Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Politics
Adam Forrest, Chris Baynes, Benjamin Kentish, Lizzy Buchan

Brussels shoots down plans for Brexit deal without backstop as PM blasted over 'spin'

Brexit secretary Stephen Barclay has met his EU counterpart Michel Barnier in Brussels today after Jean-Claude Juncker insisted “we can have a deal” before the 31 October deadline.

Mr Barclay had suggested the UK should be given until the end of 2020 to come up with a replacement for the Irish backstop policy – but has been told today the EU could not consider a deal without a backstop or replacement arrangement.

It comes as Irish deputy prime minister Simon Coveney poured cold water over Boris Johnson's tentative claims of progress, saying: "We are not close to a deal".

As it happened...

Good morning and welcome to The Independent's live coverage of events at Westminster, Brussels and beyond.
Labour MPs planning to vote for any Brexit deal secured by Boris Johnson have been warned by party big-hitters that it will be the “stuff of right-wing Tory dreams”.
 
The warning comes after Labour MPs Stephen Kinnock and Caroline Flint tried to rescue an agreement by meeting Michel Barnier in Brussels, having claimed up to 50 colleagues could lend their support to deal.
 
All the details here.
 

Labour MPs warned not to vote for a Boris Johnson Brexit deal because it will be 'stuff of right wing dreams'

It ‘would be the culmination of a decade-long project which is of the right, by the right and for the right’, Tom Watson tells colleagues
Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay will meet with the EU’s chief negotiator Michel Barnier today after Jean-Claude Juncker made some racy remarks and insisted “we can have a deal” before the Halloween deadline.
 
Barclay will head to Brussels for talks following the European Commission president’s warm words, which will have buoyed hopes in Downing Street.
 
Speaking to Sky News, Juncker said “we can have a deal”, but was unable to put the chances at more than 50/50 when pressed.
 
Juncker said that he has no “erotic relation” with the Irish backstop, which aims to prevent a hard border returning to the island of Ireland but has been a major sticking point to getting a deal through Parliament.
 
“If the objectives are met - all of them - then we don’t need the backstop,” he added.
 
Boris Johnson could refuse to recall parliament even if the Supreme Court rules that his decision to suspend it was unlawful, the government has said.
 
The claims pave the way for a potentially explosive row early next week when the judges are expected to reach a verdict.
 
Benjamin Kentish has all the details.
 

Boris Johnson could refuse to recall parliament even if decision to suspend it was unlawful, lawyers say

Court told that prime minister would be entitled to ‘consider a further prorogation’ if first one is deemed to be invalid
Simon Coveney, Ireland’s deputy prime minister and minister for foreign affairs and trade, said he believes the “mood music” is improving over Brexit negotiations. It echoes similar comments made by Irish premier Leo Varadkar.
 
He said, however, that there are still “serious problems”, and that the UK government must come forward with alternative proposals to resolve issues around the Irish border.
 
Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, he said: “We are still waiting for serious proposals from the British government.”
 
He said there is “still quite a wide gap” between solutions proposed by the UK Government and what Ireland and the EU will “be able to support”.
 
He said the onus is on the UK government to come forward with alternative proposals to “resolve the Irish border question”.
Paul McCartney has said the 2016 Brexit referendum was “probably a mistake” and described our current situation as “a mess”.
 
Read more of the ex-Beatle’s thoughts here:
 

Sir Paul McCartney says Brexit referendum was 'probably a mistake'

Music legend was speaking ahead of the release of a new book of photographs by his late wife, Linda
Stephen Kinnock, who met with Michel Barnier in Brussels yesterday, has been on Newsnight explaining why some of his fellow Labour MPs desperately want to back a Brexit deal.
 
Labour frontbencher Emily Thornberry has said Boris Johnson is following Donald Trump’s “strongman” playbook.
 
In an interview with Politics Home, she said: “It’s dangerous to behave in such a way that you are causing chaos and disorder and breaking everything up without any idea of what you want to replace it with, and to give the impression of forward movement by being fundamentally disruptive – that’s totally from Trump’s playbook. It’s really, really unsettling.
 
“And presumably they hope that through that, people will think ‘Oh my goodness, everything is so chaotic we need to hang on to the strong man’. That’s how Donald Trump plays it.”
 
Thornberry also called Johnson “arrogant and lazy”.
Energy minister Kwasi Kwarteng has said the Tory party has suspended members over “Islamophobic material”.
 
“We are trying to get to grips with this problem,” he told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.
 
Asked whether he thinks an independent inquiry is needed, Kwarteng said: “I think the party has enough structure and discipline and focus to try and deal with this problem in the first instance. Obviously this is something that is ongoing.
 
“I don’t know exactly when we will be able to announce what structures we have in order to expel or maintain the suspension of these members, but there is no doubt that we took very summary action when we found out last night what had been going on.”
 
Ireland deputy prime minister Simon Coveney has urged all sides to be honest that “we are not close to a deal right now”.
 
Despite admitting the mood music had improved, Coveney suggested there was some “spin” going on about the current status of negotiations.
 
Our correspondent Lizzy Buchan has more details.
 

'We are not close to a deal': Ireland's deputy prime minister rubbishes Johnson 'spin' Brexit progress being made

There is a 'wide gap' between solutions UK government is proposing and what the EU will be able to support, says Coveney
Liz Truss is in Tokyo, and posing for photos. The international trade secretary said she would “cross any road” for a trade deal with Japan.
 
Truss said: “Businesses should be reassured that there is huge political will on both sides to begin negotiating a new free trade agreement with Japan as soon as possible.”
 
 
Senior Labour MP Harriet Harman said she will maintain her bid to replace John Bercow as Speaker despite her local party’s call for her to abandon the ambition.
 
Camberwell and Peckham constituency party voted to urge Harman to pull out of the race and hinted she could face a Labour candidate at the next general election – rather than the usual convention of the main parties not standing against the occupant of the chair.
 
Harman said on Twitter: “A confident and respected House of Commons representing every constituency in this country & holding govt to account is vital to our parliamentary democracy.
 
“The Speaker is at the heart of this – that’s why I going for it.”

Labour's Naz Shah has called for the prime minister to sack a Tory minister who allegedly made Islamophobic remarks. 

She was responding to complaints from Sajjad Karim, a Conservative Party member and former MEP, who said: "I have experienced conversations taking place with Islamophobic content directly about me, being conducted by very senior members of the Conservative Party - in fact parliamentarians, one of whom is in fact a serving minister at this moment in time.

"Ultimately, this is about values and if we allow Islamophobia, or any other form of discrimination, to go unchecked, what we are doing actually is undermining our own values."

Mr Karim has not revealed the name of the minister in question, but said he would give it to Conservative Party headquarters if they wanted to investigate the incident.

Ms Shah said: "Whoever this is, they are not fit to serve as an MP, let alone as a government minister.

"Boris Johnson must act, find out who it is and sack them."

Labour veteran Margaret Hodge has condemned the "pointless and divisive" tactics by activists keen to prevent Harriet Harman from standing to be the next Speaker.
 
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn is expected to address the climate strike in London this afternoon, where he will thank the young people attending for leading by example.
 
He is expected to tell crowds: "I know the situation can look bleak. We have a prime minister that has called global warming a ‘primitive fear without foundation’. The US President is a full-blown climate denier, putting our planet in danger by pulling out of the Paris Climate Agreement. And the Amazon is on fire, looted by big corporations with a Brazilian president watching on who doesn't care.
 
"But when we see young people demanding urgent action, it's an inspiration. When I see this movement growing – and it's growing every day – I know we can tackle the climate emergency.
 
"The next Labour government will welcome your pressure and hear your demands for change. We will kick start a Green Industrial Revolution and protect our planet, so it’s there to give life and joy to generations to come."
 
We are running a separate liveblog on the protests here.
 
 
If Labour commits to full integration of private schools into the state sector where I teach, this will frame the whole election," writes primary school teacher and Labour councillor James McAsh.
 
Read his piece here:

Cross-party MPs are planning to table legislation to force the government to adopt a radical climate change target to slash greenhouse gas emissions by 2030.

Ahead of a global wave of climate protests on Friday, Labour frontbencher Clive Lewis and Green MP Caroline Lucas have announced plans for a bill that would bring forward the deadline for net-zero carbon emissions by two decades.

Theresa May vowed to introduce a legally binding target to cut carbon emissions by 2050 after recommendations from independent climate change advisers - but campaigners want the government to move faster to tackle the looming climate crisis.

Brexit Party MEPs abstained from voting on a European Parliament resolution on Thursday which called on Iran to release imprisoned EU-Iranian nationals, including British citizen Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe.

The resolution called on Iranian authorities to “immediately and unconditionally” release all dual-nationals and human rights campaigners jailed as political prisoners.

As well as naming Ms Zaghari-Ratcliffe, who has been imprisoned in Iran since April 2016, the resolution also named EU citizens Ahmadreza Djalali and Kamran Ghaderi, who are also being held in Iran.

The Muslim Council of Britain has said the latest revelations are a "manifestation of institutional Islamophobia" in the Conservative party.

Harun Khan, secretary general of the organisation, said: "An independent and specific inquiry into Islamophobia specifically is long overdue.

"Sadly the Conservative response has been woeful. From denial, through to now a reluctant commitment to a broad and watered down investigation that we fear will do nothing to address this problem.

"The fact that former MEP Sajjad Karim has confirmed a current serving minister has made Islamophobic comments directly about him, is extremely serious and indicative of the scale of the problem.

"Investigating this minister immediately is essential will be the latest test of the apparent resolve of the party. If no action is taken, and instead they remain a minister, it will yet again demonstrate its failure to take this problem seriously."

Read our piece here.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.