There's no single "right" way to be a dividend investor. Some folks want to focus on long-term growth by prioritizing companies with long track records of uninterrupted dividend increases.
Others zero in on quality, favoring firms with sustainable payout ratios and strong balance sheets that are less likely to cut their dividends.
A third approach is to target stocks with above-average yields compared to their sector or the broader market.
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) offer many ways to implement this strategy, but not all high-yield ETFs are built the same. Understanding the key differences is essential before investing.
Understanding high-yield ETFs
High-yield ETFs are built to deliver more income than broad-market index funds. They achieve this by using rules-based frameworks that select stocks with above-average payouts.
For example, a simple version may start with an index such as the S&P 500, then filter for the highest-yielding stocks, say, the top 25% based on trailing 12-month dividend yields. From that group, the ETF constructs a portfolio. But even this approach comes with nuance.
Some funds weight holdings by dividend yield or by total cash dividends paid. Others try to avoid "yield traps," which are stocks with unsustainably high yields.
Many also cap the weight of individual stocks or sectors to keep the portfolio diversified and reduce concentration.
Beyond higher income, this strategy tends to come with other side effects. One is a tilt toward value stocks. That's because yield is calculated as dividends divided by share price, so when a stock's price falls, its yield rises.
As a result, high-yield screens often select companies that are trading at lower valuations.
However, high-yield ETFs also tend to lag the broad market during periods when growth stocks are leading.
That's because many top-performing companies, especially in technology sector, either don't pay dividends or offer very low yields, meaning they get excluded from high-yield strategies.
Finally, in taxable accounts, high-yield ETFs can face a drag. Every time a dividend is paid, it triggers a tax liability, making these funds better suited for tax-sheltered accounts like a Roth IRA.
How we chose the best high-yield ETFs
We focused on U.S.-listed high-yield ETFs that generate income from actual stock dividends and not derivatives such as covered calls. We also left out international dividend ETFs to keep the universe simple, cheap and tax efficient.
From there, we applied two core screens. First, we capped the expense ratio at 0.40%, to ensure investors keep more of the income generated.
Second, we required at least $1 billion in assets under management (AUM) as a proxy for investor trust, stability and issuer track record.
These filters helped narrow the field to ETFs that not only deliver high income but are also scalable, liquid and cost-effective additions to a long-term portfolio.
Dividend yields on equity funds represent the trailing 12-month yield, which is a standard measure for equity funds. Data is as of June 9.
Exchange-traded fund (ticker symbol) |
Dividend yield |
|---|---|
Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) |
2.9% |
SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 High Dividend ETF (SPYD) |
4.5% |
iShares Core High Dividend ETF (HDV) |
3.5% |
Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD) |
4.0% |
WisdomTree U.S. High Dividend Fund (DHS) |
3.5% |
- Assets under management: $56.8 billion
- Expense ratio: 0.06%, or $6 annually on every $10,000 invested
- Dividend yield: 2.9%
The Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) tracks the FTSE High Dividend Yield Index, which includes U.S. companies with forecasted forward dividend yields above the 55th percentile of its selection universe.
To improve tax efficiency, the index also excludes real estate investment trusts (REITs).
VYM currently holds a broadly diversified portfolio of over 580 stocks with a market cap-weighted approach and low turnover of about 13%.
The high-yield leans heavily into financial, health care, and industrial stocks, giving it a mild value and quality tilt without sacrificing diversification.
Learn more about VYM at the Vanguard provider site.
- Assets under management: $6.8 billion
- Expense ratio: 0.07%
- Dividend yield: 4.5%
The SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 High Dividend ETF (SPYD) takes a straightforward approach to its strategy.
It starts with the S&P 500, already screened for size, revenue, profitability and liquidity, and then selects 80 stocks with the highest dividend yields. Those stocks are then equally weighted and rebalanced twice a year.
SPYD offers a higher yield than broader funds such as VYM but with trade-offs. For one, it holds no more than 80 names, making it far less diversified.
The high-yield ETF also includes a 23.7% allocation to REITs, which can reduce tax efficiency.
Sector-wise, it leans heavily into utilities (18.2%) and consumer staples (15.1%), giving it a much different profile than the overall S&P 500 for better or worse.
Learn more about SPYD at the State Street Global Advisors provider site.
- Assets under management: $10.9 billion
- Expense ratio: 0.08%
- Dividend yield: 3.5%
The iShares Core High Dividend ETF (HDV) tracks the Morningstar Dividend Yield Focus Index, a more qualitative approach than most dividend benchmarks.
Stocks are selected based on three proprietary Morningstar ratings: Economic Moat Rating (to identify companies with durable competitive advantages); Uncertainty Rating (to assess the range of potential valuation outcomes); and Distance to Default Score (a measure of volatility and leverage).
HDV excludes REITs and holds a concentrated portfolio of about 75 stocks, weighted by trailing 12-month dividends paid.
Currently, it leans heavily into consumer staples stocks (22.4%), energy (19.9%) and health care (16.3%). The index's strict rules result in high turnover of around 67% annually, making this a surprisingly active ETF despite its passive label.
Learn more about HDV at the iShares provider site.
- Assets under management: $69.3 billion
- Expense ratio: 0.06%
- Dividend yield: 4.0%
The Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD) isn't specifically billed as a high-yield ETF, but its strategy delivers above-average income alongside quality and growth filters.
The multifactor approach makes SCHD one of the most well-rounded and best-performing dividend ETFs available right now.
SCHD tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index, which starts by selecting companies with at least 10 consecutive years of dividend payments.
It then applies a composite screen based on free cash flow to total debt, return on equity, dividend yield and five-year dividend growth.
The resulting portfolio is weighted by market cap, with 4% limits for individual stocks and 25% for sectors.
Learn more about SCHD at the Schwab provider site.
- Assets under management: $1.2 billion
- Expense ratio: 0.38%
- Dividend yield: 3.5%
The WisdomTree U.S. High Dividend Fund (DHS) tracks a fundamentally weighted index.
So instead of using market cap, DHS weights holdings based on the total cash dividends each company is projected to pay, adjusted by a composite risk score that accounts for value, quality and momentum.
Companies scoring higher receive a larger weighting, while those with weaker fundamentals are scaled down.
The portfolio is tilted toward consumer staples (20.8%), health care (19.3%), and financial stocks (19.1%).
DHS also pays dividends monthly, an added perk for income-focused investors.
Learn more about DHS at the WisdomTree provider site.
