Natalie Mayer, judge: This is a classic composition, and a wonderful expression has been caught. I wonder if the photographer was thinking of Steve McCurry's famous Afgahn Girl image when he shot this? This photographer has made a technically competent image and captured an expression that is very endearing. Lovely. Photograph: Robert Tyler
Natalie Mayer, judge: This is a nice natural moment, well captured. Choosing a wider aperture in order to blur out that background would have helped remove those distracting back elements. Photograph: Robert Hoey
Natalie Mayer, judge: This is lovely. Cold and crisp. The sparse composition works well giving the image a good sense of isolation. Photograph: Peter Leyden