off to the second villa with the rest of the boys.
Toby clearly wasn't feeling loyal and cracked on with Mary and even shared a bed with her.
As host Laura Whitmore asked Toby how he felt about the fact that Abigail had stayed loyal to him, he looked rather sheepish.
"I dunno what to say at the moment, I’m shocked," he replied. "I just thought it was early days."
Abigail looked gutted, but she wasn't the only one who was shocked at Toby's decision.
Chloe, who was previously in a couple with Toby before Abigail, held her hand over her mouth before saying: "What a pr**k."
But it seems some viewers weren't even surprised at Toby's behaviour, with one person joking on Twitter: "at this point Toby’s a prostitute moving from girl to girl #LoveIsland."
Someone else posted: "Toby is just hop scotching between girls to stay in the race. What a player #LoveIsland."
A third added: "my heart hurts for abi... how is toby playing THREE girls, mary better run. #LoveIsland."
Meanwhile, Chloe chose to partner up with Dale while Hugo walked back into the main villa with Amy.
Announcing her decision, Chloe said: "It’s fair to say my journey in Love Island hasn’t been plain sailing.
"I think it’s fair to say I’ve not stopped laughing since you came in, I’ve had the best time," she added, speaking to the group of new boys.
Dale looked happy about the fact that Chloe had chosen him and put his arm around her as they sat by the fire pit.
Love Island fans will witness the rest of the re-coupling during Friday's episode and will be waiting with bated breath to see if Liam walks back in alone - or with Lillie on his arm.
Love Island continues at 9pm on ITV2.
